Page 1 of 1
1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Thu Sep 19, 2019 8:26 pm
by Alan
Assuming Ducks have a 12 game season they have played one quarter of the season, time for first quarter grades. I'm doing it for just Cristobal, Arroyo and Avalos, but feel free to grade other assistants. For example the new WR coach is doing a good job compared to last years cluster, so a B+ for Boulknigjt.
Cristobal - C+, still learning on the job but improving
Arroyo - C- maybe he has finally woke up with the Montana game
Avalos - B+ D, IMO, is the best I have seen in a few years, a great job by our new DC in the short time he has been Duck, but still room to improve.
Maybe someone can help me remember to do this at the end of game six for second quarter grades, see any perceived progression or regression.
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 6:25 am
by GoDucksIn09
Not sure how many wake up calls Arroyo needs. I think C- is generous.
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 7:02 am
by Phenom
lol look at the play by play analysis video. Arroyo has had a really good year so far.
MC - B
Arroyo - B
Avalos - A-
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 8:44 am
by chapelhillduck
Phenom wrote:lol look at the play by play analysis video. Arroyo has had a really good year so far.
MC - B
Arroyo - B
Avalos - A-
Yep, this exactly
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 9:25 am
by UofDuck
Alan wrote:Assuming Ducks have a 12 game season they have played one quarter of the season, time for first quarter grades. I'm doing it for just Cristobal, Arroyo and Avalos, but feel free to grade other assistants. For example the new WR coach is doing a good job compared to last years cluster, so a B+ for Boulknigjt.
Cristobal - C+, still learning on the job but improving
Arroyo - C- maybe he has finally woke up with the Montana game
Avalos - B+ D, IMO, is the best I have seen in a few years, a great job by our new DC in the short time he has been Duck, but still room to improve.
Maybe someone can help me remember to do this at the end of game six for second quarter grades, see any perceived progression or regression.
I’m curious how a head coach that takes over a dumpster fire and salvages a recruiting class, then follows it up with a historic recruiting class, hires a home-run D coordinator and has us near top 15 in the country gets a C-?
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 9:53 am
by GrandpaDuck
I think it is very inaccurate to grade the OC separate from the Head Coach when you have an Offensive head coach who is hands on involved in the offense. The HC in these instances is the defacto Head Offensive Coordinator particularly in scheme design, weekly game plan, and key in game calls (like going on 4th down).
For instance the play calling during the first half dry spell sucked. (Yes yes QB11 ((who aint who you think he is)) thinks it's great). There was a 3 run to 1 pass ratio going on despite having a QB who was hot and a run game that was getting mediocre results. Normally going with what isn't working and ignoring what is sucks.
BUT that well could have been part of the weekly game plan. Use the game as practice, show nothing to Stanford, test a variety of running backs, get film on how the running game does against a defense that stunts and penetrates (an Achillies heal last year). I don't know how much of that was in the game plan but it wouldn't be a bad one.
Instead of grading the individual offensive coaches I would be more inclined to want to grade them as a unit by category. Like game management, play calling, offensive scheme. Even doing that, I will wait for conference play to see the real offense.
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 10:12 am
by nogerO
Head Coach B- Head scratching game management issues ongoing...trending up.
Offensive coordinator B Play calling of late has been very good. I'm still of the opinion that the second half play calling at Auburn wasn't his doing...trending up.
Defensive coordinator B+ Looking good. Waiting on a larger sampling of opponents. Trending up.
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 10:15 am
by Alan
UofDuck wrote:Alan wrote:Assuming Ducks have a 12 game season they have played one quarter of the season, time for first quarter grades. I'm doing it for just Cristobal, Arroyo and Avalos, but feel free to grade other assistants. For example the new WR coach is doing a good job compared to last years cluster, so a B+ for Boulknigjt.
Cristobal - C+, still learning on the job but improving
Arroyo - C- maybe he has finally woke up with the Montana game
Avalos - B+ D, IMO, is the best I have seen in a few years, a great job by our new DC in the short time he has been Duck, but still room to improve.
Maybe someone can help me remember to do this at the end of game six for second quarter grades, see any perceived progression or regression.
I’m curious how a head coach that takes over a dumpster fire and salvages a recruiting class, then follows it up with a historic recruiting class, hires a home-run D coordinator and has us near top 15 in the country gets a C-?
Well I think he’s doing a very good job in the first three games of this first quarter of the season , His Clock management has been suspect. Calling that extra Time out to try to get Herbert back in the game when he went down is completely on his shoulders. So he showing signs of a new coach with much to learn and he’s making mistakes that is hurting the team. I fully expect to greet him hire next quarter. Grandpa I respect your opinion and your knowledge do you have a grade for each of those three coaches?
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 10:43 am
by pezsez1
Head Coach B- Head scratching game management issues ongoing...trending up.
Just wanted to say one thing about his game management... he took lots of criticism for calling a timeout at the start of the Auburn game. But what happened after that? Ducks got a first down on the first play of the game, and we went on to score a TD and control the first half.
If that timeout was what it took to get us off to that kind of start, then I'm not going to criticize it. There were plenty of other things in that game with far more questionable outcomes.
Re: 1st quarter grades for HC, OC and DC
Posted: Fri Sep 20, 2019 10:50 am
by GrantDuck
Phenom wrote:lol look at the play by play analysis video. Arroyo has had a really good year so far.
MC - B
Arroyo - B
Avalos - A-
Would go with this too.
I was a big of a critic of Arroyo as anyone last year and wanted him gone, but outside the 2nd half of the Auburn game, I'm fairly happy with him so far. Our lack of skill position guys makes his job pretty tough.