Page 1 of 3

Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2020 7:16 pm
by StevensTechU
Left- 2008 team that went 10-3 and won the Holiday Bowl. Right 2020.

QB- Jeremiah Masoli / Tyler Shough
RB- Jeremiah Johnson / CJ Verdell
WR- Jaison Williams / Johnny Johnson
WR- Jeff Maehl / Mycah Pittman
WR- Jamere Holland / Jaylon Redd
TE- Ed Dickson / Cam McCormick
OL- Fenuki Toupou / Steven Jones
OL- Jeff Kendall / TJ Bass
OL- Max Unger / Alex Forsyth
OL- Mark Lewis / Sala Aumavae-Laulu
OL- Jacob Hucko / George Moore

DE- Nick Reed / Kayvon Thibodeaux
DT- Ra'Shon Harris / Austin Faoliu
DT- Will Linehan / Jordon Scott
DE/OLB- Will Tukuafu / Mase Funa
LB- Spencer Paysinger / Adrian Jackson
LB- John Bacon / Isaac Slade-Mautuatia
LB/DB- Jerome Boyd / Bennett Williams
DB- Patrick Chung / Verone McKinley
DB- TJ Ward / Nick Pickett
DB- Walter Thurmond / Mykael Wright
DB- Jairus Byrd / Deommodore Lenoir

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2020 7:50 pm
by GrandpaDuck
Can we put Casey Mathews in for John Bacon? Didnt he end up starting the last seven games?

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2020 8:09 pm
by StevensTechU
GrandpaDuck wrote:Can we put Casey Mathews in for John Bacon? Didnt he end up starting the last seven games?
Bacon is a fraternity brother of mine, so I have to leave it as it is. haha

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2020 9:10 pm
by lukeyrid13
Bacon was playing well until he tore his knee in 07

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 5:39 am
by DCfeatherbutt
2008 was my favorite Duck team.

Chip mixed with Masoli, Maehl, Dickson, Unger. Yes please.

My expectations for his year are officially tamped down. Sure could have used Sewell this year.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 6:52 am
by StevensTechU
I've thought about comparing rosters of current teams to past ones a lot because I frequently hear it said, usually from the recruitniks, how much more talented Oregon is becoming than what Ducks teams used to be. Looking at the 2008 team, I think our depth now is arguably better, but frankly don't know when we'll have a starting lineup with that much star power again. I picked 2008 at random, but what a mix of college all-stars and future NFL stars up and down the roster.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 7:35 am
by Duck07
StevensTechU wrote:I've thought about comparing rosters of current teams to past ones a lot because I frequently hear it said, usually from the recruitniks, how much more talented Oregon is becoming than what Ducks teams used to be. Looking at the 2008 team, I think our depth now is arguably better, but frankly don't know when we'll have a starting lineup with that much star power again. I picked 2008 at random, but what a mix of college all-stars and future NFL stars up and down the roster.
I want to say that Mariota's Jr or Sr year finally beat out the 2005 roster for most NFL players but I think the 05 roster wins on longevity/talent in the league. Max and Haloti are both borderline HOF candidates who will both likely miss out on their jackets.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 8:52 am
by OregonFan4Life
Duck07 wrote:
StevensTechU wrote:I've thought about comparing rosters of current teams to past ones a lot because I frequently hear it said, usually from the recruitniks, how much more talented Oregon is becoming than what Ducks teams used to be. Looking at the 2008 team, I think our depth now is arguably better, but frankly don't know when we'll have a starting lineup with that much star power again. I picked 2008 at random, but what a mix of college all-stars and future NFL stars up and down the roster.
I want to say that Mariota's Jr or Sr year finally beat out the 2005 roster for most NFL players but I think the 05 roster wins on longevity/talent in the league. Max and Haloti are both borderline HOF candidates who will both likely miss out on their jackets.
I think the 2012 (Mariota's Fr year) had the most talented team overall, lots of NFL calibre talent on both sides of the ball, but some injuries and other unfortunate things caused that team to not have as many NFL players (Ifo, Pharoah, and Colt for example). But that team had Marcus, DAT, Ifo, Hill, Mitchell, Kiko, Clay, Armstead, Dion Jordan, Buckner, Barner, Huff, Addison, Grasu, Long, Fisher, Colt, and Pharoah. For me personally it's hard to think of an Oregon team that had that much talent. I think the current Oregon program is building more talented defenses, but the offense isn't quite there yet.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 9:10 am
by StevensTechU
Mentally, I went down the list and looked at how many 2020 starters would start over their 2008 counterparts. It's not many. For instance, this year's DB group is expected to be good, but I don't think any of them are starting over TJ Ward, Patrick Chung, Jairus Byrd, and Walter Thurmond III. Especially when you consider that they were all upperclassmen in 2008. Similarly, I like CJ Verdell, but I'll trade him for Jeremiah Johnson any day of the week.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 9:38 am
by lukeyrid13
StevensTechU wrote:Mentally, I went down the list and looked at how many 2020 starters would start over their 2008 counterparts. It's not many. For instance, this year's DB group is expected to be good, but I don't think any of them are starting over TJ Ward, Patrick Chung, Jairus Byrd, and Walter Thurmond III. Especially when you consider that they were all upperclassmen in 2008. Similarly, I like CJ Verdell, but I'll trade him for Jeremiah Johnson any day of the week.
I agree....but to be fair, we lost 3 starters already. Holland is a 1st rounder and would start somewhere in the secondary. Wright reminds me a lot of Thurmond actually but is just slightly larger and unfortunately WT3 tore his knee early in that season.

I think a lot of our fans have really overrated our OL for this year. We will have really really good OL play for the next 5-6 years now, but this year will definitely be a stopgap year and our weakest year at that position.

I think the front 7 this year is far more athletic and versatile overall. Nick Reed is arguable the most successful (college only ) DE of modern Ducks football but the rest of the front 7, while relentless, was undersized

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 9:39 am
by GrandpaDuck
StevensTechU wrote:Mentally, I went down the list and looked at how many 2020 starters would start over their 2008 counterparts. It's not many. For instance, this year's DB group is expected to be good, but I don't think any of them are starting over TJ Ward, Patrick Chung, Jairus Byrd, and Walter Thurmond III. Especially when you consider that they were all upperclassmen in 2008. Similarly, I like CJ Verdell, but I'll trade him for Jeremiah Johnson any day of the week.
[Cough Cough] Plus Blount was a 1000 yard rusher in 2008.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 3:46 pm
by GrantDuck
Secondary of 2008 will be legendary.

Our Front 7 talent on defense now is quite a bit better than that season, conversely.


Bellotti always had a lot of talent on offense at the skill spots. Coach Cam helped a lot in that.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 8:39 pm
by Duck07
Lenoir would start over Jairus Byrd at CB if only because Jairus was a Safety playing Corner.

I think Sunny Harris in this 3-4 would have been a real nice player in this system and obviously you start an experienced Spencer Paysinger. Nick Reed and Will Tukuafu would have played the opposite role in this system imo at which point you might take him over Funa due to the experience.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 9:18 pm
by StevensTechU
Duck07 wrote:Lenoir would start over Jairus Byrd at CB if only because Jairus was a Safety playing Corner..
Jairus had 17 interceptions in three seasons playing cornerback. Deommodore has 5. It's not even close, imo.

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2020 9:42 pm
by Phalanx
StevensTechU wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Lenoir would start over Jairus Byrd at CB if only because Jairus was a Safety playing Corner..
Jairus had 17 interceptions in three seasons playing cornerback. Deommodore has 5. It's not even close, imo.
It is interesting how few interceptions both Lenoir and Graham had last year - two guys who fancy themselves NFL material. Not to say that picks are everything, but it would be nice to see more of them from the corners this year.