Page 1 of 1
Could Oregon go to the GO-GO this season
Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2020 5:27 am
by Merganzer
After Chip rewrote the book on offense with the Blur, you might think Oregon was done, but there could be yet another step coming.
https://fishduck.com/2020/11/oregon-foo ... o-offense/
Re: Could Oregon go to the GO-GO this season
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2020 1:51 pm
by DuckMastaFunk
Interesting read. Too bad it is nothing but speculation. The go-go offense sounds fun.
Thanks for posting Merg!
Re: Could Oregon go to the GO-GO this season
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2020 9:48 pm
by GoDucksTroll
Note: sorry this is long and a bit disjointed. A summary of what we can learn about Moorhead’s offense based on his time at Penn State.
I’ve been playing around with different stats and analytics for the last few years. Mostly doing a ranking formula, not a predictive one but I’ll probably do that as well. Some position ranking ones as well, started off as a project to see if there are patterns in what makes a successful NFL QB from their college days. There really isn’t, if anyone is curious - but starting more than 24 games in college and meeting a floor level of athleticism is pretty close.
Anyway, I went in to look at Penn State’s offense in 2016 and 17, and Mississippi State 2018 and 19. Moorhead’s time there wasn’t a big help because there is no way Oregon will run anything close to that type of offense.
Moorhead doesn’t like super fast tempo. Raw stats or adjusted for garbage time show that his Miss St team was slower than 2019 Oregon, about 4 offensive plays per game slower. At Penn State they were similar to 2019 Oregon, an offensive play or two faster. So don’t expect Ball Coach Joe to be the catalyst for a new blur.
Comparing Penn State’s Moorhead offense with Arroyo’s 2019 Oregon:
* Penn State had much better skill players. Saquon Barkley, Mike Gesicki, Dasean Hamilton, and a few other great WRs including Juwan Johnson. Oregon had a much better OL. Difference at QB as well, Trace McSorley was a smaller but faster type who would be ran a little more.
* Similarities: Run/pass rate nearly identical. Yards per play very similar. Just much closer on a ton of metrics than I expected. Like, if you didn’t know which offense is which and just looked at the numbers you might think that 2017 Penn State and 2019 Oregon were just different years of the same team.
* Differences: since these are more important I’ll bullet point them-
- Penn State scored more offensive TDs. I’ll get to that later.
- Penn State had more INTs and fewer fumbles for a similar turnover rate.
- While situational run/pass play calling was mostly similar Oregon had a higher rate of runs on first down. Connected to the next point.
- Penn State lost yards, often and a lot. Barkley lost more yards than the entire Oregon team. It skews the stats.
- Oregon didn’t lose yards. Top-10 in that, while PSU was bottom 10.
- Why the disparity? The pistol explains part of it, but UO didn’t lose yardage on shotgun runs either. Oregon’s OL was better on run plays not allowing stuffs.
- Penn State allowed more sacks. A statistically significantly higher rate. But not on third down.
- Penn State passed better on third down. They allowed fewer pressures and Trace McSorley was just plain better than Justin Herbert on third down. Herbert missed throws, the OL gave up pressures.
Key differences, the ones where improvement would be huge compared to Arroyo’s offense:
- Explosion plays. Plays of 10-20 yards were fairly even, slight edge to PSU. Plays of 30+ yards were similar as well. BUT AND A HUGE BUT: Penn State consistently got more 20-29 yard plays. Like 2.5 more per game. That is huge, and pretty much explains Penn State getting more yards.
- Moorhead loves to run the QB in the red zone. 11 TDs in 2017 for McSorley. Fordham stats were hard to come by, but this is a Moorhead staple. (I should note that Herbert didn’t need to run in the red zone. He was 19 TD and 0 INT without suffering a big completion percentage drop like other QBs. Ridiculously good)
- Penn State had fewer dud drives, ones where you go 3 and out. Why? It’s usually a hallmark of either really talented teams. Chip’s best offenses didn’t do great in this metric, but advanced stats considers it very important.
Penn state scored more offensive TDs. They also had better field position, not because of the return game (similar results) but because their defense produced more three and outs. It could be a Pac-12/Big10 difference. They were also much less penalized as a team. Their FG kicker was equally as bad, and they attempted more, so it wasn’t due to going for it on fourth downs.
Conclusion: Penn State was more effective despite losing yardage more often. Big chunk plays and more consistency on the first three downs are huge reasons why. Whether it’s talent, running the QB more, fewer penalties - probably a combo of all of those.
Things to consider: Moorhead had a huge impact on Penn State. Before (UDub’s new OC) and after just weren’t the same. It can’t be explained by Saquon Barkley alone. Moorhead’s Miss State teams ran a completely different offense.
Re: Could Oregon go to the GO-GO this season
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2020 12:14 am
by GoDucksTroll
Update to my super long reply, with a small sample size against two mediocre defenses:
Oregon is first in the country in yards per play (8.2), first in yards per rush (7.2), tenth in yards per pass attempt (9.6)
Also first in third down conversion percentage (72% which is 10% higher than the second team).
Those are incredible numbers even if the opponents have been bad defensively. Not sustainable, and an advantage of marrying Moorhead’s system with some of the pistol sets that nobody has tape on.
If it wasn’t for the turnovers I couldn’t have dreamed of a better start.