Page 1 of 2

Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:12 pm
by bigsugarduck
Has there ever been a player that, in performing such a way, has made their previous team look worse than Herbert has with Oregon? I reckon there have been plenty of players who have performed spectacularly below expectations (thus reflecting poorly on the previous team), but nothing like this...

It is so fun watching Herbert, but the better he does, the worse Oregon looks...a confounding, bizarre, unpresented thing to reconcile.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:25 pm
by Alan
Justin was at Oregon during a very low time in Duck recent history, Helf, Slick Willy, then to new coach Cristabol, OC’s, new offense. I don’t know who you can blame.... a rookie new coach from the SEC? Nope, it was just the way things happened, no real blame, maybe Helf and Willy? I think if Herbert played under our current OC he would have been used better and with luck Cristabol will learn from what Justin is doing now,

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 3:10 pm
by Duck07
Are we really going to repeat a national narrative we know is BS?

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 3:27 pm
by bigsugarduck
Duck07 wrote:Are we really going to repeat a national narrative we know is BS?
That narrative is not really going to change. It is pretty baked in, despite what die hard Oregon fans try to say. That said, my question still stands...Has anything like Herbert/Oregon happened in the past?

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 3:31 pm
by StevensTechU
Alan wrote:Justin was at Oregon during a very low time in Duck recent history, Helf, Slick Willy, then to new coach Cristabol, OC’s, new offense. I don’t know who you can blame.... a rookie new coach from the SEC? Nope, it was just the way things happened, no real blame, maybe Helf and Willy? I think if Herbert played under our current OC he would have been used better and with luck Cristabol will learn from what Justin is doing now,
I would exclude Helf from the perspective of how his coaching reflected on Herbert's performance at Oregon. Herbert was quite successful as a true freshman in his lone year under Helfrich. Then things went off the rails a bit, and he probably should've been more acclaimed than he end up being. Another way of saying that is if Helf had stuck around, Oregon would've been 3-8 every year but Justin would've probably put up video game numbers.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:18 pm
by GoDucksTroll
Herbert’s showing is a huge PR win for Oregon. You have a rookie of the year setting passing records and looking like a future superstar, everything else is just minor details.

The narrative that he didn’t do as great as expected will be forgotten by next year when his performance is no longer a surprise. Writers who set the national narrative will also get bored, and the CFB ones know Oregon had turnover and a different OC. I can’t imagine it hurting recruiting quite the opposite. What is Clay Helton going to say? Look at them, they could only get Herbert drafted sixth overall while my boy Sam Darnold is killing it? Recruits don’t even care about that. Plus, recruits barely follow college football. Coach Pimp is out there telling people he developed Royce Freeman and I’m sure kids believed him.

All people will remember is that Justin Herbert went to Oregon and he’s really good.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:52 pm
by GrantDuck
First off, the narrative his horse crap and we all know it. Herbert won a lot of games, a Rose Bowl, and put up great #'s at Oregon. Yes, Arroyo was a mediocre OC, but this narrative that Herbert wasn't good at Oregon or Oregon didn't win with him is garbage that's being perpetuated by idiots who didn't analyze him properly and are rationalizing it for their egos, instead of just saying "yeah we missed."

That said, I'm with the sentiments in this thread. Short term, probably not great look for Oregon. Long term, if Herbert is a great QB in the NFL, it's only going to help. We also have the next great one in the pipeline in Ty Thompson.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 11:03 am
by Duck07
I'm of the mindset that everything Justin struggled through during his time here is a major part of why he's been able to have such immediate success so rather than accepting this nonsense I'll just put a better lenses on it:

Accuracy can be attributed to having to try to pinpoint every throw with guys who struggled to catch the ball.

Pocket movement can be attributed to having an OL as a HC coach who forced him to be a pocket passer rather than a mobile threat.

4 year starter for a Major program with a winning record, Conf Title and Rose Bowl. He literally checks every box that Bill Parcells used in evaluating QBs decades ago and what's funny is that Justin is that old-school passer in many ways in a modern league and he's doing just fine. (In essence he's everything that Tennessee, for some reason, thought Marcus was going to be)

Justin was also a serious student, electing to choose a difficult degree over one that required less study time in favor of more subjective grading scales. He's done quite well at diagnosing coverages and that can't be simply because of a couple of months time with his new OC/QB coach.

He likely also saw actually better Secondary play in practice last year than he does currently especially when you consider his WRs now are NFL starters for most teams vs who he was throwing to last year. If you asked the Chargers to swap out our entire starting 4 DBs last year for their starting 4 this year I don't know anyone who wouldn't roll with the youngins with where they'll likely be drafted this spring.

He's succeeding in the NFL right now because of what he experienced at Oregon, not in spite of it.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 11:41 am
by Phalanx
Duck07 wrote:I'm of the mindset that everything Justin struggled through during his time here is a major part of why he's been able to have such immediate success so rather than accepting this nonsense I'll just put a better lenses on it:

Accuracy can be attributed to having to try to pinpoint every throw with guys who struggled to catch the ball.

Pocket movement can be attributed to having an OL as a HC coach who forced him to be a pocket passer rather than a mobile threat.

4 year starter for a Major program with a winning record, Conf Title and Rose Bowl. He literally checks every box that Bill Parcells used in evaluating QBs decades ago and what's funny is that Justin is that old-school passer in many ways in a modern league and he's doing just fine. (In essence he's everything that Tennessee, for some reason, thought Marcus was going to be)

Justin was also a serious student, electing to choose a difficult degree over one that required less study time in favor of more subjective grading scales. He's done quite well at diagnosing coverages and that can't be simply because of a couple of months time with his new OC/QB coach.

He likely also saw actually better Secondary play in practice last year than he does currently especially when you consider his WRs now are NFL starters for most teams vs who he was throwing to last year. If you asked the Chargers to swap out our entire starting 4 DBs last year for their starting 4 this year I don't know anyone who wouldn't roll with the youngins with where they'll likely be drafted this spring.

He's succeeding in the NFL right now because of what he experienced at Oregon, not in spite of it.
I have thought the same. Oregon for Herbert was like training with Mr. Miyagi. It might not have looked like it, but he was being prepared for the rigors of the NFL. His receivers now must be a breath of fresh air. They actually run the routes they're supposed to, get open, and catch the ball! The funniest part though is all the pre-draft commentary from draft experts. Justin was a bad leader, he was inaccurate, he had no touch, he didn't know how to line up under center, etc. He continues making a joke out of all of their commentary.

This idea that he somehow developed into a star all of a sudden is humorous to me. He was absolutely killing it in the Senior Bowl practices, dropping long-distance dimes to receivers all over the place with his rocket arm, and yet somehow, the 'experts' figured that skill wouldn't translate to the NFL. Now they think he learned it this summer during quarantine. Right.

I thought Justin was better than Tua coming out of college, and now a lot of the talking heads are saying the same. In addition to his skill set, he is built to endure the hits and come back every week, as he has been proving from Day 1. Unlike Marcus and Tua, Justin is built for the pro game. Having followed Joey and Marcus over the years, it's so surreal to see how easy it is for Justin. He's like a hot knife going through warm butter. People here are worried about the narrative reflecting on Oregon, but the one that will endure is that Justin, a kid from Eugene, Oregon, after tearing it up in the Rose Bowl, is now setting rookie records in the NFL. Now that Burrows is out (which was also predictable), Justin is in the spotlight all by himself. That can't be anything but good for Oregon.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 12:49 pm
by buckmarkduck
He was fine when he was free to play as a Fr and half his SO year. Once he got hurt, it seemed like the coaches reined him in to much. If we allowed him to run, the way Shough has been free to do, he would have been much better. I also bet we would have gone 12-0 with Moorehead as OC. You can't make decisions based on being afraid someone gets hurt.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 2:29 pm
by Boom
NFL wide receivers help.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 3:17 pm
by GoDucksTroll
Boom wrote:NFL wide receivers help.
I counted up skill position players drafted, and projected as first round picks for this upcoming draft.

Tua’s Alabama: 5 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 second round RB, 1 third round RB, 1 second round TE.

Burrow’s LSU: 3 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 fourth round TE, 1 seventh round TE.

Herbert’s Oregon: 1 third round RB, 1 seventh round WR.

All of the listed players have been drafted. Alabama’s Devonta Smith and Jaylen Waddle as well as LSU’s Ja’mar Chase are the consensus top-3 WRs in the upcoming draft.

The disparity is huge. Both Burrow and Tua played with more first round skill talent then they’ll ever have at their disposal on an NFL roster. Herbert is slinging TDs to undrafted free agents because that’s what he’s used to. How did all the NFL draft people barely mention this?

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 3:19 pm
by GoDucksTroll
Editing error: all players drafted except the three listed surefire first round WRs and Alabama’s RB Najee Harris projected as a second rounder at worst, and LSU’s WR Terrace Marshall who is either a first or second round WR.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Thu Nov 26, 2020 9:04 pm
by RanDux
GoDucksTroll wrote:
Boom wrote:NFL wide receivers help.
I counted up skill position players drafted, and projected as first round picks for this upcoming draft.

Tua’s Alabama: 5 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 second round RB, 1 third round RB, 1 second round TE.

Burrow’s LSU: 3 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 fourth round TE, 1 seventh round TE.

Herbert’s Oregon: 1 third round RB, 1 seventh round WR.

All of the listed players have been drafted. Alabama’s Devonta Smith and Jaylen Waddle as well as LSU’s Ja’mar Chase are the consensus top-3 WRs in the upcoming draft.

The disparity is huge. Both Burrow and Tua played with more first round skill talent then they’ll ever have at their disposal on an NFL roster. Herbert is slinging TDs to undrafted free agents because that’s what he’s used to. How did all the NFL draft people barely mention this?
Great post. That and the conservative play-calling by our former OC are the reasons Justin didn't light it up more in college like he is now in the NFL. Enjoy it, people. He is a joy to watch.

Re: Herbert Oregon narrative

Posted: Fri Nov 27, 2020 7:39 am
by Alan
RanDux wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:
Boom wrote:NFL wide receivers help.
I counted up skill position players drafted, and projected as first round picks for this upcoming draft.

Tua’s Alabama: 5 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 second round RB, 1 third round RB, 1 second round TE.

Burrow’s LSU: 3 first round WRs, 1 first round RB, 1 fourth round TE, 1 seventh round TE.

Herbert’s Oregon: 1 third round RB, 1 seventh round WR.

All of the listed players have been drafted. Alabama’s Devonta Smith and Jaylen Waddle as well as LSU’s Ja’mar Chase are the consensus top-3 WRs in the upcoming draft.

The disparity is huge. Both Burrow and Tua played with more first round skill talent then they’ll ever have at their disposal on an NFL roster. Herbert is slinging TDs to undrafted free agents because that’s what he’s used to. How did all the NFL draft people barely mention this?
Great post. That and the conservative play-calling by our former OC are the reasons Justin didn't light it up more in college like he is now in the NFL. Enjoy it, people. He is a joy to watch.
X2 Troll! Great post! Thanks for doing the research, Herbert will be fun to watch in the coming years, I hope the Chargers can build a team around him and keep him healthy.