Page 1 of 3
Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 3:33 am
by duckfan96
Who, in all reality, didn’t see this happening. Defensive backfield new, OL new, new qb. When you leave starters in as long as Oregon did last year it doesn’t give back ups a lot of game time experience. Shough, to me and I’m no expert, looks lost at times. Seemed like he was hurt? If he is hurt put in Brown. At least kicker kicked straight.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 3:51 am
by jimmy12
The offense is not the problem, it's the LBs and one side of the CBs and S. When Wight is out, we are vulnerable. The safety's are slow and not quick to react. Happle is good positionally but doesn't have the speed to close.
The LBs are troubling. Mase Funa is SLOW and out of shape. He had a kid in the offseason and really took a step back it seems. Sewell is a monster, but guesses wrong a fair amount. When he's not in his back up misses 75% of the time. ISM got picked on all game. He missed a LOT of tackles and was in the wrong place in pass coverage.
This team was hurt by no spring ball and no 4th quarter program.
This season is a lost season anyway. For me, it's about developing the young players. We weren't eligible for the playoff and you're kidding yourself if you believe that we won't have to cancel one game. It will happen. We seem to be playing a lot of players. Things will get better. I still think the Ducks win the North.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 4:12 am
by Everythingsducky
‘ This team was hurt by no spring ball and no 4th quarter program.’
Lazy excuse. All teams had to deal with it.
When you never hear of the d-line making any plays, it speaks for itself. Maybe KT gets a mention, but outside of that, the d-line play has been non-existent. I always mention the loss of Holland and Breeze being huge. But to go from the D last year to this year, a few players shouldn’t equate to such an absolute drop into turd-ville for an entire defense.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 4:25 am
by jimmy12
Everythingsducky wrote:‘ This team was hurt by no spring ball and no 4th quarter program.’
Lazy excuse. All teams had to deal with it.
When you never hear of the d-line making any plays, it speaks for itself. Maybe KT gets a mention, but outside of that, the d-line play has been non-existent. I always mention the loss of Holland and Breeze being huge. But to go from the D last year to this year, a few players shouldn’t equate to such an absolute drop into turd-ville for an entire defense.
Ok pal-- sky is falling. Not giving excuses, just believe it was a differentiator last year. This year we've fallen in line with everyone else.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 8:11 am
by StevensTechU
Everyone always says that by the third year, that's when it's the new coach's team. I'm looking at the commit list from 2018, ranked #13 by 247 in the country, and it's frankly panned out as one of the worst Oregon recruiting classes I've ever seen.
'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL.
Edit: here's a link to the 2018 class that has two guys going first round in the nfl and then a while lot of nothing.
https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... l/Commits/
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 8:39 am
by ducks5ever
Good teams need a good QB. Shough hasn't done much to convince me that he's the guy. Instead he's already tossed 4 interceptions and many other risky balls against weak pac-12 competition. I get it, he's a new QB but he's already had a year to work with the WR's and we should ideally field a QB that can win us games, not the one we want to develop for the next season. For perspective, Herbert only tossed 4 interceptions in 9 games when he became a starter his freshman year (new OL then too) and he was only on campus for a few months.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 8:48 am
by nogerO
StevensTechU wrote:Everyone always says that by the third year, that's when it's the new coach's team. I'm looking at the commit list from 2018, ranked #13 by 247 in the country, and it's frankly panned out as one of the worst Oregon recruiting classes I've ever seen.
'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL.
Edit: here's a link to the 2018 class that has two guys going first round in the nfl and then a while lot of nothing.
https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... l/Commits/
Mario's inability to see that he needed to play backups last year when we were comfortably ahead (especially Shough FFS!) is biting him in his backside this year. Plus this attitude that we're gonna run it right up the middle because we've got the toughest and bestest O line in the country is pretty troubling. But that's what you get when your coach is a lineman.
Oh well this year doesn't count, right? Just more practice. Well there is that losing to the beevies thing...

Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:53 am
by duck023
ducks5ever wrote:Good teams need a good QB. Shough hasn't done much to convince me that he's the guy. Instead he's already tossed 4 interceptions and many other risky balls against weak pac-12 competition. I get it, he's a new QB but he's already had a year to work with the WR's and we should ideally field a QB that can win us games, not the one we want to develop for the next season. For perspective, Herbert only tossed 4 interceptions in 9 games when he became a starter his freshman year (new OL then too) and he was only on campus for a few months.
Everyone likes to blame the qb but at least when I blamed Herbert it was when the defense was playing great. You can't blame Shough for what happened against Oregon St because there is no way Herbert wins that game.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:57 am
by Duck07
duck023 wrote:
Everyone likes to blame the qb but at least when I blamed Herbert it was when the defense was playing great. You can't blame Shough for what happened against Oregon St because there is no way Herbert wins that game.
Herbert doesn't throw 2 INTs against that defense. In fact, the 2nd INT is very likely a TD with Herbert. Go watch the INT again. You trying to crap on Herbert isn't proving that Shough is the guy we need at QB. He missed on several throws last night that cost us.
There's also the knowledge that we already knew the Defense sucked this year after 3 games and will be reliant upon our Offense to win. Almost as if that's the story of Oregon this millennium.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:58 am
by duck023
nogerO wrote:StevensTechU wrote:Everyone always says that by the third year, that's when it's the new coach's team. I'm looking at the commit list from 2018, ranked #13 by 247 in the country, and it's frankly panned out as one of the worst Oregon recruiting classes I've ever seen.
'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL.
Edit: here's a link to the 2018 class that has two guys going first round in the nfl and then a while lot of nothing.
https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... l/Commits/
Mario's inability to see that he needed to play backups last year when we were comfortably ahead (especially Shough FFS!) is biting him in his backside this year. Plus this attitude that we're gonna run it right up the middle because we've got the toughest and bestest O line in the country is pretty troubling. But that's what you get when your coach is a lineman.
Oh well this year doesn't count, right? Just more practice. Well there is that losing to the beevies thing...

I feel a lot of you guy's only remember winning the Rose Bowl but forgot what that regular season was actually like. Every game Oregon won they barely won except for USC and Utah. In the USC game Shough played great in garbage time and is the main reason that game was such a blow out.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 10:10 am
by duck023
Duck07 wrote:duck023 wrote:
Everyone likes to blame the qb but at least when I blamed Herbert it was when the defense was playing great. You can't blame Shough for what happened against Oregon St because there is no way Herbert wins that game.
Herbert doesn't throw 2 INTs against that defense. In fact, the 2nd INT is very likely a TD with Herbert. Go watch the INT again. You trying to crap on Herbert isn't proving that Shough is the guy we need at QB. He missed on several throws last night that cost us.
There's also the knowledge that we already knew the Defense sucked this year after 3 games and will be reliant upon our Offense to win. Almost as if that's the story of Oregon this millennium.
I'm sorry you can't have one of the best defenses in the country to one of the worst in the country and then blame the sophomore qb for losing. LSU and Alabama lose guy's to the pros all the time an their defense never falls off like Oregon's did this year. I don't want to hate on Herbert but I'm going to bring up some of the old topics I brought up if people are going to pretend like he was this perfect qb that never did anything wrong. Everyone forgets that a huge narrative with Herbert was he couldn't score any points in the 4th quarter so the coach would purposely leave him in the game longer then normally just so he could get some confidence in late game scenario's. I've seen Herbert throw bad interceptions too.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 10:29 am
by buckmarkduck
Shough is okay, probably too 3 qb in the confrence. But this is also probably the worse set of QB's the pac has had in 30 years.
The real issue is our D.
The DL returned a lot of guys, yet they all look like they didn'tift a weight or do cardio all off-season. Especially Austin and now flabby Mac. Have we ever had a DL look so good one year, then go in the toilet the next, the way this one has?
LB- Sewell has been good, although I'd say he hasn't had the impact Dye had as a Fr. Slade, is okay in pass D, but routinely can't get off blocks for at least 5 yards, so the RB has a free 5 yards almost every time. Our OLB are a real problem. I'd like to see Thibs moved to Funa spot. Funa can't even run anymore, can't get off blocks and misses tackles when he gets there.
Safety is what it is. A bunch of guys who don't belong as starters. Picket, Happle ect. Wouldn't be starting at Boise St, why are they starting at UO? Manning should be moved to safety ASAP.
Bottom line, I think some of these Sr, have what our 1998 team had. They are only worried about the NFL, and not focused on the team. We also have the injury to Flowe, who should be starting next to Sewell right now.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 10:32 am
by ducks5ever
duck023 wrote:ducks5ever wrote:Good teams need a good QB. Shough hasn't done much to convince me that he's the guy. Instead he's already tossed 4 interceptions and many other risky balls against weak pac-12 competition. I get it, he's a new QB but he's already had a year to work with the WR's and we should ideally field a QB that can win us games, not the one we want to develop for the next season. For perspective, Herbert only tossed 4 interceptions in 9 games when he became a starter his freshman year (new OL then too) and he was only on campus for a few months.
Everyone likes to blame the qb but at least when I blamed Herbert it was when the defense was playing great. You can't blame Shough for what happened against Oregon St because there is no way Herbert wins that game.
I'm not blaming Shough for the loss. Obviously if you give up 41 points, you're probably going to lose the game. As part of rebuilding, you need a new QB too. All I'm saying here is that Shough hasn't shown himself to be the guy and we're probably rebuilding with the wrong starting material. Yeah, ypp is ok but that's because we have some talented WR's who can create separation, get yards after the catch, and snag balls that aren't placed that well. He has his occasional bright spots but just a few of those won't win you games next year either (when the defense hopefully gets it together).
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 11:21 am
by duck023
ducks5ever wrote:duck023 wrote:ducks5ever wrote:Good teams need a good QB. Shough hasn't done much to convince me that he's the guy. Instead he's already tossed 4 interceptions and many other risky balls against weak pac-12 competition. I get it, he's a new QB but he's already had a year to work with the WR's and we should ideally field a QB that can win us games, not the one we want to develop for the next season. For perspective, Herbert only tossed 4 interceptions in 9 games when he became a starter his freshman year (new OL then too) and he was only on campus for a few months.
Everyone likes to blame the qb but at least when I blamed Herbert it was when the defense was playing great. You can't blame Shough for what happened against Oregon St because there is no way Herbert wins that game.
I'm not blaming Shough for the loss. Obviously if you give up 41 points, you're probably going to lose the game. As part of rebuilding, you need a new QB too. All I'm saying here is that Shough hasn't shown himself to be the guy and we're probably rebuilding with the wrong starting material. Yeah, ypp is ok but that's because we have some talented WR's who can create separation, get yards after the catch, and snag balls that aren't placed that well. He has his occasional bright spots but just a few of those won't win you games next year either (when the defense hopefully gets it together).
I don't think he is nearly as talented as Herbert but Shough does know how to move the ball up and down the field. I remember when Burmeister and Locke had a hard time scoring over 10 points its not easy finding a qb that can score 30 points every game.
Re: Rebuilding
Posted: Sat Nov 28, 2020 11:38 am
by GoDucksIn09
The only thing will say with Shough is at some point have to figure out when not to throw the ball or throw it away, and also how to read what the opposing defense is doing. Heard many times where he should have kept the ball and ran with it and that would make a huge difference. The offense is still putting up 30 points a game though which is a number that should by itself win most games.
I do not understand the defense. It has more seniors on it than the offense but over the last year it seems they have forgot how to tackle, how to pressure the quarterback, etc etc. I do not blame Avalos for it because he is not on the field. The defense was told all week about needing to contain Oregon States running back. It seemingly went in one ear and right out the other. Our defense has more 5 star talent on it than the whole team of Oregon State does. The talent level difference is mind boggling, but talent alone does not win games. I truly feel we lose to Washington, and if we make it to the Pac 12 championship lose that game. Maybe we beat Cal but right now, no way we beat the huskies. Personally I am fine with that. Let these prima donnas have the sour taste of how bad their defense is in their mouth all winter. Maybe if they get to play in spring, will come out with the fire and desire to show they are not that bad. I do not see them getting that taste out of mouth in the next month.