Just talking to a some football guys I know. Looking at the running backs we have this season. Do we think any of these guys would start for an Oregon team in the last 20 years? Its a resounding no. So lets give the Oline / Coaches a small break as we have some pretty historically bad running backs. I am not talking stats here because stats are a product of the offense that is run. I am talking pure skill to the eye. Verdell has physical tools but the vision of crazy eyes from Mr. Deeds. Baby Dye has the speed but has the strength of gumby and is nothing more than a speed bump in pass protection and has the ball security of Herman Ho Ching. CHL is fine as short yardage back but nothing more. I mean holy yikes we had some lean RB 'crutin years lol.
Would they start over?
Reuben Droughns? No
Mo Morris? No
Onterrio Smith ? No
Terrance Whitehead? No
Johnathan Stewart ? No
Jerimiah Johnson? No
LaGarett Blount? No
LMJ ? No
Kenjon Barner ? No
Royce Freeman ? No
Thomas Tyner ? No
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 8:05 am
by pezsez1
I don't remember Terrance Whitehead being a world-beater until his senior year, and even then he was just solidly serviceable... but otherwise, yeah, all those RBs get the start over our current RBs quite easily.
I'm really miffed over CJ Verdell. He was so much better down the stretch of last season -- and not just because the line was better, but he was legit better at avoiding and breaking tackles -- but this season he all but disappeared. I'm not sure I've ever seen a starting skill player regress as quickly as he has, especially after such improvement.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 9:35 am
by justducky0
Whitehead would be the only "maybe" for me as well, his top end speed was not great but his ability to get YAC far outweigh Verdell or Baby Dye.
Verdells vision has been terrible so if you couple that with spotty offensive line play aka not as many obvious holes you start to understand why he may struggle.
Also watch this play, none of Oregons running backs are making this play
If you combined the best traits of all of our current RBs you probably get Terrance Whitehead. He did have the benefit of playing behind a good OL.
He was a complete RB (run-catch-block) and when you consider that he and Tyner are the only RBs on that list above that were not NFL backs, it makes it all the more impressive the run we've had. He was only a HM Pac 10 RB too.
Gosh Darn that Sweet Golden Voice...
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 11:58 am
by justducky0
Oregon has had a great string of backs that is for sure. It really is disappointing to see the current lineup.
I cringe every time I see Baby Dye run between the tackles or attempt at pass protection. Its almost comical if it was not so bad. I think the coaches might have a blind spot there. I mean look how long it took them to put Kattleman in.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 12:57 pm
by GrantDuck
Travis Dye is averaging 7.5 YPC. He has 200+ yards receiving in 5 games and 3 receiving TD's. He has 1 fumble.
Sure, he's not the pro prospect as some of the guys on that list..but....
I want some of what you are smoking if you think he's "bad".
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 1:11 pm
by karlhungis
I bet these guys would look way better under coach Campbell.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 1:16 pm
by woundedknees
Shoot, Karl, you and I would look decent under Coach Cam... The dude was a running back whisperer!
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 2:37 pm
by karlhungis
woundedknees wrote:Shoot, Karl, you and I would look decent under Coach Cam... The dude was a running back whisperer!
Which is why I think this is an unfair comparison. I think the accurate title should be 2020 RB coaching is historically bad.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:29 pm
by justducky0
GrantDuck wrote:Travis Dye is averaging 7.5 YPC. He has 200+ yards receiving in 5 games and 3 receiving TD's. He has 1 fumble.
Sure, he's not the pro prospect as some of the guys on that list..but....
I want some of what you are smoking if you think he's "bad".
You're missing my premise which is fine as this is an online forum. I don't think anyone who understands football would say Travis Dye is on the level of any of the last 20 years RBs.
Maybe a another way to look at is is, look at Baby Dye and how he plays, scores, gets yardage ect is is there any other back that list that would not be doing what he is doing? The answer is a resounding no.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Mon Dec 14, 2020 8:08 pm
by karlhungis
justducky0 wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:Travis Dye is averaging 7.5 YPC. He has 200+ yards receiving in 5 games and 3 receiving TD's. He has 1 fumble.
Sure, he's not the pro prospect as some of the guys on that list..but....
I want some of what you are smoking if you think he's "bad".
You're missing my premise which is fine as this is an online forum. I don't think anyone who understands football would say Travis Dye is on the level of any of the last 20 years RBs.
Maybe a another way to look at is is, look at Baby Dye and how he plays, scores, gets yardage ect is is there any other back that list that would not be doing what he is doing? The answer is a resounding no.
I think it is impossible to say how he would perform under coach Cam. I think it is fair to say a handful of those guys would have been viewed as busts if they were coached by Mastro instead of Cam. I think Dye could have been pretty impressive under the old system.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Tue Dec 15, 2020 12:15 am
by GoDucksTroll
I’ve said this before that comparing running backs from different eras and offensive systems is difficult. I also think our Arroyo offense was not running back friendly in terms of consistent runs to the second level. That’s as much on the offensive system as it is on the OL and RBs.
* Verdell: would put up great numbers in 2012 for Chip Kelly. He had two 200 yard rushing games in the same season (it’s a rare occurrence even by Oregon standards), his 257 yard rushing and 50+ receiving game against Wazzu is one of the best games ever by a Duck RB. I don’t think he’s as talented as most of those guys, and his durability is a huge issue.
* Travis Dye: he’s been amazing this year and we should be using him more. I don’t think he can be an every down back, but he’s improved so much that I am very impressed and I wasn’t a big fan of him before.
* Cyrus: just use him sparingly near the goal line. I did a big statistical run through last month on why giving him the ball is bad when someone thought I was being overly harsh on him.
This group of running backs is not as bad as people are making them out to be, but they’re certainly not as good as we’ve had and not in the realm of some of those guys. We’ve been lucky and have seen some great backs, so we could be spoiled. Other than Jefferson at OSU who is proven to be a better back in this conference now than CJ or Travis?
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Tue Dec 15, 2020 12:26 am
by Phalanx
The guy at UCLA is pretty good.
I was thinking, "What about Travis?" while reading some of these criticisms. He's been doing pretty well this year. One problem we seem to have this year is being able to run for a first down with any consistency. Verdell doesn't seem right this year - I've heard he might be nursing a hamstring injury. Obviously they don't think much of Dollars, or he would be out there more. Another overrated recruit, apparently.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Tue Dec 15, 2020 1:30 am
by GoDucksTroll
Phalanx wrote:The guy at UCLA is pretty good.
I was thinking, "What about Travis?" while reading some of these criticisms. He's been doing pretty well this year. One problem we seem to have this year is being able to run for a first down with any consistency. Verdell doesn't seem right this year - I've heard he might be nursing a hamstring injury. Obviously they don't think much of Dollars, or he would be out there more. Another overrated recruit, apparently.
Dollars really dropped in the recruiting rankings, from 68th overall to 151st. In 247’s rankings they had 337th and the 45th ranked player in California. When he transferred to Mater Dei he was the backup to a 5’7” RB who was ranked in the 2000s and went to play at Cal Poly. Dollars rushed for 600 yards, other kid for 1,300.
Dollars ran a 4.80 40 at The Opening regional. He has great agility and can move, but maybe he’s just not fast enough. I hope I’m wrong, we’ll have to wait and see.
Re: 2020 Running Backs are Historically bad
Posted: Tue Dec 15, 2020 9:07 am
by justducky0
GoDucksTroll wrote:I’ve said this before that comparing running backs from different eras and offensive systems is difficult. I also think our Arroyo offense was not running back friendly in terms of consistent runs to the second level. That’s as much on the offensive system as it is on the OL and RBs.
* Verdell: would put up great numbers in 2012 for Chip Kelly. He had two 200 yard rushing games in the same season (it’s a rare occurrence even by Oregon standards), his 257 yard rushing and 50+ receiving game against Wazzu is one of the best games ever by a Duck RB. I don’t think he’s as talented as most of those guys, and his durability is a huge issue.
* Travis Dye: he’s been amazing this year and we should be using him more. I don’t think he can be an every down back, but he’s improved so much that I am very impressed and I wasn’t a big fan of him before.
* Cyrus: just use him sparingly near the goal line. I did a big statistical run through last month on why giving him the ball is bad when someone thought I was being overly harsh on him.
This group of running backs is not as bad as people are making them out to be, but they’re certainly not as good as we’ve had and not in the realm of some of those guys. We’ve been lucky and have seen some great backs, so we could be spoiled. Other than Jefferson at OSU who is proven to be a better back in this conference now than CJ or Travis?
This is a good point, Verdell is the only one that has the physical tools to stack up with the backs on the list I provided above. In my mind I look at these guys and I compare them 1v1 with the RBs of the past and go if you have to start 1 who do you go with and non of the current running backs start in my mind over the running backs on the list.