Page 1 of 2

Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 2:23 pm
by StevensTechU
For the folks that think the title is true, Oregon high school football had 7 all-Pac-12 selections this year, including 5 on the first team.

Offense:
QB- Sam Noyer, Colorado, 2nd team (Beaverton HS)
OL- Jaxson Kirkland, uw, 1st team (Jesuit HS)
OL- Alex Forsyth, Oregon, 2nd team (West Linn HS)

Defense:
DL- Osa Odigizuwa, UCLA, 1st team (David Douglas HS)
DL- Marlon Tuipulotu, USC, 1st team (Central HS)
DB- Talanoa Hufanga, USC, 1st team, Defensive Player of the Year (Crescent Valley HS)
DB- Elijah Molden, uw, 1st team (West Linn HS)

Good players come from everywhere.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 2:32 pm
by Duck07
Sam Vidlak from Hidden Valley is going to the perfect coach and offense for his skillset and I'd wager before he's done he'll see his name on that list someday.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 2:48 pm
by mrpd21
What's garbage is that only one player is on roster at an in-state university. That has to change.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 3:05 pm
by SuperDuck
StevensTechU wrote:For the folks that think the title is true, Oregon high school football had 7 all-Pac-12 selections this year, including 5 on the first team.

Offense:
QB- Sam Noyer, Colorado, 2nd team (Beaverton HS)
OL- Jaxson Kirkland, uw, 1st team (Jesuit HS)
OL- Alex Forsyth, Oregon, 2nd team (West Linn HS)

Defense:
DL- Osa Odigizuwa, UCLA, 1st team (David Douglas HS)
DL- Marlon Tuipulotu, USC, 1st team (Central HS)
DB- Talanoa Hufanga, USC, 1st team, Defensive Player of the Year (Crescent Valley HS)
DB- Elijah Molden, uw, 1st team (West Linn HS)

Good players come from everywhere.

Are you still stuck on that? That was YEARS ago!

I never said that Oregon HS football is garbage. What I said was I thought (at that time) that Oklahoma HS football was superior. That was a long time ago. Probably at least 5-7 years, if not more.

Honestly, I have no idea who has the best HS recruits at this point and time. I've been out of the loop for many years on HS football from both states, so I can't provide an informed decision.

Bygones, man. I respect your knowledge and enjoy reading your posts.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 3:32 pm
by StevensTechU
I literally spit out my water laughing. This post had absolutely nothing to do with you ^^. 99% of the time, I don't remember who on the board says what, because everyone has a variation of "Duck" in their name. Also, I wasn't on this board 5-7 years ago, so I think you're really taking something personal that wasn't directed your way. lol

Only person I can generally pinpoint their posts is Alan. I'm hopeful that I'll crack a Coors with Alan someday when this pandemic is over. Pezsez (sp) is memorable, too.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 4:44 pm
by SuperDuck
StevensTechU wrote:I literally spit out my water laughing. This post had absolutely nothing to do with you ^^. 99% of the time, I don't remember who on the board says what, because everyone has a variation of "Duck" in their name. Also, I wasn't on this board 5-7 years ago, so I think you're really taking something personal that wasn't directed your way. lol

Only person I can generally pinpoint their posts is Alan. I'm hopeful that I'll crack a Coors with Alan someday when this pandemic is over. Pezsez (sp) is memorable, too.
Okay. No harm, no foul.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 6:09 pm
by GoDucksTroll
I was thinking about this earlier in the year when I saw that Samari Toure was a stud at Montana, Happle came here, and Sam Noyer was starting. That Oregon HS class of 2016 wound up way better than Washington’s. The 2017 class had some real studs.

Oregon recruits are generally underrated. It’s difficult to evaluate them when the overall talent level is low. Doesn’t mean that there aren’t stars to be found.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Tue Dec 22, 2020 6:43 pm
by StevensTechU
And you throw in that if Brady Breeze would've played this year, he's all-conference if he picks up where he left off last season.

I don't think Oregon HS football is anything special. On a per capita basis, Oregon probably produces one of the lowest levels of Power 5-quality players of any state or territory because of how many D1 football players are black or Polynesian and Oregon doesn't have many of either population. All that said, there are still 4 million people in the state, and there are bound to be some good players, so you don't want to discount the good ones. There are Myles Wades and Thomas Tyners, but there are also Jordan Poyers, Justin Herberts, and Kendrick Bournes.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 2:46 am
by alxtw
mrpd21 wrote:What's garbage is that only one player is on roster at an in-state university. That has to change.
We were at our low, lost our identity, and transitioning between head coaches during those years. If we were in our current state and on field production during the years of recruiting those in-state prospects, we probably could have gotten any of those guys if we wanted them. (Excluding Marlon, who was originally a cali kid)

A few Oregon kids, who are currently playing well outside of the Pac-12, could also be added to that list to support that Oregon HS football isn't trash.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 7:04 am
by whosyourwally
StevensTechU wrote:And you throw in that if Brady Breeze would've played this year, he's all-conference if he picks up where he left off last season.

I don't think Oregon HS football is anything special. On a per capita basis, Oregon probably produces one of the lowest levels of Power 5-quality players of any state or territory because of how many D1 football players are black or Polynesian and Oregon doesn't have many of either population. All that said, there are still 4 million people in the state, and there are bound to be some good players, so you don't want to discount the good ones. There are Myles Wades and Thomas Tyners, but there are also Jordan Poyers, Justin Herberts, and Kendrick Bournes.
Man, I loved Tyner. His last year, when he was healthy, he was our best back. That spin move against Stanford......


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 8:33 am
by buckmarkduck
Now do Utah, who has almost half as many people.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 11:00 am
by GoDucksTroll
buckmarkduck wrote:Now do Utah, who has almost half as many people.
I don’t think Oregon producing great college players is a zero sum game where it means Utah isn’t better. But Utah high school football isn’t questioned as often as Oregon.

Demographic differences have to be accounted for. Utah has a large Polynesian community. Mississippi has a smaller population than Utah, and they produce significantly more top football players. Louisiana, about the same population as Oregon, is even more out of this world. In the last three years Louisiana has had 5 5-stars and 38 4-stars. Demographic and cultural differences.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 4:30 pm
by buckmarkduck
GoDucksTroll wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:Now do Utah, who has almost half as many people.
I don’t think Oregon producing great college players is a zero sum game where it means Utah isn’t better. But Utah high school football isn’t questioned as often as Oregon.

Demographic differences have to be accounted for. Utah has a large Polynesian community. Mississippi has a smaller population than Utah, and they produce significantly more top football players. Louisiana, about the same population as Oregon, is even more out of this world. In the last three years Louisiana has had 5 5-stars and 38 4-stars. Demographic and cultural differences.
I don’t think Oregon HS football is terrible. But I do think when you look around the country and compare it to just power 5 states. It probably produces the least D1 talent of any of those states.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Wed Dec 23, 2020 11:37 pm
by duck023
There are a lot of diamonds in the rough in Oregon. It's not quite California but the top players that come from Oregon are usually pretty solid Keanon Lowe is the perfect example of an Oregon football player.

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2020 11:06 am
by StevensTechU
John Bates (Lebanon HS, Boise St) also just announced that he's leaving BSU to go pro.

I don't think Oregon puts out a ton of high level talent, but what annoys me is when Oregon kids who are clearly talented get discounted because they play in Oregon, and also when the overall quality of Oregon teams gets discounted as it compares to quality of play in other states (such as suggesting Mississippi small school ball is better than Oregon large school ball). In general, the best 6a team in the state in a given year is probably one of the top 150 teams in the country, give or take. They'll still get the doors blown off of them by Bishop Gorman and IMG Academy, but they compare well to the quality of play of most of the country.