bellsduck wrote: Thu Feb 19, 2026 2:39 pm
Sort of funny that a few years ago, tackling was identified as an issue and people blamed lack of hitting during practices. So which is it, do we want better tackling by practicing it during the week, or do we want potentially fewer injuries (there's no proof hitting during practices caused this) through the season? This is where a teams depth becomes so very important.
I guess I am not so much wondering about tackling or hitting by itself, instead, overall long-run fatigue. Maybe something about Lanning attempting too much. Longer practices, more meetings, more slideshows in the auditorium, more time spent doing something in the football building. A program living, eating, and breathing football, great right up to the point it becomes too much... and ends up running on fumes in late December.
If someone wants to suggest simple more tackling doesn't directly mean more injuries I'll certainly listen to the thought. However, more tackling along with more drills, more reps, more film, more meetings, more lifting, more conditioning, I think very likely could lead over time to more injuries.
Again, Muhammed, "It's a tough schedule. It's legit all day... It's lenient in some other programs, but this one is kinda tough."
Something is going on at the end of the last two Duck seasons. As the biggest game of the season has approached, the team has been banged up, had guys out, and has generally looked flat, and after going 13-0 then 13-1, it has barely showed up. Ohio State packed it in early at 41-15 and it probably should have been worse, Indiana seemed bored scoring on Oregon at 56-15.
Depth is great but so is having one's starters. Ohio State and Indiana (2024/2025) made it to their 16th game of the year with all their skill starters.
Indiana/Miami 2025: Mendoza (16-27-186), Black (17-79), Hemby (19-60), Cooper (5-71), Sarratt (3-28), Becker (4-65), Nowakowski (2-17)
Ohio State/ND 2024: Howard (17-21-231), Judkins (11-100), Henderson (12-49), Smith (5-88), Egbuka (6-64), Tate (2-31), Scott (1-4)
These teams when first blasting Oregon, Stewart was out (both games), James (who had almost 1300 yards) took a hard hit early and went to the locker room and never returned, Davison, Whittington, and Limar were all gone for Indiana, Dakorian and Bryant did return later in the year (but neither really looked 100%). Sadiq famously had 29, 22, 19, and 11 receiving yards his last 4 games (5.4 ypc/0 TDs). Throw in losing your LT in the second quarter one game as well.
Indiana and Ohio State were good; but, limping into both games and getting blasted still isn't really explained by just playing a talented opponent. Maybe losing by 10-14 would fit that narrative, not getting eviscerated.