What is your top 10?

[UOducksTK1]

Here's mine...

#1 Oregon
#2 Auburn
#3 Oklahoma
#4 Boise State
#5 TCU
#6 Michigan State
#7 LSU
#8 Alabama
#9 Utah
#10 Stanford

[ducksrock]

I cant disagree with this selection...Lets see how it plays out....

[ducks1311]

#1 Oregon
#2 Auburn
#3 Oklahoma
#4 Boise State
#5 Michigan St.
#6 Bama
#7 Stanford
#8 Oklahoma St.
#9 TCU
#10 Utah

[bfrees23]

#1 Oregon
#2 Auburn
#3 Boise State
#4 TCU
#5 Michigan St.
#6 Oklahoma
#7 Oklahoma St
#8 Stanford
#9 Utah
#10 Alabama

I don't understand why everyone is okay with Oklahoma being ranked so high. They have played ONE road game (cinci who is 3-3) and one neutral site game with Texas, had a hard time with Utah St. @ home (not Utah...Utah STATE), Struggled with Air Force @ home. They have a decent win against Florida St, and Jeckle and Hyde Texas.
I for one am not impressed with Oklahoma!
I would love to see an Oregon vs Oklahoma for the championship! I think Oregon would man handle them!
I'm not counting my ducks yet, because Oregon has a LOT of tough games ahead of them!, but honestly.......Oklahoma?

[duckgrad99]

If you're an Oregon fan, I don't think you can complain about other teams being ranked "too high". To be fair, the ducks haven't beaten anyone good except for Stanford so far.

[bfrees23]

If you're an Oregon fan, I don't think you can complain about other teams being ranked "too high". To be fair, the ducks haven't beaten anyone good except for Stanford so far.

Your absolutly right, they haven't played a tough schedule (not our fault Tennessee sux this year). But, It's hard to argue with the #'s.

I only have a probs with Oklahoma and LSU being in the top 10. I would have been more comfortable with Auburn being #1 in the BCS.

[bellsduck]

#1. Oregon
#2. Boise St
#3. TCU
#4. Auburn
#5. Utah
#6. Oklahoma
#7. Michigan State
#8. Oklahoma St
#9. LSU
#10. Alabama

[wheaton4prez]

I think that the rankings should be 100% objective, based on points. So, my ranking follows Sagarin's points only column:

#1 Oregon
#2 Stanford
#3 TCU
#4 Boise State
#5 Alabama
#6 Missouri
#7 Oklahoma
#8 South Carolina
#9 Florida State
#10 Nebraska

These rankings may be shocking to some. But, they are all supported by how teams performed on the field against opponents of various strengths. For example, Auburn needed over-time to beat 3-3 Clemson and LSU only beat 2-4 UT by 2 points, bringing their ratings down. At the same time, teams that have one or even two losses are not necessarily worse (on average) than undefeated teams. For example, South Carolina who gained a lot of merit by beating Alabama by 14 (who had been blowing everyone out).

The only thing I would change is to add a cap on points counted. That might make some adjustments for teams with lots of cupcakes (including Oregon this year). But, I don't think it applies as much for this example because the purpose of the cap would be to discourage running up scores. Since doing that doesn't count and coaches know that, it shouldn't have been a factor this year. Although, some personalities are probably more inclined to run up scores than others and that could skew the results some.

[Zyme]

#1)Dux
#2)BSU
#3)TCU
#4)Ok
#5)MSU
#6)Utah
#7)Auburn
#8)Missouri
#9)Ok St
#10)LSU
#11)Stanford (lost to #1)
#12)Florida State (lost to #4)
#13)Ohio St (lost to team in the teens)
#14)Alabama (lost to a team in the twenties)
#15)WVU (best big east team, and its not even close, big east needs some love in the top 15)

[Supreme]

1. Oregon
2. Boise State
3. Auburn
4. Oklahoma
5. TCU
6. Alabama
7. Michigan State
8. LSU
9. Utah
10. Missouri