Byron Marshall
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
- Juice
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 685
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:19 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Byron Marshall
okay we get it... you don't like tra carson.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Byron Marshall
Yes, I did watch the ASU game last season, I was in the ASU section courtesy of Omar Bolden. If you want to base your entire projection of next years team off of that game while failing to even mention DT being injured early in the 3rd then I really shouldn't even bother responding to you frankly. Here's another thing you failed to think about? When was the last time an Oregon RB went a full year uninjured? Trying to preface all of this behind the notion that it won't happen unless an injury occurs is absurd and about as obtuse as one can get in a "projection."gogreen55 wrote:Did you watch the Arizona State game this past season? That was a mini preview of what is to come, against a good opponent in a close game with LMJ injured. Barner carried the bulk of the load at RB, DAT was the primary backup RB while also factoring into the passing game (just like he will next season) and Carson was a non-factor with 1 carry. I am not saying that Carson is necessarily going to be a non-factor this upcoming season, but being a "different" back didn't get him more carries than Barner or DAT this past season and there is absolutely no reason to believe being "different" will get him more carries than either of them next season. The reason for this is because the coaches don't give a rat's ass about players being "different," they care about getting the ball to their best players. Barner and DAT are clearly the best running backs on the roster, thus they will get the bulk of the carries.Duck07 wrote:Now it might be more realistic if Carson only gets around 800 yards and falls short of 1000 but either way I don't think KB gets as many carries per game as LMJ did the last two years and that means more of those "bulk" carries will go to Carson in my estimation because he's an entirely different back than KB or DAT.
Seriously though, barring injuries, there is a 0% chance Carson breaks 1,000 yards next season.
Now as far as rat's asses go, last year our top 3 rbs were LMJ, KB and DAT. Do you seriously expect KB and DAT to fill that 1,800 yard void all by themselves? Right now its more likely that this team becomes a more run heavy team next season than a balanced one because we've got 3 good rb's returning as opposed to 0 wrs. Spring ball will tell us a lot, but right now there is nothing absurd about believing that Carson could get around 800-1000 yards rushing, especially when you consider that it's not unreasonable to imagine Tra getting around 130-150 carries next and about 500 carries between KB, DAT and Tra. At 5.6ypc that puts him around 850 yards. It's much more likely for Tra to get around 10 carries a game than for DAT over the course of an entire season but DAT will have more total yards while we play to each player's strength.

-
gogreen55
- Senior
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:39 pm
Re: Byron Marshall
Yeah, what was I thinking? It is absolutely crazy for me to look at an actual game that LMJ missed and see how the coaches handled it. Instead, I should base it on what you did, which is....what exactly? Oh yeah, absolutely nothing other than your silly theory that the coaches are going to give the "bulk" carries to a player because he is "different" rather than actually better.Duck07 wrote:If you want to base your entire projection of next years team off of that game while failing to even mention DT being injured early in the 3rd then I really shouldn't even bother responding to you frankly.
Look, let me spell this out again in clear terms. As I said in my previous post, you can look at that specific game, or you can look at the entire season as a whole. Any which way you look at, both Barner and DAT got more carries than Carson because they are better running backs in this offense. Hello? This is pretty straight forward stuff. Better, not different. There is no logical reason to believe this philosophy will change next season, based on the past actions of the pertinent coaches and based on simple common sense.
You don't need to look any further back than last season for a season in which the running back health was good enough to prevent the #3 running back from reaching 1,000 yards rushing. Or the season before that. Or the season before that....you get the idea. In fact, despite LMJ missing a couple games last season, the health at RB was good enough to prevent the #2 running from even reaching 1,000 yards. Same with the season before that, and the season before that.....you get the idea. Great question though.Duck07 wrote:When was the last time an Oregon RB went a full year uninjured? Trying to preface all of this behind the notion that it won't happen unless an injury occurs is absurd and about as obtuse as one can get in a "projection."
Furthermore, most projections aren't based on players on top of the depth chart encountering catastrophic, season ending injuries. Of course, it is always a possibility, which is why people qualify their statements with terms like "barring injury," as I did in my previous post. You do provide some quality, unintentional comedy by claiming that is "absurd" though.
You are asking me if I expect KB and DAT will rush for a combined 1,800 yards next season? "Barring injury," that is a given.Duck07 wrote:Now as far as rat's asses go, last year our top 3 rbs were LMJ, KB and DAT. Do you seriously expect KB and DAT to fill that 1,800 yard void all by themselves?
Good lord. It seems to be a theme here, but I think you will find your above statement to be proven completely off base next season. If anything, next season will likely feature a stronger passing game. A senior QB at the controls, Huff presumably will be healthier than he was this past season, Rahsaan Vaughn's speed will be a bigger factor in the offense with a year under his belt, guys like Dungy, Lowe and Hawkins got a little seasoning and there will be an influx of speed and talent with the receivers that redshirted. Even with losing Paulson and Tuinei, all things considered, I would expect Thomas to have bigger passing numbers next season as a senior.Duck07 wrote:Right now its more likely that this team becomes a more run heavy team next season than a balanced one because we've got 3 good rb's returning as opposed to 0 wrs.
Anyway, there is no use to continue going around and around in circles on this topic any more than I already have. Feel free to bookmark this thread and pull it up at the conclusion of next season. When Carson finishes the season with about half the rushing yards you are expecting (assuming he is able to win the #3 RB spot), I will refrain from saying I told you so.
-
gogreen55
- Senior
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:39 pm
Re: Byron Marshall
I actually like Tra just fine. Pointing out things like he isn't as fast as J Stew isn't being a hater, in my view. It is just reality.swagnatic101 wrote:okay we get it... you don't like tra carson.
Coach Campbell told Tra that he needed to get faster in order to get a scholarship offer from Oregon. He was being honest.
-
bigfootlebowski
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 427
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:10 am
Re: Byron Marshall
Actually I like any back...that with LMJ, DAT, and Barner ahead of him still was far enough along to NOT redshirt...He will be good but as we know isnt the speed burner, we havent had that bruiser fb type player...so basically maybe Carson is more of FB than RB...and he will help us down the road, but he isnt the guy that takes it up the middle makes one move and is gone, rather letrs say its teh 4th qtr the d is getting tired and we need to run clock he will be good for running over people and getting tough yardage...hes no DAT but they did lift his redshirt for a reason...gogreen55 wrote:I actually like Tra just fine. Pointing out things like he isn't as fast as J Stew isn't being a hater, in my view. It is just reality.swagnatic101 wrote:okay we get it... you don't like tra carson.
Coach Campbell told Tra that he needed to get faster in order to get a scholarship offer from Oregon. He was being honest.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Byron Marshall
Yup, I was right about you being obtuse for sure. So how do you see roughly 600 carries and 4000 yards rushing being dished out next season?

- UofO8
- Senior
- Posts: 2538
- Joined: Wed Nov 04, 2009 3:41 pm
Re: Byron Marshall
Pfft, 2k for Barner and 2k for DaT! DUH!Duck07 wrote:Yup, I was right about you being obtuse for sure. So how do you see roughly 600 carries and 4000 yards rushing being dished out next season?
I think Tra stole someones lunch money

- Boom
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5816
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
- GM: Houston Rockets
Re: Byron Marshall
He just doesn't get it.Duck07 wrote:Yup, I was right about you being obtuse for sure. So how do you see roughly 600 carries and 4000 yards rushing being dished out next season?
Barner & DAT will be our 2 best players on offense next season. Chip's going to have them on the field at the same time. Not rotating snaps...
With Barner back for next season... I don't see DAT moving away from the TZR position. He's was our top receiver this year and we're only getting younger at that position.
And unless Bryan Marshall is some kind of freak... Carson will be the primary backup at RB guaranteeing him 150+ carries next season.
And about the ASU game... Barner will not be taking 30+ carries next year... Carson was never in the primary game plan last year and 1 week of practice wasn't going to change that. That was a terrible example.