2012 Recruiting

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39362
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by greenyellow »

mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Image
squintsdd
Senior
Posts: 2108
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:39 am

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by squintsdd »

greenyellow wrote:
mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research
User avatar
ksmack
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 356
Joined: Wed Jan 06, 2010 12:40 am

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by ksmack »

I think that guy was a beaver fan and an imposter! :lol:

First to get Buckner and Kyle long and Bair..Pharaoh brown and Dwayne stanford those are huge gets! Balducci is no drop off either.

and by the way the coaches aren't done yet, to lock up so more talent. JUst be patient and wait and see. Quack!

I understand the weather is depressing so you decided to create this discussion. but really? I will look at it this way you forgot to take your Prozac this am. We all will let this one go! Go Ducks.
Its Otime everytime, Quack loud and Proud!
User avatar
Boom
All Pac-12
Posts: 5816
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
GM: Houston Rockets

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by Boom »

greenyellow wrote:
mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
I think Hamani Stevens probably counts as one of the replacements
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by uodux1212 »

squintsdd wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research
There's always the JC route as well....
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
User avatar
Boom
All Pac-12
Posts: 5816
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
GM: Houston Rockets

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by Boom »

vagusnerve wrote:Either way, this class has some solid talent and will contribute on the field without a doubt. I'm starting to wonder, though, if the core of guys that got us here today (LMJ, KM, DT, Harris, Boyett, Clay) is more of an anomaly... I think once those guys graduate we may not see replacements that are nearly as good, and we may have been taking for granted that the coaches recruited some really talented players that we haven't appreciated enough.
:lol: Have you not been following recruiting for the last 3 years!? :lol:

The coaches have loaded this team with talent.

One could easily argue that our future core guys are more talented than the ones you listed

time will tell
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by vagusnerve »

squintsdd wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research

What? When did I ever say in the OP that the Ducks have done a poor job recruiting? The people replying on this thread obviously didn't read what I wrote.

It wasn't negative at all. Let's all face that fact that the Ducks missed out on their top targets at OL and WR. Doesn't mean I want to hang coach Kelly just because I point that out.

Wow.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by ncduck »

I just said I was surprised that we only have one OL. I didn't say we failed. I also said we had a really good class.

What's not surprising about us only having one known OL commit at this point? We have three roster spots available to fill, yet we only have one guy who will only play one year.

I'm most surprised about it due to the solid recruiting we had just last year. It seems like someone just turned off the faucet.

If you are not surprised, did you expect us to have basically no long term people on the line in this class? Of course you didn't expect it, that's why it's surprising.

Again, for the zillionth time, good class, great depth already on the roster, not freaking out. Just surprised. Nothing wrong with that.
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by vagusnerve »

ncduck wrote: Again, for the zillionth time, good class, great depth already on the roster, not freaking out. Just surprised. Nothing wrong with that.
Which is essentially what I said in the original post. Someone call off the dogs they're hungry.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39362
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by greenyellow »

vagusnerve wrote:
ncduck wrote: Again, for the zillionth time, good class, great depth already on the roster, not freaking out. Just surprised. Nothing wrong with that.
Which is essentially what I said in the original post. Someone call off the dogs they're hungry.
Kind of what I was saying also.
Image
mijaha
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 139
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 12:33 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by mijaha »

greenyellow wrote:
mijaha wrote:
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.

This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.

We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.

However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.

How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??

In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
My thoughts were, Chip isn't done yet, Still holding out for a surprise OL recruit before NLI day
I've gotta think he knew this was going to be a long process, and with 17 year olds, its who's there last in some cases. Notice all the de-commits and kids who are still available
woundedknees
All-American
Posts: 12826
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:06 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by woundedknees »

So, if the Ducks add Thomas Johnson, Poutasi, and by some freak of fate, Armstead, where will they be ranked?
Autzen Stadium... Where great teams go to die...Hard!

Image
ducksvb6
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 494
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:18 pm
Location: San Diego

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by ducksvb6 »

This is a quick summary of our OLine candidates for next year. We have depth and youth. Johnstone and Yuretagoyena will compete immediately. I didn't check on year status but I think York is the only Senior. Correct me if that's wrong. Center is set with Grasu for at least two more years and maybe three. That leaves sixteen candidates for four positions. i think we will survive at OLine.

54 Hamani Stevens
55 Hroniss Grasu
57 Trevor Fox
58 James Escher
60 Ryan Clanton
61 Nick Cody
62 Matt Pierson
63 Mana Greig
64 Tyler Johnstone
68 Jamal Prater
69 Brandon Thomas
71 Everett Benyard
72 Andre Yuretagoyena
75 Jake Fisher
77 Carson York
78 Karrington Armstron
Kyle Long
Stetzon Blair
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by vagusnerve »

woundedknees wrote:So, if the Ducks add Thomas Johnson, Poutasi, and by some freak of fate, Armstead, where will they be ranked?
The answer is it would depend on the service... none of which are particularly accurate.

It just goes back to my original point. I'll restate it a bit more clearly: the coaches have a board and know who they want. Guys like Robert Lewis, rumoured to be visiting soon, aren't high on their board. He's the type of guy they'll take if everything else falls through. Bryan Harper, another recent offer, is in the same boat.

The two positions where the coaches aren't landing their top guys are OL and WR.

The coaches could end up grabbing Poutasi, or even Peat or Murphy at OL. If so, it's a jackpot. Otherwise, they'll probably be forced to bring in a SDSU or Fresno type of guy.

Thomas Johnson would be an awesome addition at WR. But if he doesn't come we're looking at guys like Javon Williams (who doesn't even have an offer from the Ducks yet) or Robert Lewis.

It doesn't matter where the Ducks are ranked at the end of the year, it matters if the coaches are getting the players they want.
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: 2012 Recruiting

Post by maxduck »

ducksvb6 wrote:This is a quick summary of our OLine candidates for next year. We have depth and youth. Johnstone and Yuretagoyena will compete immediately. I didn't check on year status but I think York is the only Senior. Correct me if that's wrong. Center is set with Grasu for at least two more years and maybe three. That leaves sixteen candidates for four positions. i think we will survive at OLine.

54 Hamani Stevens
55 Hroniss Grasu
57 Trevor Fox
58 James Escher
60 Ryan Clanton
61 Nick Cody
62 Matt Pierson
63 Mana Greig
64 Tyler Johnstone
68 Jamal Prater
69 Brandon Thomas
71 Everett Benyard
72 Andre Yuretagoyena
75 Jake Fisher
77 Carson York
78 Karrington Armstron
Kyle Long
Stetzon Blair
I believe Blair is scheduled for D line. A couple days ago Moseley did his recap of the offensive line. His projection...
PROJECTING 2012
LT: Ryan Clanton, Sr.; Kyle Long, Sr.; Tyler Johnstone, RFr.; Andre Yruretagoyena, RFr.
LG: Carson York, Sr.; Mana Greig, Jr.; Jamal Prater, RFr.
C: Hroniss Grasu, So.; Karrington Armstrong, Jr.; Hamani Stevens, So.
RG: Nick Cody, Sr.; Trevor Fox, Jr.
RT: Jake Fisher, So.; Everett Benyard, Jr.; James Euscher, RFr.; Matt Pierson, RFr.; Brandon Thomas, So.
THOUGHTS: With three full-time starters and two experienced backups slotted into the starting spots, this looks like a group the Ducks can win with. The reserves aren't all that experienced, but the same could have been said of the 2011 offensive line for Oregon, and it held up pretty well. The versatility of players like Cody, Clanton, Fisher, Armstrong and Benyard will mean the Ducks can be flexible with their starting lineup and also in incorporating backups in the rotation. It looks like another group that, while it may not garner a bunch of postseason honors, can get the job done for the Oregon offense.

http://www2.registerguard.com/cms/index ... sive-line/
Post Reply