Perspective on this recruiting class.

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by Duck07 »

Since some of our fowl friends are experiencing what I like to call R.A.D. or Recruiting Affective Disorder which is a mood disorder whereby one's emotional state and well-being are influenced by the numerous items pertaining to College Football Recruiting and the National Signing Day. These are but not limited to: 17 year old boys playing games with their recruiters, perception of one team's class versus yours, and usually include the imaginative machinations of what said recruit could do followed by disclaimers.

This symptom is usually cured by first pressing the Green Button below
Image
and taking a big deep breath.
Image
Those Chrome Helmets pack quite the punch!
Followed by reading the in-flight magazine located under your seat titled "The Duck07 2012 Class Perspective"

In this manual you will find these interesting thoughts and concepts beginning with an introduction by Don Duckleone reminding you to do what's best for you:

"First off, why are you questioning the Overlord Chip Kelly? Don't you know you that Sith Lord P.K. has a machine that tracks all of this and he sends it Santa? Yea, you just messed up your kids Christmas next year. Now, my friend Duck07 has something he'd like to say."

Alright, first thing to understand with this class is that we have a LOT of underclassmen already on the team and yes that makes a difference with landing recruits. Next, we have gotten a lot players in this class that can either contribute right away or sooner rather than later in their careers. Let's just look at this from a position by position basis.

QB: Rodrigues and Lockie. I don't believe there is a QB that we could have gotten in this class that would legitimately challenge BB or MM (and certainly not DT had he stayed like was assumed for so long) this spring or fall. Both of these guys look like ideal fits for what Chip wants. I'm not going to view a single QB recruit of his be it a 2* or 5* until 1 of his QB's actually under-performs on the field for us. Also, the book isn't even close to being written about the QB race and while its unlikely one of them wins it, one of them may very well make it as the #3.

RB: We all figured that LMJ was going to leave at the beginning of the season and while we held out hope, in the end he did what we long figured would happen. Depth is not an issue unless an inury occurs and guess what, when is that never the case? Byron Marshall is another guy who fits what we do. Perhaps another guy would be nice and this is another crucial thing to remember: there might be one we don't know about. This thing happens all the time in recruiting but even if its just BM, I like his prospects be them in the short or long-term for us.

WR: We had hoped we'd see a bit more from the WR unit and it didn't happen. We have some of the same questions going in but we cannot discount any of the RS's until, again they actually underperform. Yes, Huff and Vaughn both need to step it up, but in looking at who we picked up, Dwayne Stanford is the kind of bigger bodied WR we've missed with Drew Davis gone. If he sees the field next year, which is certainly possible, he'll have been a tremendous pick-up for us.

TE: If you've got a problem with Brown and Bayliss well there's not much I can do for you, really. Both are big, athletic and fast. In time, they'll be pretty strong too and really, the young talent at WR/TE says we could just as easily transition to being a Top 10 passing offense nationally from our where we are as a running team.

OL: I think this is one of the ZOMG! positions based in large part because of the talent to be had. I don't disagree with that at all, it certainly is a very talented OL class. It's also not over. CP (if he commits) and Long would make this a nice class based on adding a few more talented bodies, but we return 7 of our top 10 OL and have some nice depth from last years class so even if we don't have a giant haul (which was unlikely to begin with), our depth says we're not missing much.

Now, before we get into defense, there are the NA fans and detractors. It's obvious which boat I'm in but what's important to remember in this is that a personal bias about what the defense (or offense) "should" do has no bearing on what the coaches will do. So you think this one recruit is going to be an awesome player but he plays an entirely different system, it's unrealistic to expect us to go after them.

DL: Balducci, Bair, Buckner, Carriger, Cottrel, Daniel may not have the combined * ranking some of you would like to see, but when you look at each player, you will find they fit very well with what we want to do. Balducci has dominated as of late. I give a great deal of stock to the Lineman who dominate/outmuscle/outwork their counterparts during all-star practices. I believe it's also been reported that Poutasi (OL), Buckner and OLB Castro all did the same thing. I'll take the guys who beat up the 5* any day of the week over them. Really, that's the best way to describe some of these guys too. They look like they want to beat you up. In a DL, that's a great thing.

LB: Castro and Bafaro. As mentioned above about Castro, he looks like a guy who could play as a true FR. He looks to be another nightmare of LB's that come off the edge for us. I don't know much about Bafaro but we've gotten tremendously better at recruiting LBs and again, once you start looking at the depth, you realize we're trying to find guys that can come in to play a back-up role. We're not having to find starters and that's a good thing for us. Yes, Kwon would have been nice but I don't think from a talent stand-point there is a whole lot "more" we can do with who was reasonable to get.

DB: Amoako twins, Daniels and Dunmore. Just like with RB recruits, if you are going to criticize these guys, Don Duckleone is going to slap you with a glove with Coach Neal's hand on it. Even if Oshay decides to do just T&F, we've got plenty of depth/talent to where we only needed to get guys that fit our system. We got quite a few earlier commitments than we have previously and that speaks to the changes in our program. Guys want to play for Oregon and it's no longer just regionally, its nationally.

Further, we've got a top 25 class. I don't care if it becomes Top 5 or #25, we get the players we need, not the ones that look good. ESPN just re-did the 08 class and guess what, we finished 2nd to Alabama who won 2 NCs during that time. Even while the media hoots and hollars about the "Return of Troi" we've got the better head to head record over the last decade, oh and that thing called 3-Time Defending Conference Champions. I get that LMJ, the greatest RB in team history just left and that DT, one of the best QBs (not the best) left too, but nobody, and I mean nobody expected Dennis Dixon and that 07 team to compete for a NC. Anybody who says otherwise is a liar. Why do I bring this up? Since Chip came to Oregon when has the offense not been amazing? Since he's been Head Coach, we only lose to the nation's best teams and we're considered one of the nation's best.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.


If that doesn't drive home the point to simply enjoy this team and all the absurdities that come with recruiting, then you need my advanced technique!

Image
Image
mijaha
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 139
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 12:33 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by mijaha »

Excellent read, wish all the chicken little's would just take a pause and reflect where we are from where we've been

In Chip I trust
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by maxduck »

I may not always agree with your position but that is a 5 star post and a serious contender for the #1 post of the year!
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by duckfan22 »

+10000000000000000000000000000
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40724
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by UOducksTK1 »


Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8818
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

:lol: Great post man. What people have to realize is we run a unique system. So we don't always want or need all the "nfl prototype" players. Because we are not an nfl prototype team. I would argue that our coaches, for the most part, recruit PERFECTLY. And this class doesn't have the headliner that makes it look pretty but IMO this is the most stacked class we've ever had. Loaded with big time talents from top to bottom. And that is how you build a power house, not with 2-3 5*s to top off an average class ie Cal.
Image
roleplay3r1
One Star Recruit
Posts: 61
Joined: Wed Nov 10, 2010 11:50 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by roleplay3r1 »

Duck07 wrote:Even while the media hoots and hollars about the "Return of Troi" we've got the better head to head record over the last decade
Don't believe that's true. IIRC, USC is 5-4 against the Ducks since 2001.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by Duck07 »

roleplay3r1 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Even while the media hoots and hollars about the "Return of Troi" we've got the better head to head record over the last decade
Don't believe that's true. IIRC, USC is 5-4 against the Ducks since 2001.
yea, I double-checked and you're right. Point still stands that we're the 3x Champs and they still have to win it on the field before its theirs.
Image
User avatar
OreDucks01284
Senior
Posts: 3635
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:29 pm
Location: Salem, Oregon

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by OreDucks01284 »

Duck07 wrote:Since some of our fowl friends are experiencing what I like to call R.A.D. or Recruiting Affective Disorder which is a mood disorder whereby one's emotional state and well-being are influenced by the numerous items pertaining to College Football Recruiting and the National Signing Day. These are but not limited to: 17 year old boys playing games with their recruiters, perception of one team's class versus yours, and usually include the imaginative machinations of what said recruit could do followed by disclaimers.

This symptom is usually cured by first pressing the Green Button below
Image
and taking a big deep breath.
Image
Those Chrome Helmets pack quite the punch!
Followed by reading the in-flight magazine located under your seat titled "The Duck07 2012 Class Perspective"

In this manual you will find these interesting thoughts and concepts beginning with an introduction by Don Duckleone reminding you to do what's best for you:

"First off, why are you questioning the Overlord Chip Kelly? Don't you know you that Sith Lord P.K. has a machine that tracks all of this and he sends it Santa? Yea, you just messed up your kids Christmas next year. Now, my friend Duck07 has something he'd like to say."

Alright, first thing to understand with this class is that we have a LOT of underclassmen already on the team and yes that makes a difference with landing recruits. Next, we have gotten a lot players in this class that can either contribute right away or sooner rather than later in their careers. Let's just look at this from a position by position basis.

QB: Rodrigues and Lockie. I don't believe there is a QB that we could have gotten in this class that would legitimately challenge BB or MM (and certainly not DT had he stayed like was assumed for so long) this spring or fall. Both of these guys look like ideal fits for what Chip wants. I'm not going to view a single QB recruit of his be it a 2* or 5* until 1 of his QB's actually under-performs on the field for us. Also, the book isn't even close to being written about the QB race and while its unlikely one of them wins it, one of them may very well make it as the #3.

RB: We all figured that LMJ was going to leave at the beginning of the season and while we held out hope, in the end he did what we long figured would happen. Depth is not an issue unless an inury occurs and guess what, when is that never the case? Byron Marshall is another guy who fits what we do. Perhaps another guy would be nice and this is another crucial thing to remember: there might be one we don't know about. This thing happens all the time in recruiting but even if its just BM, I like his prospects be them in the short or long-term for us.

WR: We had hoped we'd see a bit more from the WR unit and it didn't happen. We have some of the same questions going in but we cannot discount any of the RS's until, again they actually underperform. Yes, Huff and Vaughn both need to step it up, but in looking at who we picked up, Dwayne Stanford is the kind of bigger bodied WR we've missed with Drew Davis gone. If he sees the field next year, which is certainly possible, he'll have been a tremendous pick-up for us.

TE: If you've got a problem with Brown and Bayliss well there's not much I can do for you, really. Both are big, athletic and fast. In time, they'll be pretty strong too and really, the young talent at WR/TE says we could just as easily transition to being a Top 10 passing offense nationally from our where we are as a running team.

OL: I think this is one of the ZOMG! positions based in large part because of the talent to be had. I don't disagree with that at all, it certainly is a very talented OL class. It's also not over. CP (if he commits) and Long would make this a nice class based on adding a few more talented bodies, but we return 7 of our top 10 OL and have some nice depth from last years class so even if we don't have a giant haul (which was unlikely to begin with), our depth says we're not missing much.

Now, before we get into defense, there are the NA fans and detractors. It's obvious which boat I'm in but what's important to remember in this is that a personal bias about what the defense (or offense) "should" do has no bearing on what the coaches will do. So you think this one recruit is going to be an awesome player but he plays an entirely different system, it's unrealistic to expect us to go after them.

DL: Balducci, Bair, Buckner, Carriger, Cottrel, Daniel may not have the combined * ranking some of you would like to see, but when you look at each player, you will find they fit very well with what we want to do. Balducci has dominated as of late. I give a great deal of stock to the Lineman who dominate/outmuscle/outwork their counterparts during all-star practices. I believe it's also been reported that Poutasi (OL), Buckner and OLB Castro all did the same thing. I'll take the guys who beat up the 5* any day of the week over them. Really, that's the best way to describe some of these guys too. They look like they want to beat you up. In a DL, that's a great thing.

LB: Castro and Bafaro. As mentioned above about Castro, he looks like a guy who could play as a true FR. He looks to be another nightmare of LB's that come off the edge for us. I don't know much about Bafaro but we've gotten tremendously better at recruiting LBs and again, once you start looking at the depth, you realize we're trying to find guys that can come in to play a back-up role. We're not having to find starters and that's a good thing for us. Yes, Kwon would have been nice but I don't think from a talent stand-point there is a whole lot "more" we can do with who was reasonable to get.

DB: Amoako twins, Daniels and Dunmore. Just like with RB recruits, if you are going to criticize these guys, Don Duckleone is going to slap you with a glove with Coach Neal's hand on it. Even if Oshay decides to do just T&F, we've got plenty of depth/talent to where we only needed to get guys that fit our system. We got quite a few earlier commitments than we have previously and that speaks to the changes in our program. Guys want to play for Oregon and it's no longer just regionally, its nationally.

Further, we've got a top 25 class. I don't care if it becomes Top 5 or #25, we get the players we need, not the ones that look good. ESPN just re-did the 08 class and guess what, we finished 2nd to Alabama who won 2 NCs during that time. Even while the media hoots and hollars about the "Return of Troi" we've got the better head to head record over the last decade, oh and that thing called 3-Time Defending Conference Champions. I get that LMJ, the greatest RB in team history just left and that DT, one of the best QBs (not the best) left too, but nobody, and I mean nobody expected Dennis Dixon and that 07 team to compete for a NC. Anybody who says otherwise is a liar. Why do I bring this up? Since Chip came to Oregon when has the offense not been amazing? Since he's been Head Coach, we only lose to the nation's best teams and we're considered one of the nation's best.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.

We're at the point as a school where a single loss may put us out of the NC game and playing in the Rose Bowl is considered a consolation.


If that doesn't drive home the point to simply enjoy this team and all the absurdities that come with recruiting, then you need my advanced technique!

Image
+1000000, great post!
Image
headshottzzzz
One Star Recruit
Posts: 65
Joined: Wed Nov 10, 2010 3:46 am

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by headshottzzzz »

Thank you. Some of these fans going crazy because we don't have any 5* recruits must have only just joined the bandwagon. Oregon's recruiting better than it ever has before, and people are complaining. Just crazy.
User avatar
alabamaduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 873
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:56 pm
Location: Birmingham, Alabama

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by alabamaduck »

Well done sir, well done!
Image
User avatar
nehalem
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 774
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 5:15 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by nehalem »

maxduck wrote:I may not always agree with your position but that is a 5 star post and a serious contender for the #1 post of the year!
Ah man, their's a "post of the year?" I'd have been posting more if I knew that. Didn't read the whole post as I couldn't get past the really impressive airplane pictograms-but I will now.

Don't know if this has been addressed yet, but I'm worried about our lack of recruiting on the OL and DL in this years class. We need that steady trickle of talent each year to avoid those previous boom and bust cycles.

Not fixated on this, but would it be wrong if I nominated myself for "post of the year?" My resume is a little thin and I would consider it a great honor.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40724
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by UOducksTK1 »

maxduck wrote:I may not always agree with your position but that is a 5 star post and a serious contender for the #1 post of the year!
Haha that's actually not a half-bad idea. Gathering the best posts throughout the year and by the end of the year have a free vote. Winner gets boggle and a ducks tshirt.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
nehalem
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 774
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 5:15 pm

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by nehalem »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
maxduck wrote:I may not always agree with your position but that is a 5 star post and a serious contender for the #1 post of the year!
Haha that's actually not a half-bad idea. Gathering the best posts throughout the year and by the end of the year have a free vote. Winner gets boggle and a ducks tshirt.
In all seriousness, and it's hard for me to admit this, not because of any animosity towards duck07, but because of my hyper competitive nature, it's a great post.
User avatar
sickaduck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 466
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:10 pm
Location: Medford

Re: Perspective on this recruiting class.

Post by sickaduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
maxduck wrote:I may not always agree with your position but that is a 5 star post and a serious contender for the #1 post of the year!
Haha that's actually not a half-bad idea. Gathering the best posts throughout the year and by the end of the year have a free vote. Winner gets boggle and a ducks tshirt.
Throw in a Fresca and I will start posting more...
Post Reply