ducksvb6 wrote:This is a quick summary of our OLine candidates for next year. We have depth and youth. Johnstone and Yuretagoyena will compete immediately. I didn't check on year status but I think York is the only Senior. Correct me if that's wrong. Center is set with Grasu for at least two more years and maybe three. That leaves sixteen candidates for four positions. i think we will survive at OLine.
54 Hamani Stevens
55 Hroniss Grasu
57 Trevor Fox
58 James Escher
60 Ryan Clanton
61 Nick Cody
62 Matt Pierson
63 Mana Greig
64 Tyler Johnstone
68 Jamal Prater
69 Brandon Thomas
71 Everett Benyard
72 Andre Yuretagoyena
75 Jake Fisher
77 Carson York
78 Karrington Armstron
Kyle Long
Stetzon Blair
I don't want to burst your bubble bro, but you've got things a bit mixed up.
Bair is DL. Long will only play one year. York may not play his senior year. And you've got a slew of walk ons on the list who are not likely to contribute except on the scout team.
Clanton and Cody will also be seniors... and a couple of those guys haven't panned out like Armstrong and Trevor Fox.
We'll likely see a few young guys play as Rfr next year, and by their Soph years they'll have to step in out of necessity.
The coaches went after multiple top OL prospects but so far have come up empty handed. It's not the end of the world, but it's pretty obvious to everyone that they were going after some guys this year at OL and couldn't bag them. That could change of course.
ducksvb6 wrote:This is a quick summary of our OLine candidates for next year. We have depth and youth. Johnstone and Yuretagoyena will compete immediately. I didn't check on year status but I think York is the only Senior. Correct me if that's wrong. Center is set with Grasu for at least two more years and maybe three. That leaves sixteen candidates for four positions. i think we will survive at OLine.
54 Hamani Stevens
55 Hroniss Grasu
57 Trevor Fox
58 James Escher
60 Ryan Clanton
61 Nick Cody
62 Matt Pierson
63 Mana Greig
64 Tyler Johnstone
68 Jamal Prater
69 Brandon Thomas
71 Everett Benyard
72 Andre Yuretagoyena
75 Jake Fisher
77 Carson York
78 Karrington Armstron
Kyle Long
Stetzon Blair
I don't want to burst your bubble bro, but you've got things a bit mixed up.
Bair is DL. Long will only play one year. York may not play his senior year. And you've got a slew of walk ons on the list who are not likely to contribute except on the scout team.
Clanton and Cody will also be seniors... and a couple of those guys haven't panned out like Armstrong and Trevor Fox.
We'll likely see a few young guys play as Rfr next year, and by their Soph years they'll have to step in out of necessity.
The coaches went after multiple top OL prospects but so far have come up empty handed. It's not the end of the world, but it's pretty obvious to everyone that they were going after some guys this year at OL and couldn't bag them. That could change of course.
ducksvb6 wrote:This is a quick summary of our OLine candidates for next year. We have depth and youth. Johnstone and Yuretagoyena will compete immediately. I didn't check on year status but I think York is the only Senior. Correct me if that's wrong. Center is set with Grasu for at least two more years and maybe three. That leaves sixteen candidates for four positions. i think we will survive at OLine.
54 Hamani Stevens
55 Hroniss Grasu
57 Trevor Fox
58 James Escher
60 Ryan Clanton
61 Nick Cody
62 Matt Pierson
63 Mana Greig
64 Tyler Johnstone
68 Jamal Prater
69 Brandon Thomas
71 Everett Benyard
72 Andre Yuretagoyena
75 Jake Fisher
77 Carson York
78 Karrington Armstron
Kyle Long
Stetzon Blair
I don't want to burst your bubble bro, but you've got things a bit mixed up.
Bair is DL. Long will only play one year. York may not play his senior year. And you've got a slew of walk ons on the list who are not likely to contribute except on the scout team.
Clanton and Cody will also be seniors... and a couple of those guys haven't panned out like Armstrong and Trevor Fox.
We'll likely see a few young guys play as Rfr next year, and by their Soph years they'll have to step in out of necessity.
The coaches went after multiple top OL prospects but so far have come up empty handed. It's not the end of the world, but it's pretty obvious to everyone that they were going after some guys this year at OL and couldn't bag them. That could change of course.
The Ducks are certainly doomed.
Where did I say they were doomed? I critiqued the post because it wasn't accurate. At all.
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.
This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.
We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.
However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.
How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??
In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research
What? When did I ever say in the OP that the Ducks have done a poor job recruiting? The people replying on this thread obviously didn't read what I wrote.
It wasn't negative at all. Let's all face that fact that the Ducks missed out on their top targets at OL and WR. Doesn't mean I want to hang coach Kelly just because I point that out.
Wow.
It's not that you actually say it, it's that you imply it. Your wording implies that oregon missed out on their top targets so they have to settle on mediocre talent. You haven't even seen half the kids from last years class hit the field and you're already comparing this years class to what's leaving. Why don't you wait and see how things pan out before saying that the fans took anything for granted.
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.
This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.
We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.
However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.
How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??
In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research
What? When did I ever say in the OP that the Ducks have done a poor job recruiting? The people replying on this thread obviously didn't read what I wrote.
It wasn't negative at all. Let's all face that fact that the Ducks missed out on their top targets at OL and WR. Doesn't mean I want to hang coach Kelly just because I point that out.
Wow.
It's not that you actually say it, it's that you imply it. Your wording implies that oregon missed out on their top targets so they have to settle on mediocre talent. You haven't even seen half the kids from last years class hit the field and you're already comparing this years class to what's leaving. Why don't you wait and see how things pan out before saying that the fans took anything for granted.
Dude, for the love of god, just because someone is critical of something does not mean that they think the sky is falling.
I don't get the whole "don't question our leader" thing... no coach is perfect, and no team is gonna get every player they want. If you listen to people in the know, they will all tell you the same thing I just did: the OL is a big need in this class and so far the coaches have lost out on their top prospects. As I said above, that may change.
mijaha wrote:
How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??
In Chip I trust
But when they lose multiple OL to graduation, you'd think they would probably replace them in the next class. To have 1 OL in the class and he has possibly only has 1 year to play, that doesn't seem like long-term planning on the coaches' part. That looks like they knew they struck out on some HS players and will try addressing it next year with another large OL class.
Strike outs happen, it doesn't mean we've had poor recruiting like the OP seems think. This thread was started because the OP didn't do his research
What? When did I ever say in the OP that the Ducks have done a poor job recruiting? The people replying on this thread obviously didn't read what I wrote.
It wasn't negative at all. Let's all face that fact that the Ducks missed out on their top targets at OL and WR. Doesn't mean I want to hang coach Kelly just because I point that out.
Wow.
It's not that you actually say it, it's that you imply it. Your wording implies that oregon missed out on their top targets so they have to settle on mediocre talent. You haven't even seen half the kids from last years class hit the field and you're already comparing this years class to what's leaving. Why don't you wait and see how things pan out before saying that the fans took anything for granted.
Dude, for the love of god, just because someone is critical of something does not mean that they think the sky is falling.
I don't get the whole "don't question our leader" thing... no coach is perfect, and no team is gonna get every player they want. If you listen to people in the know, they will all tell you the same thing I just did: the OL is a big need in this class and so far the coaches have lost out on their top prospects. As I said above, that may change.
Yes, Oregon needs OL recruits, but considering what the coaching staff has done with some of the lesser recruited guys in the past I'm not worried. So, you can listen to the guys who are "in the know" and I'll look at the results on the field.
WIth no long term recruits on the OL in this class, there would be no results on the field in this class. This class being the subject matter of the OP.
ncduck wrote:WIth no long term recruits on the OL in this class, there would be no results on the field in this class. This class being the subject matter of the OP.
There were classes before this and there will be after this. We just had a pretty damn good OL class last year, none of which have played yet. I'm not concerned.
We lost three to graduation and haven't filled any. I think long term we want at least a couple guys on the OL in every class so none of our position groups resemble Ernie Kent style recruiting (ie no balance from year to year).
I think that's the point people are making. I also think that everyone is aware that this thing isn't over and that if we can grab Whitaker and maybe another guy, this will be a non-issue.
As is, it's a message board where people discuss things like this ad nauseum. So it makes sense that it's being discussed.