Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Elduderino
Senior
Posts: 2242
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:19 pm
Location: CA

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by Elduderino »

NCDucks09 wrote:
Quack_12 wrote:
NCDucks09 wrote:1. Byron Marshall - With the vacancy of LMJ, Barner needs help and DaT is only a 7-12 carry/game RB, Tra is too slow.
2. Arik Armstead - 6'8", 280lbs DE, with Basketball agility and hops, reminds me of JPP (NY Giants).
3. Bralon Addison - Speedy playmaker that could make a big splash on returns, as a reciever, tazer, or even QB!
4. Dwayne Stanford - 6'5" big-bodied receiver, if he can catch, will be clutch for Bennett's big arm.
5. Stetzon Bair - Do you guys remember Brandon, and how the Ducks develop brothers, I thought so...
6. Amoako Brothers - They remdind me of TJ Ward's size/speed/power, double trouble.

Sleeper: Cody Carriger - 6'6", 230lbs dude that runs a 11.0 second 100m sprint!!! Could play TE or the hybrid DE/OLB for the Ducks. Needs to put on the size and power without losing a step.
LOL say that to his face :lol:
As long as I said it a good 6-10 ft away, it'd be alright because I could just run away... ;)

All jokes aside, I like Tra, but he's no LGB, he's got size, but not quite the same explosion. In the Speed Option, there's no time to work up a head of speed.
Eh, it's too early to tell on Tra. Remember, LGB was fairly well developed when he got here. Tra is still a true freshman--who was able to still average (I think) somewhere around 5 ypc in garbage time when everyone knew we were running the ball. I'm excited to see how this year goes for him; probably will give us a little better sample size.
AKA: CAgrown
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by vagusnerve »

I think Tra will be good because he's got some muscle and some quickness. But elite speed is one thing he does not possess. Sorry.

That doesn't mean he won't thrive in Kelly's system. I think he did a great job as a true freshman and I expect him to carry the ball in competitive games next year. That is, unless Marshall beats him out for the #3 spot.

Barner will get 20 carries a game for sure, with some passes. DAT will get 5-10 carries a game with a lot of slot too. So someone is going to have to pick up the remaining carries, and my best guess is Tra.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by Phenom »

I don't know if Barner will be able to carry the rock 20+ a game for the entire year.
User avatar
TheMaehlMan
Junior
Posts: 1874
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 4:21 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by TheMaehlMan »

Phenom wrote:I don't know if Barner will be able to carry the rock 20+ a game for the entire year.
Agreed, but that isn't a big deal. With Bennett at quarterback there will be more carries coming from the quarterback position this season as well.
Image

Going to miss the Maehl Man
thomas time
Senior
Posts: 4692
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 3:18 am

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by thomas time »

1. Armstead
2. Marshall
3. Stanford
4. Addison
5. Bair
6 Buckner
AugustDuck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 432
Joined: Wed Jul 21, 2010 7:57 am

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by AugustDuck »

thomas time wrote:1. Armstead
2. Marshall
3. Stanford
4. Addison
5. Bair
6 Buckner
I like how, even with Darron gone, your name still works in the foreseeable future with DAT and Tyner.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40718
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by UOducksTK1 »

AugustDuck wrote:
thomas time wrote:1. Armstead
2. Marshall
3. Stanford
4. Addison
5. Bair
6 Buckner
I like how, even with Darron gone, your name still works in the foreseeable future with DAT and Tyner.
+1

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by NCDucks09 »

TheMaehlMan wrote:
Phenom wrote:I don't know if Barner will be able to carry the rock 20+ a game for the entire year.
Agreed, but that isn't a big deal. With Bennett at quarterback there will be more carries coming from the quarterback position this season as well.
You guys are nuts, Barner carried 31 times last year against ASU for 170+ yards while LMJ was out, and that was playing the second half with Bennett. He's basically a carbon copy of LMJ (a little taller and a little heavier and a little slower). He will carry the rock 20-25 times a game, Bennett will carry 5-10 times a game, DaT will carry 5-10 times a game, and Tra or Marshall will get the leftovers.

Injuries are a part of football. Even J.Stewart was hurt all the time and he was the most physically gifted athlete we've seen. RB is a workhorse position, that's why depth is so important. Hence the reason I'm sorry we lost Lache and Dontae last year because with the departure of LMJ lays a heavy burden on Kenjon. We know he'll get banged up and we know that DaT can't carry the ball 20 times a game, so who is going to move the chains for us? Tra or Marshall...
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by Duck07 »

Avg carries per game last 3 seasons: 45, 48, 42.

At 45 rushes/game my pre-spring breakdown looks like this:

KB: 17-19
Tra:8-10
DaT: 6-8
QB: 5-7

Over the course of the season I'd expect those to end up being close to the per game averages. Feel free to gripe about Kenjon not getting eleventy billon carries a game but I just don't see him toting the rock for 25 touches a game and making it a full season, especially when we can expect to shift a few carries to the qb simply taking the ball on the read-option. That and I think we are all drastically dumping on Tra for no reason (don't even talk to me about speed) and completely forgetting the fact that he ran for more yards as a True FR on less carries than the last True FR RB Jonathan Stewart. Snoop had more TD's but that team was so devoid of offensive talent that trying to compare T-White to LMJ/KB and a fr counterpart in DAT is beyond ludicrous. Tra had a stellar season all things considered to for anybody to project that he's going to suck it up next year is foolish. As for DAT, I think most are in agreement that while his carries will go up (55 for 4/game) it will be in the receiving dept where he makes his biggest rise imo (46 rec for 3/game)
Image
AugustDuck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 432
Joined: Wed Jul 21, 2010 7:57 am

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by AugustDuck »

Duck07 wrote:Avg carries per game last 3 seasons: 45, 48, 42.

At 45 rushes/game my pre-spring breakdown looks like this:

KB: 17-19
Tra:8-10
DaT: 6-8
QB: 5-7

Over the course of the season I'd expect those to end up being close to the per game averages. Feel free to gripe about Kenjon not getting eleventy billon carries a game but I just don't see him toting the rock for 25 touches a game and making it a full season, especially when we can expect to shift a few carries to the qb simply taking the ball on the read-option. That and I think we are all drastically dumping on Tra for no reason (don't even talk to me about speed) and completely forgetting the fact that he ran for more yards as a True FR on less carries than the last True FR RB Jonathan Stewart. Snoop had more TD's but that team was so devoid of offensive talent that trying to compare T-White to LMJ/KB and a fr counterpart in DAT is beyond ludicrous. Tra had a stellar season all things considered to for anybody to project that he's going to suck it up next year is foolish. As for DAT, I think most are in agreement that while his carries will go up (55 for 4/game) it will be in the receiving dept where he makes his biggest rise imo (46 rec for 3/game)
I agree that Tra seems to get dumped on by Duck fans on every board. I feel he will get the rock often, as long as he moves the chains and doesn't fumble. Every player doesn't need to be a home run threat as long as he can get 5-6 yards per carry, he will be fine.
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by uodux1212 »

AugustDuck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Avg carries per game last 3 seasons: 45, 48, 42.

At 45 rushes/game my pre-spring breakdown looks like this:

KB: 17-19
Tra:8-10
DaT: 6-8
QB: 5-7

Over the course of the season I'd expect those to end up being close to the per game averages. Feel free to gripe about Kenjon not getting eleventy billon carries a game but I just don't see him toting the rock for 25 touches a game and making it a full season, especially when we can expect to shift a few carries to the qb simply taking the ball on the read-option. That and I think we are all drastically dumping on Tra for no reason (don't even talk to me about speed) and completely forgetting the fact that he ran for more yards as a True FR on less carries than the last True FR RB Jonathan Stewart. Snoop had more TD's but that team was so devoid of offensive talent that trying to compare T-White to LMJ/KB and a fr counterpart in DAT is beyond ludicrous. Tra had a stellar season all things considered to for anybody to project that he's going to suck it up next year is foolish. As for DAT, I think most are in agreement that while his carries will go up (55 for 4/game) it will be in the receiving dept where he makes his biggest rise imo (46 rec for 3/game)
I agree that Tra seems to get dumped on by Duck fans on every board. I feel he will get the rock often, as long as he moves the chains and doesn't fumble. Every player doesn't need to be a home run threat as long as he can get 5-6 yards per carry, he will be fine.
+1 and +1... I think a lot of fans are spoiled with LMJ's play the last 2-3 years, he's the exception, not the rule. We dont need our 2nd/3rd string RB to be a home run threat to score every time he touches the ball, 5-6 per is great. All things considered I thought Tre looked good in the limited carries he got...
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8818
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

^Absolutely. I love what Tra brings to this team. He has great vision & really nice quickness for his size, I think he's going to add an awesome dimension to our run game.
Image
User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by NCDucks09 »

After having Dixon/Snoop/JJ, then Masoli/JJ/LGB, then Masoli/LGB/LMJ/Barner, then LMJ/Barner/Huff, then LMJ/Barner/DaT, you bet I'm a spoiled Duck fan that is used to the kind of Athletes that can take it to the crib on any given carry!!! And why shouldn't I be or have these kind of expectations under the Nike/Kelly recruiting plan? We'll have Marshall/Blackmon/Sumler/Addison pool to select from to keep that string going with Barner/DaT/Huff (Healthy). And Thomas Tyner and who knows what other speedy recruits to pick from in 2013. These are great times to be an Oregon fan...

I like Tra, but he needs to improve on his explosive speed this offseason, if he wants to compete and increase his carries and the time at which he receives his carries. It doesn't really matter how many yards he ran for in HS when compared to LMJ, different season, different competition, too many variables to extrapolate that to compare apples to apples.

I'd look for Marshall to be in the mix early for carries next year, depending on how quickly he assimilates the offense.
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by Duck07 »

NCDucks09 wrote:I like Tra, but he needs to improve on his explosive speed this offseason, if he wants to compete and increase his carries and the time at which he receives his carries.
Yup, nobody has a legitimate reason as to why they expect Tra to suddenly suck next year. Snoop doesn't have explosive speed and he did just fine. Neither did JJ or LGB. Frankly, Kenjon doesn't even have explosive speed. While Tra isn't going to beat any of our rb's in the 40, none of our other rbs play with the extra 30 pounds either which is certainly something this offense needs more than another jitterbug.

By all means though, continue to believe that Tra is going to regress this spring summer and not be a factor next season at all.
Image
User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Rank your top 6 favorite recruits in this class

Post by NCDucks09 »

Duck07 wrote:
NCDucks09 wrote:I like Tra, but he needs to improve on his explosive speed this offseason, if he wants to compete and increase his carries and the time at which he receives his carries.
Yup, nobody has a legitimate reason as to why they expect Tra to suddenly suck next year. Snoop doesn't have explosive speed and he did just fine. Neither did JJ or LGB. Frankly, Kenjon doesn't even have explosive speed. While Tra isn't going to beat any of our rb's in the 40, none of our other rbs play with the extra 30 pounds either which is certainly something this offense needs more than another jitterbug.

By all means though, continue to believe that Tra is going to regress this spring summer and not be a factor next season at all.
Whoa, when did I say Tra would suck and regress, those are words being typed into my fingertips for me...?

We've done pretty well with 'jitterbug' running backs so far...back to back 12 win seasons, a NCG, and a Rose Bowl victory. Yeah, doing just fine with 'jitterbug' rb's.

JJ was pretty explosive off of the line and had great agility.

LGB took awhile to get going, but in the open field, his moves, hurdles, stiff arms, and bashing made it almost impossible to tackle him.

For a 235-240lbs rb, running a 4.48 s 40 is pretty darn explosive = Snoop

AND...one thing that Snoop, LMJ, JJ, Barner, LGB, and DaT all have in common = Instantly Recognizable Talent. And I haven't seen that out of Tra yet. So, while he may improve this offseason and turn out to be a good power back, he also may just stay the way he is. Kind of like Hawkins.
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
Post Reply