Silas Redd

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
KeenanHowry15
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 405
Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2009 1:06 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by KeenanHowry15 »

@ Braveheart

Yeah you bring up good points but i was saying IN MY OPINON

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?

Look back at USC's running game during those (3) games never breaking 140 yards

Does the addition of Redd give you more rushing yards than past games?

Our defense has done a good job keeping your run game at bay, and arguably we have our best defense this year

This will be an interesting matchup to watch to say the least
Image
User avatar
JIDuck97
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 998
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 8:42 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by JIDuck97 »

Here is where I respectfully disagree with Braveheart regarding USC vs. Oregon. Oregon is a defend the run first team so a team has to be able to pass on Oregon in order to successfully do anything with the run. Thus, the previous posters comment about Matt Barkley needing to beat us with his arm is most likely true. Think back to the Auburn/Oregon game. Cam Newton struggled to pass on Oregon and it took forever for Auburn's run game to do anything due to that. Thus the low score. Last year it was Matt Barkley torching Oregon's young corners that got the score up to where it was for USC. Had he not been able to that, in all likelihood the run game would have been bottled up and USC would have scored a lot less. Oregon fans tend to groan when the Oregon D is in a third and 6 kind of situation on the field against a good offense. Third and 3 or 4 and Oregon fans are hoping that the other team is sucker enough to try and run it.
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Braveheart »

KeenanHowry15 wrote:@ Braveheart

Yeah you bring up good points but i was saying IN MY OPINON

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?

Look back at USC's running game during those (3) games never breaking 140 yards

Does the addition of Redd give you more rushing yards than past games?

Our defense has done a good job keeping your run game at bay, and arguably we have our best defense this year

This will be an interesting matchup to watch to say the least
.......yes. He's quicker than the bigger backs we've had Tyler, Bradford,and Stafon. More physical and tough than our outside runners McKnight, Gable, Morgan. He compares well to Moody McNeal, but he's bigger, quicker, and with better COD.
Here is where I respectfully disagree with Braveheart regarding USC vs. Oregon. Oregon is a defend the run first team so a team has to be able to pass on Oregon in order to successfully do anything with the run. Thus, the previous posters comment about Matt Barkley needing to beat us with his arm is most likely true. Think back to the Auburn/Oregon game. Cam Newton struggled to pass on Oregon and it took forever for Auburn's run game to do anything due to that. Thus the low score. Last year it was Matt Barkley torching Oregon's young corners that got the score up to where it was for USC. Had he not been able to that, in all likelihood the run game would have been bottled up and USC would have scored a lot less. Oregon fans tend to groan when the Oregon D is in a third and 6 kind of situation on the field against a good offense. Third and 3 or 4 and Oregon fans are hoping that the other team is sucker enough to try and run it.
Barkley can and will pass on Oregon, I'm not worried about that. I'd like for USC to do an LSU to UO (run the ball and control the clock).
Image
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Silas Redd

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Braveheart wrote:
KeenanHowry15 wrote:@ Braveheart

Yeah you bring up good points but i was saying IN MY OPINON

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?

Look back at USC's running game during those (3) games never breaking 140 yards

Does the addition of Redd give you more rushing yards than past games?

Our defense has done a good job keeping your run game at bay, and arguably we have our best defense this year

This will be an interesting matchup to watch to say the least
.......yes. He's quicker than the bigger backs we've had Tyler, Bradford,and Stafon. More physical and tough than our outside runners McKnight, Gable, Morgan. He compares well to Moody McNeal, but he's bigger, quicker, and with better COD.
Here is where I respectfully disagree with Braveheart regarding USC vs. Oregon. Oregon is a defend the run first team so a team has to be able to pass on Oregon in order to successfully do anything with the run. Thus, the previous posters comment about Matt Barkley needing to beat us with his arm is most likely true. Think back to the Auburn/Oregon game. Cam Newton struggled to pass on Oregon and it took forever for Auburn's run game to do anything due to that. Thus the low score. Last year it was Matt Barkley torching Oregon's young corners that got the score up to where it was for USC. Had he not been able to that, in all likelihood the run game would have been bottled up and USC would have scored a lot less. Oregon fans tend to groan when the Oregon D is in a third and 6 kind of situation on the field against a good offense. Third and 3 or 4 and Oregon fans are hoping that the other team is sucker enough to try and run it.
Barkley can and will pass on Oregon, I'm not worried about that. I'd like for USC to do an LSU to UO (run the ball and control the clock).


If Oregon fumbles the ball three times with one leading to a touchdown and the other two deep in Oregon territory, then go for it.
Image
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Braveheart »

If Oregon fumbles the ball three times with one leading to a touchdown and the other two deep in Oregon territory, then go for it.
If you insist. 8-)
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6483
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Silas Redd

Post by pezsez1 »

Here is where I respectfully disagree with Braveheart regarding USC vs. Oregon. Oregon is a defend the run first team so a team has to be able to pass on Oregon in order to successfully do anything with the run. Thus, the previous posters comment about Matt Barkley needing to beat us with his arm is most likely true. Think back to the Auburn/Oregon game. Cam Newton struggled to pass on Oregon and it took forever for Auburn's run game to do anything due to that. Thus the low score. Last year it was Matt Barkley torching Oregon's young corners that got the score up to where it was for USC. Had he not been able to that, in all likelihood the run game would have been bottled up and USC would have scored a lot less. Oregon fans tend to groan when the Oregon D is in a third and 6 kind of situation on the field against a good offense. Third and 3 or 4 and Oregon fans are hoping that the other team is sucker enough to try and run it.
This, a million times.

Every time Redd carries the ball, taking a throw away from Barkley to Woods & Lee, then advantage Oregon.

The Ducks have always been stellar at stopping the run. Always. It's just the way our defense schemes are designed. We line up to stop the run no matter who's carrying the rock. It could be Silas Redd, or it could be a walk-on. We're still going to cheat the run, go after the QB and trust our secondary to make big plays when things break down.

Oregon's D-line this year may be one of the best in school history... and our linebacker corp will be stellar as well. I don't see anyone, USC included, doing much against us on the ground this year. Anyone who tries too hard will just be wasting their effort.

If USC beats us this season, they'll have to do it the same way they did last season: an awesome game from Barkley, awesome games by Woods/Lee, and an uncharacteristically sloppy game by the UofO offense for at least 2.5 to 3 quarters.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duxball
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 108
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:43 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by duxball »

Brave- it's a pretty neat thing for a die hard fan to come on this site and be informative as well as civil. Thanks for not being a troll. Youre a great fan and always welcome.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: Silas Redd

Post by ncduck »

Agreed. Braveheart does an admirable job of taking and dishing jabs without being offensive. A skill I myself need to work on. You're always welcome here.
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Braveheart »

duxball wrote:Brave- it's a pretty neat thing for a die hard fan to come on this site and be informative as well as civil. Thanks for not being a troll. Youre a great fan and always welcome.
Thank you. Most of you ducks here have been very welcoming, and that's why I continue to frequent this site.
Image
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Silas Redd

Post by uodux1212 »

Braveheart wrote:
duxball wrote:Brave- it's a pretty neat thing for a die hard fan to come on this site and be informative as well as civil. Thanks for not being a troll. Youre a great fan and always welcome.
Thank you. Most of you ducks here have been very welcoming, and that's why I continue to frequent this site.
+1

We've had a few awesome rival fans on the site (bud, AU40) and BH is a great addition. I appreciate an outside opinion every now and then ;)
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Silas Redd

Post by lukeyrid13 »

I think Redd will certainly help USC but I don't think he'll have much of an affect on the usc/oregon game.
Keys to that game
- barkley vs oregon corners
- usc d-line depth and keeping up in 2nd half especially
- mm or bb being able to handle the pressure and pass the ball
- special teams (esp. uo return game)
- turnovers
- oregon's pace

then i think would come usc's running game. For the rest of their pac-12 games though he should be key to them never missing a beat on offense so even if mcneal is having an off game they should be able to handle everyone else
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Kimber45 »

Braveheart wrote:
KeenanHowry15 wrote:@ Braveheart

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?
.......yes. He's quicker than the bigger backs we've had Tyler, Bradford,and Stafon. More physical and tough than our outside runners McKnight, Gable, Morgan. He compares well to Moody McNeal, but he's bigger, quicker, and with better COD.
Let's take a short walk down history lane according to Scout:

2006
Stafon Johnson - 5 *
Emanual Moody - 4 *
Stanley Havili - 4 *
Kenny Ashley - 3 *
Allen Bradford - 5 * (#4 LB)

2007
Joe McKnight - 5 * (#1 RB)
Broderick Green - 4 *
Marc Tyler - 5 * (#2 RB)

2008
Curtis McNeal - 4 *
Brian Baucham - 2 *

2009
No RBs

2010
Dillon Baxter - 5 *
D. J. Morgan - 4 *

2011
Amir Carlisle - 4 *
George Farmer - 5* (converted WR)
Javorious Allen - 3 *

Nobody has done less with running back talent in recent years than USC. Of that list, I'd say that S. Havili is probably the guy who most exceeded his potential.

Silas Redd could very well come into SC and do great things for your running game. If he does, however, I'll credit Penn State for his discipline and toughness - not the prima donna "we breaking bread" course of instruction apparently offered at USC.
Last edited by Kimber45 on Wed Aug 01, 2012 1:16 am, edited 1 time in total.
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Braveheart »

Kimber45 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:
KeenanHowry15 wrote:@ Braveheart

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?
.......yes. He's quicker than the bigger backs we've had Tyler, Bradford,and Stafon. More physical and tough than our outside runners McKnight, Gable, Morgan. He compares well to Moody McNeal, but he's bigger, quicker, and with better COD.
Let's talk a short walk down history lane according to Scout:

2006
Stafon Johnson - 5 *
Emanual Moody - 4 *
Stanley Havili - 4 *
Kenny Ashley - 3 *
Allen Bradford - 5 * (#4 LB)

2007
Joe McKnight - 5 * (#1 RB)
Broderick Green - 4 *
Marc Tyler - 5 * (#2 RB)

2008
Curtis McNeal - 4 *
Brian Baucham - 2 *

2009
No RBs

2010
Dillon Baxter - 5 *
D. J. Morgan - 4 *

2011
Amir Carlisle - 4 *
George Farmer - 5* (converted WR)
Javorious Allen - 3 *

Nobody has done less with running back talent in recent years than USC. Of that list, I'd say that S. Havili is probably the guy who most exceeded his potential.

Silas Redd could very well come into SC and do great things for your running game. If he does, however, I'll credit Penn State for his discipline and toughness - not the prima donna "we breaking bread" course of instruction apparently offered at USC.
I agree 100%. The running-back "stable" was one of Pete Carroll's biggest mistakes near the end of his run. However, it's done with, and things are back to how they were before the stable.
Image
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: Silas Redd

Post by Kimber45 »

Braveheart wrote:
Kimber45 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:
KeenanHowry15 wrote:@ Braveheart

Does Redd have a better skill set than the other SC backs we have faced the past 3 years?
.......yes. He's quicker than the bigger backs we've had Tyler, Bradford,and Stafon. More physical and tough than our outside runners McKnight, Gable, Morgan. He compares well to Moody McNeal, but he's bigger, quicker, and with better COD.
Let's talk a short walk down history lane according to Scout:

2006
Stafon Johnson - 5 *
Emanual Moody - 4 *
Stanley Havili - 4 *
Kenny Ashley - 3 *
Allen Bradford - 5 * (#4 LB)

2007
Joe McKnight - 5 * (#1 RB)
Broderick Green - 4 *
Marc Tyler - 5 * (#2 RB)

2008
Curtis McNeal - 4 *
Brian Baucham - 2 *

2009
No RBs

2010
Dillon Baxter - 5 *
D. J. Morgan - 4 *

2011
Amir Carlisle - 4 *
George Farmer - 5* (converted WR)
Javorious Allen - 3 *

Nobody has done less with running back talent in recent years than USC. Of that list, I'd say that S. Havili is probably the guy who most exceeded his potential.

Silas Redd could very well come into SC and do great things for your running game. If he does, however, I'll credit Penn State for his discipline and toughness - not the prima donna "we breaking bread" course of instruction apparently offered at USC.
I agree 100%. The running-back "stable" was one of Pete Carroll's biggest mistakes near the end of his run. However, it's done with, and things are back to how they were before the stable.
Darn you and your reasonable opinions. ;)
duck55
Senior
Posts: 2157
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:37 am
Location: Keizer OR

Re: Silas Redd

Post by duck55 »

Braveheart wrote:Yeah, I knew it was game set match when locals spotted him with Lane Kiffin, Robert Woods, and Matt Barkley at Roscoe's the other day ago. Roscoe's has helped USC out recruiting so much it's an extension of USC's facilities (IMO). :lol:

[/url]
Hope this doesn't get the NCAA looking into a booster recruiting type violation :oops:
Post Reply