US ARMY BOWL

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

US ARMY BOWL

Post by NCDucks09 »

Impressions:

USC #1 QB Recruit, Max Browne: His mobility looks slow and his deep ball floats. I'm not super impressed with him right now. Although, that floater ball just scored a TD to that 6'7" Derrick Griffin WR.

USC #1 RB Recruit, Justin Davis: Also, not super impressed with him from the limited exposure I've seen so far. His strength looks limited, just saw him get pancaked by a OLB trying to pass block.

Oregon #4 RB Recruit, Thomas Tyner: I've seen only one play he was in on so far, he ran it for 10 yards up the middle and broke about 3 tackles. I'm thinking that there are some politics going on as to who plays in this US Army Bowl because Tyner looked faster and stronger than most on the field when he actually got a carry.

Washington #15 DE Recruit, Joe Mathis: Looked pretty fast and strong for his 255lbs and had a great sack.

Texas A&M: Every WR out there is committing to them right now. I have to wonder how much better Oregon would have been with Johnny Football instead of Super-Mario? Would Oregon have beaten Stanford and be playing in the Natty right now? Or would he have dropped a couple of games that Mariota won earlier in the season, such as, the game at SC?

Louisville #2 WR Recruit, James Quick: Big surprise he declared to the same school that his Dad is alumni of and where his sister runs track, but looking at the Duck hat up there alongside Louisville and tOSU almost had me thinking we might get a surprise commit. Oh, btw, he just caught a deep TD pass from Jeremy Johnson (Auburn commit).

Undeclared #2 RB Recruit, Derrick Green: He looks good going North and South, but reminds me of LGB when running sideline to sideline.

It's fun to get an early impression of these guys and who will boom and who will bust at the next level.
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
User avatar
Diehardduckfan
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 317
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:36 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by Diehardduckfan »

Tyner literally got three carries, only two of which were OK opportunities. They subbed him in a few times (one play at a time), but everytime he came in, they called a passing play and good ol max would either chuck the ball in in accurately or get sacked.
Thomas would only go in for one play at a time and either TenPenny or Elliot would come in and ofcourse they would then call a running play, or a screen pass.
Definitely politics invloved.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by greenyellow »

Diehardduckfan wrote:Tyner literally got three carries, only two of which were OK opportunities. They subbed him in a few times (one play at a time), but everytime he came in, they called a passing play and good ol max would either chuck the ball in in accurately or get sacked.
Thomas would only go in for one play at a time and either TenPenny or Elliot would come in and ofcourse they would then call a running play, or a screen pass.
Definitely politics invloved.
Absolute crap from whomever was coaching today. To not give your fastest player more carries just reeks of dirty politics.
Image
User avatar
TheMaehlMan
Junior
Posts: 1874
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 4:21 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by TheMaehlMan »

Who cares. We all know Tyner is gonna be a stud at Oregon anyway.
Image

Going to miss the Maehl Man
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by Braveheart »

No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
Image
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by brich75 »

Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
Yup no injuries is All we should care a out. We know he is good and so does every team in the PAC 12! Tyner will be great regardless if he got carries in that game or not. Seemed liked USC was getting a ton of touches because they had 12 players out there. Not politics just odds.
Image
ducksrock
Senior
Posts: 2739
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:08 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by ducksrock »

brich75 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
Yup no injuries is All we should care a out. We know he is good and so does every team in the PAC 12! Tyner will be great regardless if he got carries in that game or not. Seemed liked USC was getting a ton of touches because they had 12 players out there. Not politics just odds.

Who is USC? I don't recognize the school letters as anything significant...Are they an up and coming program? I doubt anytime soon.... :lol:
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by brich75 »

ducksrock wrote:
brich75 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
Yup no injuries is All we should care a out. We know he is good and so does every team in the PAC 12! Tyner will be great regardless if he got carries in that game or not. Seemed liked USC was getting a ton of touches because they had 12 players out there. Not politics just odds.

Who is USC? I don't recognize the school letters as anything significant...Are they an up and coming program? I doubt anytime soon.... :lol:
They should be up and coming, but they are sliding at a downward angle! They have a ton of talent but a clown for a coach. Lets just hope he doesn't get fired or we might get to know USC again.
Image
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by brich75 »

Did anyone else notice the kid that returned the kickoff for a touchdown. When he crossed the goal line he copied DAT with the sprinter lean.
Image
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by Phenom »

FWIW 247 had Tyner as the most impressive RB at the practices .
User avatar
Diehardduckfan
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 317
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:36 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by Diehardduckfan »

Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
You don't know if there is not any politics. You really don't. No seriously take a step back for second and think about it.... You really don't.... know that... do you? I admit I don't know if there really is politics, but it does seem weird how everytime Tyner came in it was a passing play. The rotations weren't consistent either. Don't be that guy on the board who claims to know things he doesn't. Let people vent. Remember you're not a duck fan so you're not thinking from our shoes. Fans want to see their recruits get a chance. There is no way Max Browne deservered the amount of reps he got the way he played. The game isn't that important career wise for the players but it is important to them personally, for the fans its about seeing our school get pub and we felt Tyner just didn't get the chance to create some special moments that we all know he is capable of. 3 carries really? From reports from practices we've all read 3 carries is hardly deserving for Thomas Tyner. Tell me I am wrong. Or would you rather watch TenPenny run straight into the butt of his offensive linemen again?

And another thing I've watched these games for years and I'm tired of seeing the exact same teams promoted between commercials for the Army game at least, USC, Notre Dame, and Michgan. And guess what, for the last few years all of those teams classes haven't panned out really ( Notre Dame the exception this year).
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by SuperDuck »

ducksrock wrote:
brich75 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
Yup no injuries is All we should care a out. We know he is good and so does every team in the PAC 12! Tyner will be great regardless if he got carries in that game or not. Seemed liked USC was getting a ton of touches because they had 12 players out there. Not politics just odds.

Who is USC? I don't recognize the school letters as anything significant...Are they an up and coming program? I doubt anytime soon.... :lol:
USC = University of South Carolina :)
John 3:36
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by maxduck »

Diehardduckfan wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
You don't know if there is not any politics. You really don't. No seriously take a step back for second and think about it.... You really don't.... know that... do you? I admit I don't know if there really is politics, but it does seem weird how everytime Tyner came in it was a passing play. The rotations weren't consistent either. Don't be that guy on the board who claims to know things he doesn't. Let people vent. Remember you're not a duck fan so you're not thinking from our shoes. Fans want to see their recruits get a chance. There is no way Max Browne deservered the amount of reps he got the way he played. The game isn't that important career wise for the players but it is important to them personally, for the fans its about seeing our school get pub and we felt Tyner just didn't get the chance to create some special moments that we all know he is capable of. 3 carries really? From reports from practices we've all read 3 carries is hardly deserving for Thomas Tyner. Tell me I am wrong. Or would you rather watch TenPenny run straight into the butt of his offensive linemen again?

And another thing I've watched these games for years and I'm tired of seeing the exact same teams promoted between commercials for the Army game at least, USC, Notre Dame, and Michgan. And guess what, for the last few years all of those teams classes haven't panned out really ( Notre Dame the exception this year).
I don't pay much attention to the all star games but can you explain how the alleged politics work? How does a coach benefit by giving the ball to player X over player Y? Are you saying the sponser (US Army?) finds an advantage in a USC recruit putting up better stats than an Oregon recruit?
User avatar
AutzenMember
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1097
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:47 pm
Location: Hockinson, WA

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by AutzenMember »

maxduck wrote:
Diehardduckfan wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
You don't know if there is not any politics. You really don't. No seriously take a step back for second and think about it.... You really don't.... know that... do you? I admit I don't know if there really is politics, but it does seem weird how everytime Tyner came in it was a passing play. The rotations weren't consistent either. Don't be that guy on the board who claims to know things he doesn't. Let people vent. Remember you're not a duck fan so you're not thinking from our shoes. Fans want to see their recruits get a chance. There is no way Max Browne deservered the amount of reps he got the way he played. The game isn't that important career wise for the players but it is important to them personally, for the fans its about seeing our school get pub and we felt Tyner just didn't get the chance to create some special moments that we all know he is capable of. 3 carries really? From reports from practices we've all read 3 carries is hardly deserving for Thomas Tyner. Tell me I am wrong. Or would you rather watch TenPenny run straight into the butt of his offensive linemen again?

And another thing I've watched these games for years and I'm tired of seeing the exact same teams promoted between commercials for the Army game at least, USC, Notre Dame, and Michgan. And guess what, for the last few years all of those teams classes haven't panned out really ( Notre Dame the exception this year).
I don't pay much attention to the all star games but can you explain how the alleged politics work? How does a coach benefit by giving the ball to player X over player Y? Are you saying the sponser (US Army?) finds an advantage in a USC recruit putting up better stats than an Oregon recruit?
Yo, I got this. Tyner didn't say "y'all" enough during the practice sessions.
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: US ARMY BOWL

Post by Braveheart »

Diehardduckfan wrote:
Braveheart wrote:No politics or conspiracies. Kids practice for 4 days, the coaches decide what happens in the game based on practice. Nobody is going to get a lot of touches, and some get less than others. The main thing is Tyner proved he belonged with the few touches he got, and he didn't injure himself.
You don't know if there is not any politics. You really don't. No seriously take a step back for second and think about it.... You really don't.... know that... do you? I admit I don't know if there really is politics, but it does seem weird how everytime Tyner came in it was a passing play. The rotations weren't consistent either. Don't be that guy on the board who claims to know things he doesn't. Let people vent. Remember you're not a duck fan so you're not thinking from our shoes. Fans want to see their recruits get a chance. There is no way Max Browne deservered the amount of reps he got the way he played. The game isn't that important career wise for the players but it is important to them personally, for the fans its about seeing our school get pub and we felt Tyner just didn't get the chance to create some special moments that we all know he is capable of. 3 carries really? From reports from practices we've all read 3 carries is hardly deserving for Thomas Tyner. Tell me I am wrong. Or would you rather watch TenPenny run straight into the butt of his offensive linemen again?

And another thing I've watched these games for years and I'm tired of seeing the exact same teams promoted between commercials for the Army game at least, USC, Notre Dame, and Michgan. And guess what, for the last few years all of those teams classes haven't panned out really ( Notre Dame the exception this year).
I hate to link to bleacher report, but here it is.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1471 ... nd-results

Thomas Tyner and Altee Tenpenny both had 4 carries, and Justin Davis had 3. Justin Davis was the no.1 RB on the depth chart heading into the game. Max Browne had less reps than Hayden Rettig. The West's O-line wasn't good (thanks to undersized players Falah, Raulerson, etc...) so they limited the running plays. The East ran more because Khaliel Rodgers and Brendan Mahon were handling business up front. Tyner got as many opportunities on the west as any other back. Early in the game they talked about his amazing senior season and broke down his record breaking 10 TD game. Dude got his shine, there's no conspiracy to limit his (or any other player's) touches due to team affiliation. There's nothing to gain from that. These are HS coaches that do not know these kids (unless they coached them before), and make the decisions based on the couple of days they have them practice. Even then, touches are pretty even for most every year.

And another thing I've watched these games for years and I'm tired of seeing the exact same teams promoted between commercials for the Army game at least, USC, Notre Dame, and Michgan. And guess what, for the last few years all of those teams classes haven't panned out really ( Notre Dame the exception this year).
The little commercials this year were for the teams that had the most players. http://www.youtube.com/user/ArmyAllAmer ... ture=watch
I assume it's like that for every year. The traditional powers have the most kids in these games annually, and that's why they receive more coverage. Even A&M had their own commercial since they had a lot of commits at the game. Oregon had one representative...Thomas Tyner. Once again, there is no conspiracy.

I'm not stopping you from venting, just like you can't stop me from giving my opinion. I hear where you're coming from, but I just think your claim is faulty at best.
Image
Post Reply