Quote from Tyrell Robinson about UW

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Quote from Tyrell Robinson about UW

Post by NCDucks09 »

JIDuck97 wrote:
NCDucks09 wrote:After watching Tyree's highlights on defense against the pass from '11, I say put him in at cornerback, how sweet would having a DB who is 6'4" with hops, who could contest deep jump balls against SC receivers be? :)

The only problem I could see with a 6'4 cornerback (any 6'4 cornerback) would potentially be hip movement when it comes to turning to match up with the receiver after a fake, stutter step, or juke. 6'4 tends to be a little tall to get rapid hip turning movement. This is why most cornerbacks tend to be int he 5'10-6'1.5 range.
Granted I have no idea what Tyree's hip movement is like when he is backpedalling, but it can be costly to place a guy at cb who may not be able to get the correct steps and hip turn when a guy cuts toward an open area at the last moment.
I'm sorry, but I don't buy the whole 'hip movement' excuse for corners being shorter. That's like saying Lebron James can't defend Chris Paul on the perimeter because he's too tall to keep up with a shorter guy. And we all know Lebron can play any position or guard any position. Some athletes can do it, some can't, but it's not a definite rule.

I don't mind him at WR, but I definitely don't like him at safety because he doesn't seem that explosive or strong to deliver a mean tackle.

The reason I say corner is because no one puts their fast tall guys with hops on defense, they always put them on offense, so it would be a great way to nullify those mis-matches with our defense.

Some of the best corners in the NFL are taller.

Antonio Cromartie is 6'2"
Dion Sanders is 6'1"
Nnamdi Asomugha is 6'2"
Charles Tilman is 6'2"
Charles Woodson 6'1"
Brandon Browner 6'4"
Richard Sherman 6'3"

Guess what, Seattle's CB's were the best in the league in 2012. Both beting over 6'3"...
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
User avatar
JIDuck97
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 998
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 8:42 am

Re: Quote from Tyrell Robinson about UW

Post by JIDuck97 »

NCDucks09 wrote:
JIDuck97 wrote:
NCDucks09 wrote:After watching Tyree's highlights on defense against the pass from '11, I say put him in at cornerback, how sweet would having a DB who is 6'4" with hops, who could contest deep jump balls against SC receivers be? :)

The only problem I could see with a 6'4 cornerback (any 6'4 cornerback) would potentially be hip movement when it comes to turning to match up with the receiver after a fake, stutter step, or juke. 6'4 tends to be a little tall to get rapid hip turning movement. This is why most cornerbacks tend to be int he 5'10-6'1.5 range.
Granted I have no idea what Tyree's hip movement is like when he is backpedalling, but it can be costly to place a guy at cb who may not be able to get the correct steps and hip turn when a guy cuts toward an open area at the last moment.
I'm sorry, but I don't buy the whole 'hip movement' excuse for corners being shorter. That's like saying Lebron James can't defend Chris Paul on the perimeter because he's too tall to keep up with a shorter guy. And we all know Lebron can play any position or guard any position. Some athletes can do it, some can't, but it's not a definite rule.

I don't mind him at WR, but I definitely don't like him at safety because he doesn't seem that explosive or strong to deliver a mean tackle.

The reason I say corner is because no one puts their fast tall guys with hops on defense, they always put them on offense, so it would be a great way to nullify those mis-matches with our defense.

Some of the best corners in the NFL are taller.

Antonio Cromartie is 6'2"
Dion Sanders is 6'1"
Nnamdi Asomugha is 6'2"
Charles Tilman is 6'2"
Charles Woodson 6'1"
Brandon Browner 6'4"
Richard Sherman 6'3"

Guess what, Seattle's CB's were the best in the league in 2012. Both beting over 6'3"...
Fair enough. This is why I included the bolded section. This is something talking heads have gone over during NFL drills. Obviously there are always exceptions. I think it has more to do with tendencies. The basketball comparison is not the greatest due to field width vs court width. When you lose a guy briefly on a ball court you can get back to him really quickly in many situations whereas when you lose a guy on a football field he has a long way to go away from you. Your argument about taller CBs in the NFL is very much valid, but I believe tends to show the exceptions. Still, this could just be talking heads being talking heads but I would bet there is some "typical" validity to it. Chris Paul looks like he tends to be faster than LeBron but by knowing where to be LeBron can guard against him on a court that much better. On a football field all the little things can make a huge difference.
Post Reply