GoDucksIn09 wrote:It seems in the recruiting game that integrity and character have gone out the window. We no longer have a society where a person's word is anything more than just playing the recruiting game and it means diddly squat. Whatever happened to being a man of their word. Juju is just like a long line of guys who have said liked Oregon and wanted to go there blah blah blah only to pick another school.
What bothers me most with this decision is the feeling that Oregon is settling in on mediocrity and being ok with not getting the top prospects and contending for the Pac 12 championship or national championship. We can say all the right phrases about fit and what not but getting top notch prospects leads to top notch play. Not everybody pans out. But settling for a top 25 class... or less... uggggggg... we have got to do better.
Bothers me too that moms are more concerned bout where they want a kid... than where the kid wants to go. This is not the first time we have seen mom getting her way and the kid not going to where they want to play.
srsmiley007 wrote:Don't worry, way overrated. Not particularly fast or quick after watching film not sure how he got a 5Star rating. I'm predicting a bust for JUJU anyway, to slow... 4.71 40 isn't going to light anyone up. Watched the film and wasn't particularly impressed with how his game will transition at the next level. Didn't see what they saw at either receiver or free safety.
6 posts, definitely a troll
“If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way,” he said. “We turned the ball over a lot. We beat ourself. Just be real with yourself right now. We beat ourself.”
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
GoDucksIn09 wrote:It seems in the recruiting game that integrity and character have gone out the window. We no longer have a society where a person's word is anything more than just playing the recruiting game and it means diddly squat. Whatever happened to being a man of their word. Juju is just like a long line of guys who have said liked Oregon and wanted to go there blah blah blah only to pick another school.
What bothers me most with this decision is the feeling that Oregon is settling in on mediocrity and being ok with not getting the top prospects and contending for the Pac 12 championship or national championship. We can say all the right phrases about fit and what not but getting top notch prospects leads to top notch play. Not everybody pans out. But settling for a top 25 class... or less... uggggggg... we have got to do better.
Bothers me too that moms are more concerned bout where they want a kid... than where the kid wants to go. This is not the first time we have seen mom getting her way and the kid not going to where they want to play.
The rating average for the class is still high but it just seems like missing on a high-profile target like Smith and also some good DTs has taken the wind out of the sails for those following recruiting. Today just seemed ho-hum, when compared to previous NSDs, because of the lack of any major news with this class. Oregon has gotten virtually no mention on any of the major recruiting sites or ESPN regarding this class which I think is also coloring how people feel this class is stacking up to others in the conference and the nation. I think a lot of fans feel Oregon should be in on a lot more recruits than they seemed to be this year.
I think a lot of fans feel Oregon should be in on a lot more recruits than they seemed to be this year.
Well, for some perspective, we haven't won a Pac-12 title in two years and we just went to the Alamo Bowl. And we went through a major defensive coaching change.
The previous year, we went through an even bigger coaching change after losing one of the most interesting, successful coaches in recent college football history.
And, until about a month ago (less, actually), we weren't even sure of which kind of defensive linemen to go after.
GoDucksIn09 wrote:It seems in the recruiting game that integrity and character have gone out the window. We no longer have a society where a person's word is anything more than just playing the recruiting game and it means diddly squat. Whatever happened to being a man of their word. Juju is just like a long line of guys who have said liked Oregon and wanted to go there blah blah blah only to pick another school.
What bothers me most with this decision is the feeling that Oregon is settling in on mediocrity and being ok with not getting the top prospects and contending for the Pac 12 championship or national championship. We can say all the right phrases about fit and what not but getting top notch prospects leads to top notch play. Not everybody pans out. But settling for a top 25 class... or less... uggggggg... we have got to do better.
Bothers me too that moms are more concerned bout where they want a kid... than where the kid wants to go. This is not the first time we have seen mom getting her way and the kid not going to where they want to play.
Maybe I'm crazy but I hate that too. These games these young kids play are so dumb and quite frankly they should be embarrassed by it. However, while I agree this NSD was underwhelming and disappointing, I don't see how Oregon is setling on mediocrity. While we missed in certain areas, our secondary class is one of the best in the nation. Besides, what should Oregon do if a recruit chooses another school? Publicly insult the kid? We don't have Lane Kiffin or Steve Sarkisian as coach, just move on, not to say the coaches won't learn from this, but nothing to do but move on and do the best you can with the recruits we got.
I think a lot of fans feel Oregon should be in on a lot more recruits than they seemed to be this year.
Well, for some perspective, we haven't won a Pac-12 title in two years and we just went to the Alamo Bowl. And we went through a major defensive coaching change.
The previous year, we went through an even bigger coaching change after losing one of the most interesting, successful coaches in recent college football history.
And, until about a month ago (less, actually), we weren't even sure of which kind of defensive linemen to go after.
GoDucksIn09 wrote:It seems in the recruiting game that integrity and character have gone out the window. We no longer have a society where a person's word is anything more than just playing the recruiting game and it means diddly squat. Whatever happened to being a man of their word. Juju is just like a long line of guys who have said liked Oregon and wanted to go there blah blah blah only to pick another school.
What bothers me most with this decision is the feeling that Oregon is settling in on mediocrity and being ok with not getting the top prospects and contending for the Pac 12 championship or national championship. We can say all the right phrases about fit and what not but getting top notch prospects leads to top notch play. Not everybody pans out. But settling for a top 25 class... or less... uggggggg... we have got to do better.
Bothers me too that moms are more concerned bout where they want a kid... than where the kid wants to go. This is not the first time we have seen mom getting her way and the kid not going to where they want to play.
Maybe I'm crazy but I hate that too. These games these young kids play are so dumb and quite frankly they should be embarrassed by it. However, while I agree this NSD was underwhelming and disappointing, I don't see how Oregon is setling on mediocrity. While we missed in certain areas, our secondary class is one of the best in the nation. Besides, what should Oregon do if a recruit chooses another school? Publicly insult the kid? We don't have Lane Kiffin or Steve Sarkisian as coach, just move on, not to say the coaches won't learn from this, but nothing to do but move on and do the best you can with the recruits we got.
As much as people want Helfrich admit there were mistakes and lament over who they missed out on, he provided a positive outlook that many don't want to see. I'm sure they'll have discussions on how to target players better in some closed-door meetings but I think having a full staff for an entire recruiting cycle will give us a better idea if the staff is good enough to continue Oregon's recent run.
maxduck wrote:A couple items from the Oregonian signing day thread, Who was excited about any of these players...
RT @wilnerhotline: NSD perspective: Oregon's '08 class had Blount, James, Barner, Jordan, Alonso. But ranked #5 in Pac10:
but everybody was about these...
WOW! Oregon's top 2 signed recruits in 2010 never played a down for the Ducks! Lache Seastrunk and Curtis White.
We won't know about this class for a couple years.
Yep. Plus the Ducks got two really good players from Florida, One of the best RB's in the nation from Texas, a top recruit from Lousiana, Swain from the heartland...I mean they recruited from almost all four corners of the country. UO isn't going to win all of the battles, but just the fact they are on the national radar basically across the country will only help moving forward with kids from everywhere. As long as the Ducks keep winning, their footprint will continue to grow. Compared to just a few years ago, I think it has been impressive.
There was a lot working against Oregon this year in recruiting. First, the rest of the conference has stepped up its game, notably SC and UCLA. Oregon is no longer the only top team in town and are thus vying heavily for the same recruits as the Cali and AZ schools. It's hard to overcome hometown/state schools and distance. Second, the PNW was absolutely bare this year for recruits. The state of Washington was in a down year and Oregon was, well, being Oregon with a couple good recruits and then some lower-level talent. Third, the shuffling of Oregon's coaching staff I think played more of a role than even Helfrich let on. The changing of defensive philosophy and the hiring of new coaches at the end just played havoc with them closing out on that side of the ball. Plus, having Chinander only available for the last month is basically what Oregon went through after getting Aiken and Lubick so late in the recruiting cycle.
2015 should (hopefully) be a better class due to much needed stability in the coaching staff and a deeper overall talent pool in the PNW and the West Coast. Competition will still be stiff for all these recruits but Oregon really just has to have another good season and target the right players.
Pretty obvious that Smith's mom made the decision for him...
“If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way,” he said. “We turned the ball over a lot. We beat ourself. Just be real with yourself right now. We beat ourself.”
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
1. I don't think public speaking is in his future
2. Wow if you are able to read body language and in between the lines of what he said....it was never his decsion to make...momma wanted her baby close to home. Sucks when parents cant get out of the way of their own kids. Friday Night Tykes much.
GoDucksIn09 wrote:It seems in the recruiting game that integrity and character have gone out the window. We no longer have a society where a person's word is anything more than just playing the recruiting game and it means diddly squat. Whatever happened to being a man of their word. Juju is just like a long line of guys who have said liked Oregon and wanted to go there blah blah blah only to pick another school.
What bothers me most with this decision is the feeling that Oregon is settling in on mediocrity and being ok with not getting the top prospects and contending for the Pac 12 championship or national championship. We can say all the right phrases about fit and what not but getting top notch prospects leads to top notch play. Not everybody pans out. But settling for a top 25 class... or less... uggggggg... we have got to do better.
Bothers me too that moms are more concerned bout where they want a kid... than where the kid wants to go. This is not the first time we have seen mom getting her way and the kid not going to where they want to play.
Were you complaining when Swain and Talia came to us after committing elsewhere? These kids are 17-18 years old making what could turn out to be the biggest decision of their lives. If they decide to go elsewhere, say good luck and leave it at that. Getting pissed and taking pot shots at teenagers is a bad look. Some of you take it as a personal insult when a guy has serious interest in us then commits elsewhere. The kid grew up in LA and playing in LA allows his family/friends to see him play in person numerous times every year as opposed to playing at Oregon where he'd play in LA once every 2 years.
If you're trying to make societal statements based on recruiting, I'd look at the fans/bloggers/scouts. We have a society that thinks it's ok/normal to harass/bash a kid because of where he wants to go to school. That's much more troubling to me than a kid changing his mind, regardless of what precipitated the change.
Off topic, this is a prime example as to why high school seniors shouldn't need their parents signature on a letter of intent. I think it's ridiculous that someone old enough to have a full scholarship offered to them isn't old enough to make that decision for themselves.