Ya'll remember..

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Phenom »

Trust me on this guys, Lockie is not the answer. I heard from a source close to him that he is not an Oregon caliber starting QB. Decent backup but that's it.
hjpop
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 823
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:52 pm
Location: Salem, OR

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by hjpop »

If the coaches were willing to stick with him as a backup and JR left, that's a good indication that the coaches have faith in him and his ability to get in if needed and at the least manage the game. I agree with the other poster in that, until there's a gametime situation that is not mop-up, we don't know how good/bad Lockie really is.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Phenom »

hjpop wrote:If the coaches were willing to stick with him as a backup and JR left, that's a good indication that the coaches have faith in him and his ability to get in if needed and at the least manage the game. I agree with the other poster in that, until there's a gametime situation that is not mop-up, we don't know how good/bad Lockie really is.
Not exactly. He was the best backup but that's not saying much.
hjpop
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 823
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:52 pm
Location: Salem, OR

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by hjpop »

Right now, if we're serious in hoping that Mahalik redshirts, that's all we need to say, really. A good decent backup who can throw, if need be, and can manage the game is a luxury that some teams (i.e. Univ. of Hawaii, for example) would sell their souls for.
squintsdd
Senior
Posts: 2111
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:39 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by squintsdd »

Teams like Alabama thrive off quarterbacks that are nothing more that game managers. Unfortunately, you're not going to keep up with the more high powered offenses in the Pac-12 with nothing more than a game manager unless you have a very stout defense.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Duck07 »

squintsdd wrote:Teams like Alabama thrive off quarterbacks that are nothing more that game managers. Unfortunately, you're not going to keep up with the more high powered offenses in the Pac-12 with nothing more than a game manager unless you have a very stout defense.
I've been pretty darn critical of DT in the past but lets not forget for one moment where that "game manager" took us. In case anyone has forgotten, Oregon is a RUNNING team. Yes, we need a QB that can throw very well but in the last few threads I've read our Defense is being taken behind the woodshed by most and any idea that a DT type QB could lead us back to the NC in today's format is somehow impossible.

A game manger in Oregon's offense is still more potent than an Alabama game manager and our defense is no longer in that awkward middle of the country rankings like it was under Bellotti; we're a D with the ability to be Top 15 with an offense as potent as any in the nation. Ifo is gone next year but its not like our recruiting on that side of the ball has been paltry. Jimmie Swain was a big pickup for us and I'm hopeful that Pellum can create a real monster out of our Defense.

I know everyone wants to get their panties in a giant knot and start crying but let the season play out and see what happens, not just with our season but with other teams. Kyler Murray might see the writing on the wall from ATM this season and decide he's better off elsewhere because the last #1 QB for them did pan out. Alabama's "attempts" at the spread could be pathetic or not even come to fruition, causing BB to rethink how honest Nick Satan and Lame Kitten are. Shoot, maybe Marcus decides to come back.

I just can't get myself worked up over worrying about whether or not Morgan Mahalak will pan out and whether or not we already have his replacement locked up. I honestly wouldn't feel any more comfortable about keeping those QB commits had they chosen us instead of ATM or Bama simply because of the time to NSD.
Image
squintsdd
Senior
Posts: 2111
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:39 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by squintsdd »

Duck07 wrote:
squintsdd wrote:Teams like Alabama thrive off quarterbacks that are nothing more that game managers. Unfortunately, you're not going to keep up with the more high powered offenses in the Pac-12 with nothing more than a game manager unless you have a very stout defense.
I've been pretty darn critical of DT in the past but lets not forget for one moment where that "game manager" took us. In case anyone has forgotten, Oregon is a RUNNING team. Yes, we need a QB that can throw very well but in the last few threads I've read our Defense is being taken behind the woodshed by most and any idea that a DT type QB could lead us back to the NC in today's format is somehow impossible.

A game manger in Oregon's offense is still more potent than an Alabama game manager and our defense is no longer in that awkward middle of the country rankings like it was under Bellotti; we're a D with the ability to be Top 15 with an offense as potent as any in the nation. Ifo is gone next year but its not like our recruiting on that side of the ball has been paltry. Jimmie Swain was a big pickup for us and I'm hopeful that Pellum can create a real monster out of our Defense.

I know everyone wants to get their panties in a giant knot and start crying but let the season play out and see what happens, not just with our season but with other teams. Kyler Murray might see the writing on the wall from ATM this season and decide he's better off elsewhere because the last #1 QB for them did pan out. Alabama's "attempts" at the spread could be pathetic or not even come to fruition, causing BB to rethink how honest Nick Satan and Lame Kitten are. Shoot, maybe Marcus decides to come back.

I just can't get myself worked up over worrying about whether or not Morgan Mahalak will pan out and whether or not we already have his replacement locked up. I honestly wouldn't feel any more comfortable about keeping those QB commits had they chosen us instead of ATM or Bama simply because of the time to NSD.
I agree with most of what you said, but Oregon's defense tends to give up points at times to better offenses because they're on the field so much. If the coaching staff is able to slow down the offense a little bit in order to keep the other team's offense off the field I would feel slightly more confident, but a game manager just won't cut it against some teams. Looking back to last season WSU, OSU, and even UW could've beat an Oregon team that simply has a game manager on the field.

The coaching staff can always adjust, to the quarterback they have available, but I'm not overly confident in that right now since they were willing to play an injured Mariota instead of the backups last season.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Phenom »

hjpop wrote:Right now, if we're serious in hoping that Mahalik redshirts, that's all we need to say, really. A good decent backup who can throw, if need be, and can manage the game is a luxury that some teams (i.e. Univ. of Hawaii, for example) would sell their souls for.
lol no. Trust me on this.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Duck07 »

And what caliber starting level Oregon QB are we talking about here?If the standard is Marcus then ~3 schools in the nation could even lay claim to have an Oregon-caliber starting QB. If Jeremiah Masoli or Brady Leaf is the standard then we're talking about something else. If I'm ranking the last decade of Oregon QBs based purely on their abilities as a QB and not the the respective play of their teams, this is where I'd put them. Off that list Phenom, where would you say Lockie falls?
1-Marcus Mariota
2-Kellen Clemens
3-Dennis Dixon
4-Darron Thomas
5-Jeremiah Masoli
6-Nate Costa
7-Brady Leaf
8-Justin Roper
Image
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Phenom »

Duck07 wrote:And what caliber starting level Oregon QB are we talking about here?If the standard is Marcus then ~3 schools in the nation could even lay claim to have an Oregon-caliber starting QB. If Jeremiah Masoli or Brady Leaf is the standard then we're talking about something else. If I'm ranking the last decade of Oregon QBs based purely on their abilities as a QB and not the the respective play of their teams, this is where I'd put them. Off that list Phenom, where would you say Lockie falls?
1-Marcus Mariota
2-Kellen Clemens
3-Dennis Dixon
4-Darron Thomas
5-Jeremiah Masoli
6-Nate Costa
7-Brady Leaf
8-Justin Roper
Roper >>>> Leaf . from what I have heard, I would put Lockie above Leaf. Maybe on the same level as Roper and Costa. Not starting material.
User avatar
bigsugarduck
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1209
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:52 pm

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by bigsugarduck »

Phenom wrote:
Duck07 wrote:And what caliber starting level Oregon QB are we talking about here?If the standard is Marcus then ~3 schools in the nation could even lay claim to have an Oregon-caliber starting QB. If Jeremiah Masoli or Brady Leaf is the standard then we're talking about something else. If I'm ranking the last decade of Oregon QBs based purely on their abilities as a QB and not the the respective play of their teams, this is where I'd put them. Off that list Phenom, where would you say Lockie falls?
1-Marcus Mariota
2-Kellen Clemens
3-Dennis Dixon
4-Darron Thomas
5-Jeremiah Masoli
6-Nate Costa
7-Brady Leaf
8-Justin Roper
Roper >>>> Leaf . from what I have heard, I would put Lockie above Leaf. Maybe on the same level as Roper and Costa. Not starting material.

I'm not sure if we can even put Costa on that list. He never really played? Probably the most successful and well know holder in the history of the program...
Stewart Mandel-"From a purely aesthetic standpoint, I much prefer to watch a good spread-rushing offense over a traditional Power-I offense, and Oregon's has been the most fun by far for the past several years. It's fast, its precise, and when Chip Kelly has the right quarterback (Dixon, Masoli) at the helm, the possibility of someone ripping off a 60-yard run exists on nearly every play."
woundedknees
All-American
Posts: 12826
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:06 pm

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by woundedknees »

Were it not for his knees, Costa would quite possibly have had a decent shot at preventing the 07 melt-down. I doubt you could suggest that of any other QB on the roster at the time.

Dude never got a decent shot to show his stuff, yet when he was on the field, healthy, he proved to be a very competent back-up.
Autzen Stadium... Where great teams go to die...Hard!

Image
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by SuperDuck »

woundedknees wrote:Were it not for his knees, Costa would quite possibly have had a decent shot at preventing the 07 melt-down. I doubt you could suggest that of any other QB on the roster at the time.

Dude never got a decent shot to show his stuff, yet when he was on the field, healthy, he proved to be a very competent back-up.
Costa was a very good QB. Even Mike Bellotti said that he could have saved the 2007 season if he were healthy.

Personally, I'd put Dennis Dixon ahead of Clemons. I might even put Masoli ahead of him, but those were different teams and Clemons was before Chip, so it's not really a fair assessment.
John 3:36
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by SuperDuck »

woundedknees wrote:Were it not for his knees, Costa would quite possibly have had a decent shot at preventing the 07 melt-down. I doubt you could suggest that of any other QB on the roster at the time.

Dude never got a decent shot to show his stuff, yet when he was on the field, healthy, he proved to be a very competent back-up.
Costa was a very good QB. Even Mike Bellotti said that he could have saved the 2007 season if he were healthy.

Personally, I'd put Dennis Dixon ahead of Clemons. I might even put Masoli ahead of him, but those were different teams and Clemons was before Chip, so it's not really a fair assessment.
John 3:36
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Ya'll remember..

Post by Phenom »

Yeah, I would put both DD and DT ahead of KC.

BTW, we just offered Waller.
Post Reply