rockthief wrote:Lockie's first start today. He did okay. Alie did not throw a pass. No way to compare them.
^^+1
Also, people, he may have been with the team now 3 years but how many of that was running the 1s? He's backed up Marcus and, before that, ran the scout team. He has also little game time where it counts (and started his first ever collegiate game today). He may have been antsy and a bit reluctant but he showed he can scramble when needed to and made some plays. He was 23 of 31 for 228 and 2 TDs with no Int. and he threw to 12 receivers.
That's hardly "take away his scholarship" play at all (someone from FB said this, which is pathetic.)
Which is almost a 75% completion percentage. Not bad for a first start.
I'm sure it took him a while to settle down, it's not like he's a seasoned vet, but once he did he did fine. He received player of the game and had good numbers, my only knock on him is when he called his own number on the read option he was indecisive where to go, I felt he made the wrong cut at times. I think we have a very good back up to Adams in Lockie and he will probably get the reins next season unless we bring in another transfer.
I was surprised to see Alie get all the rest of the times, makes me wonder why we didn't see any other youngsters. Is there that much separation between Alie and everyone else?
Lockie is exactly what we thought he was, a game manager. Against a defense that pressures frequently, I think he would struggle. He does not have the scramble speed, and doesn't seem to be very creative when things break down.
We all saw why VA was named the starter over Lockie and why VA continued to play at MSU. Lockie is not a play maker, he is a game manager, he was hesitant with some of his decisions and missed on some of his longer throws, most of the pass plays were the short dink and dunks. He is a great backup to have but VA has a stronger arm, seems more confident and though is prone to turn the ball over as a result he can make something out of nothing and will have more explosion plays. I think VA needs to play against Utah but maybe give him more rest against Colorado. Utah has a great defense, probably better than MSU and are very physical so VA will likely take some shots.
There are those who even think Allie is a better qb than Lockie. Quicker decision making, better arm and athletism. And as you saw, the team loves him.
I do think that had Lockie been able to play the second half against EWU, then maybe he would have been better to play the second half against MSU. We only had one offensive TD against the Spartans until the fourth quarter, and VA looked lost in the pocket at times, even when he had time to throw. I really believe Lockie could have made better decisions and possibly done a better job at getting the ball out to our playmakers... but after seeing how he started against GS, I'm glad the coaches stuck with VA.
I feel better about Lockie as our backup though. I think he'd be good enough to win most of the games on our schedule. He showed good judgment when running, he smartly threw the ball away (whereas VA may be more likely to throw a pick), and he also showed some elusiveness. A healthy VA though is definitely a solid step up.