Should Helf call the plays?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
Jaw327
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 81
- Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am
Should Helf call the plays?
First of all, everything was terrible.
Nothing good came from this game
Did it look as bad on TV as it did from the 10 yard line?
So, I'm not sure what Scott Frost is doing, since he got the job I felt he did a pretty good job calling the plays but maybe that was just because he had Marcus. This year his play calling has been horrible
Royce Freeman up the middle gain of 4 yards
Royce Freeman up the middle gain of 2 yards
Vernon Adams Pass Incomplete
Ian Wheeler punt for 10 and a half yards
He doesn't know how to or doesn't want to get the ball in the hands of our fastest shiftiest dudes. Neither TBJ or Taj came into the game until it was well over.
Now we've got Nelson hurt and Marshall probably really hurt.
2 QB's who can't do anything
side note - man I feel bad for VA, he's just completely lost out there. I think its a combo of the broken finger and shaken confidence from realizing he made a terrible mistake
But Frost keeps calling the same plays and they almost always get the same result.
The first drive at MSU worked perfectly, they couldn't stop us. Then Frost just stopped doing that and started trying to run Royce up the middle. He had one nice gain but everything after that was garbage. Our Offensive line, especially Hagerty, is bad, they can't open running lanes, so why keep trying to run it up the middle?
arghhh I'm starting to ramble.
Back to my initial question, should Helfrich call the plays? I know he won't fire anyone or make any big changes during the season but I think taking play calling duties is one step he could take.
Nothing good came from this game
Did it look as bad on TV as it did from the 10 yard line?
So, I'm not sure what Scott Frost is doing, since he got the job I felt he did a pretty good job calling the plays but maybe that was just because he had Marcus. This year his play calling has been horrible
Royce Freeman up the middle gain of 4 yards
Royce Freeman up the middle gain of 2 yards
Vernon Adams Pass Incomplete
Ian Wheeler punt for 10 and a half yards
He doesn't know how to or doesn't want to get the ball in the hands of our fastest shiftiest dudes. Neither TBJ or Taj came into the game until it was well over.
Now we've got Nelson hurt and Marshall probably really hurt.
2 QB's who can't do anything
side note - man I feel bad for VA, he's just completely lost out there. I think its a combo of the broken finger and shaken confidence from realizing he made a terrible mistake
But Frost keeps calling the same plays and they almost always get the same result.
The first drive at MSU worked perfectly, they couldn't stop us. Then Frost just stopped doing that and started trying to run Royce up the middle. He had one nice gain but everything after that was garbage. Our Offensive line, especially Hagerty, is bad, they can't open running lanes, so why keep trying to run it up the middle?
arghhh I'm starting to ramble.
Back to my initial question, should Helfrich call the plays? I know he won't fire anyone or make any big changes during the season but I think taking play calling duties is one step he could take.
-
gofightingducks
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5533
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
At this point in the season, conservative play calling needs to be tossed out the door, they need to be more aggressive and creative and Helfrich hopefully is thinking the same thing and needs to make that clear to Frost. The playbook doesn't need to be dumbed down for a QB who has been in the system for three years with an experienced line, RB, TE's and WR's. Even if Adams plays, sweep plays, misdirection, quick slants, easy things that work to open things up a bit.
-
trnxcam
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 261
- Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2010 3:59 pm
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
Can we hire Chip to call plays on Saturdays? 
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
I dunno, his playcalling in the national championship was abysmal. I still remember yelling at my TV, "IF I SEE ANOTHER RUN BETWEEN THE TACKLES RIGHT INTO THE STRENGTH OF THEIR DEFENSE AGAIN I'M GONNA FLY DOWN THERE AND PUNCH YOU IN THE FACE".trnxcam wrote:Can we hire Chip to call plays on Saturdays?
-
gofightingducks
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5533
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
QuackininBama wrote:I dunno, his playcalling in the national championship was abysmal. I still remember yelling at my TV, "IF I SEE ANOTHER RUN BETWEEN THE TACKLES RIGHT INTO THE STRENGTH OF THEIR DEFENSE AGAIN I'M GONNA FLY DOWN THERE AND PUNCH YOU IN THE FACE".trnxcam wrote:Can we hire Chip to call plays on Saturdays?
He was stubborn at times and there was a couple of games that might have cost the Ducks games but under Kelly I believe the worst loss was the LSU one and that was only 13 points and that was on the road to open the season.
-
duckfan22
- Senior
- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
they can call all the plays they want to.. If the QB cant run the play called it doesnt matter.
VA had problems not related to his broken fingure. He seemed to panic in the pocket when it broke down.
Ran when he had players open and Lockie looked better in the beginning but still made his
share of mistakes. Also the offensive line couldnt block and i wont even bring up the defense.
VA had problems not related to his broken fingure. He seemed to panic in the pocket when it broke down.
Ran when he had players open and Lockie looked better in the beginning but still made his
share of mistakes. Also the offensive line couldnt block and i wont even bring up the defense.
-
gofightingducks
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5533
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
duckfan22 wrote:they can call all the plays they want to.. If the QB cant run the play called it doesnt matter.
VA had problems not related to his broken fingure. He seemed to panic in the pocket when it broke down.
Ran when he had players open and Lockie looked better in the beginning but still made his
share of mistakes. Also the offensive line couldnt block and i wont even bring up the defense.
^ THIS .......... the whole team looks bad
-
Jaw327
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 81
- Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
ohh absolutely, the whole team was atrocious. It was like a JV team showed up and even then didn't bother to play.gofightingducks wrote:duckfan22 wrote:they can call all the plays they want to.. If the QB cant run the play called it doesnt matter.
VA had problems not related to his broken fingure. He seemed to panic in the pocket when it broke down.
Ran when he had players open and Lockie looked better in the beginning but still made his
share of mistakes. Also the offensive line couldnt block and i wont even bring up the defense.
^ THIS .......... the whole team looks bad
I don't think, despite what the coaches say, that it's just a matter of making a bunch of small fixes. I think the problem is a larger problem, a cultural problem and all the small things are just symptoms of the larger problem.
I see almost nothing that says the ship can be turned around this season. Like how would the defense even get fixed without being completely revamped from the top?
I'm just wondering if, in order to not lose every single game on the schedule, Helfrich needs to take some concrete steps now, and knowing he wont fire anybody, should he at least take over play calling duties, just to change something, anything.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
I've had a couple of days to think about this and have come to a realization about the offense.
After seeing the difference between VA and Lockie in terms of our tempo and ball movement, I don't think the problem is play-calling as much as it is execution.
For whatever reason -- finger or mindset, who knows -- VA is struggling. Obviously, he and Lockie are working with the same gameplan, and when Lockie goes in there, our offense looks MUCH more like what we're used to.
So would Helfrich calling the plays make any difference? Probably not, no. Would him calling the plays be productive or beneficial in any way? Again, probably not. All that might really accomplish is reinforcing the belief that Frost is incompetent, even if that view is completely false (which, honestly, none of us knows). That would be incredibly detrimental from an internal perspective, and internal functioning is way more important than external perception.
But if the coaches are going to start VA, then they need to be darned well certain he's 100 percent ready. If he's not ready, then they need to roll with Lockie and give him a fair chance to succeed.
Yeah, Lockie turned the ball over... but at least he moved the ball downfield and didn't just rapidly go three-and-out. And it's not like VA hasn't had his share of turnovers either.
After seeing the difference between VA and Lockie in terms of our tempo and ball movement, I don't think the problem is play-calling as much as it is execution.
For whatever reason -- finger or mindset, who knows -- VA is struggling. Obviously, he and Lockie are working with the same gameplan, and when Lockie goes in there, our offense looks MUCH more like what we're used to.
So would Helfrich calling the plays make any difference? Probably not, no. Would him calling the plays be productive or beneficial in any way? Again, probably not. All that might really accomplish is reinforcing the belief that Frost is incompetent, even if that view is completely false (which, honestly, none of us knows). That would be incredibly detrimental from an internal perspective, and internal functioning is way more important than external perception.
But if the coaches are going to start VA, then they need to be darned well certain he's 100 percent ready. If he's not ready, then they need to roll with Lockie and give him a fair chance to succeed.
Yeah, Lockie turned the ball over... but at least he moved the ball downfield and didn't just rapidly go three-and-out. And it's not like VA hasn't had his share of turnovers either.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
Take some ideas from Utah.. They had some great play calls and trick plays. They showed us how to run an offense, so take note Frost.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
Helfrich has never called plays at Oregon. We have no idea how he would do. Kind of like we had no idea how he would be as a head coach as he had no track record at that either. If he did start calling plays, at least no one would have a "book" on his tendencies.
- pudgejeff
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:21 am
- GM: Sacramento Kings GM
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
GrandpaDuck wrote:Helfrich has never called plays at Oregon. We have no idea how he would do. Kind of like we had no idea how he would be as a head coach as he had no track record at that either. If he did start calling plays, at least no one would have a "book" on his tendencies.
-
hjpop
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:52 pm
- Location: Salem, OR
Re: Should Helf call the plays?
During the Rose Bowl, they mentioned that Frost calls the plays and that Helf would pitch in if things were not going as he thought they should (which means does he? Who knows). I'm more concerned that Frost, or whoever calls them ultimately, seem to tighten up and bury their heads in the ground when things start going south and they just don't open up and get loose. We didn't bring in a run game with any dimension, always Freeman and that's it. Our run game opens up when we mix guys, it's always been like that, so I'm not sure what has happened between last year and this year. The drop-off in coaching calls has been glaring.