Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

A lot of fans, myself included, watched what happened on Saturday and have seen what's been happening all season, look at the stats that rank our Defense as one of the absolute worst in the country and think that there is no way Don Pellum doesn't get fired after this season.

But if I really think about it I see it's more likely that there is almost no way Helfrich will ever fire DP.
DP should have never been promoted in the first place, Helfrich should have seen that, Mullens should have seen that, but they did it anyway. It's one of the most clear cut cases of nepotism in college sports. "Hey this guys not qualified but he's my buddy so yeah, you've got the job"

Side note - At times I feel bad for DP, he's a super nice guy and it was clear after the Utah game that he had no idea what he was doing and I'm sure that sucks for him but still...

Outside of a 6-6 season and a loss to the Beaves I think it's highly unlikely DP get's let go. I would love to get some new blood in there, get a DC that is aggressive that can fire up the team that at least knows what they are doing.

But I would never root for my Ducks to have a bad season, or lose a couple games, or lose any games and unfortunately the only way we will see any changes is if the season goes in the toilet.

It's the fan's dilemma
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by pezsez1 »

This is more of the same-old circular discussion that's been happening since last year, and at this point it's a somewhat pointless thing to talk/argue about because different people here have different metrics for success -- which means we all view this issue from completely different perspectives.

I will say this though. If Oregon's D shows any kind of improvement as the year goes on, then I'd actually be surprised if Pellum gets fired.

Imagine the national perception of working for Oregon if people were hired/fired as recklessly as fans would like. Pellum fields a respectable defense in his first year here, and then -- with more inexperience than we've had in 15 years -- the defense struggles. BOOM, YOU ARE FIRED!!! Sounds like a great place to work, doesn't it?

(Random thought... I'm kind of surprised people are blaming Pellum and not Nick Allioti for apparent problems with defensive recruiting.)

Now, if this continues all season long, and not only do we keep getting beat but we actually show no signs of inspiration or improvement? Then, yeah, we could start talking about how shocking it might be if Pellum isn't fired. As it stands, though, this thread seems a bit premature. Even if you don't like Pellum -- and right now, I'm not sold on him, either -- everyone should be able to step back and look at this realistically. It's not the job of the AD to make decisions based on emotion.

But let's talk about Helfrich. Why do people keep talking about Helfrich as if he'd be afraid to fire a guy who is dragging down his operation? You do realize that Helfrich has millions of dollars personally at stake in Oregon's success, right? And people are entertaining the notion that he'd rather keep a friend on his staff (are they even friends?) than earn millions of dollars by keeping his own job?

That's just insane. It also doesn't reflect the reality that Helfrich just passed over a fourth-year junior QB in favor of a transfer who'd only been here for a few weeks.

I'm a pretty nice, laid-back guy in RL, to the point people sometimes mistake me as being passive. Yet I've fired two of my friends from my content team because they weren't pulling their weight. I have full confidence in Helf's ability to make the right personnel moves. Even if Pellum's hiring turns out to be a mistake, that doesn't make Helf a bad HC as long as he trims the fat at the right time.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

pezsez1 wrote:This is more of the same-old circular discussion that's been happening since last year, and at this point it's a somewhat pointless thing to talk/argue about because different people here have different metrics for success -- which means we all view this issue from completely different perspectives.

I will say this though. If Oregon's D shows any kind of improvement as the year goes on, then I'd actually be surprised if Pellum gets fired.

Imagine the national perception of working for Oregon if people were hired/fired as recklessly as fans would like. Pellum fields a respectable defense in his first year here, and then -- with more inexperience than we've had in 15 years -- the defense struggles. BOOM, YOU ARE FIRED!!! Sounds like a great place to work, doesn't it?

(Random thought... I'm kind of surprised people are blaming Pellum and not Nick Allioti for apparent problems with defensive recruiting.)

Now, if this continues all season long, and not only do we keep getting beat but we actually show no signs of inspiration or improvement? Then, yeah, we could start talking about how shocking it might be if Pellum isn't fired. As it stands, though, this thread seems a bit premature. Even if you don't like Pellum -- and right now, I'm not sold on him, either -- everyone should be able to step back and look at this realistically. It's not the job of the AD to make decisions based on emotion.

But let's talk about Helfrich. Why do people keep talking about Helfrich as if he'd be afraid to fire a guy who is dragging down his operation? You do realize that Helfrich has millions of dollars personally at stake in Oregon's success, right? And people are entertaining the notion that he'd rather keep a friend on his staff (are they even friends?) than earn millions of dollars by keeping his own job?

That's just insane. It also doesn't reflect the reality that Helfrich just passed over a fourth-year junior QB in favor of a transfer who'd only been here for a few weeks.
I'm guessing you didn't actually read what I wrote, that seems to be your thing. You just saw another opportunity to post the same tired argument in favor of our defense that you've been posting ad-nauseam for the past couple weeks.

Next time, before commenting, go ahead and actually read the original post.
Thanks
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by pezsez1 »

I'm guessing you didn't actually read what I wrote, that seems to be your thing. You just saw another opportunity to post the same tired argument in favor of our defense that you've been posting ad-nauseam for the past couple weeks.
No, I did read what you wrote, and it was very well thought-out except for your intro, which is the spark for the same-old circular convo.

Also, had you read what I wrote, you'd see I didn't even go there.

EDIT: I can see how you misunderstood my intention... but my point is that you have to look at this from the standpoint of someone who is a bit more objective. Emotional fans are not objective. If the D rebounded from this and actually salvaged a decent season, then firing Pellum would not send a great message about the inner-workings of our AD... so firing him would actually be more of a surprise than not firing him.

In short, this entire thread is probably at least six weeks premature.

Also, your second paragraph (about Helfrich) reflects a complete lack of understanding of Helf's reality.

But, hey, you're welcome.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by duckfan22 »

There's always the possibility if the defense continues to play the same way that
Pellum decides it's time to retire at the end of the year. Some coaches actually see the
light at the end of the tunnel and decide its best to move on in life.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

pezsez1 wrote:
I'm guessing you didn't actually read what I wrote, that seems to be your thing. You just saw another opportunity to post the same tired argument in favor of our defense that you've been posting ad-nauseam for the past couple weeks.
No, I did read what you wrote, and it was very well thought-out except for your intro, which is the spark for the same-old circular convo.

Also, had you read what I wrote, you'd see I didn't even go there.

EDIT: I can see how you misunderstood my intention... but my point is that you have to look at this from the standpoint of someone who is a bit more objective. Emotional fans are not objective. If the D rebounded from this and actually salvaged a decent season, then firing Pellum would not send a great message about the inner-workings of our AD... so firing him would actually be more of a surprise than not firing him.

In short, this entire thread is probably at least six weeks premature.

Also, your second paragraph (about Helfrich) reflects a complete lack of understanding of Helf's reality.

But, hey, you're welcome.
Dude, please just stop. It's clear that you've set yourself on this track of being the board contrarian and feel it necessary to disagree with everyone else, even if they aren't saying anything worth disagreeing with.
But I maintains that you either didn't read what I wrote or simply didn't understand what I wrote.
I didn't start this thread to get in nonsense arguments with you so unless you want to add something to the conversation.
Tell us why you think DP will or won't keep his job or really anything constructive please don't comment.
And don't tell me what is and isn't timely to talk about. You aren't a moderator, stop trying to act like one
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

duckfan22 wrote:There's always the possibility if the defense continues to play the same way that
Pellum decides it's time to retire at the end of the year. Some coaches actually see the
light at the end of the tunnel and decide its best to move on in life.
True, that could happen, but I have a hard time seeing it.
I think it's probably pretty hard to voluntarily give up a sweet job that you only just got
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by pezsez1 »

Dude, please just stop. It's clear that you've set yourself on this track of being the board contrarian and feel it necessary to disagree with everyone else, even if they aren't saying anything worth disagreeing with.
You're a relative newcomer in this community, so I forgive you for not having the proper context to make an educated assumption about my motivations. But had you been around here prior to 73 posts ago, you'd know that my views on the team have steadily evolved over a number of years.

I am outspoken, yes. Analytical, yes. But a contrarian? I think you need to look up what that means.
But I maintains that you either didn't read what I wrote or simply didn't understand what I wrote.
Fine. Not my problem.
I didn't start this thread to get in nonsense arguments with you so unless you want to add something to the conversation.
I did add something to the convo. You either didn't read it, ignored it or couldn't understand it. Ultimately, not my problem either.

And if you seriously did write this thread to have an objective conversation without bringing up nonsense points/arguments, then you did a really crappy job at it, especially with the nonsensical stuff you said about Helfrich.
Tell us why you think DP will or won't keep his job or really anything constructive please don't comment.
Already did. Again, for whatever reason, this has escaped you. Not my problem!
And don't tell me what is and isn't timely to talk about. You aren't a moderator, stop trying to act like one
My apologies if my posts are so well-constructed and direct that I come off as a self-proclaimed moderator. ;)
Willie Taggart is a dick.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I do not see Helfrich firing Pellum. I have no real insight into his position on Pellum. It is just a gut feeling. Helfrich seemed to be more interested in the continuity of the coaching staff... and while that is admirable.. it can also be something that loses its luster and teams start figuring out how to play against ya. I don't think it will matter at the end of year what Oregon's record will be. My gut feeling is unless Pellum becomes a man and admits he can not do the job... then we are stuck with him. In the end it will end up costing Helfrich his job as well. That is just my opinion. I know Pez as much as respect him as a contributor to the board is on the other side and will support Pellum no matter the record. Worse loss since 1977... being last in every major defensive category... being the laughing stock of the country... and people now thinking Oregon overrated has not changed his opinion of Pellum. I would suspect Jaws... nothing will.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

I definitely worry that we'll see the same thing we saw last year; bad defense all season but Pellum manages to pull things together the last couple games and as a result keeps his job. Meanwhile the fundamental, systemic flaws still exist and are largely ignored.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by pezsez1 »

I know Pez as much as respect him as a contributor to the board is on the other side and will support Pellum no matter the record.
This season is definitely changing my views on what should happen. But, as you know, my mindset coming into this season is obviously different than the mindsets of others, so it's going to take me longer to arrive at the "fire Pellum!" stage that others seem to be at right now.... hence, why I pointed out to Jaw that my views evolve over time... it's not like I've randomly supported the defense because I think it's fun or different.

I like 80s music, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Starbucks. I'm not exactly a hipster.

And if the defense improves, then yeah, I may not arrive at the "fire Pellum" stage (and the defense improving at this point is iffy). But it's pointless for me to speculate on how I'll feel two months from now; I'm more worried about whether the Ducks can win this Saturday.

I'd like to think that nobody's mind on anything is ever set in stone, as anything can change on any given Sunday... or, in this case, Saturday.

And to get this back on topic, I'll leave off by repeating what I said up above... that the defense would really have to keep tanking all season long to justify firing Pellum without potentially damaging the university's credibility in the eyes of his potential replacements. For him to retire or "resign" under those circumstances would be much more palatable.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:I definitely worry that we'll see the same thing we saw last year; bad defense all season but Pellum manages to pull things together the last couple games and as a result keeps his job. Meanwhile the fundamental, systemic flaws still exist and are largely ignored.
Exactly this. I don't see the defensive problems being something that can be easily fixed. Sure the secondary can cover better, players can stop blowing their assignments every other play but at this point it'd be like putting a band-aid on a bloody corpse.

I think, barring a total collapse and a 6-6 or below season, I don't see Pellum going anywhere. I just can't see how Helfrich, the guy who gave him the job in the first place, is going to fire him unless he has no choice.
Which is unfortunate as someone who wants us to have a good or at least serviceable defense, but as a fan I certainly don't want the Ducks to have a bad season, I want us to win every game going forward. Hence the conundrum.
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by fpsduck »

Unless we see some major changes to our defensive schemes and our anemic offense, I don't see how we get to 6 wins.
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2718
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by duckfan96 »

Some people support dp and others have been anti dp(jaw) since they joined. All that being said I wouldn't be surprised to see dp resign this offseason. What is Frosts excuse tho? Where are all the fire frost posts cause last game (and msu) the offense was fn horrible.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Don't be surprised if Pellum is still DC next season

Post by Jaw327 »

duckfan96 wrote:Some people support dp and others have been anti dp(jaw) since they joined. All that being said I wouldn't be surprised to see dp resign this offseason. What is Frosts excuse tho? Where are all the fire frost posts cause last game (and msu) the offense was fn horrible.
Frost's play calling has been terrible all year, I've said that a number of times. I don't think Offense is our biggest issue, I think it is certainly a big issue just not close to being the biggest.
Frost's lack luster play calling isn't the reason why Ducks D ranks close to the bottom in every major category.

I just can't see how DP would voluntarily resign. Would you? I think it's too hard to give up a cushy job without being pressured to do so.
After all this is only his second season as DC, I doubt he would be like "yeah, you guys are right, I suck, I'll resign"
Post Reply