I've always gotten a good laugh about that narrative. Roper completed 17 of 30 passes for 154yds and 4 TDs. JStes rushed for 253yds. Roped had a nice day,'but people love to lie about how he looked out there, and how we actually won that game. That game was dominated by Stew from start until finish.
Wait, what narrative?
I just said he tore it up in the bowl game. Did you mean to quote someone else?
All I'm saying is Allie deserves at least as much time as Roper had to get going. Roper needed at least a month to go from being "worse than Brady Leaf with two sprained ankles" to "killed a ranked team in the Sun Bowl."
I've always gotten a good laugh about that narrative. Roper completed 17 of 30 passes for 154yds and 4 TDs. JStes rushed for 253yds. Roped had a nice day,'but people love to lie about how he looked out there, and how we actually won that game. That game was dominated by Stew from start until finish.
Wait, what narrative?
I just said he tore it up in the bowl game. Did you mean to quote someone else?
All I'm saying is Allie deserves at least as much time as Roper had to get going. Roper needed at least a month to go from being "worse than Brady Leaf with two sprained ankles" to "killed a ranked team in the Sun Bowl."
Isn't it ironic that Roper, JStew and the Ducks, beat South Florida, the guy who's head coach was Jim Leavitt, currently the defensive coordinator at Colorado?
buckmarkduck wrote:
Chip wasn't what I'd call a qb developer, more like he was smart enough to work his O around the skills of the QBs he had. As you see in Philly, if his qb isn't very skilled, his O doesn't go very well just like our pass game this year.
I like Helf and frost, but I wonder if a qb coach isn't needed for the staff? Frost honestly hasn't shown any great skill at developing talent, and either WR or Qb, and Helf is busy with the entire team.
I agree with every part of what you said here. I think Helf probably spends a bit more time with QBs now than he does other positions, but it's not like he's leading their position meetings, so it's definitely a Frost issue. My pipe dream is Frost gets hired somewhere else, Oregon promotes Lubick to QB coach/OC, finds someone else to come in and coach WRs. But with the way the season is going, I can't imagine Frost will be more attractive as a HC candidate than he was last offseason.
what in lubick's past suggests he'd make a great qb coach? part of our problem right now with coaches is the Peter principle and promoting them one level above their competency.
buckmarkduck wrote:
Chip wasn't what I'd call a qb developer, more like he was smart enough to work his O around the skills of the QBs he had. As you see in Philly, if his qb isn't very skilled, his O doesn't go very well just like our pass game this year.
I like Helf and frost, but I wonder if a qb coach isn't needed for the staff? Frost honestly hasn't shown any great skill at developing talent, and either WR or Qb, and Helf is busy with the entire team.
I agree with every part of what you said here. I think Helf probably spends a bit more time with QBs now than he does other positions, but it's not like he's leading their position meetings, so it's definitely a Frost issue. My pipe dream is Frost gets hired somewhere else, Oregon promotes Lubick to QB coach/OC, finds someone else to come in and coach WRs. But with the way the season is going, I can't imagine Frost will be more attractive as a HC candidate than he was last offseason.
what in lubick's past suggests he'd make a great qb coach? part of our problem right now with coaches is the Peter principle and promoting them one level above their competency.
Sent from my KFASWI using Forum Fiend v1.3.3.
Yeah, just because your a OC doesn't mean you have to be the qb coach also. Lubick is a great WR coach, don't take that from him
Why Lubick as QB/OC- he was the passing game coordinator for a Heisman trophy winner, he has a proven record of recruiting, he has a proven record of developing talent, and he is already familiar with what Oregon does on offense meaning there would be no adjustment period (yet he has experience in many other offensive systems). More than anything, I like what players say about how he teaches, and feel it would translate to any position. He's a big advocate for using film from the professional ranks to coach technique to players. He doesn't want his players to look like college players, he wants them to look like all-pros.
pezsez1 wrote:Wasn't the first game Roper appeared in that 0-??? loss to UCLA?
Roper and the other guy (Kemp?) were so bad that when Dixon went down against Arizona, we opted to play the entire second half with Brady Leaf, who had sprained both of his ankles.
Roper played again in that OT Civil War loss before tearing it up in the Sun Bowl a month later.
I'm not trying to make excuses for Lockie at this point, but I think Taylor Allie deserves a bit of slack. He can run the option, and he did hit a huge pass in last night's game! He deserves massive props right now.
Cody Kempt. He was pretty awful in Chip's offense. If we started Roper instead of Kempt in the Civil War we probably win that game.
Roper was no Mariota, but he was 4-0 as a starter.
If you want to get straight to the bit that was quoted, jump to 12:55.
My take- Helf looked a little uncomfortable talking about the subject. It really seems like Mahalak lost the support of his coaches, and probably hasn't done enough to get it back, but the door will be open until he waves the white flag.
Thanks for the follow up. Man, I can't even wrap my mind around how bad he must be doing for there to be a "significant gap" between him and the other QB's.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
karlhungis wrote:Thanks for the follow up. Man, I can't even wrap my mind around how bad he must be doing for there to be a "significant gap" between him and the other QB's.
Seriously. It's kind of depressing. Watching the spring game, he didn't look bad and arguably threw the best ball out of the lot. Perhaps he's turning the ball over like crazy, because otherwise I have no idea how he could be so terrible.
karlhungis wrote:Thanks for the follow up. Man, I can't even wrap my mind around how bad he must be doing for there to be a "significant gap" between him and the other QB's.
It kinda cracked me up when I watched, because it seemed like Helf was trying really hard to explain Mahalak's growth in a politically correct way. After digging for a nice way to say it, it finally just came out bluntly.
Taj Griffin took some snaps at QB during the Spring game....and he's an awesome threat as a runner. The Lockie & Alie are NOT a threat to run at all. Why not let him take the reins against WSU and see what he may be able to do at QB until VA is ready to come back!