Recruiting Update - 10/14

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14

Post by StevensTechU »

SuperDuck wrote:
Uh, have you ever seen high school football played in Oklahoma? I'm not trying to be a jerk or anything, I'm just wondering. Those kids live and breathe football from the time they're in grade school. My cousin used to be a lower level high school coach and an assistant at a couple other mid-size and bigger schools. I used to help keep stats in the press box and have seen several games. Many of those kids are really good. I'd have a hard time seeing many or any of Oregon's premier teams "throttle" anyone at the top two levels there. That's just my opinion, though.
Since you're familiar with Oklahoma ball, can you offer a distinction between 6A-I, 6A-II, and 5A there? Wilson plays 5A, so perhaps I should even say that he plays in the 3rd highest division.

I grew up in a small town in Oregon, where people lived and breathed football (and wrestling), and if our high school team played a high caliber 6A team they would have murdered us because their talent across the board is greater.

My statement comes from two things, and I'll use two teams Sheldon has played this year as examples (Jesuit, Tigard)- national rankings (by MaxPreps and USA Today), and number of kids that end up playing in college. Jesuit has been a semi-frequent member of the USA Today Top 25 over the years, meaning they're really good on more than just a regional level. This year, MaxPreps has Jesuit currently ranked 153rd in the country, while the highest ranked team in all of Oklahoma 5A, Skiatook, is 315th, and the best team Wilson has played this year, Ardmore, is 1,008th in the country. Sherwood, also Oregon 6A, is ranked 100th.

Then on the comment about kids playing in college- Tigard has a sophomore DB with an offer from Purdue. Two-way lineman Conner Crist has Ivy League offers. I don't know every kid on the current roster, but 3 of their players from last year are playing D1 this year (Sam Inos, Tysen Prunty, and Pepe Tanuvasa). Further, one of the reasons that schools like So. Oregon, EWU, and Linfield have been wildly successful over the years is that, while there isn't a ton of Oregon talent, there's more than there's assumed to be, so they end up making lower-level schools look really good.

So I stand by my statement. And further, I think Jesuit, Sheldon, Sherwood, and West Linn could/would win Oklahoma 5A state titles.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14

Post by SuperDuck »

StevensTechU wrote:
SuperDuck wrote:
Uh, have you ever seen high school football played in Oklahoma? I'm not trying to be a jerk or anything, I'm just wondering. Those kids live and breathe football from the time they're in grade school. My cousin used to be a lower level high school coach and an assistant at a couple other mid-size and bigger schools. I used to help keep stats in the press box and have seen several games. Many of those kids are really good. I'd have a hard time seeing many or any of Oregon's premier teams "throttle" anyone at the top two levels there. That's just my opinion, though.
Since you're familiar with Oklahoma ball, can you offer a distinction between 6A-I, 6A-II, and 5A there? Wilson plays 5A, so perhaps I should even say that he plays in the 3rd highest division.

I grew up in a small town in Oregon, where people lived and breathed football (and wrestling), and if our high school team played a high caliber 6A team they would have murdered us because their talent across the board is greater.

My statement comes from two things, and I'll use two teams Sheldon has played this year as examples (Jesuit, Tigard)- national rankings (by MaxPreps and USA Today), and number of kids that end up playing in college. Jesuit has been a semi-frequent member of the USA Today Top 25 over the years, meaning they're really good on more than just a regional level. This year, MaxPreps has Jesuit currently ranked 153rd in the country, while the highest ranked team in all of Oklahoma 5A, Skiatook, is 315th, and the best team Wilson has played this year, Ardmore, is 1,008th in the country. Sherwood, also Oregon 6A, is ranked 100th.

Then on the comment about kids playing in college- Tigard has a sophomore DB with an offer from Purdue. Two-way lineman Conner Crist has Ivy League offers. I don't know every kid on the current roster, but 3 of their players from last year are playing D1 this year (Sam Inos, Tysen Prunty, and Pepe Tanuvasa). Further, one of the reasons that schools like So. Oregon, EWU, and Linfield have been wildly successful over the years is that, while there isn't a ton of Oregon talent, there's more than there's assumed to be, so they end up making lower-level schools look really good.

So I stand by my statement. And further, I think Jesuit, Sheldon, Sherwood, and West Linn could/would win Oklahoma 5A state titles.

And I'll just say that although I respect your opinion, I stand by mine, too and won't waste anymore energy on the subject. ;)
John 3:36
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14

Post by srsmiley007 »

StevensTechU wrote:
SuperDuck wrote:
Uh, have you ever seen high school football played in Oklahoma? I'm not trying to be a jerk or anything, I'm just wondering. Those kids live and breathe football from the time they're in grade school. My cousin used to be a lower level high school coach and an assistant at a couple other mid-size and bigger schools. I used to help keep stats in the press box and have seen several games. Many of those kids are really good. I'd have a hard time seeing many or any of Oregon's premier teams "throttle" anyone at the top two levels there. That's just my opinion, though.
Since you're familiar with Oklahoma ball, can you offer a distinction between 6A-I, 6A-II, and 5A there? Wilson plays 5A, so perhaps I should even say that he plays in the 3rd highest division.

I grew up in a small town in Oregon, where people lived and breathed football (and wrestling), and if our high school team played a high caliber 6A team they would have murdered us because their talent across the board is greater.

My statement comes from two things, and I'll use two teams Sheldon has played this year as examples (Jesuit, Tigard)- national rankings (by MaxPreps and USA Today), and number of kids that end up playing in college. Jesuit has been a semi-frequent member of the USA Today Top 25 over the years, meaning they're really good on more than just a regional level. This year, MaxPreps has Jesuit currently ranked 153rd in the country, while the highest ranked team in all of Oklahoma 5A, Skiatook, is 315th, and the best team Wilson has played this year, Ardmore, is 1,008th in the country. Sherwood, also Oregon 6A, is ranked 100th.

Then on the comment about kids playing in college- Tigard has a sophomore DB with an offer from Purdue. Two-way lineman Conner Crist has Ivy League offers. I don't know every kid on the current roster, but 3 of their players from last year are playing D1 this year (Sam Inos, Tysen Prunty, and Pepe Tanuvasa). Further, one of the reasons that schools like So. Oregon, EWU, and Linfield have been wildly successful over the years is that, while there isn't a ton of Oregon talent, there's more than there's assumed to be, so they end up making lower-level schools look really good.

So I stand by my statement. And further, I think Jesuit, Sheldon, Sherwood, and West Linn could/would win Oklahoma 5A state titles.
Excellent Call Steven. Appreciate your summary a ton. Really did a great job. Thanks for putting in the time on that. Also, solid compelling argument. In fairness, I'm convinced that Herbert is the real deal and first in quite some time so I'm not real concerned(for once in the last 2 months). While we (discussed him in a previous thread and you've seen my thoughts. The best distinguishing items beyond footwork, throwing motion, armstrength and abilty to read progressions is how the handle extreme pressure (bodies hanging on them, etc.) of all the film you've seen, they never show the QB throwing falling backwards with guys draped on their legs. Watch Herberts, there's not just one but multiple footage with bodies all over him and he makes the pass 20 - 40 yards thowing while falling backwards. That's the delta between the real deal and just "good measurables." All of the other guys (wilson, green, etc.) doesn't show anything other than throws in the clear.

Anyway, great work Steven. Keep it up and Thanks!
Post Reply