They won two Pac-12 Championships and the Rose Bowl once with Hogan starting as QB, I don't see how any of that can be pointed to bad coaching. And my stance is that this is the first real test for the coaches and saying that they're failing this far is an understatement.wlduck wrote:Hogan sucked for most of 3 years. Now he's playing great. Was it bad coaching before? Good coaching now? Same guys. Lot of Stanford fans thought McCaffery was under used last year. Bad coaching? Maybe.
Again, my stance is let the year play out and then see.
Food For Thought
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15452
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Food For Thought

-
cesame
- Two Star Recruit
- Posts: 102
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Why is this the first real test? Because there's no Mariota? .........
Helfrich took the team to the NCG last year. Even in years when Chip had a title contending team he managed to not get to the big game.
Down years happen and there's clearly a precedent set when teams lose their Heisman trophy winner and the program doesn't perform as well the next season. Combine that will losing your starting QB and it's no wonder why the Ducks aren't as good this year.
Props to the OP for bringing this thread up. Shaw was no less of a coach last year or against Northwestern the first game of the season this year.
Helfrich deserves a lot more benefit of the doubt then he's been getting.
Helfrich took the team to the NCG last year. Even in years when Chip had a title contending team he managed to not get to the big game.
Down years happen and there's clearly a precedent set when teams lose their Heisman trophy winner and the program doesn't perform as well the next season. Combine that will losing your starting QB and it's no wonder why the Ducks aren't as good this year.
Props to the OP for bringing this thread up. Shaw was no less of a coach last year or against Northwestern the first game of the season this year.
Helfrich deserves a lot more benefit of the doubt then he's been getting.
-
cesame
- Two Star Recruit
- Posts: 102
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Just look at last year how Helfrich and crew turned the ship around and finished the season
PAC 12 CG against 10-1 Arizona: 51-13
Rose Bowl against undefeated FSU: 59-20
So in those two huge Championship games the Ducks won by a combined score of 110-33. Certainly coaching has nothing to do with that.....
Yeah they lost to Ohio State, but they were playing with their hair on fire at the end of last season. They were simply the better team.
PAC 12 CG against 10-1 Arizona: 51-13
Rose Bowl against undefeated FSU: 59-20
So in those two huge Championship games the Ducks won by a combined score of 110-33. Certainly coaching has nothing to do with that.....
Yeah they lost to Ohio State, but they were playing with their hair on fire at the end of last season. They were simply the better team.
-
Duckattack7
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1106
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
- Location: Lake Oswego
Re: Food For Thought
I think we all wait and see what happens. I am all for getting rid of DP but if he can bring in a big recruiting class I say give him one more chance. If he flops then get rid of him. The secondary really is young and sometimes you just arent ready.
Return Of the Quack!
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Food For Thought
We played with fire those last few games of the year, no doubt. Our D looked legit for the first time in DP's short DC career. I feel like we have enough sample so far to recognize our outstanding defenses in those few games asan anomaly, and what we saw the majority of last year and the start of this year is closer to how DP's defenses. I think our defense was more talented last year, but I don't have an answer for those few games.cesame wrote:Just look at last year how Helfrich and crew turned the ship around and finished the season
PAC 12 CG against 10-1 Arizona: 51-13
Rose Bowl against undefeated FSU: 59-20
So in those two huge Championship games the Ducks won by a combined score of 110-33. Certainly coaching has nothing to do with that.....
Yeah they lost to Ohio State, but they were playing with their hair on fire at the end of last season. They were simply the better team.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15452
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Food For Thought
I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.

- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39397
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Food For Thought
I'm not sure why you have to call people who have a difference of opinion delusional. You seem to do a lot of namecalling over that more often than not.OregonFan4Life wrote:I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.

-
mdm0302
- Freshman
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:38 pm
- Location: Eugene O
Re: Food For Thought
agreed and agreedgreenyellow wrote:I'm not sure why you have to call people who have a difference of opinion delusional. You seem to do a lot of namecalling over that more often than not.OregonFan4Life wrote:I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15452
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Besides that point to when I was name calling? I'm just expression an opinion, maybe delusional wasn't the best word but I don't see how anyone can compare what Oregon is headed to where Stanford was last year. Whatever the sensitivity level on this board is way too high and quite annoying if you ask me. If you can't handle something like what I posted then you shouldn't be on a message board where debates are common.

-
mdm0302
- Freshman
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:38 pm
- Location: Eugene O
Re: Food For Thought
respectful debates?OregonFan4Life wrote:Besides that point to when I was name calling? I'm just expression an opinion, maybe delusional wasn't the best word but I don't see how anyone can compare what Oregon is headed to where Stanford was last year. Whatever the sensitivity level on this board is way too high and quite annoying if you ask me. If you can't handle something like what I posted then you shouldn't be on a message board where debates are common.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15452
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Hey back after Utah when I was expressing my opinion I had posters calling me bandwagon and saying that I'm not s true fan, why wasn't that an issue? But like I said, it's a forum, sometimes the debates get a little less respectful, and I try to stray from that, but sometimes I see posts I disagree with so passionately it happens. But like I said, I don't care when people name call me, it's just a forum, whatever.mdm0302 wrote:respectful debates?OregonFan4Life wrote:Besides that point to when I was name calling? I'm just expression an opinion, maybe delusional wasn't the best word but I don't see how anyone can compare what Oregon is headed to where Stanford was last year. Whatever the sensitivity level on this board is way too high and quite annoying if you ask me. If you can't handle something like what I posted then you shouldn't be on a message board where debates are common.

-
mdm0302
- Freshman
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:38 pm
- Location: Eugene O
Re: Food For Thought
ya i feel ya.. forums can get messyOregonFan4Life wrote:Hey back after Utah when I was expressing my opinion I had posters calling me bandwagon and saying that I'm not s true fan, why wasn't that an issue? But like I said, it's a forum, sometimes the debates get a little less respectful, and I try to stray from that, but sometimes I see posts I disagree with so passionately it happens. But like I said, I don't care when people name call me, it's just a forum, whatever.mdm0302 wrote:respectful debates?OregonFan4Life wrote:Besides that point to when I was name calling? I'm just expression an opinion, maybe delusional wasn't the best word but I don't see how anyone can compare what Oregon is headed to where Stanford was last year. Whatever the sensitivity level on this board is way too high and quite annoying if you ask me. If you can't handle something like what I posted then you shouldn't be on a message board where debates are common.
-
cesame
- Two Star Recruit
- Posts: 102
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Did those coaches lose their starting QB from the year before as well as the next season? Cause that's what happened.OregonFan4Life wrote:I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.
The whole narrative of Helfrich being lucky to have Mariota is as lame as it gets. He's the one who found, recruited and developed him. He gets every single bit of the credit for having Marcus on this team. That's not even debatable as far as I'm concerned. If you're not going to give credit to coaches who recruit and develop players then you're just being unreasonable.
If you're not happy with Helfrich after last season then you'll never be happy with 99.9% of the coaches Oregon would bring in. His Ducks beat the undefeated defending national champions by 39pts in the Rose Bowl. It's arguably the most successful win in program history. Off the top of my head it's arguably better than any win in the Chip Kelly era.
Shaw wasn't a bad coach last year
Sumlin wasn't a bad coach after losing 5 of his last 7 last year, including a 59-0 loss to Alabama
Auburn went 8-5 last year... is Malzahn a bad coach now? 4-2 this year and out of the college playoff probably. He sucks!
There needs to be more perspective. Now there are real issues on defense and the team should be better, so replacing Pellum is a real talk to have. But Helfrich? Forget about it. Way too soon.
-
wepto
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:07 pm
Re: Food For Thought
Frankly, the offense is doing fine. We have a top 10 offense--even with poor QB play. Every program is going to have years with poor QB play. It is the reality of the position; you can't recruit more than one quality QB most years. Frost and Greatwood are both doing a good job. There isn't a problem with the play calling. Criticising the play calling with the benefit of hindsight is one of the most annoying memes in sports.cesame wrote:Did those coaches lose their starting QB from the year before as well as the next season? Cause that's what happened.OregonFan4Life wrote:I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.
The whole narrative of Helfrich being lucky to have Mariota is as lame as it gets. He's the one who found, recruited and developed him. He gets every single bit of the credit for having Marcus on this team. That's not even debatable as far as I'm concerned. If you're not going to give credit to coaches who recruit and develop players then you're just being unreasonable.
If you're not happy with Helfrich after last season then you'll never be happy with 99.9% of the coaches Oregon would bring in. His Ducks beat the undefeated defending national champions by 39pts in the Rose Bowl. It's arguably the most successful win in program history. Off the top of my head it's arguably better than any win in the Chip Kelly era.
Shaw wasn't a bad coach last year
Sumlin wasn't a bad coach after losing 5 of his last 7 last year, including a 59-0 loss to Alabama
Auburn went 8-5 last year... is Malzahn a bad coach now? 4-2 this year and out of the college playoff probably. He sucks!
There needs to be more perspective. Now there are real issues on defense and the team should be better, so replacing Pellum is a real talk to have. But Helfrich? Forget about it. Way too soon.
That being said, Helfrich is the head coach. He needs to put a good, Pac 12 level defense on the field. This defense wouldn't be good in the Mountain West. Portland State might have a better defense. Still, Helfrich is doing half his job well, unlike Pellum, who continues to be completely clueless. Helf's seat is already warm--even though he probably won't get fired this year--would he keep his job if the team finishes 3-9? Hopefully we don't have to find out.
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: Food For Thought
So 8-5 and you're OK?OregonFan4Life wrote:I really can't understand the mentality and dare I say delusion of some duck fans! This isn't a down year, this looks to be way worse! 8-5 is a down year for consistent championship contenders, not dropping to bottom feeder level. This is the first real test cause they don't have arguably the best college football player ever, every other single college football coach would love to have had a Mariota during their career, but Helf was lucky enough to get him. Now that he doesn't have the miracle worker, this was the test for how he'd do with the type of team other coaches have, and it's looking miserable, and please stop blaming VA being injured! If Helf didn't want to deal with injuries then he should never have become a head coach. The way Oregon is playing this year is far worse than how Stanford was playing last year.