How many coaches should be fired?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

buckmarkduck wrote:
cesame wrote:Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

Morgan Mahalak is still very much in play. He's not even close to being a finished product, and as a redshirt FRESHMAN, don't even begin to start counting him out. Not every player comes in right away and shines like Mariota. He's the exception, not the rule.
Joey was the man midway through his So year, when Aj went out vs Arizona. Dixon started out fine then Bellotti ruined him, by screwing with his confidence. I can tell you, Morgan is in the dog house, maybe he turns it around but believe me the coaches during the summer, encouraged him to look elsewhere.

I don't understand how none of this is the coaches fault? I don't think anyone is saying to fire them because of it, but the blame belongs squarely on the coaches. It's pretty simple, now they need to fix it. UO hasn't had a bad #1 (not backups forced in due to injuries) qb in 25 years. I've said it before, even last year, frost is a fine OC, but I don't think he's a very good qb coach. They need to hire a qb guru. Not every OC in America is a qb coach.
So why worry when it happens after 1 season? Is there no faith in them to get it right going forward?

They probably have their future QB in Jonsen on the team already so it's just not something I'm going to panic about. Down years/transition years happen, and they're still averaging 41 pts/g with horrific QB play. It could be a lot worse.

Add Jonsen to the mix and the rushing attack next year will be lethal. Dilfer called him a Colin Kaepernick type athlete with his feet and athleticism.
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by fpsduck »

cesame wrote:Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

.
Joey came in and saved the Ducks' season as a sophomore (1999).

Darron Thomas looked great as a true freshman in the limited time he played.
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

fpsduck wrote:
cesame wrote:Why is Morgan Mahalak considered a miss? He's a redshirt freshman. Other than Mariota, when was the last time that young of a QB was the #1 guy for the Ducks? Let's take a look

Thomas was a redshirt sophomore
Masoli was a junior
Dixon wasn't the man until his SENIOR year
Kellen Clemens redshirt sophomore (split some reps with Fife that year)
JOEY HEISMAN wasn't the man until his JR year

.
Joey came in and saved the Ducks' season as a sophomore (1999).

Darron Thomas looked great as a true freshman in the limited time he played.
My point was being the unquestioned leader at QB coming into the season.

I know Joey came in but the season didn't start with him.

Darron Thomas did look great against Boise St, but the score was like 37-14 or something when he came in. That's a little different.

As far as Dixon to the poster above, he threw more INT's than TD's his JR year. That year he started off good but really went south as the season finished. He finally took off when he was a SR.

Maybe time proves Mahalak is a dud. It's just too early to make that call imo. He's only a redshirt freshman.
User avatar
MFRDuckFan
Senior
Posts: 4829
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:52 pm
Location: Medford

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by MFRDuckFan »

I love to re-visit this video when I think we're floundering because 2007 was a train wreck after we lost Dennis, 2008 was iffy with 3 losses and we won some games, but we had some tighter ones. Not the huge blow outs everyone seems to remember. THIS GAME WAS EPIC..........

The current football team should watch this video 100 times and see how much fire the Ducks brought that day. They had an absolute blast! Biggest joy was ruining little brother's bid for the Rose Bowl. Not that we're playing them today, but I enjoy the feel of that game. True joy by the players.

cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

timberduck wrote:If we didn't have Royce we would probably be the worst team in the Pac 12. Think about that. 9 months removed from playing in the natty.

Elite programs and elite coaches have down years, but they don't implode like this. They don't get blown out by 40+ points at home. When's the last time USC, Ohio State, Alabama etc. lost by 40 points in their own stadium? Has it ever happened?

This season is a failure of coaching at some level, probably multiple levels.
Last year Texas A&M lost 5 of their last 7 regular season games including a 59-0 loss to Alabama. Fire Kevin Sumlin?

In 2009 USC with Pete Carroll lost 55-21 to Stanford. Fire Pete Carroll?

Oregon has been so good for so long that I think fans are forgetting what it's like not to be a top 5 team every year. It happens.
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

And what did Texas A&M and USC have in common?

Breaking in new QB's, like Oregon is doing this year.
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3976
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by UofDuck »

And A&M fired their D coordinator.
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by vagusnerve »

cesame wrote:And what did Texas A&M and USC have in common?

Breaking in new QB's, like Oregon is doing this year.

Yeah, except they had QBs they were breaking in that would turn out to be good players.

We have Jeff Lockie.

I can't believe what I'm reading. The current QB depth chart looks like this:

Jeff Lockie jr
Taylor Alie ?? WALK ON
....

Vernon Adams Sr, injured
Travis Johnsen, fr injured
morgan mahalak fr ???

That is the worst QB depth chart I've ever seen at any level of college ball.

Good luck convincing me that isn't on the coaches. THey should have been recruiting the heck out of guys the last couple years, knowing that Jrod and Lockie would/should never play.

Now we're relying on a walk on?

It's a joke. Everyone read how other Pac 12 coaches were completely baffled about the choices this coaching staff has made. Big time coaching failures.
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by cesame »

Worst depth you've ever seen? So you thought Brady Leaf was good depth? The depth in 2008 after Masoli?

Even with the bad QB play this season, the offense is still averaging 41 pts/g, good for 9th in the country. The offense is still doing its job despite no QB.

The bigger problem is the defense. The injuries at QB just compound the problem and make the margin for error ever so slim.

Btw #9 Texas A&M just got smoked by #10 Alabama at home. Terrible QB play a big reason why they lost.

Is their answer to fire Kevin Sumlin? Alabama keeps stomping a mud hole in his program.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by Alan »

cesame wrote:Worst depth you've ever seen? So you thought Brady Leaf was good depth? The depth in 2008 after Masoli?

Even with the bad QB play this season, the offense is still averaging 41 pts/g, good for 9th in the country. The offense is still doing its job despite no QB.

The bigger problem is the defense. The injuries at QB just compound the problem and make the margin for error ever so slim.

Btw #9 Texas A&M just got smoked by #10 Alabama at home. Terrible QB play a big reason why they lost.

Is their answer to fire Kevin Sumlin? Alabama keeps stomping a mud hole in his program.
Just to stir the pot and......... His statement was tthe worst depth chart he has ever seen at "any level". He may be new to college footbal this week....... No apologies, just getting tired of all the negativity and off the cuff comments with no backing or research here.
vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by vagusnerve »

cesame wrote:Worst depth you've ever seen? So you thought Brady Leaf was good depth? The depth in 2008 after Masoli?

Even with the bad QB play this season, the offense is still averaging 41 pts/g, good for 9th in the country. The offense is still doing its job despite no QB.

The bigger problem is the defense. The injuries at QB just compound the problem and make the margin for error ever so slim.

Btw #9 Texas A&M just got smoked by #10 Alabama at home. Terrible QB play a big reason why they lost.

Is their answer to fire Kevin Sumlin? Alabama keeps stomping a mud hole in his program.
I'd take Brady leaf et al over lockie and alie. Not sure if you're serious? At least leaf could toss the ball down field. Lockie/alie combo is horrifyingly bad, if you don't see that I don't know what to tell you.

No reason to put words in my mouth, I'm not advocating firing helfrich. Pellum, yes could see that.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

cesame wrote:And what did Texas A&M and USC have in common?

Breaking in new QB's, like Oregon is doing this year.

And A&m did fire the DC.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by SuperDuck »

vagusnerve wrote:
cesame wrote:And what did Texas A&M and USC have in common?

Breaking in new QB's, like Oregon is doing this year.

Yeah, except they had QBs they were breaking in that would turn out to be good players.

We have Jeff Lockie.

I can't believe what I'm reading. The current QB depth chart looks like this:

Jeff Lockie jr
Taylor Alie ?? WALK ON
....

Vernon Adams Sr, injured
Travis Johnsen, fr injured
morgan mahalak fr ???

That is the worst QB depth chart I've ever seen at any level of college ball.

Good luck convincing me that isn't on the coaches. THey should have been recruiting the heck out of guys the last couple years, knowing that Jrod and Lockie would/should never play.

Now we're relying on a walk on?

It's a joke. Everyone read how other Pac 12 coaches were completely baffled about the choices this coaching staff has made. Big time coaching failures.
Okay, let me get this straight. It's Vernon Adams and Travis Jonsen's fault that they got injured, right? Also, it's all this staff's fault that Jeff Lockie, recruited during the Chip Kelly era, before Scott Frost ever became offensive coordinator, isn't doing well? They should definitely accept SOME of the responsibility, but they can't make the kid an instant success. He's been in the system 4 years now. He either gets it or he doesn't.

Morgan Mahalak apparently wasn't as up to speed as the rest of the QBs, so the coaches have him running the scout team. That's all the coaches fault? It's actually kind of a good thing that we have someone that talented with the scouts, because it's a huge part of game preparation for the rest of the team.

I realize that everyone's upset, and so am I, but this isn't entirely on the coaches - including Pellum. He should absolutely review his schemes and make changes or he won't be around much longer as a DC. Still, it's not his fault that Chris Seisay and Reggie Daniels were injured. Daniels is the only returning starter and Seisay played well replacing Ifo after he was lost for the playoffs last year. He has several players back there that are either true freshman or redshirt freshman. Pellum didn't do that.

You know how when a team loses a starter in the secondary and you expect the opposing coaches to pick on him because he's either not as good (obviously), not as experienced, young or all three? Well, how would you like to have that be 75% of your secondary?

I can go out on a limb and say that although we'll be better in some areas next year, we'll be worse at others. The entire team is going through a transition period and it's going to take at least another 1-2 years to get back to an elite level.
John 3:36
wlduck
Sophomore
Posts: 1722
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by wlduck »

All of them. At every school. And then they should be publicly flogged.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: How many coaches should be fired?

Post by buckmarkduck »

cesame wrote:Worst depth you've ever seen? So you thought Brady Leaf was good depth? The depth in 2008 after Masoli?

Even with the bad QB play this season, the offense is still averaging 41 pts/g, good for 9th in the country. The offense is still doing its job despite no QB.

The bigger problem is the defense. The injuries at QB just compound the problem and make the margin for error ever so slim.

Btw #9 Texas A&M just got smoked by #10 Alabama at home. Terrible QB play a big reason why they lost.

Is their answer to fire Kevin Sumlin? Alabama keeps stomping a mud hole in his program.

At some point a coach who has that much talent, will be asked to win a conference title or step aside. He's had serious talent and not won near as much as he should. He's approaching Tedford status.
Post Reply