Fans Calling Plays

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by Duck07 »

StevensTechU wrote:I'll be more concise with my point- Frost/Helfrich DID exactly what a strong contingent of fans have wanted them to do, and it was the worst mistake they made in this game. That's interesting. Secondly, nobody is saying people can't have their own opinions and offer criticisms; but don't be upset if your criticism receives its own criticism. We're all here for discourse.

I've thought playcalling has been atrocious in games this season, namely with how many designed runs for VA in the EWU and MSU games. This one I felt was actually decent, except for the packages with somebody other than Adams taking snaps. Die wildcat, die. (<-- see, I also have criticisms if that wasn't already apparent)
Most fans are lemmings of the finest order and just like to hear themselves talk. None of the changes on offense were things I wanted to see done for example.
Image
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by FlDuckFan »

Frost tried to get cute not creative with the exception if the end around. Installing RPO's like we used to, using motion to create a mismatch, some form a of a zone read . That's creativity, that's what has been Oregon football in our recent successful history. None of these things have been there consistently all season , along with the RB'S rotation which gets an excuse this week because we needed a rb with the ability to pick up the blitz.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by duckfan22 »

One creative play that caught my eye last night was the Touchdown to Carrington.
ASU didnt have enough defenders to cover all the receivers on the side Carrington was on.
Oregon motioned to that side and ASU was in a blitz with safetys. That left Carrington all by
himself.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by Duck24 »

StevensTechU wrote:I'll be more concise with my point- Frost/Helfrich DID exactly what a strong contingent of fans have wanted them to do, and it was the worst mistake they made in this game. That's interesting. Secondly, nobody is saying people can't have their own opinions and offer criticisms; but don't be upset if your criticism receives its own criticism. We're all here for discourse.

I've thought playcalling has been atrocious in games this season, namely with how many designed runs for VA in the EWU and MSU games. This one I felt was actually decent, except for the packages with somebody other than Adams taking snaps. Die wildcat, die. (<-- see, I also have criticisms if that wasn't already apparent)
Not being a smart ass but what was it that everyone wanted them to do? Addison as a QB?

I've been clamoring for us to throw the ball down the field which will free up more space at the second level for our RB's to get loose. The issue has been that we haven't had a QB capable of completing the deep pass until VA came back.

I think everyone (fans and media alike) agrees the play-calling last night was an absolute dumpster fire. Anyone with even a remedial knowledge of football knows that running up the middle against a team that frequently brings 6-7 guys is a bad idea. Yes, you may break one or two big ones if you get beyond the LOS but you are frequently going to put yourself in 2nd and 9 situations where your play-calling becomes much more predictable. The wildcat should have a special place in football purgatory.

Up until we got VA back I don't think the complaints of the play-calling had any merits because we didn't have a QB capable of playing at a D1 level. Now that he is back, the complaints are deserved. Very few teams have as much talent at the skill positions as Oregon yet the play-calling has impeded their abilities. Frost needs to get his crap together or Helf needs to take the play-calling duties back.
User avatar
AutzenMember
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1097
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:47 pm
Location: Hockinson, WA

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by AutzenMember »

Play calling is not just about what play is called...it is also about timing. WHEN the play is called. It looked to me like the OC had no clue what the defense was running (or didn't care). Royce is a beast, but has not chance up the middle against a stout run-blitz on 3rd and short. Wildcat on a 2-pt conversion??? Wrong time to call those plays.

EVERY play works when the players execute, but good play-calling gives players a better chance to execute. I didn't get the feeling that Frost had any idea what defense they would be facing from play to play, nor did they have appropriate audibles in place to counter. ASU blitzes pretty much EVERY play...so why not have a short route over the middle as a hot read designed into each play? Adams was getting surged with no receivers ready (look at some of the replays while Adams is under siege and you'll see the receivers in longer routes). Call plays where Adams can take advantage of the blitzes.

Offensive play-calling is a game of chess you play with the defensive calls. My opinion...Frost either doesn't know how to read/predict defenses, or is just flat out getting outmaneuvered/out-coached.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by duckfan22 »

play calling is also a guessing game. Your calling a play based on tendecies the other team
has shown either during the game or previous games. Does not mean the D-cord will show
that same alignment so to speak. Teams also show one thing and back out at the last minute.
I agree running up the middle wasnt the best choice last night. The best thing is a little more
misdirection plays. The end around worked because we caught ASU in a blitz to stop the middle run.
Oregon use to run plays to set up other plays...We would pound the middle and pound the middle then
bam a fly sweep or double reverse. We dont see that as much. But you have to have guy at qb to make
that work. We used to see some option out of the spread that we dont see now. We also dont make enough
use of the tight end. We have skill there and have always been a huge weapon. I think as long as VA stays healthy
we see more tight end passing.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by UOducksTK1 »

You talk about wildcats and creativity. I think having Royce as a wildcat makes no sense, you need someone who can change direction quickly, and get through the hole fast. And he's got to at least have a decent ability to throw the ball. So the idea is OK, we just suck at execution and it was terribly implemented. And once it doesn't work a few times, don't beat it to death. We learned all this, the hard way last night. I mean was anyone really guessing what would happen when Royce was the lone player in the backfield those two plays? ASU can stack all 11 guys, Royce isn't going to throw it lol.

And about the creativity, yes I saw it in the first half. There were definitely a few plays (some blown dead like you pointed out), that looked solid. I liked that! Even a couple plays that didn't work out, I saw some variety, it was awesome to see. But then we had a couple of attempted half back passes / trick plays that just blew up in our face. I swear, the timing of these trick plays and just how it develops is the worst. Maybe that's not all on the coaches, but I don't know a team that executes trick plays more poorly than Oregon this year.

So hey, yes a little props to the coaches for a little variety, but it was still hard to watch. Like I said, Oregon's execution on some of their creativity and trick plays is pretty bad.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

I just looked it up and our offense is still 8th in the country in total yards, 12th in YPG and averaging 42 points a game, which is 8th in the country as well. Obviously the play calling left a lot to be desired but the offense is producing and putting up really good numbers considering what we've had at QB for the majority of the season.

The defense is everything that's wrong with this team. They are 118th in YPG, 124th in pass YPG, and 117th PPG (38.4) I'm becoming a broken record but our offensive success has ruined our ability to objectively analyze this team. The expectations for the offense are unrealistically high and at the same time we expect NOTHING from the defense. People are just as upset about our top ten offense as they are about our BOTTOM FOUR defense. It's insanity.
Image
rockthief
Senior
Posts: 4877
Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
Location: Stand By Me

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by rockthief »

Pellum has to be sweating about his impending demise. It has to occur because how could it not? Offense is fun to watch while the defense makes me cringe repeatedly. After eight games one with think something would be tweak with the defense but I sure don't see a thing. Buckner is so good, so very good. Lucky for us!
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by fpsduck »

AutzenMember wrote:Play calling is not just about what play is called...it is also about timing. WHEN the play is called. It looked to me like the OC had no clue what the defense was running (or didn't care). Royce is a beast, but has not chance up the middle against a stout run-blitz on 3rd and short. Wildcat on a 2-pt conversion??? Wrong time to call those plays.

Offensive play-calling is a game of chess you play with the defensive calls. My opinion...Frost either doesn't know how to read/predict defenses, or is just flat out getting outmaneuvered/out-coached.

Winner winner, chicken dinner.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by duckfan22 »

Next Saturday night will be a real challenge.. You have a pass happy Cal team coming in with
a decent but not great defense. If Cal's QB iS allowed to stand in the pocket and thorw
in comfort it will make for a long night. And our offense has to be on spot...
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by srsmiley007 »

pezsez1 wrote:
I've thought playcalling has been atrocious in games this season, namely with how many designed runs for VA in the EWU and MSU games. This one I felt was actually decent, except for the packages with somebody other than Adams taking snaps. Die wildcat, die. (<-- see, I also have criticisms if that wasn't already apparent)
Agreed.

I don't think I ever go through a single game without having "fan moments" and getting worked up over play calls here and there... but the offense executed a decent game plan last night that exploited ASU's blitzing. Cut out that OT wildcat, and I'd feel much better (but Frost actually offered a pretty interesting explanation for that play in the interview linked here).
Pez is back.... Welcome home brother. In fairness we're all getting worked up. Frost definitely screwed up some last night be not awful. It's funny how we are all griping about the O when they still put up 41 in regulation. Ugghh, has anyone seen the D lately? Any concerns about the scheme, play calls and adjustments there? While we want to crush Frost I think I can give him a pass for what hasn't been his finest year but this D (last year and this year) is ridiculous. Without turnovers the scheme is atrocious and especially the development of the LB's. Everyone's crushing the DB's but look at the ILB's they're worse than ever. When was the last time any of you saw an ILB shoot a gap for a TFL. Walker did a little last year but this is horrible.... DP is the single biggest downfall of this program and with only his 29 years at Oregon, he is a lock to never adapt or change his scheme, techniques, etc. Please retire, pretty please...
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by UOducksTK1 »

fpsduck wrote:
AutzenMember wrote:Play calling is not just about what play is called...it is also about timing. WHEN the play is called. It looked to me like the OC had no clue what the defense was running (or didn't care). Royce is a beast, but has not chance up the middle against a stout run-blitz on 3rd and short. Wildcat on a 2-pt conversion??? Wrong time to call those plays.

Offensive play-calling is a game of chess you play with the defensive calls. My opinion...Frost either doesn't know how to read/predict defenses, or is just flat out getting outmaneuvered/out-coached.

Winner winner, chicken dinner.
Totally agree, execution and timing of plays are poor right now. The wildcat and halfback pass plays weren't necessarily bad calls, just called at the time and executed at a very low level. We'll get it together eventually... No better time than next Saturday against Cal!

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
wlduck
Sophomore
Posts: 1722
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by wlduck »

FlDuckFan wrote:Frost tried to get cute not creative with the exception if the end around. Installing RPO's like we used to, using motion to create a mismatch, some form a of a zone read . That's creativity, that's what has been Oregon football in our recent successful history. None of these things have been there consistently all season , along with the RB'S rotation which gets an excuse this week because we needed a rb with the ability to pick up the blitz.
And this feels like why coaches get frustrated with fan/media reactions to games. The end around play was creative.........because it worked? Now obviously that's the final say about good/bad- did it work. But there are plenty of plays called by coaches that have good reasons to be called, and just fail because of execution, or something the other team does. One of my favorite things to do while watching games with friends is ask "what would you do here?" before a play is run. Slows down the criticism afterwards sometimes.

I'm not negating what you said, or other comments people have made about play calling. I just think this illustrates fan thinking. It worked, so the reasoning was sound. If it fails, it was poorly thought out. And that's not always the case.
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by FlDuckFan »

wlduck wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:Frost tried to get cute not creative with the exception if the end around. Installing RPO's like we used to, using motion to create a mismatch, some form a of a zone read . That's creativity, that's what has been Oregon football in our recent successful history. None of these things have been there consistently all season , along with the RB'S rotation which gets an excuse this week because we needed a rb with the ability to pick up the blitz.
And this feels like why coaches get frustrated with fan/media reactions to games. The end around play was creative.........because it worked? Now obviously that's the final say about good/bad- did it work. But there are plenty of plays called by coaches that have good reasons to be called, and just fail because of execution, or something the other team does. One of my favorite things to do while watching games with friends is ask "what would you do here?" before a play is run. Slows down the criticism afterwards sometimes.

I'm not negating what you said, or other comments people have made about play calling. I just think this illustrates fan thinking. It worked, so the reasoning was sound. If it fails, it was poorly thought out. And that's not always the case.
End around was a good play because it got our athlete the ball in space, not because it did worked. Freeman at wildcat when our line has been subpar is a bad idea because everyone is going to play the run. Addison in at QB looked like it had never been practiced before or had only a hand full of reps. When someone who isn't the QB is taking the snap the defense is going to pin their ears back and bring the pressure thus putting Freeman and Addison at a disadvantage and giving them a smaller room to work.
Post Reply