Good and Bad against ASU
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Good and Bad against ASU
I really want to hear some analysis of what people observed in last night's game. Feel free to add to my list or disagree with any points.
Good-
-Robinson and Springs at the corners is looking like a solid tandem. DB group did alright last night.
-DL, maybe not all game but Mondeaux played with fire. And overall we had decent pressure for rarely blitzing. It's actually incredible compared to ASU who blitzes constantly.
-VA's long ball. It's deadly. It was a little hard to go deep too much just because ASU blitzes so much, but that option is totally there.
-Kicking game, other than our punting, it's been solid. Our special teams as a whole outplayed ASU.
-Explosive plays, nice to see some big plays. Missed that.
-We won.
Bad-
-Ugo Amadi. I know he will be a good player for us, but right now he is getting pushed around a lot.
-Offensive execution, I feel like we had a few plays fail due to execution (Carrington's drop, penalty on the Allen endaround, and VA throwing behind or missing receivers on screen/short routes). It was hard for us to get many sustaining drives. We relied heavily on some big plays. Won't work against Stanford.
-Don Pellum, almost 750 yards and 40 first downs. You can't have Oregon's roster an allow that against ASU. If I performed that way at my job, I'd get fired.
-Rodney Hardrick, I hate to say bad things about a duck, but Hardrick is definitely one of the worst LBs I think I've seen play at Oregon. He's frequently out of position, missing tackles, etc. Our LB as a whole was pretty bad last night, but Hardrick usually leads the way. Also noticed we don't rotate many LBs. Seems like Mattingly and Ragin are the only two off the bench.
-Picking up the blitz. You know what ASU will do, but we struggled to find a solution. Coaching problem.
Overall-
Gotta love how we fought though. A win is a win. Reminded me a lot of that Arizona game when Masoli threw the game tying TD to Dickson.
Good-
-Robinson and Springs at the corners is looking like a solid tandem. DB group did alright last night.
-DL, maybe not all game but Mondeaux played with fire. And overall we had decent pressure for rarely blitzing. It's actually incredible compared to ASU who blitzes constantly.
-VA's long ball. It's deadly. It was a little hard to go deep too much just because ASU blitzes so much, but that option is totally there.
-Kicking game, other than our punting, it's been solid. Our special teams as a whole outplayed ASU.
-Explosive plays, nice to see some big plays. Missed that.
-We won.
Bad-
-Ugo Amadi. I know he will be a good player for us, but right now he is getting pushed around a lot.
-Offensive execution, I feel like we had a few plays fail due to execution (Carrington's drop, penalty on the Allen endaround, and VA throwing behind or missing receivers on screen/short routes). It was hard for us to get many sustaining drives. We relied heavily on some big plays. Won't work against Stanford.
-Don Pellum, almost 750 yards and 40 first downs. You can't have Oregon's roster an allow that against ASU. If I performed that way at my job, I'd get fired.
-Rodney Hardrick, I hate to say bad things about a duck, but Hardrick is definitely one of the worst LBs I think I've seen play at Oregon. He's frequently out of position, missing tackles, etc. Our LB as a whole was pretty bad last night, but Hardrick usually leads the way. Also noticed we don't rotate many LBs. Seems like Mattingly and Ragin are the only two off the bench.
-Picking up the blitz. You know what ASU will do, but we struggled to find a solution. Coaching problem.
Overall-
Gotta love how we fought though. A win is a win. Reminded me a lot of that Arizona game when Masoli threw the game tying TD to Dickson.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
rockthief
- Senior
- Posts: 4877
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
- Location: Stand By Me
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
Well done.
I cannot figure our LB play. I am completely flummoxed there. If we are that bad how about playing guys who will be here next year.
I cannot figure our LB play. I am completely flummoxed there. If we are that bad how about playing guys who will be here next year.
-
srsmiley007
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 745
- Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
It's not the talent all it's the coach. DP is also the ILB coach and after 29 years can't point to a Hall of Famer or highly esteemed LB that he ever coached. Not one..... Kiko is by all accounts the only one of note but that was only for 1 year. I'm leaving Matthews out of discussion because of bloodline and starting sometimes over a 5 year career doesn't count. He's awful at individual coaching and coordinating. Problem is that LB's are the heart and sole of any defense and should be able to assist with the short passing game and of course, dominate the running game.... Here it's neither.
Mattingly should be starting. Swain should also start seeing some time. However, I think he doesn't really know how to coach the position or identify real talent. I always felt that Coleman would've made a much better inside LB than Outside. Malone was awful. Walkers actually gotten worse with his tutelage. What's weird is the line play actually appears better and the OLB's seem to be a bit better.
I agree with y'all on the players.. Hardrick most especially. He's almost like a coaches son out there. No talent, terrible for years and they keep expecting him to yield a different result. It's a joke. He's been the worst player on defense for 2 years. I don't think it's a case of JW and RH being better as much as a seniority thing. Again, coach not playing the right guys.
Mattingly should be starting. Swain should also start seeing some time. However, I think he doesn't really know how to coach the position or identify real talent. I always felt that Coleman would've made a much better inside LB than Outside. Malone was awful. Walkers actually gotten worse with his tutelage. What's weird is the line play actually appears better and the OLB's seem to be a bit better.
I agree with y'all on the players.. Hardrick most especially. He's almost like a coaches son out there. No talent, terrible for years and they keep expecting him to yield a different result. It's a joke. He's been the worst player on defense for 2 years. I don't think it's a case of JW and RH being better as much as a seniority thing. Again, coach not playing the right guys.
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
Good:
-VA
-The effort and emotion the team played with. Haven't seen that in a while.
Bad:
-The defense
Worse:
-The coaching
-VA
-The effort and emotion the team played with. Haven't seen that in a while.
Bad:
-The defense
Worse:
-The coaching
-
uostudent
- Senior
- Posts: 3561
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:03 pm
- Location: Los Angeles
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
Oregon's secondary is young and inexperienced, but will get better.
What's worrisome is what they have at LB.
A few good points:
-Tyson Coleman would probably be more productive as an ILB. As an outside pass rusher, he tends to overpursue.
-Joe Walker has declined this season. Not sure if he's getting bad reads or is just out of position.
-Rodney Hardrick is atrocious. Seems like a good guy, but is truly a terrible all around football player.
Jimmie Swain definitely needs to play more. The talent is there, he just needs reps. I'm not nearly as impressed with Mattingly. The guy is very talented, but doesn't have the best instincts.
Evan Baylis is a great blocking TE, but he would have been an awesome ILB.
What's worrisome is what they have at LB.
A few good points:
-Tyson Coleman would probably be more productive as an ILB. As an outside pass rusher, he tends to overpursue.
-Joe Walker has declined this season. Not sure if he's getting bad reads or is just out of position.
-Rodney Hardrick is atrocious. Seems like a good guy, but is truly a terrible all around football player.
Jimmie Swain definitely needs to play more. The talent is there, he just needs reps. I'm not nearly as impressed with Mattingly. The guy is very talented, but doesn't have the best instincts.
Evan Baylis is a great blocking TE, but he would have been an awesome ILB.
“If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way,” he said. “We turned the ball over a lot. We beat ourself. Just be real with yourself right now. We beat ourself.”
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
And frankly I think our secondary already has shown signs of improvement. Ihenacho and Amadi were just too raw to be thrown into the mix so early.uostudent wrote:Oregon's secondary is young and inexperienced, but will get better.
What's worrisome is what they have at LB.
A few good points:
-Tyson Coleman would probably be more productive as an ILB. As an outside pass rusher, he tends to overpursue.
-Joe Walker has declined this season. Not sure if he's getting bad reads or is just out of position.
-Rodney Hardrick is atrocious. Seems like a good guy, but is truly a terrible all around football player.
Jimmie Swain definitely needs to play more. The talent is there, he just needs reps. I'm not nearly as impressed with Mattingly. The guy is very talented, but doesn't have the best instincts.
Evan Baylis is a great blocking TE, but he would have been an awesome ILB.
I said this in a different thread, but I agree that Walker has definitely had a disappointing season. Coleman has probably been our best LB this year.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
No one talks about the play, but Allen dropped a potential TD also on a short throw. He had no one in front of him if he catches it.
The lb play. Let's just say, the 4 SRs can't graduate soon enough.
Nelson had 15 tackles, not bad for a guy who just switched to D. Though I'd like to see him play O still from time to time, he's just to explosive with the ball to not play him.
Adams looked like Russel Wilson on some of those plays out there. He's showing a lot more zip on his passes and a little bit better feet as he gets healthy.
Benoits play was a huge boost, wish we would have gone with a few two back sets (one on each side of the qb) with him in there. Seemed like we were more willing to do that in years past, but not much this year. I think he deserves to play more.
The lb play. Let's just say, the 4 SRs can't graduate soon enough.
Nelson had 15 tackles, not bad for a guy who just switched to D. Though I'd like to see him play O still from time to time, he's just to explosive with the ball to not play him.
Adams looked like Russel Wilson on some of those plays out there. He's showing a lot more zip on his passes and a little bit better feet as he gets healthy.
Benoits play was a huge boost, wish we would have gone with a few two back sets (one on each side of the qb) with him in there. Seemed like we were more willing to do that in years past, but not much this year. I think he deserves to play more.
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
You'd have to set the bar pretty low to see improvement here. Bercovici looked like Mariota out there completing 32 passes for 398 yards and 5 touchdowns. We picked him off twice="improvement"? Ugh, its ugly, all the way around. This might be historically the worst defense Oregon has every fielded.UOducksTK1 wrote:
And frankly I think our secondary already has shown signs of improvement.
-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
I would also add Carrington in to the good. Other than the one terrible drop, he was fantastic.Duck24 wrote:Good:
-VA
-The effort and emotion the team played with. Haven't seen that in a while.
Bad:
-The defense
Worse:
-The coaching
Our defense is allowing schools to set records against us. ASU has had a pedestrian offense until they play us, then boom... most yards and first downs in school history. DP is now officially embarrassing the program.
Scott Frost is a moron. Those "trick" plays were some of the dumbest "tricks" I've seen. Did he see all of the attention that the Colts got for their moronic trick play and think that he wanted in on that action?
Between Frost and Pellum, our coaching staff did everything they could do to try and lose this game but thankfully the players still made enough plays to pull off the win. My hat is off to the players, but my lord I am sick and tired of some of the crap our staff is pulling.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
QuackininBama wrote:You'd have to set the bar pretty low to see improvement here. Bercovici looked like Mariota out there completing 32 passes for 398 yards and 5 touchdowns. We picked him off twice="improvement"? Ugh, its ugly, all the way around. This might be historically the worst defense Oregon has every fielded.UOducksTK1 wrote:
And frankly I think our secondary already has shown signs of improvement.
I agree with both sides here. But let's be real. I'd bet half of those completions are to guys the Lbs were responsible for. They all 4 suck.
As for Frost, I agree the trick plays are terrible, but he's a 2nd year OC he'll learn. And even with half our games having two guys at qb who should be on the cheer squad, our O is still 12th in the country.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
This. A lot of those yards were yards after catch. Bercovici didn't complete very many passes longer than 15 yards in the air. Poor tackling and poor LB play probably is responsible for half of those yards. Take Amadi out, and the DB core played a good game.buckmarkduck wrote:QuackininBama wrote:You'd have to set the bar pretty low to see improvement here. Bercovici looked like Mariota out there completing 32 passes for 398 yards and 5 touchdowns. We picked him off twice="improvement"? Ugh, its ugly, all the way around. This might be historically the worst defense Oregon has every fielded.UOducksTK1 wrote:
And frankly I think our secondary already has shown signs of improvement.
I agree with both sides here. But let's be real. I'd bet half of those completions are to guys the Lbs were responsible for. They all 4 suck.
As for Frost, I agree the trick plays are terrible, but he's a 2nd year OC he'll learn. And even with half our games having two guys at qb who should be on the cheer squad, our O is still 12th in the country.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
And I know applying transitive property to football is ignorant, but when I watch the job Harbaugh has done at Michigan who has been struggling for some time now, I wonder why Oregon, who has been flying high getting some of the best recruits in the nation can't at least field an average defense. In ONE YEAR Harbaugh, with not even nearly the same recruiting classes Oregon has been getting is the number one ranked defense in the nation, giving up 242 yards a game, only given up 91 points for an average of 11.4 points a game to offenses.
I know, I know, we are playing much better competition, this is true, but there is no excuse for how bad a job Pellum has done, he just isn't fit for the job. With even an average defense we are going to the Rose Bowl this year. You can't tell me with the national brand Phil and the university has build we can't attract even an average defensive coordinator..........
I know, I know, we are playing much better competition, this is true, but there is no excuse for how bad a job Pellum has done, he just isn't fit for the job. With even an average defense we are going to the Rose Bowl this year. You can't tell me with the national brand Phil and the university has build we can't attract even an average defensive coordinator..........
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
Not that we are lacking in skill position players, but having him in the first 6 games could have been the difference between a W and a L. He's a talented player.karlhungis wrote:I would also add Carrington in to the good. Other than the one terrible drop, he was fantastic.Duck24 wrote:Good:
-VA
-The effort and emotion the team played with. Haven't seen that in a while.
Bad:
-The defense
Worse:
-The coaching
BTW on his first touchdown, pretty sure he flashed ASU logo with his hand and then did a very discrete cut throat. Lol he hasn't completed learned from when Addison did it, but at least it was much more secretive.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
QuackininBama wrote:And I know applying transitive property to football is ignorant, but when I watch the job Harbaugh has done at Michigan who has been struggling for some time now, I wonder why Oregon, who has been flying high getting some of the best recruits in the nation can't at least field an average defense. In ONE YEAR Harbaugh, with not even nearly the same recruiting classes Oregon has been getting is the number one ranked defense in the nation, giving up 242 yards a game, only given up 91 points for an average of 11.4 points a game to offenses.
I know, I know, we are playing much better competition, this is true, but there is no excuse for how bad a job Pellum has done, he just isn't fit for the job. With even an average defense we are going to the Rose Bowl this year. You can't tell me with the national brand Phil and the university has build we can't attract even an average defensive coordinator..........
A quick search would show you that it's actually Michigan who has out recruited the ducks over the last 4 years, not the other way around. So don't go giving Harbaugh to much credit, he's a stupid play by a intern coach from having L #3 last night, with a D possessing 2 of the top 5 corners in America. They have ton of talent, just Houke was a bad coach.
Last edited by buckmarkduck on Sun Nov 01, 2015 11:50 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
TualatinDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 2439
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
- Location: Tualatin
Re: Good and Bad against ASU
Bad;
DP's defense. Im not one to call for a coaches head but I just cant wrap my head around how bad our defense is this year. Its seriously embarassing. Even the Beavers held Utah to 27...........
Running between the tackles when edge runs were $ and there all night.
Good;
We figured out how to score points.
DP's defense. Im not one to call for a coaches head but I just cant wrap my head around how bad our defense is this year. Its seriously embarassing. Even the Beavers held Utah to 27...........
Running between the tackles when edge runs were $ and there all night.
Good;
We figured out how to score points.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher