Fans Calling Plays

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by karlhungis »

FlDuckFan wrote:
wlduck wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:Frost tried to get cute not creative with the exception if the end around. Installing RPO's like we used to, using motion to create a mismatch, some form a of a zone read . That's creativity, that's what has been Oregon football in our recent successful history. None of these things have been there consistently all season , along with the RB'S rotation which gets an excuse this week because we needed a rb with the ability to pick up the blitz.
And this feels like why coaches get frustrated with fan/media reactions to games. The end around play was creative.........because it worked? Now obviously that's the final say about good/bad- did it work. But there are plenty of plays called by coaches that have good reasons to be called, and just fail because of execution, or something the other team does. One of my favorite things to do while watching games with friends is ask "what would you do here?" before a play is run. Slows down the criticism afterwards sometimes.

I'm not negating what you said, or other comments people have made about play calling. I just think this illustrates fan thinking. It worked, so the reasoning was sound. If it fails, it was poorly thought out. And that's not always the case.
End around was a good play because it got our athlete the ball in space, not because it did worked. Freeman at wildcat when our line has been subpar is a bad idea because everyone is going to play the run. Addison in at QB looked like it had never been practiced before or had only a hand full of reps. When someone who isn't the QB is taking the snap the defense is going to pin their ears back and bring the pressure thus putting Freeman and Addison at a disadvantage and giving them a smaller room to work.
What made matters worse for me is that when Freeman was back there for the direct snap, with the box completely loaded ready to attack the run.... we motion out the only chance we had to do anything other than run Freeman up the gut. And what do you know... it got stuffed.

Then on the Addison play, again...ASU was loading the box, clearly not respecting the pass threat and a time out was called. They had a chance to do something different but no, same damned play even after ASU had even more time to think about it, with predictable results.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
wlduck
Sophomore
Posts: 1722
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by wlduck »

karlhungis wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
wlduck wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:Frost tried to get cute not creative with the exception if the end around. Installing RPO's like we used to, using motion to create a mismatch, some form a of a zone read . That's creativity, that's what has been Oregon football in our recent successful history. None of these things have been there consistently all season , along with the RB'S rotation which gets an excuse this week because we needed a rb with the ability to pick up the blitz.
And this feels like why coaches get frustrated with fan/media reactions to games. The end around play was creative.........because it worked? Now obviously that's the final say about good/bad- did it work. But there are plenty of plays called by coaches that have good reasons to be called, and just fail because of execution, or something the other team does. One of my favorite things to do while watching games with friends is ask "what would you do here?" before a play is run. Slows down the criticism afterwards sometimes.

I'm not negating what you said, or other comments people have made about play calling. I just think this illustrates fan thinking. It worked, so the reasoning was sound. If it fails, it was poorly thought out. And that's not always the case.
End around was a good play because it got our athlete the ball in space, not because it did worked. Freeman at wildcat when our line has been subpar is a bad idea because everyone is going to play the run. Addison in at QB looked like it had never been practiced before or had only a hand full of reps. When someone who isn't the QB is taking the snap the defense is going to pin their ears back and bring the pressure thus putting Freeman and Addison at a disadvantage and giving them a smaller room to work.
What made matters worse for me is that when Freeman was back there for the direct snap, with the box completely loaded ready to attack the run.... we motion out the only chance we had to do anything other than run Freeman up the gut. And what do you know... it got stuffed.

Then on the Addison play, again...ASU was loading the box, clearly not respecting the pass threat and a time out was called. They had a chance to do something different but no, same damned play even after ASU had even more time to think about it, with predictable results.
Predictable? He dropped the snap. He's a 4th year wide receiver who has played in a ton of big games. I don't think that an experienced WR dropping a snap right to him is predictable. And yet watch that play again. If he handles the snap it looked like the play had a good chance. There was space and blockers in front. I don't know if it would have worked or not.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by Duck07 »

What hasn't been discussed at all in this thread is that Playcalling is not a result of what you do on Saturday alone. Playcalling is about everything you did during the week to prepare for this opponent.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Fans Calling Plays

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Rewatched some of the game, I actually do applaud the offense for making adjustments and trying to introduce some creativity. The play calling as a whole was still average at best, but the desire to make changes when things haven't been working so great made me happy.

A step in the right direction, but still lots of room for refinement. I think we see Oregon's offense have a coming-out party against Cal.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Post Reply