What's Wrong With the Defense
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Woah there, Bucky.
I'm not using anything as an excuse. I'm just pointing out the very simple fact that our defense has been simplified, and that's part of the reason it's so bad.
Isn't that the whole purpose of this thread? To discuss things that are wrong with the defense?
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
The simplification of our defense is what it is, and it could be blamed on either poor coaching or a lack of talent/experience -- or both -- but frankly I don't care about delving into that too deeply. I'll let y'all take those liberties.
I'm not using anything as an excuse. I'm just pointing out the very simple fact that our defense has been simplified, and that's part of the reason it's so bad.
Isn't that the whole purpose of this thread? To discuss things that are wrong with the defense?
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
The simplification of our defense is what it is, and it could be blamed on either poor coaching or a lack of talent/experience -- or both -- but frankly I don't care about delving into that too deeply. I'll let y'all take those liberties.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
Duckattack7
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1106
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
- Location: Lake Oswego
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
We have plenty of athletes to win out, yes the defense is bad but we can beat everyone including stanford. It wont be easy and we have to keep getting better. If we lose anymore games and then it will be a concern, Yes we have injuries but we also have enough talent to beat everyone and these last few weeks will really show how good we are.
Return Of the Quack!
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
pezsez1 wrote:Woah there, Bucky.
I'm not using anything as an excuse. I'm just pointing out the very simple fact that our defense has been simplified, and that's part of the reason it's so bad.
Isn't that the whole purpose of this thread? To discuss things that are wrong with the defense?
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
The simplification of our defense is what it is, and it could be blamed on either poor coaching or a lack of talent/experience -- or both -- but frankly I don't care about delving into that too deeply. I'll let y'all take those liberties.
I was calling you out. I've read that excuse by litterly dozens of posters and heard it from many others. I was pointing out, D doesn't have to be complicated to be ran right.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
This isn't a "simplified" defense, that would be giving it too much credit. This is like a kid who goes out and gets his lincoln logs and then takes them back to his legos and wonders why they don't fit together.pezsez1 wrote:Woah there, Bucky.
I'm not using anything as an excuse. I'm just pointing out the very simple fact that our defense has been simplified, and that's part of the reason it's so bad.
Isn't that the whole purpose of this thread? To discuss things that are wrong with the defense?
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
The simplification of our defense is what it is, and it could be blamed on either poor coaching or a lack of talent/experience -- or both -- but frankly I don't care about delving into that too deeply. I'll let y'all take those liberties.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Buck,
Maybe you should think a bit harder before "calling me out" again.
Seriously. Do I need to put a disclaimer on every post just to calm the pitchforkers?
Is that where we're at now?
Hmmm, might as well. Because yes, this is where we are now.
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
Maybe you should think a bit harder before "calling me out" again.
Seriously. Do I need to put a disclaimer on every post just to calm the pitchforkers?
Is that where we're at now?
Hmmm, might as well. Because yes, this is where we are now.
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
vegasdom
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 233
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2015 11:22 pm
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Its the D coach obviously. He played the same D vs Florida State that he played vs Ohis State. He sucks at making adjustments. Linebackers are weak against the run. Secondary is/was very inexperienced. Tackling! 3-4 is not working when 8 drop into coverage and the opposing QB has all day to throw.
This program has been elite for some time because of the Offense. Now that they are not scoring big points early it has exposed the D. They need to bring in elite coaching. If Utah and Stanford can come up with good defense they is NO excuse why the Ducks can't.
This program has been elite for some time because of the Offense. Now that they are not scoring big points early it has exposed the D. They need to bring in elite coaching. If Utah and Stanford can come up with good defense they is NO excuse why the Ducks can't.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Conventional wisdom would hold that the Oregon program turned elite because of the offense. However, whether you're looking at it based on NFL draft picks, or by stats such as points per game, points per possession, yards per play, turnovers, etc. Oregon's defense has consistently been one of the best in the conference and country.
-
gofightingducks
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5533
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Nothing that hasnt already been said time and time again but the DL and Joe Walker have been pretty solid, in fact for the month of October after the Ducks simplified things and went more base D the Ducks led the nation for the month in sacks, and that is with pretty much only rushing 3 or 4. The linebackers outside JW have pretty much been below average all season which is disappointing and despite continuing to give up so many yards through the air the secondary has continued to improve. The two things that stand out is the missed tackles still and the amount of rushing yards the D has been giving up even with continuing to give up so many through the air. There is a lot of talent, probably the most ever and though they are young the mistakes in my opinion are mostly because of poor coaching, the lack of the fundamentals, poor form tackling, stupid penalties and just plain terrible scheming.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
While this is true, you should be made aware that many people on this board simply don't share this view.Conventional wisdom would hold that the Oregon program turned elite because of the offense. However, whether you're looking at it based on NFL draft picks, or by stats such as points per game, points per possession, yards per play, turnovers, etc. Oregon's defense has consistently been one of the best in the conference and country.
This is a long-running conversation that's been going on for years. Folks like myself look at everything you said above (and various other factors) and see that Oregon has traditionally had an above-average defense that actually works very well with our offense. And, in fact, people like me argue that in our most crushing losses, it has often been the offense that's failed to show up in crucial moments.
Others have said our defense has always sucked -- they basically point to total defense rankings and the fact we don't consistently hold other teams to just two or three scores per game. The "no excuses" mentality of this crowd often causes them to overlook or ignore factors such as opponents scoring points after we've emptied our benches in the fourth quarter, or how we give opponents more chances to score because of our pace of play.
In one way, none of that is relevant this year, because this season our defense does indeed suck, and everyone agrees on that.
But this ongoing narrative of our defense always being bad is, in my opinion, the reason why some folks here seemed very quick to whip out the pitchforks despite other obvious factors such as massive inexperience in the secondary.
Sigh... and now...
I've said this a few times, but I'm going to refrain from saying anything about the coaches until further notice. Please don't take that as either a sign of support or condemnation. I just don't want to get into any of that in this setting.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
There are a few ways in which I'll address the ill's of the _efense. Philosophy, Schematics and Personnel. I believe this to give the most complete answer as well as something that I've been harping on for years.
Philosophically speaking the program has long been known for Win The Day and Fast. Hard. Finish. Defensively its been about bend but don't break, creating turnovers and excelling in the red zone, or at least those have been the long stated goals from the defensive coaches about what they are trying to accomplish from the scheme. For a long time under NA, a primary goal was to stop the running game at the behest of the passing game and to a large degree it was quite successful albeit maddening to see 3rd and longs converted with ease. There is absolutely no stated rhyme or reason to what Pellum wants from the defense, just platitudes about playing with swag in the past. Buddy Ryan was a great defensive coach but a terrible HC because he was too single-minded about his defense's but they all still produced. Ryan believed that his defense should be forcing the issue against the offense and that his defense can score points. That is a far contrast to our belief that our defense HAS to give up 3rd down conversions and this is one of my biggest gripes with so many on this forum and elsewhere that its taken as gospel that the defense must give up all those first downs because of the offense. Well, whether the offense goes 3 and out or 3 and in is all the same. The defense doesn't need a swag attitude to win those battles, they need the attitude that all the best defenses have and that is one that does not capitulate to the offense.
Schematically, the decisions to run a 34 vs 43, even vs odd front, Man vs Zone are really all negligible. Either scheme can be as effective both against the run or the pass (or ineffective) as the other based upon all these factors. Further, what is used as a team's base defense typically goes out the window when its time to run Nickel and Dime sub-packages. This is where one of my main gripe lies, because to me, this is where the coaches have really failed the players because using Base against a lot of spread formations is absurd. LB's constantly being used as Nickel corners is not a recipe for success. The Bear front when we do use it is almost comical to me because we get guards pulling on us with no disruption up the middle. We are very predictable on defense and its been that way for a very long time, too.
One thing we did start to finally do more of is using the OLB as an actual pass rusher. Rushing 3 is playing Prevent, and prevent only prevents you from...Bringing 4 and showing Even fronts is like taking your second step in the 34 after you learned how to 2-gap and fly to the ball as a LB. Which, is really the biggest issue for our particular version of the 34. The ILB's should be cleaning house. Any system designed to keep them free means they should should be all over the place in the run game but that has rarely been the case. I'm a fan of the Double A gap blitz because its the fastest route to the QB and it forces the OL to have to adjust for the possibility of it. Against teams that like to pull the guards we struggle to get on the Guards hip in the backfield because of the down block. There is a serious lack of game-planning that goes into each game because we don't try and scheme to stop a team's bread and butter plays. Rather, we just keep doing the same thing.
As far as the passing game goes, the DBs are never asked to help disrupt the timing of the routes by pressing and releasing. Much like with game-planning for the running game, the same is true against teams that love to pass the ball. Formation adjustments, personnel adjustments rarely occur. Jim Johnson's defenses always tried to destroy the opponents blocking scheme and work from there. We show no desire on defense to make the offense to adjust to us because we try and get cute with coverage disguises. Is that OLB in Zone or Man? Ooh, he's playing the flat, tough read!
Personnel wise, the strength of this defense lies in its defensive line, both now and in the foreseeable future. After last years recruiting class I believe my biggest question going in wasn't as much about QB but about possible defensive changes and sub packages in order to play to the strengths of the defensive personnel. Now some will say that with 7 SR's in the front 7 that going in it was fine to stay in a base 34 and I don't disagree about the base personnel, its that that is all we use and we rarely have any true sub packages to change things up and respond to what the offense is doing. We could go two deep easily with a 4 man DL and we might have 10 when you put French as a DE.
Charles Nelson is finally playing defense, something we expected to happen in the spring when looking at the roster but I don't really fault the DB's much right now. Its one thing to have growing pains with young players and that's been especially true this season but we have seen some progression in the current scheme. I feel this year has been a bottom up problem in that the foundations of the defense are flawed and the further up you go, the more atrocious it looks which is why the CB's get picked on so much. As we've started to rush 4 (still not even a blitz) we've seen some more incomplete passes because the QB has to rush the throw due to pressure. As far as the tackling goes, that's a practice problem and I've said in the past that if changes to practices have to occur for improvements, than it needs to happen yesterday. You don't have to tackle all the way to the ground to practice and improve your form either, you just need good form and coaching. Trying to not strip the ball away as the first man is a big help too.
I'm not going to write a thesis but I think that covers all the major problems.
Philosophically speaking the program has long been known for Win The Day and Fast. Hard. Finish. Defensively its been about bend but don't break, creating turnovers and excelling in the red zone, or at least those have been the long stated goals from the defensive coaches about what they are trying to accomplish from the scheme. For a long time under NA, a primary goal was to stop the running game at the behest of the passing game and to a large degree it was quite successful albeit maddening to see 3rd and longs converted with ease. There is absolutely no stated rhyme or reason to what Pellum wants from the defense, just platitudes about playing with swag in the past. Buddy Ryan was a great defensive coach but a terrible HC because he was too single-minded about his defense's but they all still produced. Ryan believed that his defense should be forcing the issue against the offense and that his defense can score points. That is a far contrast to our belief that our defense HAS to give up 3rd down conversions and this is one of my biggest gripes with so many on this forum and elsewhere that its taken as gospel that the defense must give up all those first downs because of the offense. Well, whether the offense goes 3 and out or 3 and in is all the same. The defense doesn't need a swag attitude to win those battles, they need the attitude that all the best defenses have and that is one that does not capitulate to the offense.
Schematically, the decisions to run a 34 vs 43, even vs odd front, Man vs Zone are really all negligible. Either scheme can be as effective both against the run or the pass (or ineffective) as the other based upon all these factors. Further, what is used as a team's base defense typically goes out the window when its time to run Nickel and Dime sub-packages. This is where one of my main gripe lies, because to me, this is where the coaches have really failed the players because using Base against a lot of spread formations is absurd. LB's constantly being used as Nickel corners is not a recipe for success. The Bear front when we do use it is almost comical to me because we get guards pulling on us with no disruption up the middle. We are very predictable on defense and its been that way for a very long time, too.
One thing we did start to finally do more of is using the OLB as an actual pass rusher. Rushing 3 is playing Prevent, and prevent only prevents you from...Bringing 4 and showing Even fronts is like taking your second step in the 34 after you learned how to 2-gap and fly to the ball as a LB. Which, is really the biggest issue for our particular version of the 34. The ILB's should be cleaning house. Any system designed to keep them free means they should should be all over the place in the run game but that has rarely been the case. I'm a fan of the Double A gap blitz because its the fastest route to the QB and it forces the OL to have to adjust for the possibility of it. Against teams that like to pull the guards we struggle to get on the Guards hip in the backfield because of the down block. There is a serious lack of game-planning that goes into each game because we don't try and scheme to stop a team's bread and butter plays. Rather, we just keep doing the same thing.
As far as the passing game goes, the DBs are never asked to help disrupt the timing of the routes by pressing and releasing. Much like with game-planning for the running game, the same is true against teams that love to pass the ball. Formation adjustments, personnel adjustments rarely occur. Jim Johnson's defenses always tried to destroy the opponents blocking scheme and work from there. We show no desire on defense to make the offense to adjust to us because we try and get cute with coverage disguises. Is that OLB in Zone or Man? Ooh, he's playing the flat, tough read!
Personnel wise, the strength of this defense lies in its defensive line, both now and in the foreseeable future. After last years recruiting class I believe my biggest question going in wasn't as much about QB but about possible defensive changes and sub packages in order to play to the strengths of the defensive personnel. Now some will say that with 7 SR's in the front 7 that going in it was fine to stay in a base 34 and I don't disagree about the base personnel, its that that is all we use and we rarely have any true sub packages to change things up and respond to what the offense is doing. We could go two deep easily with a 4 man DL and we might have 10 when you put French as a DE.
Charles Nelson is finally playing defense, something we expected to happen in the spring when looking at the roster but I don't really fault the DB's much right now. Its one thing to have growing pains with young players and that's been especially true this season but we have seen some progression in the current scheme. I feel this year has been a bottom up problem in that the foundations of the defense are flawed and the further up you go, the more atrocious it looks which is why the CB's get picked on so much. As we've started to rush 4 (still not even a blitz) we've seen some more incomplete passes because the QB has to rush the throw due to pressure. As far as the tackling goes, that's a practice problem and I've said in the past that if changes to practices have to occur for improvements, than it needs to happen yesterday. You don't have to tackle all the way to the ground to practice and improve your form either, you just need good form and coaching. Trying to not strip the ball away as the first man is a big help too.
I'm not going to write a thesis but I think that covers all the major problems.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
So just say it then, "the Oregon program turned elite because of the defense."StevensTechU wrote:Conventional wisdom would hold that the Oregon program turned elite because of the offense. However, whether you're looking at it based on NFL draft picks, or by stats such as points per game, points per possession, yards per play, turnovers, etc. Oregon's defense has consistently been one of the best in the conference and country.

-
duckfan22
- Senior
- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
07 that just maybe the best post in a very long time. I think your spot on. One other thing i have
noticed the D plays to Pellums personality. He is kinda laid back and does not have the passion some
coaches have. The D kinda of plays to that also. They are not aggressive dont have that killer instinct.
To me it easy for opposing teams to game plan on offense as they know how were going to line up.
Every team that is elite and is winning Championships have one thing in common. No matter what kind of
offense they have be it spread or pro they have a great defense not only in talent but scheme. Defense wins
championships and under the current philosophy we may not win a championship.
noticed the D plays to Pellums personality. He is kinda laid back and does not have the passion some
coaches have. The D kinda of plays to that also. They are not aggressive dont have that killer instinct.
To me it easy for opposing teams to game plan on offense as they know how were going to line up.
Every team that is elite and is winning Championships have one thing in common. No matter what kind of
offense they have be it spread or pro they have a great defense not only in talent but scheme. Defense wins
championships and under the current philosophy we may not win a championship.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
The statement that Oregon turned elite when the offense got on track isn't inaccurate, though. The defense has been the more consistent unit over the last 25 years.Duck07 wrote:So just say it then, "the Oregon program turned elite because of the defense."StevensTechU wrote:Conventional wisdom would hold that the Oregon program turned elite because of the offense. However, whether you're looking at it based on NFL draft picks, or by stats such as points per game, points per possession, yards per play, turnovers, etc. Oregon's defense has consistently been one of the best in the conference and country.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: What's Wrong With the Defense
Well saying its been more consistent isn't saying its the best unit, I say they've been consistently poor. Further, what happened before the players were born is irrelevant but sure let's use that but from Akili on, its easy to point to the offense outpacing the defense as the best unit each year, in almost every single year. Which years do you think the Defense was truly the better unit?StevensTechU wrote:The statement that Oregon turned elite when the offense got on track isn't inaccurate, though. The defense has been the more consistent unit over the last 25 years.Duck07 wrote:So just say it then, "the Oregon program turned elite because of the defense."StevensTechU wrote:Conventional wisdom would hold that the Oregon program turned elite because of the offense. However, whether you're looking at it based on NFL draft picks, or by stats such as points per game, points per possession, yards per play, turnovers, etc. Oregon's defense has consistently been one of the best in the conference and country.
If you really want to argue the point, this is all about the arrival of Chip. Chip took the offense from fringe top 25 unit that in some years went higher, to one consistently in the Top 10. At no point in time has the defense come from consistent Top 25 to consistent Top 10. The program didn't hit that elite level after Chip arrived because the light's on defense went on. Yes, they started playing better, something I would have expected because the job of our defense under Chip was a walk in the park against opponents that have to completely change their style of game to account for our offense.
Seriously, how is this still not understood that our Offense the last 8 years has made the job of our defense that much easier because of all the points they score?
