DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by buckmarkduck »

QuackininBama wrote:He's already there, John Neal, problem solved.

Please, no more promotions internally. Helf has made two hires from outside, and both have arguably are two strongest groups. Let Helf hire someone from outside, that's one thing he's proven he can do. And I'd wants experience, not a hot position coach who has never coached DC before.

I like the Temple DC.

Another name, and say what you will about him as a HC, but he can recruit with anyone and coach D. Ron Zook Green Bay assistant.

Dwayne Walker

And the UW DC. Just because it would be awesome to steal UWs top assistant, and he's got a bunch of guys we didn't want, playing a lot better than us.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by StevensTechU »

UofDuck wrote:I vote NO! We need young and fresh blood.
^UofDuck is a vampire.

Though you'd think Oregon's budget for coaches would be large based on the reported revenue the athletic dept makes, but those numbers are massively inflated based on gifts in the form of building, property, etc. In reality, they're actually a bit of a drain on the budget, because the annual costs of operating and maintaining facilities such as the Jaqua, HDC, etc. is in the millions. All that is to say that Oregon's going to have to find a DC for under ~700k, I'd bet. That probably means Todd Orlando is out, since he's the highest paid assistant on the UH staff in a state with no income taxes.

As for inside vs. outside hires, I've never seen any Harvard Business Review study showing one is better than the other. If the 'best' guy isn't currently on your staff, you look elsewhere.
Last edited by StevensTechU on Thu Nov 05, 2015 10:20 am, edited 1 time in total.
gofightingducks
All Pac-12
Posts: 5533
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by gofightingducks »

The one thing I do not want to see is an internal promotion, though I think John Neal is probably qualified I would like to see some new blood in the program, someone with different ideas to take the level of the D up a notch, as long as the Ducks have an offense that puts up 40+ points a game the Ducks don't need an elite defense but there needs to be some major improvement and I am not sure the culture of the program would change much with someone internally. Maybe an under the radar guy, bring in Bellotti to help evaluate talent maybe, outside of Ludwig and Crowton he did pretty well.
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by srsmiley007 »

StevensTechU wrote:
UofDuck wrote:I vote NO! We need young and fresh blood.
^UofDuck is a vampire.

Though you'd think Oregon's budget for coaches would be large based on the reported revenue the athletic dept makes, but those numbers are massively inflated based on gifts in the form of building, property, etc. In reality, they're actually a bit of a drain on the budget, because the annual costs of operating and maintaining facilities such as the Jaqua, HDC, etc. is in the millions. All that is to say that Oregon's going to have to find a DC for under ~700k, I'd bet. That probably means Todd Orlando is out, since he's the highest paid assistant on the UH staff in a state with no income taxes.

As for inside vs. outside hires, I've never seen any Harvard Business Review study showing one is better than the other. If the 'best' guy isn't currently on your staff, you look elsewhere.
That's why I like Malik out of Portland State. He's making maybe 120K/yr. right now. His defense actually pitches goose eggs, even in blowouts and along with that win against Wazzu he looks like a real up-n-comer. We can afford him and his resume isn't so overpowering that he has the leverage to fully dictate his staff as I would like to see us keep Chinander and Neal.

The outside LB play has actually been pretty good this year and really like the development of Prevot since he took over. Seems to have elevated Coleman's game which was putred. Of course, he's a solid recruiter. As for Neal, puts guys in the pro's every year and they stick, his secondary's (except this year) have always been the bread and butter of turnovers. As for Aiken, not sure I'm a fan. Because of the scheme, it's hard to evaluate his individual coaching.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by Duck07 »

Ron Aiken is clearly a stud as a position coach, as coaching collegiate 34 DL is imo one of the toughest jobs out there. That is a very physically imposing job that those young players do to 2-gap and while we know Buckner is a stud, Balducci keeps raising his play and I'd love to see him in Tennessee next season (the way LeBeau and Horton have the defense playing, it'd be nice to see them stay). Mondeaux has really come on strong and the recruits coming into campus are not small frys or under the radar pickups.

I think Neal could be the DC and wouldn't fit the Peter Principle that we absolutely do not want to repeat, but what was so obvious about Pellum that wasn't there with Neal I wonder?

I am a fan of going the smaller school route for someone who really knows their X's and O's and can teach their system to the players. I want someone who expects to be an intimidating and tough defense.
Image
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by StevensTechU »

Just read up on Malik Roberson. I think you're on to something. As I said earlier, I'm anti-Big 10 guys, because of how simple/terrible the offenses are that exist in that conference outside of tOSU and maybe Indiana. However, can't say the same about the Big Sky; he's virtually seen it all there. Obviously you want the best guy for the job, but in getting rid of a minority staff member, it also wouldn't hurt bringing in another.
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by srsmiley007 »

StevensTechU wrote:Just read up on Malik Roberson. I think you're on to something. As I said earlier, I'm anti-Big 10 guys, because of how simple/terrible the offenses are that exist in that conference outside of tOSU and maybe Indiana. However, can't say the same about the Big Sky; he's virtually seen it all there. Obviously you want the best guy for the job, but in getting rid of a minority staff member, it also wouldn't hurt bringing in another.
I wasn't really thinking about EEO aspect but his age/era would likely resonate better in recruiting. He should be able to pull in some studs. The more we talk about this the more excited I get at the plusses to this strategy. As he is moving up, they can likely retain the existing staff and changing the game plan. Alas, I'm not sure if they have the stones to make this move but it really isn't going to get better unless they do.

We'll need an elite or at least very good defense to support either TJ or Justin H. next fall. If Justin Herbert enrolls early my bet is on him to start come fall. The fact that Helf and Frost have spent so much time watching Sheldon home games this season (after JH gave his verbal) is indicative of them trying to figure out how to ingratiate him to the offense. That said, we need someone who knows how to truly manage a Defense.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by SuperDuck »

I think that realistic expectations are in order, no matter who's brought in as D-Coordinator. That's assuming Helfrich decides to make a change. My reasoning is that much of the reason the offense has been so formidable since Chip Kelly came on board is because of the blazing tempo. The offense hasn't been able to run that as much this year because of the QB situation, though Scott Frost said this week that it's coming back.

My point is that if we start scoring anywhere close to what we have the past few years, the defense is going to be spending even more time on the field - again. They're also going to need to have the depth in place to play 18-20 guys or more on a regular basis. It's a huge challenge for a good defense to hold modern offenses to a respectable point total, but if you don't have good players and depth you're going to get exposed. You'll basically be asking a good defensive unit to stay respectable on a national level while playing 30-40% more plays than most other teams do without getting a break.

These are talented young kids, but there's only so much that can realistically be asked of them. If you run the "blur offense" you have to have both depth and scheme on defense. Without both, they'll struggle.

It's amazing how many people are missing Nick Aliotti, AKA "Allow-A-Lotti". He knew exactly what he was doing and did very well at Oregon, especially under Chip.
John 3:36
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by buckmarkduck »

SuperDuck wrote:I think that realistic expectations are in order, no matter who's brought in as D-Coordinator. That's assuming Helfrich decides to make a change. My reasoning is that much of the reason the offense has been so formidable since Chip Kelly came on board is because of the blazing tempo. The offense hasn't been able to run that as much this year because of the QB situation, though Scott Frost said this week that it's coming back.

My point is that if we start scoring anywhere close to what we have the past few years, the defense is going to be spending even more time on the field - again. They're also going to need to have the depth in place to play 18-20 guys or more on a regular basis. It's a huge challenge for a good defense to hold modern offenses to a respectable point total, but if you don't have good players and depth you're going to get exposed. You'll basically be asking a good defensive unit to stay respectable on a national level while playing 30-40% more plays than most other teams do without getting a break.

These are talented young kids, but there's only so much that can realistically be asked of them. If you run the "blur offense" you have to have both depth and scheme on defense. Without both, they'll struggle.

It's amazing how many people are missing Nick Aliotti, AKA "Allow-A-Lotti". He knew exactly what he was doing and did very well at Oregon, especially under Chip.

We're only scoring 4 pts a game less, and we have the top O in the conference. That said I don't see the tempo getting much faster due to Adams.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by SuperDuck »

buckmarkduck wrote:
SuperDuck wrote:I think that realistic expectations are in order, no matter who's brought in as D-Coordinator. That's assuming Helfrich decides to make a change. My reasoning is that much of the reason the offense has been so formidable since Chip Kelly came on board is because of the blazing tempo. The offense hasn't been able to run that as much this year because of the QB situation, though Scott Frost said this week that it's coming back.

My point is that if we start scoring anywhere close to what we have the past few years, the defense is going to be spending even more time on the field - again. They're also going to need to have the depth in place to play 18-20 guys or more on a regular basis. It's a huge challenge for a good defense to hold modern offenses to a respectable point total, but if you don't have good players and depth you're going to get exposed. You'll basically be asking a good defensive unit to stay respectable on a national level while playing 30-40% more plays than most other teams do without getting a break.

These are talented young kids, but there's only so much that can realistically be asked of them. If you run the "blur offense" you have to have both depth and scheme on defense. Without both, they'll struggle.

It's amazing how many people are missing Nick Aliotti, AKA "Allow-A-Lotti". He knew exactly what he was doing and did very well at Oregon, especially under Chip.

We're only scoring 4 pts a game less, and we have the top O in the conference. That said I don't see the tempo getting much faster due to Adams.
I simply repeated what Scott Frost said.
John 3:36
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by pezsez1 »

What I miss most about Nick Aliotti was that despite how long he was here, nobody ever figured him out. There was never a team we'd face each year that would totally light us up like clockwork. He was a gritty, hard-nosed coach who fired up his players and had them blitz from all over the field. He fearlessly lived and died by the sword. Yeah, there were times that cost us, but usually his schemes unquestionably worked in our favor.

Without going into too much detail, I will say that's one thing that has disappointed me about Pellum. When he took over, I thought he'd bring a simplified-but-attacking style to the defense, but even last year we didn't see that.

I'm not gonna contribute to another back-and-forth about Aliotti, but I've got to wonder if he's the most underrated coach in our program's history.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by Duck07 »

SuperDuck wrote:I think that realistic expectations are in order, no matter who's brought in as D-Coordinator. That's assuming Helfrich decides to make a change. My reasoning is that much of the reason the offense has been so formidable since Chip Kelly came on board is because of the blazing tempo. The offense hasn't been able to run that as much this year because of the QB situation, though Scott Frost said this week that it's coming back.

My point is that if we start scoring anywhere close to what we have the past few years, the defense is going to be spending even more time on the field - again. They're also going to need to have the depth in place to play 18-20 guys or more on a regular basis. It's a huge challenge for a good defense to hold modern offenses to a respectable point total, but if you don't have good players and depth you're going to get exposed. You'll basically be asking a good defensive unit to stay respectable on a national level while playing 30-40% more plays than most other teams do without getting a break.

These are talented young kids, but there's only so much that can realistically be asked of them. If you run the "blur offense" you have to have both depth and scheme on defense. Without both, they'll struggle.

It's amazing how many people are missing Nick Aliotti, AKA "Allow-A-Lotti". He knew exactly what he was doing and did very well at Oregon, especially under Chip.
None of that is tangential. A great defense gives the offense more opportunities. Quit ignoring that this is a two way street and that the defense has to play with one eye closed and one hand tied, that's not the case at all. In fact, having an offense that scores so much only makes it easier to have a dominating defense. We just have fans like you and others who still constantly believe in this fallacy.
Image
vegasdom
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 233
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2015 11:22 pm

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by vegasdom »

Todd Orlando, U. of Houston, co-defensive coordinator former DC at Utah State.
This! Awsome D coach
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by SuperDuck »

vegasdom wrote:
Todd Orlando, U. of Houston, co-defensive coordinator former DC at Utah State.
This! Awsome D coach
Orlando will earn an annual base salary of $501,000, according to a copy of the contract obtained by the Houston Chronicle through an open records request, that is believed to make him the highest-paid coordinator at a non-Power 5 school.
http://www.chron.com/sports/cougars/art ... 356609.php


The guy is obviously a great coach. There are two things that I'd be concerned about, though.

1. If the UO did decide to pay this guy a big salary, how is the rest of the staff, Scott Frost in particular, going to perceive it? You'd almost have to give Frost a raise, too, right?

2. The fact that he IS such a great coach makes him a possible head coaching candidate elsewhere. It would be hard to see him stay with Oregon long term if he continued to be successful here.

That's the one drawback of hiring coaches outside the program. Some are opportunists and use the Ducks as a stepping stone for their next job. It's rare to see coaches like Bud Foster at Virginia Tech and Kirby Smart at Alabama anymore.

Also, if Helfrich does decide to bring in someone from outside the program, what will happen with the existing staff?
John 3:36
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: DC you would like to have - Jimmy's request

Post by srsmiley007 »

SuperDuck wrote:
vegasdom wrote:
Todd Orlando, U. of Houston, co-defensive coordinator former DC at Utah State.
This! Awsome D coach
Orlando will earn an annual base salary of $501,000, according to a copy of the contract obtained by the Houston Chronicle through an open records request, that is believed to make him the highest-paid coordinator at a non-Power 5 school.
http://www.chron.com/sports/cougars/art ... 356609.php


The guy is obviously a great coach. There are two things that I'd be concerned about, though.

1. If the UO did decide to pay this guy a big salary, how is the rest of the staff, Scott Frost in particular, going to perceive it? You'd almost have to give Frost a raise, too, right?

2. The fact that he IS such a great coach makes him a possible head coaching candidate elsewhere. It would be hard to see him stay with Oregon long term if he continued to be successful here.

That's the one drawback of hiring coaches outside the program. Some are opportunists and use the Ducks as a stepping stone for their next job. It's rare to see coaches like Bud Foster at Virginia Tech and Kirby Smart at Alabama anymore.

Also, if Helfrich does decide to bring in someone from outside the program, what will happen with the existing staff?

That's why it won't be Orlando. I had hoped he would be the guy the first time but I think he wanted to dismantle the coaching staff on D. He's now plugged into Tom Herman and if there personalities gel, will likely go with Tom to his next gig (likely Texas next year after Strong gets fired) or try and get an HC position in the next 2-4 years.

Here's the only 2 or 3 that make sense to me:

Favorite choice,Malik Roberson, Portland State University
- Low salary requirements (only makes about 120K)
- Up and comer, very successful at 2 different I-AA teams (PSU & CWU)
- Also coaches LB position
- Beat Wazzu this year with inferior talent
- We'll likely be able to retain the rest of the staff
- He already lives in Oregon and is a NW guy so not a huge transition.

Philip Snow, Temple
- West Coast Guy, older but attached to the head coach and has a lot of autonomy. Not Likely to come do to relationship with current Temple HC but would be awesome.
- Older, wouldn't be looking to jump to a head coaching job (58 yrs), recruiting ties out here.
- Would likely want his coaches to join him. Problematic for retaining existing staff

Kevin Clune, Utah State (also coaches linebackers)
- Disciple of Todd Orlando, made UH better in his 1 year there. Currently doing a pretty solid job at Utah State.
- Coaches LB's
- Likely be able to retain the rest of our staff if he comes aboard.
- Lower salary requirements
Post Reply