Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3316
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Neal is a great guy. His 2 years as passing game coordinator have not been good.

With a loaded senior laden group last year his results were mediocre. With a young group this year they were "awful", then improved to "bad" when he corrected his own mistake and got Robinson out of the safety position where he simply was dreadful.


Several things happened at about the same time to improve Oregon's defense from horrendous to mediocre

-Robinson was moved out of the safety position.

-Pellum backed off the frequent blitzing he was getting burned on earlier in the year. In the Georgia State game for instance every big play except one came against a 5 or 6 man rush from Oregon.

-Once Oregon went to more base 4 man rushes the sack numbers actually went way up. Without a hot receiver instantly open on each play, Oregon's OLBs and DL had time to get to the quarterback.

The defense has been bad, but the pass defense even last year has drug down the overall defensive results. In the games after the Robinson/Nelson switch Oregon's pass defense was around 80th. Better than 126th but hardly studly.

I don't have a problem with all those who want to get rid of Pellum, but thinking making Neal the Co-Coordinator, which he virtually already is, is going to turn around the defense is unfounded wishful thinking imo.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF

Post by Duck07 »

It's all really a matter of what sort of changes he would make with full control compared to what an outsider would do. I think we need to revert back to our old 4-2-5 defense going forward as we have a roster better suited for it and I think it better fits the conference we play against.

TCU actually calls their defense by calling a play for the front 6 and then for the back 5. One thing the coaches can get out of interviewing a lot of candidates is to start picking their brains as well which is another reason to not rush any promotions.
Image
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF

Post by srsmiley007 »

Duck07 wrote:It's all really a matter of what sort of changes he would make with full control compared to what an outsider would do. I think we need to revert back to our old 4-2-5 defense going forward as we have a roster better suited for it and I think it better fits the conference we play against.

TCU actually calls their defense by calling a play for the front 6 and then for the back 5. One thing the coaches can get out of interviewing a lot of candidates is to start picking their brains as well which is another reason to not rush any promotions.
I concur that a 4-2-5 one gap fire "D" would be preferred to the 2 gap read/react approach. I would love to see us take a more aggressive gap-attack approach to gap-hold and react approach.

Sorry GrandpaDuck, i don't really agree with your analysis but at least your providing some analysis unlike so many on the board who troll and offer nothing but silly comments so thanks for participating with true thought.

I like Neal. With regard to the secondary and blitzing in the early games(EWU and Georgia State), I can't say that blitzing was as much of an issue but the lack of press coverage/technique and inability of the LB's to handle zone concepts and how to play Hook-2-Curl zone and drop coverage reads was more problematic. Our safeties were so bad he was afraid to press and the LB's were awful in middle zone coverage. This is where we got burned and if you can't do any of that it's a recipe for disaster against the shotgun 3 step shuffle/drop. IMO, if the LB's were better in their zones we could have pressed and blitzed effectively which would have been a good bandaid for the DB's while they grew up.

As for the passing D-coordinator title it's a bit of a stretch in that it's a meaningless title that allows for a higher rate of pay and essentially respect for their expertise (like having Sr. in your title, like Sr. Director or Sr. VP) so don't read too much into that. It's not like he calls the "D" which is still called by the DC. They can't operate autonomously. All he adds is input or options associated with the scheme call so it's not like Neal's calling the "D".
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3316
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Chinander may be joining Frost at UCF

Post by GrandpaDuck »

srsmiley007 wrote:
Sorry GrandpaDuck, i don't really agree with your analysis but at least your providing some analysis unlike so many on the board who troll and offer nothing but silly comments so thanks for participating with true thought.
.....
No need to apologize as I seldom agree with your analysis so I wouldn't expect you'd agree with mine, so all is cool.
Post Reply