Man, couldn't agree more.Running quarterbacks = Broken quarterbacks
I love a QB who can really break open a play, but the threat of the run is so much more powerful than actual rushing yards.
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
Man, couldn't agree more.Running quarterbacks = Broken quarterbacks
^+1pezsez1 wrote:Man, couldn't agree more.Running quarterbacks = Broken quarterbacks
I love a QB who can really break open a play, but the threat of the run is so much more powerful than actual rushing yards.
Specifically, Mariota actually got hurt on a play where he took off and a UCLA player hit him late out of bounds.Phalanx wrote:
I don't think the ducks have run any less. Mariota got hurt because of sacks, not because of trying to run. Adams isn't as fast, so he doesn't take off as much. College football is full of running quarterbacks who aren't broken. Running is part of the game and running backs do it dozens of times every game.
Deshaun Watson, Marquise Williams, Greg Ward Jr from Houston...all running QB's who played the whole season (and those are all this year, I didn't have to go back to 2007). Running QB's are a part of the college game and always have been. Do they get injured? Yes, just like everyone else in football. Some of them are not built to withstand a hit. Some, like Jeremiah Masoli, Cardale Jones, Cam Newton, or Vince Young, are. Marcus was sacked seven times vs. Washington State last year, that is the injury I was talking about, just like his injury this year with the Titans.StevensTechU wrote:Specifically, Mariota actually got hurt on a play where he took off and a UCLA player hit him late out of bounds.Phalanx wrote:
I don't think the ducks have run any less. Mariota got hurt because of sacks, not because of trying to run. Adams isn't as fast, so he doesn't take off as much. College football is full of running quarterbacks who aren't broken. Running is part of the game and running backs do it dozens of times every game.
I applaud Helfrich for recognizing that for the rare running QB that gets through college healthy, there's a million instances of Mariota in '13, Chuckie Keeton, Taysom Hill, JT Barrett, Braxton Miller, Dennis Dixon, etc.
So...based on that data, it appears that Helfrich responded to Mariota's injury in 2013 by increasing the QB running load? Do I have that right?maxduck wrote:Primary QB rushing attempts by year, didn't see how many of these carries were actually sacks.
2010 Thomas 93
2011 Thomas/Bennett 79
2012 Mariota 106
2013 Mariota 96
2014 Mariota 135
2015 Adams/Lockie/Alie 120
Greg Ward Jr got hurt this season and that's why they lost to UConn. lol. Malik Zaire at ND is another running QB this year that lasted only a couple games.Phalanx wrote:
Deshaun Watson, Marquise Williams, Greg Ward Jr from Houston...all running QB's who played the whole season (and those are all this year, I didn't have to go back to 2007). Running QB's are a part of the college game and always have been. Do they get injured? Yes, just like everyone else in football. Some of them are not built to withstand a hit. Some, like Jeremiah Masoli, Cardale Jones, Cam Newton, or Vince Young, are. Marcus was sacked seven times vs. Washington State last year, that is the injury I was talking about, just like his injury this year with the Titans.
Helfrich may try to limit exposure to hits, but he isn't going to run a spread offense without a running quarterback.
No, not correct. There simply isn't enough information to draw that conclusion. There were more games in 2014, we don't know haw many of the carries were sacks or taking a knee at the end of a game, how many were broken plays, etc. Finally we don't know what plays were called or who called them.Phalanx wrote:So...based on that data, it appears that Helfrich responded to Mariota's injury in 2013 by increasing the QB running load? Do I have that right?maxduck wrote:Primary QB rushing attempts by year, didn't see how many of these carries were actually sacks.
2010 Thomas 93
2011 Thomas/Bennett 79
2012 Mariota 106
2013 Mariota 96
2014 Mariota 135
2015 Adams/Lockie/Alie 120


Ward rolled his ankle vs. Memphis on a SACK. If your point is that quarterbacks shouldn't be running because they will get 'broken' then I'm not seeing how Ward's injury supports that at all. He was out one game (he actually played in the game) and then rushed 31 times in the next two games, and he isn't broken.StevensTechU wrote:Greg Ward Jr got hurt this season and that's why they lost to UConn. lol. Malik Zaire at ND is another running QB this year that lasted only a couple games.Phalanx wrote:
Deshaun Watson, Marquise Williams, Greg Ward Jr from Houston...all running QB's who played the whole season (and those are all this year, I didn't have to go back to 2007). Running QB's are a part of the college game and always have been. Do they get injured? Yes, just like everyone else in football. Some of them are not built to withstand a hit. Some, like Jeremiah Masoli, Cardale Jones, Cam Newton, or Vince Young, are. Marcus was sacked seven times vs. Washington State last year, that is the injury I was talking about, just like his injury this year with the Titans.
Helfrich may try to limit exposure to hits, but he isn't going to run a spread offense without a running quarterback.
Not all the names being thrown around are used in the same capacity. Clemson uses Watson similar to how Oregon has used quarterbacks: passer 1st and 2nd, runner 3rd. Conversely, Ward Jr and Taysom Hill's legs were relied upon to win the game rather than as more of a threat to keep the defense honest, which is what I'm describing as the perspective Oregon has shifted to. Ohio State uses their QBs to run more than Oregon does.
We don't? See the breakdown the mix of run and pass in the period from 2009-2012 (Chip) to 2013-2014 (Helf) below. This year has been a cluster of 3 QBs and virtually a different offense every game through the first half of the season. We'd have to break down game-by-game film, and frankly I'm not bored enough to do that, so I thought this was plenty illustrative.Phalanx wrote:
Ward rolled his ankle vs. Memphis on a SACK. If your point is that quarterbacks shouldn't be running because they will get 'broken' then I'm not seeing how Ward's injury supports that at all. He was out one game (he actually played in the game) and then rushed 31 times in the next two games, and he isn't broken.
If Helfrich was dialing back quarterback rushes, we would see it in the stats. He isn't, and we don't.
I'm not exactly sure why you threw out this year, but in case anyone is wondering, the 2015 ratio is in bold above. (P.S. I'm being pretty generous by throwing out the 35 sacks, since a number of those were probably QB rushing plays that just didn't work.) Anyone trying to suggest that Helfrich is dialing back QB rushing should probably take the current year into account, no matter who is playing quarterback. Of course it was less in 2013 - Mariota wasn't running very well after that sack in the Stanford game, was he? In the bowl game when he was healthy, he ran 15 times.StevensTechU wrote:
We don't? See the breakdown the mix of run and pass in the period from 2009-2012 (Chip) to 2013-2014 (Helf) below. This year has been a cluster of 3 QBs and virtually a different offense every game through the first half of the season. We'd have to break down game-by-game film, and frankly I'm not bored enough to do that, so I thought this was plenty illustrative.
*Rush numbers are concluded by the number of rush attempts for the QBs minus opponents season sacks. Notable, the number of opponent sacks in recent years has spiked tremendously.
Adams/Lockie/Alie 7.1 rush/gm, 28.2 pass/gm (20.1% - 79.9%)
Mariota 2014: 7.2 rush/gm, 31.5 pass/gm (18.6% - 81.4%)
Mariota 2013: 6.4 rush/gm, 30.7 pass/gm (17.3% - 82.7%)
Mariota/Bennett 2012: 9.7 rush/gm, 28.7 pass/gm (25.2% - 74.8%)
Thomas/Bennett 2011: 5 rush/gm, 29.6 pass/gm (14.5% - 85.5%)
Thomas/Costa 2010: 8 rush/gm, 30.3 pass/gm (20.9% - 79.1%)
Masoli/Costa 2009: 9.5 rush/gm, 26 pass/gm (26.8% - 73.2%)
Every year but 1 of the Chip era we saw the QB toting the ball over 20% of his attempts. That doesn't happen in either of the two years where Helfrich had a clear quarterback. In fact, with the same primary QB (Mariota) we see the percentage of run plays drop from 25.2% to 17.3% Y-o-Y.
To one of the other points, QBs (like all players) have a risk of getting hurt regardless. Unless designed QB runs keep defensive players from sacking a quarterback, I don't know how subjecting a QB to more hits is anything but additive to the risk of getting injured. QBs get hurt when they're not running, and their risk only goes up more when you ask them to tote the ball. Hence, we were able to come up with quite the non-comprehensive list of names of injured dual-threats.