StevensTechU wrote:I don't know if people remember, but Jeremiah Poutasi really wanted to be a Duck but never got an offer. Obviously, Greatwood probably wishes he had that one back.
This is not true. Oregon did eventually offer Jeremiah Poutasi and brought him in for a late visit a few weeks before signing day. However, the Ducks bungled his recruitment prior to this. Rather than detail how they bungled it, a person can read this article...
StevensTechU wrote:I don't know if people remember, but Jeremiah Poutasi really wanted to be a Duck but never got an offer. Obviously, Greatwood probably wishes he had that one back.
Regardless of stars, after watching his film I have to say I'm not a huge fan of this offer/commitment. Samuel(u?) is absolutely a D1 body at 6'5, 310 or so. Watching his tape, though, I see lead feet that are going to make it very difficult on him to get and maintain leverage when he faces competition that is as big and powerful as he is. He projects at the guard spots to me.
Seems like this is an offer for depth to make sure there are ample bodies on the roster. Not sure I'm very excited about it, but I'll certainly hope for the best. Ryan Clanton wasn't the swiftest individual ever, but he played really well for the Ducks as a big, powerful left guard.
I get your hesitation because he's obviously possesses greater genetics a.k.a size/strength then his comp. in the vids. However, watch in slow-mo. He's always a step ahead of the rest of the line. He stays low through the 1st 3 steps keeping leverage. While he's significantly bigger than his comp. they should be quicker but his gets inside every time. That's the impressive part. Howvever, he has a lazy motor downfield. His 1st 3 steps are extremely impressive. His motor leaves something to besired. If he's not an entitled
Personality then he can be elite. If his head isn't in to it then he's a bust. The risk is worth it.
damascusduck wrote:I will take Greatwood's opinion over so called internet evaluators and star watchers every day of the week and twice on Sunday. He won't waste an offer if he doesn't think the kid has a chance to play here. Besides, it's not like he's some sleeper they picked up at the 24th hour. A Michael Speed type that no one has heard of. He has other Pac 12 offers and per Scout is the 9th rated OG on the west coast.
Greatwood has a proven track record. Nowhere was i dissing him.
There's just a couple red flags:
1) Commits to offer within hours. Anecdotally, I've only ever seen this with marginal recruits with no other major offers. Never seen this with a guy that turned out to be a baller, please fill me in if you recall someone that committed same day and turned out to be a starter for Oregon.
2) Lack of major offers. Battling teams like Oregon State, Weber State and Boise State for commits reminds me of Cody Carriger types.
I'm sure I missed a few, but starters really do mean nothing when it comes to OL. We've had our fair share of 3/4/5 star busts at OL too.
No, TK, not talking about stars here bud. Clearly, we've had some great players come in with little accolades.
I see red flags when a guy commits same day he gets the offer. That says something I think, as in, I don't have any other good options.
Gotcha. Still, I'll take the #2 player out of Nevada with 3 Pac-12 offers and a brother in the NFL. Committing on the same day he is offered doesn't mean much without knowing the fine details. Perhaps an offer was pending for other reasons.
I really can't stand when people refer to bloodlines. It means so little. Michael Jordan has kids. Barry Sanders son plays for Stanford (havent heard anything about him), sure there are some that turn out (christian mccaffrey) but in reality ,it's all work product and desire. I am with Tech here, his feet are in cement and he'll get schooled by faster stronger competition.
StevensTechU wrote:I don't know if people remember, but Jeremiah Poutasi really wanted to be a Duck but never got an offer. Obviously, Greatwood probably wishes he had that one back.
This is not true. Oregon did eventually offer Jeremiah Poutasi and brought him in for a late visit a few weeks before signing day. However, the Ducks bungled his recruitment prior to this. Rather than detail how they bungled it, a person can read this article...
There's got to be another side to the story I'm sure, but from his end I can see why he'd rather beat the crap out of the Ducks then play for them. I'm surprised the family would allow the other son to go to Oregon after that.
Anyone know who it was we opted to trip in ahead of Poutasi as we were stringing him along? If this scenario is accurate, it explains a bit about our sometimes bizarre recruiting tactics.
I don't see why that story reflects negatively on Oregon. The kid was a very borderline qualifier, and the story contradicts itself. According to the story his transcript was "essentially the same" at the time the Ducks cancelled the first visit as when he took the final visit. But he didn't know if he would qualify for Utah till July. I'm guessing the transcript was a moving target his senior year as he struggled to bring it up to standards. I can totally see why the Ducks hesitated, particularly with our emphasis on recruiting kids who actually qualify.
Just because you miss on a few good players you don't change your philosophy.
wlduck wrote:I don't see why that story reflects negatively on Oregon. The kid was a very borderline qualifier, and the story contradicts itself. According to the story his transcript was "essentially the same" at the time the Ducks cancelled the first visit as when he took the final visit. But he didn't know if he would qualify for Utah till July. I'm guessing the transcript was a moving target his senior year as he struggled to bring it up to standards. I can totally see why the Ducks hesitated, particularly with our emphasis on recruiting kids who actually qualify.
Just because you miss on a few good players you don't change your philosophy.
That's why I said, I could see from his end. We're recruiting better than ever, not suggesting we should change.
Also doesn't mean we can't do better in situations like this. Coaches are making mistakes all the time, just like the rest of us, and hopefully learning from them.
wlduck wrote:I don't see why that story reflects negatively on Oregon. The kid was a very borderline qualifier, and the story contradicts itself. According to the story his transcript was "essentially the same" at the time the Ducks cancelled the first visit as when he took the final visit. But he didn't know if he would qualify for Utah till July. I'm guessing the transcript was a moving target his senior year as he struggled to bring it up to standards. I can totally see why the Ducks hesitated, particularly with our emphasis on recruiting kids who actually qualify.
Just because you miss on a few good players you don't change your philosophy.
That's why I said, I could see from his end. We're recruiting better than ever, not suggesting we should change.
Also doesn't mean we can't do better in situations like this. Coaches are making mistakes all the time, just like the rest of us, and hopefully learning from them.
I guess I am confused by your assertion that we "could do better in situations like this". Do you mean because we missed on the kid, or do you think we were less than fully ethical. Because I read nothing in that story to back up that belief, other than vague accusations from the high school guidance counselor. We have no idea what Oregon was telling him about his grades during the process- I would bet they made him aware of the issues. And the fact that his brother is coming leads me to believe that's the case.
wlduck wrote:I don't see why that story reflects negatively on Oregon. The kid was a very borderline qualifier, and the story contradicts itself. According to the story his transcript was "essentially the same" at the time the Ducks cancelled the first visit as when he took the final visit. But he didn't know if he would qualify for Utah till July. I'm guessing the transcript was a moving target his senior year as he struggled to bring it up to standards. I can totally see why the Ducks hesitated, particularly with our emphasis on recruiting kids who actually qualify.
Just because you miss on a few good players you don't change your philosophy.
That's why I said, I could see from his end. We're recruiting better than ever, not suggesting we should change.
Also doesn't mean we can't do better in situations like this. Coaches are making mistakes all the time, just like the rest of us, and hopefully learning from them.
I guess I am confused by your assertion that we "could do better in situations like this". Do you mean because we missed on the kid, or do you think we were less than fully ethical. Because I read nothing in that story to back up that belief, other than vague accusations from the high school guidance counselor. We have no idea what Oregon was telling him about his grades during the process- I would bet they made him aware of the issues. And the fact that his brother is coming leads me to believe that's the case.
Are you just being argumentative? Or don't you think that young coaches like Helfrich and Frost make mistakes just like the rest of humanity?
We wanted Poutasi badly at the end, we didn't get Poutasi. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that was one of the "strike out" years at OL.
If we had handled the situation better, we probably end up with a future high draft pick at OL. That doesn't seem like a success to me, especially when a by-all-accounts good young guy produced the quotes and story for that article. What measurement of success are you using?
Maybe you should calm down since you seem a bit unhinged about someone challenging your assertion. We'll never fully know what happened so just drop it so you don't have a coronary or end up saying something you'll regret later.
The coaches liked Poutasi a lot, but his academics were a major issue. After missing out on literally every high school OL target - Zach Banner, Kyle Murphy, Andrus Peat, Freddie Tagaloa, Nick Davidson, Isaac Seumalo, etc. Oregon came running back to Poutasi late, despite the fact that there was a good chance that he wasn't going to qualify. Some of those targets didn't publicly commit until signing day, but they were silents to other schools. Steve Greatwood really botched that recruiting class, considering the strength at the position out West that year. I believe Kyle Long was Oregon's only OL commit that year.
“If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way,” he said. “We turned the ball over a lot. We beat ourself. Just be real with yourself right now. We beat ourself.”
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
jimmy12 wrote:I really can't stand when people refer to bloodlines. It means so little. Michael Jordan has kids. Barry Sanders son plays for Stanford (havent heard anything about him), sure there are some that turn out (christian mccaffrey) but in reality ,it's all work product and desire. I am with Tech here, his feet are in cement and he'll get schooled by faster stronger competition.
jimmy12 wrote:I really can't stand when people refer to bloodlines. It means so little. Michael Jordan has kids. Barry Sanders son plays for Stanford (havent heard anything about him), sure there are some that turn out (christian mccaffrey) but in reality ,it's all work product and desire. I am with Tech here, his feet are in cement and he'll get schooled by faster stronger competition.
1. You are looking at sons, rather than brothers. There is obviously a big difference in the bloodlines when you change half the equation.
2. If you don't think there is a correlation between brothers of professional athletes (or even sons for that matter) becoming professional athletes themselves, you are sorely mistaken. That isn't to say that the likelihood is high just because you have the bloodlines, but the percentage of people with professional bloodlines that end up becoming professionals themselves, compared to the public in general, is dramatically higher.
I like the overall glass-half-full viewpoints that are prevalent on this board, and it's why I post here. It's OK to every now and then have a critical opinion, though, so long as it doesn't go overboard with name-calling, calling for jobs, etc.
As far as circumstances, this offer reminds me of Jake Pisarcik and Kani Benoit. Both under-the-radar or undervalued players who got an Oregon offer and jumped on it late.
As far as on tape, which because I have too much free time I try to watch every commit and serious recruit, I see a huge body with a great build who doesn't move super well. As I said in my other post, I'm hopeful he can be as productive as Ryan Clanton.