StevensTechU wrote:karlhungis wrote:
Kyle Long was a lineman. I think it's a different thing when it comes to QB's. Vernon Adams didn't even look comfortable in the offense until the end of the season and now we have to find another replacement. Imagine if he was going to be back next year? Our offense would be insane and expectations would be through the roof. To me the difference between 1 and 2 years is a pretty big deal. That's why I am not a big fan of the graduate transfer situation for the QB position.
My bad. I misread and thought you asked about 1 year JUCO. But why is it different for QBs? Long didn't even start until nearly halfway through the season because he was picking up the offense still. If a guy comes in and doesn't know the full offense but is still better than the other players, what's wrong with playing him? It stinks having a guy for one year-- I'd prefer that Oregon get guys they can have for 5 --but above everything else I want guys who are going to contribute at a high level. So give me Adams and Hegarty rather than Lockie and Brenner, because they're stand-up guys who help the team succeed on the field.
+1
I don't see anything wrong at all with offering kids that will have already graduated from FCS schools. Yes, those staffs have a certain amount of time investment in them, but that shouldn't take away the players right to want to test their skills at a higher level. I'm sure that there are a lot kids at that level who've wondered what it would be like to run out onto the field with a big time program and see how well they'd do playing a full season against teams in a Power-5 conference.
Look at guys from the FBS that leave early for the NFL. Do you see FBS coaches whining about how much time they put into a player and how he "owes" them that last year?
Nonsense!
He doesn't "owe" anyone anything.
Yes, it's a privilege to be given an athletic scholarship at any level. They'll have that degree for life and will probably always look upon that institution with warm regard and appreciation. But once they've earned that degree they should be free to do anything they'd like. They agreed to come and play football on an athletic scholarship, not to sign a 4-5 year degree to play football at that school.
A one year jump to the FBS could be the difference getting a shot at the NFL or not. I don't see any problem at all and neither should anyone else.