7 Quarterbacks
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
7 Quarterbacks
As of now, Oregon has 7 guys on the roster with eligibility left or committed to join the team next season: Dakota Prukop (5th), Jeff Lockie (5th), Taylor Alie (4th), Morgan Mahalak (3rd), Travis Jonsen (2nd), Terry Wilson (1st), and Justin Herbert (1st).
My question to you all is, if you were Mark Helfrich, how would you handle this situation? Do you force some players out? Do you encourage any position changes? And most importantly, who?
Understand that any decision could come with bad PR, bad precedent, etc. It's been said that ideally you want 5 QBs on the roster. In looking at it from a reps standpoint, I think you could potentially have 2 scout team QBs and 4 travel squad guys, but that's probably the max.
My question to you all is, if you were Mark Helfrich, how would you handle this situation? Do you force some players out? Do you encourage any position changes? And most importantly, who?
Understand that any decision could come with bad PR, bad precedent, etc. It's been said that ideally you want 5 QBs on the roster. In looking at it from a reps standpoint, I think you could potentially have 2 scout team QBs and 4 travel squad guys, but that's probably the max.
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
I think he has to let it play itself out without forcing anything. I think he has to anticipate that someone leaves. If he forces anyone out, and then another player(s) decides to leave on his own, he's right back to not having the desired depth. Also, from what I can tell, forcing kids out is not the culture. And you don't want to mess with the culture.StevensTechU wrote:As of now, Oregon has 7 guys on the roster with eligibility left or committed to join the team next season: Dakota Prukop (5th), Jeff Lockie (5th), Taylor Alie (4th), Morgan Mahalak (3rd), Travis Jonsen (2nd), Terry Wilson (1st), and Justin Herbert (1st).
My question to you all is, if you were Mark Helfrich, how would you handle this situation? Do you force some players out? Do you encourage any position changes? And most importantly, who?
Understand that any decision could come with bad PR, bad precedent, etc. It's been said that ideally you want 5 QBs on the roster. In looking at it from a reps standpoint, I think you could potentially have 2 scout team QBs and 4 travel squad guys, but that's probably the max.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Is Alie on scholarship? I've heard MM was going to transfer, but with Frost leaving he might stay now. Honestly I like Wilson, but if he can't beat out Herbert or Kelley, he could end up at WR. So I guess you just let it play out, but for how great Frost was here, I feel like he sure recruited and developed his WR then QB, below what he should have. Or he just didn't have a good eye for talent. You look at his class with Blackmon, that entire class transferred and they were thought to be a bunch of studs. At qb we have had to scramble two years in a row now. I'm looking forward to what our new qb coach can do, and fingers crossed he's close to as good as Lubick with the WR.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Buck- Alie is not on scholarship, but he does get reps in practice that could potentially go elsewhere.
Kelley won't be coming in for another season (2017).
Kelley won't be coming in for another season (2017).
-
srsmiley007
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 745
- Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Widuck is right about the culture part. I'm pretty sure that either Alie, Lockie or MM will have a discussion after spring ball and elect to pursue their options on their own.StevensTechU wrote:As of now, Oregon has 7 guys on the roster with eligibility left or committed to join the team next season: Dakota Prukop (5th), Jeff Lockie (5th), Taylor Alie (4th), Morgan Mahalak (3rd), Travis Jonsen (2nd), Terry Wilson (1st), and Justin Herbert (1st).
My question to you all is, if you were Mark Helfrich, how would you handle this situation? Do you force some players out? Do you encourage any position changes? And most importantly, who?
Understand that any decision could come with bad PR, bad precedent, etc. It's been said that ideally you want 5 QBs on the roster. In looking at it from a reps standpoint, I think you could potentially have 2 scout team QBs and 4 travel squad guys, but that's probably the max.
My guess is that either Lockie or MM take off on their own depending upon where they stand in terms of playing time.I have to believe that Lockie see's the writing on the wall in terms of PT.
Bummer about Alie, if he was more accurate downfield, he could take the reigns and roll so kind of a shame because he has the arm but not the accuracy.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
StevensTechU wrote:Buck- Alie is not on scholarship, but he does get reps in practice that could potentially go elsewhere.
Kelley won't be coming in for another season (2017).
Yeah, I understand that about Kelley. My point is just say Wilson is behind Herbert at the end of camp, then if the next year he ends up 3 behind both guys. He's got the ability to play another spot. Hell you can flip that, and say Herbert falls behind those two, at 6'6 already 230, he can play TE. It's a good problem to have.
-
whosyourwally
- Freshman
- Posts: 1320
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
It'd be very surprising if MM didn't transfer. If the coaches had seen any significant development over the course of this year, they wouldn't have gone after Prukop. Pretty clear he hasn't found a spot in the coaches' plans for the future of this team. Obviously, I'd love to be wrong and see him win the job next year, but the way things have played out, that seems like a pipe dream. Plus with the 2 qb's coming in next fall, and another year for TJ to develop, it seems like it's next year or bust for MM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
I don't think it's a problem in this case.StevensTechU wrote:As of now, Oregon has 7 guys on the roster with eligibility left or committed to join the team next season: Dakota Prukop (5th), Jeff Lockie (5th), Taylor Alie (4th), Morgan Mahalak (3rd), Travis Jonsen (2nd), Terry Wilson (1st), and Justin Herbert (1st).
My question to you all is, if you were Mark Helfrich, how would you handle this situation? Do you force some players out? Do you encourage any position changes? And most importantly, who?
Understand that any decision could come with bad PR, bad precedent, etc. It's been said that ideally you want 5 QBs on the roster. In looking at it from a reps standpoint, I think you could potentially have 2 scout team QBs and 4 travel squad guys, but that's probably the max.
Prukop starts. Lockie acts as a mentor to Jonsen, Herbert and Wilson, give them the reps. Jonsen is #2, while Wilson and Herbert run the scout team.
I think Lockie and Alie are comfortable with their place on the team. Both have to know they're not going to play except in an emergency. Looks to me like Lockie would prefer to stay off the field in live action anyway.
I'm sure that Helfrich will push Mahalak to move on, but I doubt he forces it. I wonder if he'd accept a medical retirement? It doesn't seem like he wants to play football.
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
From what little I've heard on Mahalak, he just doesn't care. Word is he doesn't know the playbook, doesn't work to get better, etc.whosyourwally wrote:It'd be very surprising if MM didn't transfer. If the coaches had seen any significant development over the course of this year, they wouldn't have gone after Prukop. Pretty clear he hasn't found a spot in the coaches' plans for the future of this team. Obviously, I'd love to be wrong and see him win the job next year, but the way things have played out, that seems like a pipe dream. Plus with the 2 qb's coming in next fall, and another year for TJ to develop, it seems like it's next year or bust for MM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
This was interesting. When asked how Mahalak was developing, Costa says "Good but not great." At the same time, Costa also says that Addison could QB so take it for what you will, plus there's a need to justify Prukop's transfer, so there's a lot that could go into the response. Either way, it surprised me a bit because the practice reports seemed to indicate Mahalak has been making strides.
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... r_QBs.html
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... r_QBs.html
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Things change. He could come on.StevensTechU wrote:This was interesting. When asked how Mahalak was developing, Costa says "Good but not great." At the same time, Costa also says that Addison could QB so take it for what you will, plus there's a need to justify Prukop's transfer, so there's a lot that could go into the response. Either way, it surprised me a bit because the practice reports seemed to indicate Mahalak has been making strides.
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... r_QBs.html
But "good not great" doesn't sound very good to me, when Pellum talks up his ILBs like they're the second coming. Coaches pump sunshine, and if they're pumping partly cloudy with a chance of rain, it's basically like saying not gonna happen.
-
srsmiley007
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 745
- Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Those dang practice reports are the worlds biggest tease. You read those and you would think that Lockie and Alie are the second coming. Then poof, we see the reality. It almost looks like there's constant subterfuge with their "coach speak" so you can't get a clear read on anything.StevensTechU wrote:This was interesting. When asked how Mahalak was developing, Costa says "Good but not great." At the same time, Costa also says that Addison could QB so take it for what you will, plus there's a need to justify Prukop's transfer, so there's a lot that could go into the response. Either way, it surprised me a bit because the practice reports seemed to indicate Mahalak has been making strides.
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... r_QBs.html
Funny though, we still keep reading them.
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Maybe it's a way for Costa to try and motivate him? It seems odd that an interim position coach would make such a proclamation. I guess I'd want to know what the question asked was before jumping to any conclusions. If Costa was speaking the truth though, I trust his assessment. He was a very talented and heady QB whose body betrayed him.vagusnerve wrote:Things change. He could come on.StevensTechU wrote:This was interesting. When asked how Mahalak was developing, Costa says "Good but not great." At the same time, Costa also says that Addison could QB so take it for what you will, plus there's a need to justify Prukop's transfer, so there's a lot that could go into the response. Either way, it surprised me a bit because the practice reports seemed to indicate Mahalak has been making strides.
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... r_QBs.html
But "good not great" doesn't sound very good to me, when Pellum talks up his ILBs like they're the second coming. Coaches pump sunshine, and if they're pumping partly cloudy with a chance of rain, it's basically like saying not gonna happen.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
"How is Morgan developing?"Duck24 wrote: I guess I'd want to know what the question asked was before jumping to any conclusions. If Costa was speaking the truth though, I trust his assessment. He was a very talented and heady QB whose body betrayed him.
I like watching the interviews by KEZI over reading quotations in print. So much more context. (You also find out which reporters are total morons, and who are great)
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: 7 Quarterbacks
Anyone up for adding Kyler Murray?