Cupp. from EWU

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Cupp. from EWU

Post by whosyourwally »

pudgejeff wrote:
whosyourwally wrote:
Duck24 wrote:I, for one, think he should leave if he has the opportunity to play at a big time FBS school. There is no reason any "student"-athlete should show any loyalty to the school they are at. They could kick him to the curb tomorrow if they wanted to.

If moving up to FBS gives him a better opportunity to go pro or if another school legitimately has a masters degree he is interested in, go for it. The schools and coaches have absolutely no loyalty to these kids. They care about two things; winning and by extension, money. They have to look out for themselves because the coaches and schools sure as hell aren't going to. He is a legitimately talented player who could make an impact at the FBS level. It would probably do his draft stock some favors to move up and consistently play against top tier competition.
By this logic, shouldn't any decent player on Oregon's roster want to transfer to Alabama?



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Huh?
Right? I figured I'd get this response. The original idea I responded to is so skewed to one side that it fails to identify how we view our current position. Oregon fans believe Oregon football is at the pinnacle of the sport, but that's just not unequivocally true. Relative to most teams, we are good. And framed right, we are one of the best. It's the framing that I want to point out. Whether you play for Oregon, EWU, or in your backyard, you, as a healthy person, frame your current situation as something to be proud of. These kids are proud of their teams, school, etc. Any decision to transfer will pit pride and emotional ties against someone's framed logical appeal. Does he have a better chance to get drafted if he transfers up?
Maybe:
School prestige/brand/exposure
Better competition
Better teammates

Maybe not:
Familiarity with system and players
Best player on field, less visible flaws
Guarantee of playing time

All I'm saying is I could frame an argument that would make it seem obvious that a player should transfer from Oregon to Alabama. And an argument he should stay put.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Last edited by whosyourwally on Wed Dec 23, 2015 6:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by Duck24 »

whosyourwally wrote:
Duck24 wrote:I, for one, think he should leave if he has the opportunity to play at a big time FBS school. There is no reason any "student"-athlete should show any loyalty to the school they are at. They could kick him to the curb tomorrow if they wanted to.

If moving up to FBS gives him a better opportunity to go pro or if another school legitimately has a masters degree he is interested in, go for it. The schools and coaches have absolutely no loyalty to these kids. They care about two things; winning and by extension, money. They have to look out for themselves because the coaches and schools sure as hell aren't going to. He is a legitimately talented player who could make an impact at the FBS level. It would probably do his draft stock some favors to move up and consistently play against top tier competition.
By this logic, shouldn't any decent player on Oregon's roster want to transfer to Alabama?



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
If every decent player at Oregon graduates with eligibility remaining and feels that transferring to Bama improves their NFL draft stock or offers them a graduate program they are actually serious about...then yes. Do what's best for themselves. It's not often that you can be a wanted commodity like these guys are. Take advantage of it while you can.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by pezsez1 »

Cupp transferring from an FCS to an FBS school is a significantly different scenario than someone transferring from one FBS school to another, even if one school's football team sucks and another's doesn't.

For these players with pro aspirations, the win/loss records of their teams aren't as important as their abilities to show scouts what they can do against the highest level of competition. If you play in any of the Power 5 conferences, you'll get that level of competition, especially with the growing degree of parity in today's college game.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Cupp. from EWU

Post by whosyourwally »

pezsez1 wrote:For these players with pro aspirations, the win/loss records of their teams aren't as important as their abilities to show scouts what they can do against the highest level of competition. If you play in any of the Power 5 conferences, you'll get that level of competition, especially with the growing degree of parity in today's college game.
And so here you are framing the level of competition as the determining factor. Should it be? What if his lack of speed would be exposed? What if his chemistry with the current EWU qb and almost guaranteed playing time will lead to eye grabbing stats again? Could he not just as likely hurt his standing in the draft?
Can you say with confidence that VA helped his stock? He was already on scouts' radar. He's still not likely a high draft pick. Do we have any empirical evidence that shows that this jump to FBS has actually helped a player's stock more often than hurting it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by pezsez1 »

Do we have any empirical evidence that shows that this jump to FBS has actually helped a player's stock more often than hurting it?
You're throwing an awful lot of vague questions out there. When really, the best way to get to the NFL is to impress talent scouts against top-tier talent.

Doesn't matter if stepping up a notch helps him or hurts him. What matters is that he makes the best case possible to get a foot in the door.

He'll unquestionably have a better shot if he thrives in the FBS.

Transferring up is certainly a risk, but it's not like he'll be able to hide any inefficiencies once (or if) he starts getting seriously evaluated.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Eagledawg
High School Drop Out
Posts: 3
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2015 6:03 pm

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by Eagledawg »

vagusnerve
Freshman
Posts: 1383
Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by vagusnerve »

whosyourwally wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:For these players with pro aspirations, the win/loss records of their teams aren't as important as their abilities to show scouts what they can do against the highest level of competition. If you play in any of the Power 5 conferences, you'll get that level of competition, especially with the growing degree of parity in today's college game.
And so here you are framing the level of competition as the determining factor. Should it be? What if his lack of speed would be exposed? What if his chemistry with the current EWU qb and almost guaranteed playing time will lead to eye grabbing stats again? Could he not just as likely hurt his standing in the draft?
Can you say with confidence that VA helped his stock? He was already on scouts' radar. He's still not likely a high draft pick. Do we have any empirical evidence that shows that this jump to FBS has actually helped a player's stock more often than hurting it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Time to admit you have no idea what you're talking about hahahaha
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by whosyourwally »

vagusnerve wrote:
whosyourwally wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:For these players with pro aspirations, the win/loss records of their teams aren't as important as their abilities to show scouts what they can do against the highest level of competition. If you play in any of the Power 5 conferences, you'll get that level of competition, especially with the growing degree of parity in today's college game.
And so here you are framing the level of competition as the determining factor. Should it be? What if his lack of speed would be exposed? What if his chemistry with the current EWU qb and almost guaranteed playing time will lead to eye grabbing stats again? Could he not just as likely hurt his standing in the draft?
Can you say with confidence that VA helped his stock? He was already on scouts' radar. He's still not likely a high draft pick. Do we have any empirical evidence that shows that this jump to FBS has actually helped a player's stock more often than hurting it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Time to admit you have no idea what you're talking about hahahaha
I love comments like this. You must unconditionally love yourself. Good for you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Cupp. from EWU

Post by whosyourwally »

vagusnerve wrote: Time to admit you have no idea what you're talking about hahahaha

I picture you saying that, imagining everyone on this board standing behind you in support. That smug look on your face, arms crossed, as you think, "I don't even have to explain myself. They know."

But please do explain why a receiver who is already on the NFL's radar should consider level of competition above playing time, chemistry with teammates, and familiarity with a scheme? He's got one year to prove himself at a new school or he could keep building on his already-well-recognized career at EWU.
Take at look at recent drafts. There's a good 15-20 players taken from non-FBS schools. And even more from non-power 5 schools.
I get that standing out at Bama looks better than standing out at EWU, but as Trent Richardson would have you know, there's more to it than that.
Would you rather Flacco or McElroy be leading your team? Who got drafted higher? Where did they go to school?




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
pudgejeff
All Pac-12
Posts: 5020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:21 am
GM: Sacramento Kings GM

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by pudgejeff »

whosyourwally wrote:
vagusnerve wrote: Time to admit you have no idea what you're talking about hahahaha

I picture you saying that, imagining everyone on this board standing behind you in support. That smug look on your face, arms crossed, as you think, "I don't even have to explain myself. They know."

But please do explain why a receiver who is already on the NFL's radar should consider level of competition above playing time, chemistry with teammates, and familiarity with a scheme? He's got one year to prove himself at a new school or he could keep building on his already-well-recognized career at EWU.
Take at look at recent drafts. There's a good 15-20 players taken from non-FBS schools. And even more from non-power 5 schools.
I get that standing out at Bama looks better than standing out at EWU, but as Trent Richardson would have you know, there's more to it than that.
Would you rather Flacco or McElroy be leading your team? Who got drafted higher? Where did they go to school?




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I feel like Trent Richardson is a terrible example for you to use. He used his big school to get him drafted way higher than he should, got a big signing bonus an made a bunch of money he never would have if drafted later and cut because he wasn't already owed money.

I'm not saying your completely wrong here, but you are at a point where you seem to be contrary just to be contrary. There can be two sides to the story ,but if we are talking specifically about NFL dreams, moving up in competition is the best choice. Not saying it's a must, but it is the better choice. But that is if the decision is purely about your NFL dreams, if someone is worried about the rest of that stuff then it's going to be a personal decision. But to say playing at an FBS school, or a power 5 school, or a national title contender whichever it may be instead of an FCS school isn't better for your NFL dreams I feel like you are way off base. Obviously talent is gonna win out in the long run if you are that talented, but his measurable's aren't off the charts. Take I guy like Mullaney that transferred from OSU to Alabame, he went from never being on TV and few knowing who he was to making big time catches in big time games, that has changed his draft stock.
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by whosyourwally »

pudgejeff wrote:
whosyourwally wrote:
vagusnerve wrote: Time to admit you have no idea what you're talking about hahahaha

I picture you saying that, imagining everyone on this board standing behind you in support. That smug look on your face, arms crossed, as you think, "I don't even have to explain myself. They know."

But please do explain why a receiver who is already on the NFL's radar should consider level of competition above playing time, chemistry with teammates, and familiarity with a scheme? He's got one year to prove himself at a new school or he could keep building on his already-well-recognized career at EWU.
Take at look at recent drafts. There's a good 15-20 players taken from non-FBS schools. And even more from non-power 5 schools.
I get that standing out at Bama looks better than standing out at EWU, but as Trent Richardson would have you know, there's more to it than that.
Would you rather Flacco or McElroy be leading your team? Who got drafted higher? Where did they go to school?




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I feel like Trent Richardson is a terrible example for you to use. He used his big school to get him drafted way higher than he should, got a big signing bonus an made a bunch of money he never would have if drafted later and cut because he wasn't already owed money.

I'm not saying your completely wrong here, but you are at a point where you seem to be contrary just to be contrary. There can be two sides to the story ,but if we are talking specifically about NFL dreams, moving up in competition is the best choice. Not saying it's a must, but it is the better choice. But that is if the decision is purely about your NFL dreams, if someone is worried about the rest of that stuff then it's going to be a personal decision. But to say playing at an FBS school, or a power 5 school, or a national title contender whichever it may be instead of an FCS school isn't better for your NFL dreams I feel like you are way off base. Obviously talent is gonna win out in the long run if you are that talented, but his measurable's aren't off the charts. Take I guy like Mullaney that transferred from OSU to Alabame, he went from never being on TV and few knowing who he was to making big time catches in big time games, that has changed his draft stock.
Fair enough. I was running a fever and I got on the Internet. Fortunately I didn't have a credit card in hand.

RE: Trent Richardson. I brought him up because he's what happens when you over value the perceived level of competition. Sure it worked out for him, but we can all agree that was a terrible scouting job (by my Browns). The Browns even traded up to get him.... Also of note from the same draft, WR Brian Quick from Appalachian State was drafted ahead of Alshon Jerffreys and Ryan Broyles.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5362
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by Phalanx »

I don't have a problem with someone asking the question, 'Is it worth it in terms of goodwill built up over three years to transfer to a bigger school for one year?" I think it's a big risk, and there are probably intangibles that one gives up on. It seems likely though, that there is a payoff as well, if one succeeds at the larger school in terms of exposure. Yes, guys get drafted from smaller schools, but I have a feeling the default is to draft the guy from Alabama or even Oregon over the guy from EWU, if most others things are perceived as being equal. There is a reason why highly-recruited players with NFL aspirations invariably pick the larger school when they also got offered from the smaller ones, and I'm sure Kupp would have liked to play for a Pac 12 school if he had been given the opportunity at the outset.
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by nogerO »

It's threads like this that blur the line between what this board used to be and that "other" board where recruiting information you can get here for free all the time is "premium content" (you gotta pay). Please don't turn this into that other board. Stay civil and respectful. Everyone has a right to their opinion. Nothing wrong with agreeing to disagree...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by Duck24 »

nogerO wrote:It's threads like this that blur the line between what this board used to be and that "other" board where recruiting information you can get here for free all the time is "premium content" (you gotta pay). Please don't turn this into that other board. Stay civil and respectful. Everyone has a right to their opinion. Nothing wrong with agreeing to disagree...
With the exception of a few comments, this thread has been fine. People have differences of opinion on the matter and are stating their points. There are compelling arguments to be made for both staying and transferring. It's all circumstantial on the particular player.

This hasn't devolved into OregonLive, although when we were 3-3 it looked an awful lot like that board. As far as the premium boards, I'm much of a cheap ass to pay for that "insider info" that leaks on Twitter 3 minutes after they post it.

I think the mods have done a great job on this board, keeping it mostly football talk and keeping the trolls out. I'm guilty of going off of the rails at times and have been properly called on it. I have no complaints with the direction of this board. Everyone will have differing opinions on everything and it stays civil for the most part. You'll always get a commenter or two completely off base/off the hinges but such is life on the Internet.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Cupp. from EWU

Post by UOducksTK1 »

It's Christmas, let's be nice.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Locked