Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
I'm with the last 3 posters. Wilcox is not my choice but if you look at his record he is unlikely to be a disaster. I would expect around 50th ranked in bad years and with the right tools his historical ceiling is top 10.
Unlike some names thrown around like Hoke, Ogeron and Lovie, Wilcox has been a college DC. In fact in 4 different college programs under 3 coaches with from great to good to not bad results in 3 out of the 4 cases.
Even his results in his worse year wouldn't be that bad if he hadn't faced Stanford twice and Oregon. Most opponents scored less than 20. At Oregon he only has to face Stanford once and only has to face Oregon in the Spring game.
Wilcox is a safe bet to always put out that 50th ranked or better defense that many claim is all Oregon's Offense needs.
Unlike some names thrown around like Hoke, Ogeron and Lovie, Wilcox has been a college DC. In fact in 4 different college programs under 3 coaches with from great to good to not bad results in 3 out of the 4 cases.
Even his results in his worse year wouldn't be that bad if he hadn't faced Stanford twice and Oregon. Most opponents scored less than 20. At Oregon he only has to face Stanford once and only has to face Oregon in the Spring game.
Wilcox is a safe bet to always put out that 50th ranked or better defense that many claim is all Oregon's Offense needs.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
From pay sites, word is Ducks are still pursuing Pendergast right now. Pendergast has been offered two years from USC, but wants a third. Either is he legit interested in Oregon, or he's using them as leverage to get what he wants at USC.
Jhop mentioned that USC wants an answer by today, so this could get interesting.
Jhop mentioned that USC wants an answer by today, so this could get interesting.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
I have a hard time believing a California (Bay Area & SoCal) guy would be that interested in living in Eugene, unless he just really wants a mental break after being in the NFL. My guess is he's using us as leverage.Pendergast has been offered two years from USC, but wants a third. Either is he legit interested in Oregon, or he's using them as leverage to get what he wants at USC.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39396
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
His defenses were fine against pro-style or low-level spread offenses, but when facing against a talented, high-level spread team, his defenses fell apart. With most schools in the Pac-12 being good spread offense teams, I'm not sure if he has the skillset to draw up a defense to combat those week-in, week-out in a manner that is better than Aliotti or Pellum.GrandpaDuck wrote:I'm with the last 3 posters. Wilcox is not my choice but if you look at his record he is unlikely to be a disaster. I would expect around 50th ranked in bad years and with the right tools his historical ceiling is top 10.
Unlike some names thrown around like Hoke, Ogeron and Lovie, Wilcox has been a college DC. In fact in 4 different college programs under 3 coaches with from great to good to not bad results in 3 out of the 4 cases.
Even his results in his worse year wouldn't be that bad if he hadn't faced Stanford twice and Oregon. Most opponents scored less than 20. At Oregon he only has to face Stanford once and only has to face Oregon in the Spring game.
Wilcox is a safe bet to always put out that 50th ranked or better defense that many claim is all Oregon's Offense needs.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Keep in mind that even the nation's best defenses are vulnerable to being spanked by spread-out offenses packed with elite offensive players. That's the whole rub these days in trying to evaluate defenses, especially in a conference like the Pac-12.His defenses were fine against pro-style or low-level spread offenses, but when facing against a talented, high-level spread team, his defenses fell apart. With most schools in the Pac-12 being good spread offense teams, I'm not sure if he has the skillset to draw up a defense to combat those week-in, week-out in a manner that is better than Aliotti or Pellum.
That said, I totally share your concern about Wilcox. He's actually had the privilege of working with elite defensive players and he has STILL struggled to stop spread offenses that aren't as dangerous as Oregon's.
Aliotti actually did a pretty good job of scheming against other spread teams -- it was the bigger, more physical offenses that he tended to struggle against. Wilcox may be a better fit for slowing more physical offensive units, but if he can't defend spread offenses, then we'll have a hard time ever getting out of the Pac-12 unscathed.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
pezsez1 wrote:Keep in mind that even the nation's best defenses are vulnerable to being spanked by spread-out offenses packed with elite offensive players. That's the whole rub these days in trying to evaluate defenses, especially in a conference like the Pac-12.His defenses were fine against pro-style or low-level spread offenses, but when facing against a talented, high-level spread team, his defenses fell apart. With most schools in the Pac-12 being good spread offense teams, I'm not sure if he has the skillset to draw up a defense to combat those week-in, week-out in a manner that is better than Aliotti or Pellum.
That said, I totally share your concern about Wilcox. He's actually had the privilege of working with elite defensive players and he has STILL struggled to stop spread offenses that aren't as dangerous as Oregon's.
Aliotti actually did a pretty good job of scheming against other spread teams -- it was the bigger, more physical offenses that he tended to struggle against. Wilcox may be a better fit for slowing more physical offensive units, but if he can't defend spread offenses, then we'll have a hard time ever getting out of the Pac-12 unscathed.
2015 the year that got him fired:
Spread teams other than Oregon:
Arkansas State: 6
Arizona State: 14 (Oregon 61)
Utah: 24 (Oregon 62)
Arizona: 30
Colorado: 24 (Oregon 24)
UCLA: 21
Air Raid:
Cal: 21
He has had mixed success with Rich Rod and Graham over the years, usually getting the better but a couple of times getting rolled. He has done well against Air Raid. His Boise State D's were the best at containing Andy Dalton at TCU, Kapernick at Nevada and Utah's spread.
After dominating Oregon in 2009, Oregon has had his number and I think that is what people base there opinion of him on. But Oregon has had most peoples number. Pendergast held Oregon to 15 then the next 2 years Oregon scored 43 then 59 on his D. Pendergast's last game at Cal, OSU put 62 on them. Now Pendergast is still one of my favorites but neither he or Wilcox have been perfect against the spread but both have had some signature games against top spread teams.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
To add to my post, Pendergast's rep besides the 2010 Oregon game is 2013 USC where his D was stifling at the beginning of the year. But they played 3 spread teams that were good (not great) that year. Arizona, ASU and UCLA. Against everyone else USC gave up an average of 15 points a game. Against the 3 good spread teams they gave up an average of 43 points a game.
If I were going to make a case for struggling against spread teams and being great against the rest, Pendergast's 2013 USC team would be the poster child.
If I were going to make a case for struggling against spread teams and being great against the rest, Pendergast's 2013 USC team would be the poster child.
Last edited by GrandpaDuck on Thu Jan 07, 2016 1:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40742
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Me neither, but I also doubt he would stay as a DC at Oregon or USC more than 2 or 3 seasons anyway. Other than Cowboys stint for 6 years and his Cal stint for 4, he's a one or two year guy.pezsez1 wrote:I have a hard time believing a California (Bay Area & SoCal) guy would be that interested in living in Eugene, unless he just really wants a mental break after being in the NFL. My guess is he's using us as leverage.Pendergast has been offered two years from USC, but wants a third. Either is he legit interested in Oregon, or he's using them as leverage to get what he wants at USC.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
bdkipe
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Fri Aug 30, 2013 4:09 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Good afternoon all -
Since we are an uptempo spread team, shouldn't we be defining the metric we are judging the potential DC candidates against as far as "defensive rankings"?
I don't know as much as a lot of posters on here, but I would think the defensive metrics that blend well with our offensive style of play are in this order:
#1 - yds per play
#2 - points per possession
#3 - 3rd down efficiency
#4 - turnovers / takeaways created
#5 - sacks
That's why Hoke gives me pause. How many spread B10 teams did he line up against when he was HC at MaizeBlueU? When you play grind it out possession football against grind it out B10 teams (in Hoke's era) your ydpg an ppg are going look good.
On the Wilcox note, DonkeyU game and alleged targeting of Masoli/Dickson notwithstanding, he is one of our own, as are his dad and his brother. Once a Duck, ALWAYS a Duck. I know the Tennessee fans seem to miss him and thought highly of him.
I'm curious as to why we aren't looking at anyone who is from Derek Mason's coaching circles/philosophy (don't know if Mason has been an HC long enough to have a "tree" yet, well other than Stanford's mascot back when he was on ye olde Farm)
Since we are an uptempo spread team, shouldn't we be defining the metric we are judging the potential DC candidates against as far as "defensive rankings"?
I don't know as much as a lot of posters on here, but I would think the defensive metrics that blend well with our offensive style of play are in this order:
#1 - yds per play
#2 - points per possession
#3 - 3rd down efficiency
#4 - turnovers / takeaways created
#5 - sacks
That's why Hoke gives me pause. How many spread B10 teams did he line up against when he was HC at MaizeBlueU? When you play grind it out possession football against grind it out B10 teams (in Hoke's era) your ydpg an ppg are going look good.
On the Wilcox note, DonkeyU game and alleged targeting of Masoli/Dickson notwithstanding, he is one of our own, as are his dad and his brother. Once a Duck, ALWAYS a Duck. I know the Tennessee fans seem to miss him and thought highly of him.
I'm curious as to why we aren't looking at anyone who is from Derek Mason's coaching circles/philosophy (don't know if Mason has been an HC long enough to have a "tree" yet, well other than Stanford's mascot back when he was on ye olde Farm)
- FlDuckFan
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5068
- Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
- GM: Orlando Magic GM
- Location: Florida
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
I think good.Biggus Duckus wrote:Apparently Brady Hoke is being talked to by the Ducks. Good? Bad? Clapclapclap?
-
soduck
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 601
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:33 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
I did not like the F bombs coming from presumably Wilcox in the coaching box, which reinforced my attitude about his dirty play etc., I have been known to throw some myself, so I am not being sanctimonious. But that said as much as I don't want Wilcox, these recent discussions made me think I could live with Wilcox and of course I have a bias with him being a Husky coach and USC coach. And good points about question marks about Hoke and Pedergast. At least with Wilcox we know he knows recruiting and the pac 12 teams too. What has Hoke been doing lately? Plus Wilcox knows about living in Eugene and once a Duck always a Duck.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6495
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Just throwing this out there -- and I should consider this as well when thinking about Wilcox -- but it's important to acknowledge that USC's sanctions really crippled its ability to defend spread offenses.Pendergast's 2013 USC team would be the poster child.
Spread teams move the ball, put up more points and wear out defenses that can't get off the field. Simple as that. Any defense that doesn't have depth is likely to struggle against talented spread teams.
Might Pendergast's defenses fared better against spreads with a full complement of bodies under his command?
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Good thought provoking stuff and welcome. I would swap "points per possession" with yards per play, points count yards don't. And for myself I have found sacks to not be a positive correlative to defensive pass defense success. For instance Oregon was 9th in the country this year in Sacks. Chavis' last LSU team was a top 5 defense while being 103 in sacks. Oregon's best sack team of the Alliota 3-4 era was 2011 (3rd nationally) but was the worse Pass Defense rating of the same era.bdkipe wrote:Good afternoon all -
Since we are an uptempo spread team, shouldn't we be defining the metric we are judging the potential DC candidates against as far as "defensive rankings"?
I don't know as much as a lot of posters on here, but I would think the defensive metrics that blend well with our offensive style of play are in this order:
#1 - yds per play
#2 - points per possession
#3 - 3rd down efficiency
#4 - turnovers / takeaways created
#5 - sacks
That's why Hoke gives me pause. How many spread B10 teams did he line up against when he was HC at MaizeBlueU? When you play grind it out possession football against grind it out B10 teams (in Hoke's era) your ydpg an ppg are going look good.
On the Wilcox note, DonkeyU game and alleged targeting of Masoli/Dickson notwithstanding, he is one of our own, as are his dad and his brother. Once a Duck, ALWAYS a Duck. I know the Tennessee fans seem to miss him and thought highly of him.
I'm curious as to why we aren't looking at anyone who is from Derek Mason's coaching circles/philosophy (don't know if Mason has been an HC long enough to have a "tree" yet, well other than Stanford's mascot back when he was on ye olde Farm)
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8830
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
GrandpaDuck wrote:pezsez1 wrote:Keep in mind that even the nation's best defenses are vulnerable to being spanked by spread-out offenses packed with elite offensive players. That's the whole rub these days in trying to evaluate defenses, especially in a conference like the Pac-12.His defenses were fine against pro-style or low-level spread offenses, but when facing against a talented, high-level spread team, his defenses fell apart. With most schools in the Pac-12 being good spread offense teams, I'm not sure if he has the skillset to draw up a defense to combat those week-in, week-out in a manner that is better than Aliotti or Pellum.
That said, I totally share your concern about Wilcox. He's actually had the privilege of working with elite defensive players and he has STILL struggled to stop spread offenses that aren't as dangerous as Oregon's.
Aliotti actually did a pretty good job of scheming against other spread teams -- it was the bigger, more physical offenses that he tended to struggle against. Wilcox may be a better fit for slowing more physical offensive units, but if he can't defend spread offenses, then we'll have a hard time ever getting out of the Pac-12 unscathed.
2015 the year that got him fired:
Spread teams other than Oregon:
Arkansas State: 6
Arizona State: 14 (Oregon 61)
Utah: 24 (Oregon 62)
Arizona: 30
Colorado: 24 (Oregon 24)
UCLA: 21
Air Raid:
Cal: 21
He has had mixed success with Rich Rod and Graham over the years, usually getting the better but a couple of times getting rolled. He has done well against Air Raid. His Boise State D's were the best at containing Andy Dalton at TCU, Kapernick at Nevada and Utah's spread.
After dominating Oregon in 2009, Oregon has had his number and I think that is what people base there opinion of him on. But Oregon has had most peoples number. Pendergast held Oregon to 15 then the next 2 years Oregon scored 43 then 59 on his D. Pendergast's last game at Cal, OSU put 62 on them. Now Pendergast is still one of my favorites but neither he or Wilcox have been perfect against the spread but both have had some signature games against top spread teams.
Man, you're really killing the anti-Wilcox narrative.GrandpaDuck wrote:To add to my post, Pendergast's rep besides the 2010 Oregon game is 2013 USC where his D was stifling at the beginning of the year. But they played 3 spread teams that were good (not great) that year. Arizona, ASU and UCLA. Against everyone else USC gave up an average of 15 points a game. Against the 3 good spread teams they gave up an average of 43 points a game.
If I were going to make a case for struggling against spread teams and being great against the rest, Pendergast's 2013 USC team would be the poster child.

-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3316
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Pellum Demoted, Chinander Gone
Perhaps, but I don't buy that for the 2013 team. Every team has the same travel squad limit and USC in 2013 still had enough 4 and 5 stars to pack a complete travel squad. Remember how they loaded up in Kiffen's first year. The other thing is that though those teams were Spread, none of them were breakneck tempo. Wilcox who I am not advocating for had more depth issues in his upper classes due to the timing of the sanctions and Kiffin's front loading. But really other than UO, Wilcox didnt have a glaring Spread problem like Pendergast appears to have.pezsez1 wrote:Just throwing this out there -- and I should consider this as well when thinking about Wilcox -- but it's important to acknowledge that USC's sanctions really crippled its ability to defend spread offenses.Pendergast's 2013 USC team would be the poster child.
Spread teams move the ball, put up more points and wear out defenses that can't get off the field. Simple as that. Any defense that doesn't have depth is likely to struggle against talented spread teams.
Might Pendergast's defenses fared better against spreads with a full complement of bodies under his command?