greenyellow wrote:Not really impressed with Tialavea either. Just a really weak year for DL on the West Coast this year. I'd rather they hold onto the scholarship for next season when there's a better DL class out West.
Agree. Would rather see the coaches save the scholarships than reach for kids who won't be able to contribute at this level. Forget the recruiting rankings, McDoom is a very good prospect. He and Mayden are big losses.
I also agree, we shouldn't be settling to a standard that is so far down.
Oregon can live with 2 WRs this class. Perhaps they go after Crawford again. This de-commit has me a bit stumped, though, as McDoom as "all Ducks" just two weeks ago when asked by reporters at the Army AA game.
The Mayden loss hurts, still, because Neal has shown to be very hit-or-miss with DB recruiting. There are some 2017 CBs that Oregon has a great shot with that could make us all forget about Mayden, though.
Do you think it's possible they were looking for a reason to pull his scholarship? It seemed too easy. If the Ducks are now needing to recruit to support the 4-3, then maybe the extra WR was more of a luxury. Perhaps they wanted to pull it.
I don't think they were looking to pull it, ala Seth Green, but I think they viewed him as a marginal player that they could afford to let go in order to reaffirm their own principles. McDoom was the 3rd most talented WR commit Oregon had up until yesterday, and I think Lubick was very aware of that fact.
greenyellow wrote:Not really impressed with Tialavea either. Just a really weak year for DL on the West Coast this year. I'd rather they hold onto the scholarship for next season when there's a better DL class out West.
He'd be a waisted scholarship imho. Kid would be gone after a year or two of not being able to keep up in practice.