OK, you win. We are setting the standard in college football. Even Alabama is envious of our "don't bother developing your own players" strategy. It does look good on the program after all.Duck24 wrote:You know the team that just won the national championship started a QB who was a graduate transfer, right? The same team that was a finalist for Prukop. What does that say about their ability to develop QB's? They also had a guy who barely made an impact for the Beavers start at WR. I think it's more of a sign of the times than anything else.karlhungis wrote:Which is what started this whole debate. Does this somehow look good for the program or not? I don't care what the reasoning is behind it all, when looking at the situation I just fail to see how anyone can look at it and say..."those guys at Oregon sure are doing it right." Nobody is going to model a successful program around pulling in grad transfers at the last minute to fill critical holes in your line up. It doesn't look good for the program but it is what it is. I'm glad we are finding guys to fill in but I sure wish it didn't come to that.vagusnerve wrote:Well said. But please don't tell me there weren't coaching failures when, two years in a row, we need graduate transfers at both QB and C. It's unprecedented.StevensTechU wrote:I could write a much lengthier version of this, but I'll try to keep it short--
There are misses on the recruiting trail where coaches don't get who they want. There are mis-evaluations, where coaches get who they want but they don't pan out as thought. There are position switches. There are injuries, transfers, and retirements.
The end result, of all of that and more, is that some positions end up with more depth than others, and each year the quality and depth at each position changes. As such, we likely shouldn't treat an occurrence like having a subpar backup at a few positions as an abnormality or a sign of weakness, but instead just a rather normal occurrence, like when a team gives up a ton of rushing yards after a few DL go down (UCLA), or how a New Years Six quality team loses to UConn when they lose their QB (Houston).
Brenner and Lockie out there was an embarrassment. It happens. Learn, grow from your failure, and move on
If you don't see the failure, you'll never learn.
Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Michigan, FSU and Bama all started transfers at QB last season.
- ncduck
- Senior
- Posts: 2189
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
- Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Wait, are we now expecting to have zero holes on the two deep? If Bama had to rely on a transfer at QB, was their backup a plug and play starter? Am I understanding the point correctly? If I misunderstood, please correct me.
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5324
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
The argument (at least from my end) is being mischaracterized. I am not talking about 'missing' on guys. I am talking about training someone to successfully hike the ball to another guy who can successfully run a play. The ducks did not need a star at either position, up 31 at halftime in a bowl game, they just needed a couple of guys who were trained in how to execute a football play. The fact that nobody could is a direct reflection of a shortcoming of coaching. I don't know what else a reasonable person could call it. The tide went out, and the coaches weren't wearing anything. To imply that they were just a victim of circumstances beyond their control seems very silly to me. Get a guy who can hike the ball. Could he hike it really well in practice, but just got some kind of stage fright? Then get the other guy who has been practicing all year. You can't just let the guy hike it into the dirt over and over and over. They had at least two years to get a guy.
I guaran-freaking-tee you they are adjusting the coaching now to make sure this never happens again.
I guaran-freaking-tee you they are adjusting the coaching now to make sure this never happens again.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
I agree. It's a product of Greatwood's recruiting philosophy. He recruits the best OL he can get with hopes that someone who played guard or tackle in high school can pick up the center position (http://www.oregonlive.com/ducks/index.s ... r_hro.html). He's much more right than wrong, as we've seen over the last two decades. But this cycle he was wrong. Does that mean he needs to change his recruiting philosophy? Not so sure. I don't think Brenner's inability to hike a ball is an indictment of Greatwood's teaching skills, though, since there's a tremendous amount of evidence suggesting he's pretty darn good at his job.Phalanx wrote:The argument (at least from my end) is being mischaracterized. I am not talking about 'missing' on guys. I am talking about training someone to successfully hike the ball to another guy who can successfully run a play. The ducks did not need a star at either position, up 31 at halftime in a bowl game, they just needed a couple of guys who were trained in how to execute a football play. The fact that nobody could is a direct reflection of a shortcoming of coaching. I don't know what else a reasonable person could call it. The tide went out, and the coaches weren't wearing anything. To imply that they were just a victim of circumstances beyond their control seems very silly to me. Get a guy who can hike the ball. Could he hike it really well in practice, but just got some kind of stage fright? Then get the other guy who has been practicing all year. You can't just let the guy hike it into the dirt over and over and over. They had at least two years to get a guy.
I guaran-freaking-tee you they are adjusting the coaching now to make sure this never happens again.
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.Duck24 wrote:You know the team that just won the national championship started a QB who was a graduate transfer, right? The same team that was a finalist for Prukop. What does that say about their ability to develop QB's? They also had a guy who barely made an impact for the Beavers start at WR. I think it's more of a sign of the times than anything else.karlhungis wrote:Which is what started this whole debate. Does this somehow look good for the program or not? I don't care what the reasoning is behind it all, when looking at the situation I just fail to see how anyone can look at it and say..."those guys at Oregon sure are doing it right." Nobody is going to model a successful program around pulling in grad transfers at the last minute to fill critical holes in your line up. It doesn't look good for the program but it is what it is. I'm glad we are finding guys to fill in but I sure wish it didn't come to that.vagusnerve wrote:Well said. But please don't tell me there weren't coaching failures when, two years in a row, we need graduate transfers at both QB and C. It's unprecedented.StevensTechU wrote:I could write a much lengthier version of this, but I'll try to keep it short--
There are misses on the recruiting trail where coaches don't get who they want. There are mis-evaluations, where coaches get who they want but they don't pan out as thought. There are position switches. There are injuries, transfers, and retirements.
The end result, of all of that and more, is that some positions end up with more depth than others, and each year the quality and depth at each position changes. As such, we likely shouldn't treat an occurrence like having a subpar backup at a few positions as an abnormality or a sign of weakness, but instead just a rather normal occurrence, like when a team gives up a ton of rushing yards after a few DL go down (UCLA), or how a New Years Six quality team loses to UConn when they lose their QB (Houston).
Brenner and Lockie out there was an embarrassment. It happens. Learn, grow from your failure, and move on
If you don't see the failure, you'll never learn.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
And recognize that over the life of their careers, this has been the exception, not the rule (except for the guy who is now the head man at UCF), and move on.vagusnerve wrote: Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
-
SuperDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 4671
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
- Location: Arizona, USA
- Contact:
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
+infinity!StevensTechU wrote:And recognize that over the life of their careers, this has been the exception, not the rule (except for the guy who is now the head man at UCF), and move on.vagusnerve wrote: Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
John 3:36
-
chapelhillduck
- Senior
- Posts: 2408
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:15 am
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Question, would it have been worth blowing Hanson's redshirt only to win the bowl game? I'm a firm no
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Well that's kind of the elephant in the room, isn't it?StevensTechU wrote:And recognize that over the life of their careers, this has been the exception, not the rule (except for the guy who is now the head man at UCF), and move on.vagusnerve wrote: Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
Frost was responsible for the QBs. End of story.
Not sure how greatwood fell so hard, but he gets the benefit of the doubt.
Frost doesn't, considering what he did with the WRs.
And helfrich doesn't get a pass. He is tightening up the ship, as he should. He knows he dropped yhe ball. The pellum thing got away from him, and one could argue he gave too much independence to his assistants.
Regardless of what you think, it's clear that Mullens, knight and helfrich saw the same things I saw. That's why we're seeing big changes.
-
vagusnerve
- Freshman
- Posts: 1383
- Joined: Tue Feb 02, 2010 12:56 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
I might add, that level of f%$& up would probably get you canned just about anywhere regardless of past performance.StevensTechU wrote:And recognize that over the life of their careers, this has been the exception, not the rule (except for the guy who is now the head man at UCF), and move on.vagusnerve wrote: Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
-
gofightingducks
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5533
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Clearly there were coaching errors in talent evaluation and even more so in player development of QB and C and some other areas as well and Helfrich is aware of that and went out and got some great coaches to come in and fix those things both recruiting, scheme and development. The center issue is interesting because Greatwood is great at what he does but I think Frost was over rated and is not good at developing QBs. I think Yost will do wonders with the development and recruiting of QBs and in the passing game alongside Lubbick as coordinator and I think Greatwood will get back to doing what he has done throughout his career with the O-line.
-
duckfan22
- Senior
- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Just my thoughts only is that the center problem in the bowl game is Brenner had a bad half
of football. Or im hoping thats all it was. The qb situation i think falls on Frost. Just dont think he
was the right guy for that. And his play calling left a bit to be desired. I always thought he had a very
smug attitude when interviewed. I just wonder if Helfrich would have made a change there if Frost hadnt
left. Moving forward i think we should see a big improvement. I think we will be just fine.
of football. Or im hoping thats all it was. The qb situation i think falls on Frost. Just dont think he
was the right guy for that. And his play calling left a bit to be desired. I always thought he had a very
smug attitude when interviewed. I just wonder if Helfrich would have made a change there if Frost hadnt
left. Moving forward i think we should see a big improvement. I think we will be just fine.
-
damascusduck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 252
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 1:01 pm
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
You are a crack up. What's your eDuck name. Your posts sound eerily familiar.vagusnerve wrote:I might add, that level of f%$& up would probably get you canned just about anywhere regardless of past performance.StevensTechU wrote:And recognize that over the life of their careers, this has been the exception, not the rule (except for the guy who is now the head man at UCF), and move on.vagusnerve wrote: Alabama had other guys to make a forward pass, and hike ball. We didn't. There is the difference.
Always go after the best player. Always assume you'll be the victim of unforseen circumstances.
We dropped the ball, plain and simple. In four years they couldn't develop a guy to throw or snap? That's not even acceptable in NAIA ball.
This whinging ninny approach, coaches are infallible, is tiring.
Accept the fact that they f'd up, big time, and move on.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6488
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Jake Raulerson - Another transfer?
Reading all this back-and-forth, the best summary still seems to be "s*** happens."
Willie Taggart is a dick.