Is there a coaching problem
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15435
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Is there a coaching problem
I expect next year will be better, but just saying, if it isn't, he may be in some serious trouble. I know a lot will disagree to this, but Helf needs to take some flack for losing Malapei. Marcus literally gifted him and Oregon with a pipeline and he lost it. This isn't just losing a RB, this could be losing a pipeline and that's what really frustrates me most about this. People seem to underestimate how big of a loss this truly is. Helf needs to take flack for this.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40736
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Is there a coaching problem
Not closing on a class and losing as many quality commits as we did is not fun. But it happens. And frankly, switching OC and DCs a month or two before the class wraps up is never helpful. Last year was a weird year too with how we started with three losses early in the season, and the alamo bowl debacle to start this year was awful.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I ask this because we are seeing a class that was looking like be one of our best classes recruiting in recent history and it is finishing rather weakly On the field we fielded a team that could not close out game. We are seeing the same thing with our recruiting cycle this year. We can not close the deal. Does this signal a problem with our coaches. Couple months ago we had the best class in the Pac 12... now we are 5th in the conference. Seems to me is some kind of problem.
We are a little bit in a transition state with coaching, and having one of the more bizarre years probably since the Justin Roper/Cody Kempt days. Helf can't help VA getting hurt, but he didn't ultimately demote DP and got a good hire at DC. I think Hoke, Helf, and company will have a stronger class next year once there's more stability. No reason to stress.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6488
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Is there a coaching problem
The hiring of Yost and Hoke seem like home runs at the outset. And don't forget the impact of Lubbock at OC. This has the potential to be an all-around dynamite staff.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39387
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Is there a coaching problem
It just seemed like Lubick disappeared on the recruiting trail as I don't remember him in any photos the coaches took with recruits.pezsez1 wrote:The hiring of Yost and Hoke seem like home runs at the outset. And don't forget the impact of Lubbock at OC. This has the potential to be an all-around dynamite staff.

-
Sooth
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 593
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 9:34 am
Re: Is there a coaching problem
I know people on an internet forum are going to see this as a typical overemotional fan reaction, but I assure you that I am perfectly calm (calmer than you are, Dude...).
Anyway, this class is quite simply the worst of the modern era of Oregon football. And I don't mean that comparatively in that this class was ranked higher than this class or this class has more talent than that class, etc. There are some very good pieces in this class. I don't mean this comment to be a slight on the kids at all.
However, in terms of opportunity and momentum squandered I don't see how anyone with even a shred of knowledge of football recruiting could defend the job the coaches did this cycle. I, quite frankly, have never seen a program coming off a national title appearance with a Heisman winner and fail to capitalize on that momentum so poorly in the following recruiting cycle.
I am not an anti-Helfrich guy, but I do believe now that he is coaching for his job next season. And I'm not liking his chances at the moment.
Anyway, this class is quite simply the worst of the modern era of Oregon football. And I don't mean that comparatively in that this class was ranked higher than this class or this class has more talent than that class, etc. There are some very good pieces in this class. I don't mean this comment to be a slight on the kids at all.
However, in terms of opportunity and momentum squandered I don't see how anyone with even a shred of knowledge of football recruiting could defend the job the coaches did this cycle. I, quite frankly, have never seen a program coming off a national title appearance with a Heisman winner and fail to capitalize on that momentum so poorly in the following recruiting cycle.
I am not an anti-Helfrich guy, but I do believe now that he is coaching for his job next season. And I'm not liking his chances at the moment.
-
duckfan96
- Senior
- Posts: 2717
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm
Re: Is there a coaching problem
Hehe coaching for his job? Aren't they all coaching for their jobs? I'm not as football smart as some on this board seem to be, or think they are, but it is a ok class. All of last year people bitched how bad the linebackers were. That was met in this class. I guess since they are all not 4 and 5 stars this class sucks
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15435
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Is there a coaching problem
I don't get the Hoke and Yost excuses, how many teams get new coaches and use the new beginning and era angle and are successful with that? The fact is, no matter how you look at it, Helf screwed up this year and he should receive blame. You don't have to say fire Helf, I'm not, at least not yet, but you have to admit he didn't do too good this year at coaching Oregon.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6488
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Is there a coaching problem
Maybe Oregon could have held onto some recruits (or had a better class) by adopting the practices of some of the bigger football factories -- like the meritocracy approach of Alabama and Michigan (keep on recruiting and pull offers for lower-ranked kids), or maybe waiting until after the recruiting season before replacing the coaches who'd formed bonds with players.
Yes, it's often on the coaches when bad things happen. But part of the reason this class went south was because our program does certain things the RIGHT way. And by "right," I'm not talking about best results on the field.. I mean "right," as in "the decent thing to do."
I want us to win our national title the right way. That means being willing to get beat now and then by programs that take shortcuts.
For now, though, I don't see any big reasons to believe Helfrich will fail. In fact, I see lots of evidence to support why he'll succeed.
Yes, it's often on the coaches when bad things happen. But part of the reason this class went south was because our program does certain things the RIGHT way. And by "right," I'm not talking about best results on the field.. I mean "right," as in "the decent thing to do."
I want us to win our national title the right way. That means being willing to get beat now and then by programs that take shortcuts.
I definitely agree. And we won't really know what this past season meant for another year or two, once we can see how the program grows and changes now that we'll have more options at QB and hopefully a revitalized defense. It could turn out that last season was, in fact, a complete anomaly. Or maybe that will prove to be the norm, in which case changes will be needed. Time will tell.The fact is, no matter how you look at it, Helf screwed up this year and he should receive blame. You don't have to say fire Helf, I'm not, at least not yet, but you have to admit he didn't do too good this year at coaching Oregon.
For now, though, I don't see any big reasons to believe Helfrich will fail. In fact, I see lots of evidence to support why he'll succeed.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39387
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Is there a coaching problem
This is definitely on Helfrich for not springboarding the program from a national title appearance and Heisman Trophy. His hiring of Pellum as DC/recruiting coordinator looks to be a move that will have hurt the program for up to 2 seasons. Hopefully someone else will take over recruiting coordinator and can actually get a better list of recruits to target. With a full allotment of visits now, there should no longer be an excuse they didn't have backup options.Sooth wrote:I know people on an internet forum are going to see this as a typical overemotional fan reaction, but I assure you that I am perfectly calm (calmer than you are, Dude...).
Anyway, this class is quite simply the worst of the modern era of Oregon football. And I don't mean that comparatively in that this class was ranked higher than this class or this class has more talent than that class, etc. There are some very good pieces in this class. I don't mean this comment to be a slight on the kids at all.
However, in terms of opportunity and momentum squandered I don't see how anyone with even a shred of knowledge of football recruiting could defend the job the coaches did this cycle. I, quite frankly, have never seen a program coming off a national title appearance with a Heisman winner and fail to capitalize on that momentum so poorly in the following recruiting cycle.
I am not an anti-Helfrich guy, but I do believe now that he is coaching for his job next season. And I'm not liking his chances at the moment.

- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40736
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Is there a coaching problem
I'm not talking about Yost, as much as I'm talking about losing Chins and Frost. Big recruiting impact.OregonFan4Life wrote:I don't get the Hoke and Yost excuses, how many teams get new coaches and use the new beginning and era angle and are successful with that? The fact is, no matter how you look at it, Helf screwed up this year and he should receive blame. You don't have to say fire Helf, I'm not, at least not yet, but you have to admit he didn't do too good this year at coaching Oregon.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
And hey, Hoke helped get us Simms and Kirby at the last minute. I'll take both of those guys.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39387
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Is there a coaching problem
There's talk over on DT that Neal felt handcuffed recruiting this season and that more about this will come out later. JHop is hinting at some BTS grumbling amongst the staff. If I was Neal, I'd be a bit pissed as well with how few DB options he had the chance to pursue in the last month of recruiting.

-
liberalduck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 211
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm
Re: Is there a coaching problem
It is not as if our cupboards are bare. We have a lot of good recruits coming in. That being said, there are few, if any, programs that have had the level of success we have had over the past decade or so - And yet, many teams who shouldn't be out recruiting us every year, do just that. That is frustrating.
There are a lot of valid reasons why we lose out on some recruits - distance, weather, academic reputation compared to Stanford, USC, Cal, etc. Despite those disadvantages (and others), I think with our program's success and the fact that we have perhaps the best facilities in college football, other successful Ducks sports teams, a beautiful campus, and close ties to Nike, we should be recruiting on par with some of the best in the nation - Top ten.
Some people think we just can't recruit any better. We are doing the best as we possibly can based on our disadvantages and the advantages some other programs have over us. Personally, I don't agree. I think we simply need better recruiters.
Does anyone not think we would recruit better if we had Harbaugh coaching for us? He is able to recruit very well to whatever school he coaches. Yes, Michigan is a storied program and Stanford has its appeal, but Michigan was down and he turned them around almost immediately and look at his recruiting haul this year. As for Stanford, Stanford is recruiting well now. People see Stanford's advantages academically and locationally and it makes sense. However, Stanford hasn't always been viewed in this light. Coaching, recruiting and wins are what changed the perception people have of Stanford as a football power.
My point isn't that we need to go get Harbaugh. That is ridiculous. However, I do believe when evaluating coaches, we need to perhaps look at their recruiting abilities and weigh those skills along with their abilities to coach and motivate. I think only with better recruiting will we ever get that coveted NC. I think it is possible. We just need to get the right people. Kids want to play for a champion and our coaches need to convince them they can achieve that goal here.
There are a lot of valid reasons why we lose out on some recruits - distance, weather, academic reputation compared to Stanford, USC, Cal, etc. Despite those disadvantages (and others), I think with our program's success and the fact that we have perhaps the best facilities in college football, other successful Ducks sports teams, a beautiful campus, and close ties to Nike, we should be recruiting on par with some of the best in the nation - Top ten.
Some people think we just can't recruit any better. We are doing the best as we possibly can based on our disadvantages and the advantages some other programs have over us. Personally, I don't agree. I think we simply need better recruiters.
Does anyone not think we would recruit better if we had Harbaugh coaching for us? He is able to recruit very well to whatever school he coaches. Yes, Michigan is a storied program and Stanford has its appeal, but Michigan was down and he turned them around almost immediately and look at his recruiting haul this year. As for Stanford, Stanford is recruiting well now. People see Stanford's advantages academically and locationally and it makes sense. However, Stanford hasn't always been viewed in this light. Coaching, recruiting and wins are what changed the perception people have of Stanford as a football power.
My point isn't that we need to go get Harbaugh. That is ridiculous. However, I do believe when evaluating coaches, we need to perhaps look at their recruiting abilities and weigh those skills along with their abilities to coach and motivate. I think only with better recruiting will we ever get that coveted NC. I think it is possible. We just need to get the right people. Kids want to play for a champion and our coaches need to convince them they can achieve that goal here.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39387
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Is there a coaching problem
I think Oregon does need to change their approach and get a bit more aggressive to match some of the trends going on in recruiting. It seemed they were content to let recruits come to them instead of the other way around. They rested a bit too much on past accomplishments selling the program itself and didn't hit the recruiting trail as hard as they should, especially with all the other top recruiters at the other Pac-12 schools. Oregon just got unlucky with 2 of their top recruiters (Chins and Frost) leaving and then having a new DC with no on-field track record at Oregon to actually sell recruits. Plus, not having anymore visits hurt their ability to weather last minute flips or commitments elsewhere.
