pezsez1 wrote:Right. If you want to see a school with a coaching problem, look at USC. They have so much talent, they've been picked to win national titles in recent years even more than we have... and they can barely finish inside the top 25.
The reality of USC is that they have finished in the top 10 only 15 times since the Pac-10 was formed in 1978. Pete Carroll has 7 of those and Oregon has 7. USC is like the British Empire, they talk about tradition and past glories but really only win big when they cross the line.
Oregon demoted their DC. OC and top recruiter left for better jobs. Several positions are stacked and it is fairly obvious that immediate playing time for a true freshman isn't going to happen. Changes were made, if the Defense can operate at a 30% improvement and the offense can produce similar results of 2015 when at full strength the window should be open to make a run at the playoffs.
BTW-My nephew played against both Adams and Prukop and he felt Adams is more talented(better arm) but Prukop is a good dual overall fit for the Oregon offense. This offense has the potential to be great.
You are the same person that defended DP when others were calling for his head. The ones calling for his head ended up being right in the long run. Maybe...just maybe, there is an issue with the program and you just can't see it through your green tinted glasses.
No, I'm the person who urged people to be rational and not jump the gun after we struggled for a few games early this season... because our defense last season was statistically above average, there was no reason to start waving pitchforks so early this year, especially with such a young secondary.
By the way, I'm also the guy two seasons ago (Pellum's first) who correctly identified our defense as being above-average before the season's midway point. By the end of the year, most people agreed with me.
And this last season -- although I urged people to be patient -- by the year's end, I agreed that it was time to make a change. And I came to that conclusion DESPITE our defense actually improving for much of the second-half of the season. That's because I was able to remain objective (it's a skill) and actually break down our failings in the context of each game. Pellum's biggest problem wasn't his scheme, but his failure to make key in-game adjustments -- and that's something a lot of the parrots in here didn't start repeating until I brought it up.
If anything, that makes most of us 1-1 in terms of how we judged Pellum's defenses.
And now, again, I'm asking people to step off the crazy train and use some common sense.
I can always count on you for logical level-headed comments that make so much sense. Thanks!
I think Helfrich is a pretty damn good offensive mind, to be honest. I don't think there's any doubt about that. There are LOTS of coaches out there that could screw up offenses, even WITH Vernon Adams and Mariota. That said, verdict is still out on him as a HC. The Pellum hire was horrible and he's a below average recruiter as a HC. I think the Hoke hire was good and the Lubick promotion was good.
I think he's shown a consistent inability to close big time recruits on/around signing day. It's been a very frustrating trend over the last 3 seasons. (Baker, Smith, Vavae, the list is LONG). The mass de-commits this year was also pretty rough. Hopefully we can do a better job now that the scholarship restrictions are gone.
Prukop was a pleasant exception, but he was a transfer.
Until this staff can prove itself on the recruiting trail and the field, Helfrich and his ability to lead the program will be a question mark going forward.
I personally think Helf is incredibly smart, but I do question his ability to be a leader. I question giving him the HC position in the first place. Chip made Oregon cool and trendy, and we need that for recruiting. Helf again is a genius, but would anyone call him cool? Sure he says funny things to the press, but he seems more like your stepdad Gary than someone who makes the team cool and trendy. I know some may say this is irrelevant, but I believe image to be a huge part of college football.
GrantDuck wrote:I think Helfrich is a pretty damn good offensive mind, to be honest. I don't think there's any doubt about that. There are LOTS of coaches out there that could screw up offenses, even WITH Vernon Adams and Mariota. That said, verdict is still out on him as a HC. The Pellum hire was horrible and he's a below average recruiter as a HC. I think the Hoke hire was good and the Lubick promotion was good.
I think he's shown a consistent inability to close big time recruits on/around signing day. It's been a very frustrating trend over the last 3 seasons. (Baker, Smith, Vavae, the list is LONG). The mass de-commits this year was also pretty rough. Hopefully we can do a better job now that the scholarship restrictions are gone.
Prukop was a pleasant exception, but he was a transfer.
Pretty much my thoughts exactly. The potential is there and I'm optimistic that we'll see it but the more time goes on the more I see things that are concerning. This past season was really ugly at times.