All LOIs are in

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by SuperDuck »

pezsez1 wrote:This class is filled with solid pickups at areas of need, especially on defense.

I seriously don't get the unbridled negativity some people are expressing. If I didn't know any better, I'd think we just hauled in a bunch of 2-star guys with no offers.
Exactly.

We've also got a transfer QB that should have an immediate impact. Also, we still have a shot at Kelly, who announces later today, but guys, this is a small class.
Last edited by SuperDuck on Wed Feb 03, 2016 2:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
John 3:36
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2717
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by duckfan96 »

I'd give it a b. Filled needs at lb. got in state talent.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39387
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by greenyellow »

Class is a B-/C+ when looking at how they finished, filled needs, potential gamechangers and comparing to past classes.
Last edited by greenyellow on Wed Feb 03, 2016 2:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6488
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by pezsez1 »

We also got a couple of solid QB recruits, including a local QB who knowledgeable people here called perhaps our best pure QB recruit ever. AND we got an instant starter to hold things down while those new QBs get valuable experience.

People are going to quickly forget the letdown at the end of this recruiting cycle if our defense improves and our new QB is half as good as VA was.

B/B-.

If the Sheldon kid reaches the expectations of some folks here, then it could be an A+ when all is said and done -- but we won't know that for a couple more years.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39387
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by greenyellow »

Main problem with this class is it's not as well rounded as it should have been. They addressed needs/depth at certain positions (QB, OL, and LB) but then dropped the ball at others (RB, DL, and DB.)
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40736
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by UOducksTK1 »

AnnieDuck wrote:I confess I don't follow recruiting much until LOI day. I realize there are disappoints in who did not sign,
but ... please, someone tell me the upside of who the Ducks did get. :)
Not that there's a need for Oregon to go hard at the skill position talent, but it's always nice when Oregon can pull in a couple of the nation's top athletes. WR/ATH Dillon Mitchell is an absolute stud. His game film is fun to watch. Grabbing SEC quality talent out of the SEC is even more fun. Also, ATH Tristen Wallace is probably the most underrated recruit in this class. He had a lot of offers and was previously committed to Ohio State to play QB. He will likely play WR/TE at Oregon.

LB was a huge need in this class (and frankly in last year's class, but we whiffed a bunch), so to see us pull in some very solid talent at a weaker position was a big plus. Keith Simms, Lamar Winston, AJ Hotchkins, Darrian Franklin, Eric Bledsoe Jr., and possibly Troy Dye might be the best LB recruiting class we've ever had on paper. Switchin to a 4-3 will pretty much solidify both Bryson Young and Hunter Kampmoyer at the end positions. I like both.

It's amazing that we didn't land a single corner in this class, but that's what happens when a couple decommit and mom says no to another. S Brady Breeze is strong in-state talent though. Sure Bama took Mayden and Knott, but they did Knott take Breeze. Dye could play safety too (In fact I think he will given our influx of LB for this class and our move to 4-3).

It's also amazing that we very nearly ended up with 0 DTs in this class. While DT Wayne Kirby is by no means a big name recruit, I think his commitment is huge. To be left with no DT in this class would put us into a situation similar to our LB DC woes.

It'd be hard to match our awesome OL class last season, but this year's is nothing to sneeze at. OG Jacob Capra is already on campus. OT Logan Bathke and OG Samuel Poutasi round off the class.

TE Cam McCormick got injured his senior year, so we didn't get a great preview of what he could do, but he should be a fine TE for Oregon.

No RBs. But Oregon typically doesn't have a problem pulling guys in. With a favorable Oregon depth chart for the class of 2017, I see us landing two big name guys next year.

Two QBs in Terry Wilson and Justin Herbert.

Not hitting the DL, RB, and CB levels we wanted to is a little disappointing. Also, it feels like we had 10 guys decommit this year (Green, Warner, McDoom, Mayden, Howard, Vavae, anyone else? OK maybe not quite 10). But still some talent.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40736
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by UOducksTK1 »

greenyellow wrote:Main problem with this class is it's not as well rounded as it should have been. They addressed needs/depth at certain positions (QB, OL, and LB) but then dropped the ball at others (RB, DL, and DB.)
This, exactly. And it's actually pretty detrimental when you don't get well balanced classes. See our LB depth chart for the 2016 season.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39387
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by greenyellow »

It was 6 decommits, which is a lot for Oregon in a season. That happens when the program is sort of in a state of flux like Oregon was much of this season.
Image
damascusduck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 252
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 1:01 pm

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by damascusduck »

greenyellow wrote:Main problem with this class is it's not as well rounded as it should have been. They addressed needs/depth at certain positions (QB, OL, and LB) but then dropped the ball at others (RB, DL, and DB.)
All three spots were not a position of need. I felt they would take only one DT and they got Kirby. Dropped the ball on RB? They got stiffed at the alter by the only one they wanted. Hard to have a backup plan at that late date....I also don't think they needed a DB unless elite. Mayden and Knott chose to go elsewhere. Knott for a lack of trying by the coaches. I grade it a B. Would have been a B+ with VM.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by ncduck »

greenyellow wrote:It was 6 decommits, which is a lot for Oregon in a season. That happens when the program is sort of in a state of flux like Oregon was much of this season.
Replacing both coordinators a month prior to signing day makes this less than a surprise. It happen all the time in situations like that. The only time you see it work in favor of the school is when the school hires a huge name and/or there's more time available, not to mention OV's available, prior to signing day.

Everyone should have expected this to happen. Not meant to be an attack nor intended to be rude. Just saying that, this happens every year to schools. It just so happens this year Oregon had to swap out the two coaching positions.

Long run, I will trade all 6 of those decommits for better play calling on both sides of the ball. More wins will equal stronger future recruiting.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39387
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by greenyellow »

damascusduck wrote:
greenyellow wrote:Main problem with this class is it's not as well rounded as it should have been. They addressed needs/depth at certain positions (QB, OL, and LB) but then dropped the ball at others (RB, DL, and DB.)
All three spots were not a position of need. I felt they would take only one DT and they got Kirby. Dropped the ball on RB? They got stiffed at the alter by the only one they wanted. Hard to have a backup plan at that late date....I also don't think they needed a DB unless elite. Mayden and Knott chose to go elsewhere. Knott for a lack of trying by the coaches. I grade it a B. Would have been a B+ with VM.
Depth is the key word on the positions not hit upon in this class since it means having guys in the pipeline ready to contribute in the future and not having scholarship imbalances and gaps like they have at certain positions this upcoming season. It's important to hit nearly every position every year so they don't have to overload certain positions in a single recruiting cycle.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6488
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by pezsez1 »

The lack of the class being well-rounded is really the only problem I have with it (the disappointment of being jilted by a few high school kids will soon fade).

Fortunately, none of the positions we came up short on are positions of immediate need, which means we can ensure well-roundedness going forward with a larger class next offseason. At positions like CB, I'm glad the coaches opted to hold onto scholarships for next year rather than just extend offers to warm bodies.

I'm very excited for this Sheldon QB though -- will be interesting to see whether he or TJ takes snaps as the no. 2 QB (and I should sleep on Wilson, but the Sheldon kid got lots of props in here).

I'm also excited for the coaching changes. Both Yost and Hoke have great track records, and every defensive unit Hoke has been a part of has experienced substantial and immediate improvement.

A few years from now, I predict we'll see far more positives than negatives from this offseason. Doesn't change the fact that none of us are doing cartwheels today though.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
jimmy12
Senior
Posts: 2823
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by jimmy12 »

Everyone is all bent out of shape on the de-commits. Let's walk through these:

Theo Howard-- fast and falls a lot after the catch. Not a big loss considering the depth on the team. (If we kept howard, we would have likely not had room for Tristen Wallace. So, who would you rather have?)

Jared Mayden-- This one hurt because I loved his physicality. I did not like, however, how much of a drama queen he became.

Troy Warner- no opinion. He wanted to be with his brother.

Eddie McDoom-- was a back up plan that the staff did not love his tape. When he wavered, they jumped at the chance to get this spot back. (again so much depth at WR, does not hurt one bit)

Malepei- This one is interesting. We like his stars, BUT did you know Coach Campbell supposedly did not support his offer? Neither did I, but according to the misinformed Jhop this is the case. Chinander apparently begged to give him an offer. Wait, isn't coach Chins a LB coach? This doesn't make sense. With all the depth at this position and looking at the depth in 17's class. This one does not hurt at all. Not one bit.

Seth Green-- Our QB class is just flat out better than he appears to be so they honored the scholly as a TE. He doesn't want to be a TE.

Now, let's get to those that chose elsewhere:

Bundage-- We loved his tape and his ability to hit, but we were recruiting him at LB. How many could we afford to take? Not loss.

Caleb Kelly-- We all would have loved him. So, that's two players we would have liked. Mayden and Kelly.

Nigel Knott-- Another we would have liked. We all loved his flips and his athleticism, but he is small. Really small. Still though, we wanted him. That's 3.

Finally, Connor Murphy-- We loved his hair and his claim that Harbaugh loved his toughness.... His tape was ehhh and Hoke saw him on the Oline.... Well, we "lost" him to USC (only we stopped recruiting him 2 weeks before the end... Not a loss.

So, here we are. The sky has fallen, the world has ended. We have a new QB coach, who is rated one of the best in the business and is a heck of recruiting coordinator. QB development was a MAJOR issue under Frost. So, Helf addressed that issue with a bang. We also have a new DC with Hoke who is also an obsessive recruiter and attention to detail freak. Two massive changes. All this and we ended up with most of the recruits the coaches wanted. (sans really only Knott, Mayden, Kelly) We have the top LB class in the nation and a new band of QB's who are smart, athletic and ready to compete right away. In conclusion, if we trust the coaches ability to assess talent and we see a wholehearted change in our DF and QB development then I am over the moon excited. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results. Helf saw a trend and he addressed it. I love these moves.... for now. Yours truly-- Johnny Blue Skies.
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: All LOIs are in

Post by maxduck »

jimmy12 wrote:Everyone is all bent out of shape on the de-commits. Let's walk through these:

Theo Howard-- fast and falls a lot after the catch. Not a big loss considering the depth on the team. (If we kept howard, we would have likely not had room for Tristen Wallace. So, who would you rather have?)

Jared Mayden-- This one hurt because I loved his physicality. I did not like, however, how much of a drama queen he became.

Troy Warner- no opinion. He wanted to be with his brother.

Eddie McDoom-- was a back up plan that the staff did not love his tape. When he wavered, they jumped at the chance to get this spot back. (again so much depth at WR, does not hurt one bit)

Malepei- This one is interesting. We like his stars, BUT did you know Coach Campbell supposedly did not support his offer? Neither did I, but according to the misinformed Jhop this is the case. Chinander apparently begged to give him an offer. Wait, isn't coach Chins a LB coach? This doesn't make sense. With all the depth at this position and looking at the depth in 17's class. This one does not hurt at all. Not one bit.

Seth Green-- Our QB class is just flat out better than he appears to be so they honored the scholly as a TE. He doesn't want to be a TE.

Now, let's get to those that chose elsewhere:

Bundage-- We loved his tape and his ability to hit, but we were recruiting him at LB. How many could we afford to take? Not loss.

Caleb Kelly-- We all would have loved him. So, that's two players we would have liked. Mayden and Kelly.

Nigel Knott-- Another we would have liked. We all loved his flips and his athleticism, but he is small. Really small. Still though, we wanted him. That's 3.

Finally, Connor Murphy-- We loved his hair and his claim that Harbaugh loved his toughness.... His tape was ehhh and Hoke saw him on the Oline.... Well, we "lost" him to USC (only we stopped recruiting him 2 weeks before the end... Not a loss.

So, here we are. The sky has fallen, the world has ended. We have a new QB coach, who is rated one of the best in the business and is a heck of recruiting coordinator. QB development was a MAJOR issue under Frost. So, Helf addressed that issue with a bang. We also have a new DC with Hoke who is also an obsessive recruiter and attention to detail freak. Two massive changes. All this and we ended up with most of the recruits the coaches wanted. (sans really only Knott, Mayden, Kelly) We have the top LB class in the nation and a new band of QB's who are smart, athletic and ready to compete right away. In conclusion, if we trust the coaches ability to assess talent and we see a wholehearted change in our DF and QB development then I am over the moon excited. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results. Helf saw a trend and he addressed it. I love these moves.... for now. Yours truly-- Johnny Blue Skies.
Good post. I would add that we now have two coaches with deep ties to the Midwest and the recruiting advantages that brings. The Ducks have done well getting speed guys from Texas and the Southeast, gaining a pipeline to big OL and DL recruits should help a lot.
Post Reply