National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by ncduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
greenyellow wrote:Just looked at Alabama and they got both Knott and Mayden to along with 2 other 4* CBs. Sucks that Oregon couldn't sign at least one, even with all the struggles our CBs had this past season.
Bama lands some legit talent, as usual.. (Sigh)
We should keep in mind that star ratings on these recruiting site are influenced by number of page views. A former SEC Coach had the most clicks one year and was allowed to choose any commit to get an extra star. This comes second hand to me. The coach and my co-worker had this discussion over the Summer at a media day event.

I would suggest that we stop assigning recruiting success to bench marks that are at least in part influenced by website clicks. Do so at your own peril at least.
Look at Mayden and Knott's offer lists. I don't think page views give them offers from practically every team from every major conference.
I bring it up because of the glass half empty responses in regards to the guys we did get. If the sites are tossing around extra stars for illegitimate reasons, their analyses are polluted. Yes, those two guys left and they had a lot of offers. My point is that we got a lot of guys today that fit the needs of our team, that's why they got offers from our team.

Worrying about the lack of stars of the players we did get is foolish. I mean, if we had more clicks perhaps a few of our 3 star signed recruits would have 4 stars and a 4 star would have a 5th. Then nobody would be boo-hooing, but we didn't get the clicks so no bonus stars. Now everyone is disappointed. That is my point. People have attached their perception of a positive recruiting result on the faulty star system.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40737
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by UOducksTK1 »

ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
greenyellow wrote:Just looked at Alabama and they got both Knott and Mayden to along with 2 other 4* CBs. Sucks that Oregon couldn't sign at least one, even with all the struggles our CBs had this past season.
Bama lands some legit talent, as usual.. (Sigh)
We should keep in mind that star ratings on these recruiting site are influenced by number of page views. A former SEC Coach had the most clicks one year and was allowed to choose any commit to get an extra star. This comes second hand to me. The coach and my co-worker had this discussion over the Summer at a media day event.

I would suggest that we stop assigning recruiting success to bench marks that are at least in part influenced by website clicks. Do so at your own peril at least.
Look at Mayden and Knott's offer lists. I don't think page views give them offers from practically every team from every major conference.
I bring it up because of the glass half empty responses in regards to the guys we did get. If the sites are tossing around extra stars for illegitimate reasons, their analyses are polluted. Yes, those two guys left and they had a lot of offers. My point is that we got a lot of guys today that fit the needs of our team, that's why they got offers from our team.

Worrying about the lack of stars of the players we did get is foolish. I mean, if we had more clicks perhaps a few of our 3 star signed recruits would have 4 stars and a 4 star would have a 5th. Then nobody would be boo-hooing, but we didn't get the clicks so no bonus stars. Now everyone is disappointed. That is my point. People have attached their perception of a positive recruiting result on the faulty star system.
I agree to some extent on the stars, but it's still one of the few metrics for us to gauge a class for the most part. If someone had a ranking system that was based on the amount of BCS offers for each recruit, then I'd much rather see that personally.

To add to the bold point, I think the coaches are even more picky than most schools by going the step further and filtering out any kids that have attitudes or issues that would clash with the culture we have here.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by duckfan22 »

ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
greenyellow wrote:Just looked at Alabama and they got both Knott and Mayden to along with 2 other 4* CBs. Sucks that Oregon couldn't sign at least one, even with all the struggles our CBs had this past season.
Bama lands some legit talent, as usual.. (Sigh)
We should keep in mind that star ratings on these recruiting site are influenced by number of page views. A former SEC Coach had the most clicks one year and was allowed to choose any commit to get an extra star. This comes second hand to me. The coach and my co-worker had this discussion over the Summer at a media day event.

I would suggest that we stop assigning recruiting success to bench marks that are at least in part influenced by website clicks. Do so at your own peril at least.
Look at Mayden and Knott's offer lists. I don't think page views give them offers from practically every team from every major conference.
I bring it up because of the glass half empty responses in regards to the guys we did get. If the sites are tossing around extra stars for illegitimate reasons, their analyses are polluted. Yes, those two guys left and they had a lot of offers. My point is that we got a lot of guys today that fit the needs of our team, that's why they got offers from our team.

Worrying about the lack of stars of the players we did get is foolish. I mean, if we had more clicks perhaps a few of our 3 star signed recruits would have 4 stars and a 4 star would have a 5th. Then nobody would be boo-hooing, but we didn't get the clicks so no bonus stars. Now everyone is disappointed. That is my point. People have attached their perception of a positive recruiting result on the faulty star system.
Marcus Mariota was a 3 star. Only stated in high school his senior year. He red shirted hias first year here. He kinda worked out.
I dont get putting the knock on kids that signed with us as not being good enough. All ive read today is that this is a weak class.
These kids picked Oregon. I am happy that they did and will look forward to seeing them during their journey.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by ncduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
ncduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
greenyellow wrote:Just looked at Alabama and they got both Knott and Mayden to along with 2 other 4* CBs. Sucks that Oregon couldn't sign at least one, even with all the struggles our CBs had this past season.
Bama lands some legit talent, as usual.. (Sigh)
We should keep in mind that star ratings on these recruiting site are influenced by number of page views. A former SEC Coach had the most clicks one year and was allowed to choose any commit to get an extra star. This comes second hand to me. The coach and my co-worker had this discussion over the Summer at a media day event.

I would suggest that we stop assigning recruiting success to bench marks that are at least in part influenced by website clicks. Do so at your own peril at least.
Look at Mayden and Knott's offer lists. I don't think page views give them offers from practically every team from every major conference.
I bring it up because of the glass half empty responses in regards to the guys we did get. If the sites are tossing around extra stars for illegitimate reasons, their analyses are polluted. Yes, those two guys left and they had a lot of offers. My point is that we got a lot of guys today that fit the needs of our team, that's why they got offers from our team.

Worrying about the lack of stars of the players we did get is foolish. I mean, if we had more clicks perhaps a few of our 3 star signed recruits would have 4 stars and a 4 star would have a 5th. Then nobody would be boo-hooing, but we didn't get the clicks so no bonus stars. Now everyone is disappointed. That is my point. People have attached their perception of a positive recruiting result on the faulty star system.
I agree to some extent on the stars, but it's still one of the few metrics for us to gauge a class for the most part. If someone had a ranking system that was based on the amount of BCS offers for each recruit, then I'd much rather see that personally.

To add to the bold point, I think the coaches are even more picky than most schools by going the step further and filtering out any kids that have attitudes or issues that would clash with the culture we have here.
I like that idea for offers metric. The downside is that players that are unable to attend camps are missed by a lot of teams and therefore don't get offers. The guys with a ton of offers have usually worked hard to put themselves out there. If there were a way to mitigate for that, you could start another site.

I also like your point about how picky the coaches are. I'm a firm believer it's the reason we've seen so much success from guys who maybe don't get recruited as heavily.

Again, if we focus more on how many holes we've filled vs how many stars those guys have, we wouldn't see as many negative responses today. I think it's a great day for the future of the program.

There are so many positive things for the future of the program. We are free from recruiting restrictions. We have more coaching talent. Not only do we have more QB's on the roster, but we probably have upgraded the talent at the position if not just the competition. There should be enough talent to unseat Lockie as the go to backup. WE HAVE A NEW D! That new D will have a bunch of new LB's and at least one of them has to be better than what we've had. The secondary is going to be really good. While we have a lot of changes for this coming season, the conference will be loaded with teams that are rebuilding or have new QB's. The door is wide open. I love our chances!
woundedknees
All-American
Posts: 12826
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:06 pm

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by woundedknees »

One could suggest that the lack of space is at least partially related to Oregon's vetting process... When nearly 100% of commits qualify for admission, the odds are there may be less turnover.
Autzen Stadium... Where great teams go to die...Hard!

Image
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39387
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by greenyellow »

Helf did say they turn down some of "so-called 4 and 5*" guys because of certain issues, namely academic issues. He said they could have pushed for them and hoped they got in but they'd rather not worry about academic issues so moved to others who were sure bets.
Image
User avatar
MFRDuckFan
Senior
Posts: 4829
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:52 pm
Location: Medford

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by MFRDuckFan »

Interesting how Harbaugh pulls in the top recruit of this class & how lucky the kid's former coach works for Michigan. Harbaugh! Hmmmmm.....

http://www.app.com/story/sports/college ... /79728056/
User avatar
Bud Lee
All Pac-12
Posts: 5541
Joined: Wed Jun 29, 2011 7:03 am
Location: Da Boot

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by Bud Lee »

MFRDuckFan wrote:Interesting how Harbaugh pulls in the top recruit of this class & how lucky the kid's former coach works for Michigan. Harbaugh! Hmmmmm.....

http://www.app.com/story/sports/college ... /79728056/

Relationships between collages/coaches and the folks at the high school level plays a big part of recruiting. Down here we have been having a problem locking up Monroe (a talent rich city in LA) because one of the coaches at the big school there is one of Nick's guys.

This is one reason why we were excited to be Bebe on staff. Dude knows everyone here.
laxattack22
One Star Recruit
Posts: 82
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:37 am

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by laxattack22 »



Relationships?.... How about this:
http://www.sbnation.com/college-footbal ... -interview
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: National Signing Day = Wednesday February 3rd

Post by SuperDuck »

greenyellow wrote:Helf did say they turn down some of "so-called 4 and 5*" guys because of certain issues, namely academic issues. He said they could have pushed for them and hoped they got in but they'd rather not worry about academic issues so moved to others who were sure bets.
This^^^

I also seem to recall Helfrich saying something like "he guaranteed that some of those guys won't qualify academically."
John 3:36
Post Reply