Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by StevensTechU »

Here we are in the offseason, able to take a step back and ponder some big picture questions. One of mine is 'how do we assess Mark Helfrich." To me, the best way to evaluate a manager of any kind is to look at the decisions they've made, as that's the best indication of things to come. Below, I've highlighted what I view as Mark Helfrich's biggest decisions to date in roughly chronological order, and assigned a grade to each. I'd be happy to hear your own thoughts.


Offensive system: This is an underrated decision that Helfrich had to make, and it was almost the very first decision to be made. Helf's background is in pro-style offense, and he learned Chip's system after coming to UofO. Coaches, often with their enormous egos, tend to gravitate toward what they know. In this case, Mark determined the best system for the Ducks was the one they've used to make the program a championship-caliber team. I applaud his unselfish decision, and had an outside hire been made for head coach, they likely would've brought a new identity.
Grade: A

Culture: Perhaps the most difficult decision to assess as none of us are in the room, but an incredibly important decision nonetheless, is what culture Helfrich has chosen to. In my opinion, the right culture is one that breeds intensity, focus, respect, fun, responsible, teamwork, individualism but in such a way that it doesn't become greater than the team. In my best estimation, Mark has done a great job of creating a responsible culture where teamwork is important and players are enjoying themselves. There appears to be room for growth with intensity and even individualism in the sense that personalities really shine through (Arrion Springs is about the only guy I feel is comfortable showing his personality).
Grade: B

QB Coach/Offensive Coordinator: Any decision other than a current staffer was likely to lead to distrust and turmoil. Osborne, Campbell, and Greatwood all appeared and still do seem quite content in their roles as position coaches. Frost was really the only option.
Grade: Pass

WR Coach: With Scott Frost taking over QBs, Mark considered all options and ended up snagging the National WR Coach of the Year (FootballScoop.com) away from Duke. Whether it's been the on-field production of Josh Huff and Bralon Addison, or bringing in recruits like Dillon Mitchell, Alex Ofodile, and Kirk Merritt, it seems like Lubick has been a home run of a hire.
Grade: A

Defensive Coordinator: I think we all understand the motivation to promote from within, as there is value to continuity and rewarding staffers for their efforts. However, the combination of how bad the defense has gotten under Don Pellum combined with how successful one of the known alternatives (Todd Orlando, Houston) has been, with an "F" being complete turmoil, a grade of "D" is appropriate.
Grade: D

QB Coach: There is clearly a lack of evidence as this hire is only a few months in the books. However, David Yost appears to be as close to a home run hire as was possible. At Missouri, he recruited and trained 3 NFL-caliber quarterbacks, all who had individual style that shows Yost is adaptable. Personally, I'm greatly looking forward to seeing how Travis Jonsen, Terry Wilson, and Justin Herbert develop under his tutelage.
Grade: A-

Defensive Coordinator Pt. 2: There's a lot to be determined here, like the recent hire of the QB coach. When we review this in 1-2 years (I'm personally an advocate of at least 2), it could change, but the early indication is that bringing on Brady Hoke is a perfect fit for this staff. He'll bring an emphasis on recruiting, grow the intensity, and strengthen the brand by bringing in the credibility of a former major program head coach. The most significant drawbacks are Hoke's likelihood to move on if successful and his lack of direct DC experience.
Grade: B+
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by duckfan22 »

I believe Helfrich has done a pretty good job considering he was following the
god Chip Kelly. He showed good sense in seeing that the defense had fallen down
and couldnt get up.

Will the hire of Hoke be a winner we will see. I believe it will based on his past
history. Also what ive seen of him in interviews i think he is just what we need.
The Yost hire is the one i feel needs to be the homerun. In the ducks offense and as
much as the QB runs we MUST have a backup ready to step in. We all saw what happened
when Lockie came in. I believe there is talent at QB but they have to be ready.

It also comes down to if the players buy into these new hires. Can a totally different
personality come in at D cord and get the players respect. I think he will.

I give Helfrich a b+ so far.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3316
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Regarding Defensive Co-coordinator part II, Helfrich took a big gamble going to a 4-3. Even though we are sure to run multiple fronts, doing it from a 4-3 base with 4-3 personnel is something most every other PAC-12 team has tried, failed and dumped. Even the legendary Monty Kiffen with a huge talent advantage got steam rolled out of the conference. Art Kaufman another 4-3 super star before coming to the conference has been rocked at Cal. Wittingham has been the lone exception but even his DC when he moved to OSU immediately went to a 3-4 base.

This is not to say it can't succeed only that it is a gamble, because so many others with better resumes have not been able to pull it off. The good thing is he is following a really bad year which would be hard not to improve upon. Except Cal went from a good, not great, 3-4 to a historically bad 4-3 as the last team to try this. Since the PAC-12 was formed every single champion has run a 3-4.

Because of this I question the early B+ grade. If it works it deserves an A+ for being able to see something against the trend and make something work that the majority of other teams wanted to do but couldn't. If it fails it deserves an "F" as in wtF, weren't you paying attention? So with Hoke's inexperience and going against recent conference results how can this not be considered a gamble, like hiring Pellum. Does Oregon need to take such risks? If not, that is too high a preseason grade for this decision in my book.
rockthief
Senior
Posts: 4877
Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
Location: Stand By Me

Re: Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by rockthief »

Pellum's defense is a D minus. I cannot give it anything higher. It was a debacle of worst kind.
Being a coach is about as high pressure a job as I can imagine. They are well paid for it, but damn just think of the hours they put in and all the people wanting a coach's time.

Go Ducks!
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by UOducksTK1 »

I am curious who pushed the hiring of DP the most. If it was indeed Helfrich's top choice, or someone higher up.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Helfrich's Biggest Decisions

Post by Duck07 »

GrandpaDuck wrote:Regarding Defensive Co-coordinator part II, Helfrich took a big gamble going to a 4-3. Even though we are sure to run multiple fronts, doing it from a 4-3 base with 4-3 personnel is something most every other PAC-12 team has tried, failed and dumped. Even the legendary Monty Kiffen with a huge talent advantage got steam rolled out of the conference. Art Kaufman another 4-3 super star before coming to the conference has been rocked at Cal. Wittingham has been the lone exception but even his DC when he moved to OSU immediately went to a 3-4 base.

This is not to say it can't succeed only that it is a gamble, because so many others with better resumes have not been able to pull it off. The good thing is he is following a really bad year which would be hard not to improve upon. Except Cal went from a good, not great, 3-4 to a historically bad 4-3 as the last team to try this. Since the PAC-12 was formed every single champion has run a 3-4.

Because of this I question the early B+ grade. If it works it deserves an A+ for being able to see something against the trend and make something work that the majority of other teams wanted to do but couldn't. If it fails it deserves an "F" as in wtF, weren't you paying attention? So with Hoke's inexperience and going against recent conference results how can this not be considered a gamble, like hiring Pellum. Does Oregon need to take such risks? If not, that is too high a preseason grade for this decision in my book.
The base defense doesn't even matter when the majority of teams are playing in sub packages. So a 43 or 34 becomes largely irrelevant when you constantly keep a nickel or dime back on the field all the time. Just another glaring issue from Pellum was the LACK of any real sub packages. I don't buy the every champion runs a 34 premise because it's been Stanford and Oregon, not a different team each year to show off conference parity for example. You could look at Oregon and Stanford and conclude that the only way to win the conference is with a great running game, too.
Image
Post Reply