Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40737
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

I read somewhere that we've never had more than 3 kids wrapping up May, so to me this is the norm for Oregon.

Also, the coaches are throwing out a lot more offers than usual, so I think they are going beyond what we are accustomed to so far. And that also explains why we are striking out on more guys. If you offer 200 vs 75, you will lose more than you'll win. :)

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
lmduck

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by lmduck »

StevensTechU wrote:Perhaps we're just viewing the same situation with two different pairs of eyes. In order for one person to sell a stock, another has to buy it. What part of what I've said do you take odds with?

*edit: To add to my point, I think it's likely that we hear similar-ish things and have a different reaction. When I hear someone explain what each person in a recruiting department (or any organization) does, I think about how qualified they are to handle each function, do they have more than they can handle, which functions are likely to fall through the cracks, and which functions overlap with the other people in the organization. Then, when taken as a whole, I ponder what duties appear to be missing and which are being replicated more than they need to be. I'm also a stickler for good marketing.

It's entirely possible you look at the organization the same way and have the same information available to you and concluded upon something differently (like they're doing a fantastic job). But my money would be on we look at it two different ways, ask different questions, and different degrees of critical thought.
You make valid points and I agree in some ways. Sales and marketing are my livelihood now so I understand that. But let's be real, the sales and marketing aspect of recruiting is much different than say marketing and selling clothing as an example.

What I can tell you is I worked in Compliance at the AD for a few years. I do have some insights and I can tell you for fact there is some clear structure around recruiting. I will be honest and tell you I can't and won't elaborate on some things as that would be extremely unprofessional on my part but there is a very clear structure in place partly brought on by the aftermath of the Lyles episode. I will also tell you that Helfrich and team are not the bumbling idiots some here make them out to be.

I think the panic meter for some here is in the red zone because it's the off season and we don't have much else to discuss.

BTW- I enjoy your posts and always appreciate a spirited debate. Having been on the inside so to speak does provide some perspective. I will tell you (I'm sure it's no secret) recruiting is real tough and the stuff that goes on long before an offer even goes out would likely be very eye opening to the general public.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by StevensTechU »

lmduck wrote: You make valid points...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
To your whole post -- absolutely. And I would hope that anybody reading these takes a step back and realizes there's not a tone of 'FIRE EVERYBODY' but instead this cold, emotionless economist/consultant voice that I was born with (haha). I could go on writing a business review of the department, but suffice it to say (for now) that the biggest thing ailing the recruiting department is that there aren't enough full-time employees. Those guys work exceptionally hard, get paid peanuts, and need more help (by social media professionals, graphic designers, marketing professionals, and holding other skillsets where football is an afterthought).
gofightingducks
All Pac-12
Posts: 5533
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by gofightingducks »

I don't think the coaches are doing anything wrong. There are many factors, the first one is the state of Oregon doesn't produce a lot of talent so the coaches have to go to other school's backyards to recruit and that is always difficult. There are two other things that I think are overlooked or not talked about much, competition, some kids want to play right away and look more closely at teams with less competition. The big one though I believe is Helf and this staff are honest with the kids and are very thorough with their evaluations and often offer later than other schools, a lot of programs tell the kids what they want to hear. Chip was not so much this way but Helf is all about character guys who qualify academically, look at the run the team has had with guys qualifying and without any major incidents. I believe the whole connecting with the coaches because of social media is overblown. If a kid makes a decision based on that they are not making the most intelligent decision. Do you want a coach that can chat it up with you on Twitter or one that can coach you up and ready you for the next level?
lmduck

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by lmduck »

gofightingducks wrote:I don't think the coaches are doing anything wrong. There are many factors, the first one is the state of Oregon doesn't produce a lot of talent so the coaches have to go to other school's backyards to recruit and that is always difficult. There are two other things that I think are overlooked or not talked about much, competition, some kids want to play right away and look more closely at teams with less competition. The big one though I believe is Helf and this staff are honest with the kids and are very thorough with their evaluations and often offer later than other schools, a lot of programs tell the kids what they want to hear. Chip was not so much this way but Helf is all about character guys who qualify academically, look at the run the team has had with guys qualifying and without any major incidents. I believe the whole connecting with the coaches because of social media is overblown. If a kid makes a decision based on that they are not making the most intelligent decision. Do you want a coach that can chat it up with you on Twitter or one that can coach you up and ready you for the next level?
Amen- well said. the exact points I have tried to make and you have done such a better job ;) . If anyone thinks recruiting is about social media and playing xbox, well it's not.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8822
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

gofightingducks wrote:I don't think the coaches are doing anything wrong. There are many factors, the first one is the state of Oregon doesn't produce a lot of talent so the coaches have to go to other school's backyards to recruit and that is always difficult. There are two other things that I think are overlooked or not talked about much, competition, some kids want to play right away and look more closely at teams with less competition. The big one though I believe is Helf and this staff are honest with the kids and are very thorough with their evaluations and often offer later than other schools, a lot of programs tell the kids what they want to hear. Chip was not so much this way but Helf is all about character guys who qualify academically, look at the run the team has had with guys qualifying and without any major incidents. I believe the whole connecting with the coaches because of social media is overblown. If a kid makes a decision based on that they are not making the most intelligent decision. Do you want a coach that can chat it up with you on Twitter or one that can coach you up and ready you for the next level?
That was started and implemented entirely by Chip.
Image
User avatar
bigsugarduck
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1209
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:52 pm

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by bigsugarduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:I read somewhere that we've never had more than 3 kids wrapping up May, so to me this is the norm for Oregon.

Also, the coaches are throwing out a lot more offers than usual, so I think they are going beyond what we are accustomed to so far. and that also explains why we are striking out on more guys. If you offer 200 vs 75, you will lose more than you'll win. :)
#1 most reasonable post of the thread so far!
Stewart Mandel-"From a purely aesthetic standpoint, I much prefer to watch a good spread-rushing offense over a traditional Power-I offense, and Oregon's has been the most fun by far for the past several years. It's fast, its precise, and when Chip Kelly has the right quarterback (Dixon, Masoli) at the helm, the possibility of someone ripping off a 60-yard run exists on nearly every play."
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40737
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

bigsugarduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:I read somewhere that we've never had more than 3 kids wrapping up May, so to me this is the norm for Oregon.

Also, the coaches are throwing out a lot more offers than usual, so I think they are going beyond what we are accustomed to so far. and that also explains why we are striking out on more guys. If you offer 200 vs 75, you will lose more than you'll win. :)
#1 most reasonable post of the thread so far!
+1!

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by StevensTechU »

bigsugarduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:I read somewhere that we've never had more than 3 kids wrapping up May, so to me this is the norm for Oregon.

Also, the coaches are throwing out a lot more offers than usual, so I think they are going beyond what we are accustomed to so far. and that also explains why we are striking out on more guys. If you offer 200 vs 75, you will lose more than you'll win. :)
#1 most reasonable post of the thread so far!
Assessing a situation involves comparing to yourself, as you've done, but also comparing to your peers. I'll keep railing on this until I'm blue in the face -- Oregon should benchmark itself to the performance of Notre Dame, Nebraska, Michigan, Oklahoma and Washington. All of those schools have to cross state lines to get the majority of their recruits, and each has its individual selling points, so it comes down to who is selling its capabilities the best. Currently, Oregon is dead last of those 6.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by ncduck »

I would love for Oregon to be on par with the big boys when it comes to player talent acquisition. It would mean the UO would have won a few national titles, a historically storied program, be geographically located in a talent rich area, and be in the headlines positively even when things aren't perfect. The UO is simply not part of the club yet. I want it, but we aren't there yet.

All of that said, I believe it is beyond fair to expect a higher level of recruiting success. It should be demanded. If the current plan isn't working, adjust the plan and win.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40737
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

StevensTechU wrote:
bigsugarduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:I read somewhere that we've never had more than 3 kids wrapping up May, so to me this is the norm for Oregon.

Also, the coaches are throwing out a lot more offers than usual, so I think they are going beyond what we are accustomed to so far. and that also explains why we are striking out on more guys. If you offer 200 vs 75, you will lose more than you'll win. :)
#1 most reasonable post of the thread so far!
Assessing a situation involves comparing to yourself, as you've done, but also comparing to your peers. I'll keep railing on this until I'm blue in the face -- Oregon should benchmark itself to the performance of Notre Dame, Nebraska, Michigan, Oklahoma and Washington. All of those schools have to cross state lines to get the majority of their recruits, and each has its individual selling points, so it comes down to who is selling its capabilities the best. Currently, Oregon is dead last of those 6.
So you want Urban Meyer as our coach. Oregon is already battling against a lack of history and very poor location / lack of proximity. In addition, for Oregon to recruit to its culture makes recruiting even more selective. We could bring down our morals, recruiting anyone and everyone, and sure Oregon could probably have a top 10 recruiting class more often than not, but I don't think that will equal to anymore success than we've had the last 5 years.

Like I said in the other post, the fact we are more willing to throw out more offers this early is already a sign that the coaches want to step it up in recruiting.

I like how we operate for the most part.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
lmduck

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by lmduck »

Excellent post TK1.

Recruiting and operating like Baylor did gets you in the end. And don't try to say Baylor is an extreme example because it is not.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by StevensTechU »

ncduck wrote:I would love for Oregon to be on par with the big boys when it comes to player talent acquisition. It would mean the UO would have won a few national titles, a historically storied program, be geographically located in a talent rich area, and be in the headlines positively even when things aren't perfect. The UO is simply not part of the club yet. I want it, but we aren't there yet.

All of that said, I believe it is beyond fair to expect a higher level of recruiting success. It should be demanded. If the current plan isn't working, adjust the plan and win.
+1

Expecting Oregon to out-recruit USC, Texas, and Ohio State (consistently, at least) is ludicrous. But expecting them to do a little better every year isn't.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by StevensTechU »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
So you want Urban Meyer as our coach. Oregon is already battling against a lack of history and very poor location / lack of proximity. In addition, for Oregon to recruit to its culture makes recruiting even more selective. We could bring down our morals, recruiting anyone and everyone, and sure Oregon could probably have a top 10 recruiting class more often than not, but I don't think that will equal to anymore success than we've had the last 5 years.

Like I said in the other post, the fact we are more willing to throw out more offers this early is already a sign that the coaches want to step it up in recruiting.

I like how we operate for the most part.
Where do you get that I think Oregon should throw away morals? I like your posts, TK1, but this was such a reach that I'm not sure it's worth a thoughtful response. I'm not a particular fan of someone putting words in my mouth that aren't even remotely close to anything I've said.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15435
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Oregon never has been that good in recruiting, but this last recruiting class was quite disappointing. But honestly, after seeing Lockie, Mahalak, and that defense last season, what highly ranked profile would want to come to Oregon? Helf really screwed up promoting DP, and while he made the right move demoting him back to LB coach, recruiting difficulties are an after-effect of that. Oregon doesn't need to win the national championship next year, but if they field a good defense, have at least a 10 win season, beat the teams they should (WSU), and compete in the Pac-12, then I imagine recruiting will pick up. Until then, I'm not worried about the coaches missing the mark with recruiting, but if they have a good season and continue to lose out on a few 4 or 5 star recruits next year in similar fashion, then yeah, there might be a problem. So far the only big recruiting failure I have seen was losing Vavae Malepeai to USC. Mariota gifted the coaches a pipeline and it took them a year to lose it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
Post Reply