As pointed out he took a visit to SC (yes unofficial) but did not take one to UO.
Apparently interest was not mutual. Could things change, sure.
Your post came across like you were not happy with the fact that Oregon did not go hard after him because he is a disciple of MM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
to me, the MM thing is just icing on the cake. We should have gone after him because he is a stud. Bama doesn't offer scrubs - especially when they are in Hawaii!
Bama hasn't exactly hit home runs with their QB's.
As pointed out he took a visit to SC (yes unofficial) but did not take one to UO.
Apparently interest was not mutual. Could things change, sure.
Your post came across like you were not happy with the fact that Oregon did not go hard after him because he is a disciple of MM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
to me, the MM thing is just icing on the cake. We should have gone after him because he is a stud. Bama doesn't offer scrubs - especially when they are in Hawaii!
Bama hasn't exactly hit home runs with their QB's.
Thats besides my point
It's exactly your point...
ok big shot. my point is that Bama doest make offers to recruits who aren't studs on paper. So it is besides my point if they pan out or not. If Bama made the offer then the kid must look to be pretty damn good before he steps on campus - the fact that they haven't developed like everyone expected them to has nothing to do with what I'm saying. Thanks dude
I think there's room for both of you to be right. A Bama offer is prestigious for many reasons. They get pretty much whoever they want.
At the same time, based on the lack of topline QB's coming out of the program, there is a ton of room for folks to conclude that you don't judge future QB quality play based on a Bama offer.
On top of that, the ideal Bama QB is practically a different species when compared to the ideal Oregon QB. It is completely fair and legit that our coaches perhaps have seen his tape and didn't feel he was the best fit for what is needed. There's nothing wrong with that. In fact, they actually are aware of exactly what is asked of a potential QB in the system since they're the ones asking.
If Tua wanted desperately to play at Oregon, and the interest was mutual, I'm sure the unofficial would have happened. Since that visit never occurred, is it not fair to suggest there is not mutual interest for one reason or another?
It could be the coaches at Oregon are very interested, but Tua may be more interested in other schools. Perhaps he lost interest when Frost left. We don't know.
ncduck wrote:I think there's room for both of you to be right. A Bama offer is prestigious for many reasons. They get pretty much whoever they want.
At the same time, based on the lack of topline QB's coming out of the program, there is a ton of room for folks to conclude that you don't judge future QB quality play based on a Bama offer.
On top of that, the ideal Bama QB is practically a different species when compared to the ideal Oregon QB. It is completely fair and legit that our coaches perhaps have seen his tape and didn't feel he was the best fit for what is needed. There's nothing wrong with that. In fact, they actually are aware of exactly what is asked of a potential QB in the system since they're the ones asking.
If Tua wanted desperately to play at Oregon, and the interest was mutual, I'm sure the unofficial would have happened. Since that visit never occurred, is it not fair to suggest there is not mutual interest for one reason or another?
It could be the coaches at Oregon are very interested, but Tua may be more interested in other schools. Perhaps he lost interest when Frost left. We don't know.
As pointed out he took a visit to SC (yes unofficial) but did not take one to UO.
Apparently interest was not mutual. Could things change, sure.
Your post came across like you were not happy with the fact that Oregon did not go hard after him because he is a disciple of MM.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
to me, the MM thing is just icing on the cake. We should have gone after him because he is a stud. Bama doesn't offer scrubs - especially when they are in Hawaii!
Bama hasn't exactly hit home runs with their QB's.
Thats besides my point
It's exactly your point...
ok big shot. my point is that Bama doest make offers to recruits who aren't studs on paper. So it is besides my point if they pan out or not. If Bama made the offer then the kid must look to be pretty damn good before he steps on campus - the fact that they haven't developed like everyone expected them to has nothing to do with what I'm saying. Thanks dude
I kinda like being called big shot.
If you say a Bama offer is a good indicator that we should offer a kid, it is totally relevant that the guys they have offered haven't panned out.
And don't get so sensitive man, it's an online forum, debate is to be expected.
Could it be that his interest in USC and Bama had something to do with a pro style offense vs our up tempo spread? I mean, QB'S never think about that stuff...
mdm0302 wrote:
to me, the MM thing is just icing on the cake. We should have gone after him because he is a stud. Bama doesn't offer scrubs - especially when they are in Hawaii!
Bama hasn't exactly hit home runs with their QB's.
Thats besides my point
It's exactly your point...
ok big shot. my point is that Bama doest make offers to recruits who aren't studs on paper. So it is besides my point if they pan out or not. If Bama made the offer then the kid must look to be pretty damn good before he steps on campus - the fact that they haven't developed like everyone expected them to has nothing to do with what I'm saying. Thanks dude
I kinda like being called big shot.
If you say a Bama offer is a good indicator that we should offer a kid, it is totally relevant that the guys they have offered haven't panned out.
And don't get so sensitive man, it's an online forum, debate is to be expected.
i just saw my brain rolling my eyes so hard. of course i understand the dynamics of an online forum... and there is a difference between debating and insinuating someone else point like you know it better than they do.
Back to the topic. Like NC duck said, Bama can pretty much choose any recruit they want, so i have a hard time thinking the the U of O coaches found a red flag that Bama didn't find or was willing to look over. And I'm not going to put UO judgement over Bama judgment when we have had multiple 4 stars busts at QB as well (but that is irrelevant because of my next point). Lastly, developing a QB is a huge part of success when the kid gets on campus and this debate is centered around the potential of the kid now, before he is in school. This has nothing do with them panning out or not, this is about the chance of success now, as a recruit - if Bama can basically choose who they want and they want him, what in the hell do the U of O coaches see or not see?
Duck07 wrote:Could it be that his interest in USC and Bama had something to do with a pro style offense vs our up tempo spread? I mean, QB'S never think about that stuff...
could be true. but with his play style i don't see it. Especially with him being a "disciple" of MM who had so much success at the U of O, was drafted #2, and then had a great rookie year. Also, i didn't know he had an SC offer? that would make me questions the coaches judgment even more.
It could be that he believes his stature (short) plus going to a school with a spread offense will give him no shot at being drafted where as playing in a pro style offense could make up for his lack of height.
Or there are better QBs out there. The more I read about Tua, the more I am pleased with this decision to hold off. He has a wonky delivery and less than ideal size. His feet aren't that great either. Why would the Ducks offer just because he is a "disciple" of Marcus? By the way, calling him a disciple is really odd. What does that even mean? He knew him? He idolized him? He worked out with him? give me a break.
Duck07 wrote:Could it be that his interest in USC and Bama had something to do with a pro style offense vs our up tempo spread? I mean, QB'S never think about that stuff...
could be true. but with his play style i don't see it. Especially with him being a "disciple" of MM who had so much success at the U of O, was drafted #2, and then had a great rookie year. Also, i didn't know he had an SC offer? that would make me questions the coaches judgment even more.
It could be that he believes his stature (short) plus going to a school with a spread offense will give him no shot at being drafted where as playing in a pro style offense could make up for his lack of height.
Bruce Lee is a disciple of Ip Man, Tua is not a disciple of Mariota but Cal Lee his head coach, who I don't even think was the same coach that Marcus had.
jimmy12 wrote:Or there are better QBs out there. The more I read about Tua, the more I am pleased with this decision to hold off. He has a wonky delivery and less than ideal size. His feet aren't that great either. Why would the Ducks offer just because he is a "disciple" of Marcus? By the way, calling him a disciple is really odd. What does that even mean? He knew him? He idolized him? He worked out with him? give me a break.
whatever you wanna call him. just basing it off of what polyduck said. read the post.