Ok, I like what you did in picking peer schools to compare with rather than compare to USC, LSU, FSU Texas. Even that though is a challenge, I would drop Notre Dame for say a Wisconsin, Oklahoma is too close to the Texas recruiting hot bed to be a good comparable so swap them out with say a Missouri. Can't compare Oregon to the blatant bag-man schools like Clemson, Ole Miss, Auburn and Alabama. Its tough picking comparable peers.StevensTechU wrote:
Assessing a situation involves comparing to yourself, as you've done, but also comparing to your peers. I'll keep railing on this until I'm blue in the face -- Oregon should benchmark itself to the performance of Notre Dame, Nebraska, Michigan, Oklahoma and Washington. All of those schools have to cross state lines to get the majority of their recruits, and each has its individual selling points, so it comes down to who is selling its capabilities the best. Currently, Oregon is dead last of those 6.
Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
-
rentdodger1
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2011 8:16 pm
- Location: Paradise Valley, Az.
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
You can include in those "bag man schools" a few of the fine institutions that you name in your 1st sentence. Always have and will be. That is one of the main reasons Oregon doesn't reel in the recruits the message board recruiting experts expect. Stanford doesn't play that game either, they don't have to. Oregon has had many of these elite guys show up with their paws out and being told don't expect the cheese you will get in other areas of the country or even other schools in this conference. The players and the handlers don't want to hear that. That is the biggest disadvantage Oregon fights, not some BS that they don't text or social message their recruits enough.GrandpaDuck wrote:Ok, I like what you did in picking peer schools to compare with rather than compare to USC, LSU, FSU Texas. Even that though is a challenge, I would drop Notre Dame for say a Wisconsin, Oklahoma is too close to the Texas recruiting hot bed to be a good comparable so swap them out with say a Missouri. Can't compare Oregon to the blatant bag-man schools like Clemson, Ole Miss, Auburn and Alabama. Its tough picking comparable peers.StevensTechU wrote:
Assessing a situation involves comparing to yourself, as you've done, but also comparing to your peers. I'll keep railing on this until I'm blue in the face -- Oregon should benchmark itself to the performance of Notre Dame, Nebraska, Michigan, Oklahoma and Washington. All of those schools have to cross state lines to get the majority of their recruits, and each has its individual selling points, so it comes down to who is selling its capabilities the best. Currently, Oregon is dead last of those 6.
I did mention a couple of months ago that one of the problems Oregon faces is that young rainmaker is missing from the Oregon staff and that will be addressed in the next year. Give Helfrich credit, he is trying to play by the rules that are dealt and dictated to him. Has he made mistakes? Yes, Pellum was a big mistake but knew he had to pull the trigger now and improve that side of the ball. He is not Chip Kelly but he is not near as stubborn as Bellotti to make a change.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40738
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Fair enough. I guess I don't see an ideal solution, and I think we operate pretty efficiently given our situation and limitations. I guess I'm just curious then, what's your ideal solution?StevensTechU wrote:Where do you get that I think Oregon should throw away morals? I like your posts, TK1, but this was such a reach that I'm not sure it's worth a thoughtful response. I'm not a particular fan of someone putting words in my mouth that aren't even remotely close to anything I've said.UOducksTK1 wrote:
So you want Urban Meyer as our coach. Oregon is already battling against a lack of history and very poor location / lack of proximity. In addition, for Oregon to recruit to its culture makes recruiting even more selective. We could bring down our morals, recruiting anyone and everyone, and sure Oregon could probably have a top 10 recruiting class more often than not, but I don't think that will equal to anymore success than we've had the last 5 years.
Like I said in the other post, the fact we are more willing to throw out more offers this early is already a sign that the coaches want to step it up in recruiting.
I like how we operate for the most part.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I wish had a easy answer for Oregon and the beloved ducks we all enjoy. I understand that the school is in an area that has a lot of rain and don't see girls in bikinis year round... I also get that some kids might not think enough to do... I get all of that... but.. Oregon is one of the top 5 or 10 schools in wins.. over the last decade or so.... It has more wins... than Texas.. has more wins than USC... has more wins than Florida... has more wins than Michigan... and Ohio State... and several other schools... yet continue to lose out on players... clearly the last decade or so does not matter to lot of the kids.. We have a lot going for Oregon.. and have been sending good players to the NFL.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
La Affair de Lyles neutered the mentality of the program. Mullens is part of this issue here. Oregon used to be cutting edge in everything, now we don't even do that with our jerseys anymore. Others have caught up and Oregon is in no better place recruiting wise than it was a decade ago. Some of the excuses y'all give are the problem. Weather - so you obviously don't have any plans to play in the nfl, young recruit. Look at who has won the super bowls recently, it's not the Dolphins or Chargers but the teams that play in crap weather. Oregon does a terrible job selling itself against others and this notion that because we typically don't fill out our classes early fails the litmus when those other schools are filling out their classes faster and faster. Same is true of any other issue a recruit has. You turn it back on them and make them think about what it is they are truly after. Are you here for an education and to kick ass at football or are you here to play tiddly winks with your buddies?
I wonder how many of the coaches would punch back if you punched them in the face? I'm guessing not as many as some of you might think.
I wonder how many of the coaches would punch back if you punched them in the face? I'm guessing not as many as some of you might think.

-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I think Duck07 is largely right. I will say that yes Oregon pushed the issue of the uniforms and others have caught up with Oregon... I am not sure how much more the ducks or anyone for that matter can be more bold or cutting edge.. I think can only go so far with the uniforms. He is absolutely right about kids or whoever using the weather as an excuse. I have always felt the pacific northwest the most beautiful part of the usa. I might be biased since grew up there though. I think the coaches though are just as he said and while might get hit right in the mouth they would not fight back.. would just move on to next person... even if less talented and result in less wins. This has been the case for awhile with Oregon. There were lot of years Oregon would settle for trying to find diamonds in the rough. That is ok for couple players but.. the bar should be set high... instead of settling,, pushing for the better recruits.. Not all kids will pan out for sure.. but...is a fact... the better talent you put on the field... the more likely are to win. Alabama has been near the top in recruiting or at the top... and they keep winning championships... even with summer workouts being in a heat index of 100 plus degrees.. We might not be Alabama but we are in the top 10 in wins in last decade... Need to push for better talent... strive to be in top 10 in recruiting instead of just settling.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8822
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
How much of it is a larger problem of apathetic coaches who know they can't/won't be fired no matter how badly they perform at their jobs? Continuity is a great thing but I worry that what has set in is a complacency where a bunch of older, tenured coaches have put things cruise control. That is the death knell of a program and why keeping Pellum around bothered me so much. It is human nature to stop pushing yourself once you feel that you are secure.
We were on the cutting edge for so many years because it was absolutely necessary and our only chance of survival in big boy college football land. Now we're on top and have become fat, lazy, and complacent.
We were on the cutting edge for so many years because it was absolutely necessary and our only chance of survival in big boy college football land. Now we're on top and have become fat, lazy, and complacent.

-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Are you making a broad assumption based on 1 coach? That isn't really fair. The Ducks upgraded at QB coach and hopefully at O-Coordinator (verdict still out obviously). They definitely upgraded at D coordinator (but by how much only time will tell). Sure Pellum has a job, but how big of an exposure point is it having him coach the LBs? I would say very little. Please stop this sky is falling BS. It is depressing for all who wasted time reading.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40738
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Good reminder how we've done more with less pretty consistently over the last decade.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I wish had a easy answer for Oregon and the beloved ducks we all enjoy. I understand that the school is in an area that has a lot of rain and don't see girls in bikinis year round... I also get that some kids might not think enough to do... I get all of that... but.. Oregon is one of the top 5 or 10 schools in wins.. over the last decade or so.... It has more wins... than Texas.. has more wins than USC... has more wins than Florida... has more wins than Michigan... and Ohio State... and several other schools... yet continue to lose out on players... clearly the last decade or so does not matter to lot of the kids.. We have a lot going for Oregon.. and have been sending good players to the NFL.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
IIRC, the 2005 team had more Pro Ducks on it than any other Duck team has. It took one of the historically greatest college football teams to give them their only loss with a healthy QB. Both of those losses were later vacated by SC and OU, too.UOducksTK1 wrote:Good reminder how we've done more with less pretty consistently over the last decade.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I wish had a easy answer for Oregon and the beloved ducks we all enjoy. I understand that the school is in an area that has a lot of rain and don't see girls in bikinis year round... I also get that some kids might not think enough to do... I get all of that... but.. Oregon is one of the top 5 or 10 schools in wins.. over the last decade or so.... It has more wins... than Texas.. has more wins than USC... has more wins than Florida... has more wins than Michigan... and Ohio State... and several other schools... yet continue to lose out on players... clearly the last decade or so does not matter to lot of the kids.. We have a lot going for Oregon.. and have been sending good players to the NFL.

-
pdxduck2013
- Freshman
- Posts: 1431
- Joined: Sun Jul 28, 2013 5:20 pm
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I don't think the coaches are necessarily doing anything wrong here. This team was built upon "the Oregon Way" and finding guys who fit the program. I don't really think it's a bad thing, but it does mean that our recruiting classes are going to be different than the other elite programs (as has been the case over this entire run). We'll still pull some highly rated recruits as we always have, but I don't think we're ever going to have loaded recruiting classes like the USC, Bama, Ohio State's of the world.
I think it's really a matter of fans setting unrealistic comparisons against other teams. Among the teams who have been very good over the past decade, Oregon really is unique in that it's a program in a state without a deep talent pool of players (look at the talent coming out of California, Texas, Florida, and Ohio), and it's a school that isn't located in a large metro area (Oregon, OSU, and WSU have a disadvantage compared to the rest of the conference in this regard). I remember what it was like being an 18 year old kid and I think the appeal of big city life (or being very close to one) or warm weather with very attractive 18 year old girls is something that is understated. Many of us think about things related to recruiting as adults rather than through the lens of a recruit. To us, getting a job upon graduation is likely something that's pretty important if we were looking at a school but for the average 18 year old kid it isn't. On top of that, the kids focused on that who are wanting to play Pac 12 football would likely choose a school like Stanford, Cal, or UCLA if that was a top priority.
Ultimately, I think the coaching staff has proven their worth with building this program and with the types of players they're bringing in year over year. We can cherry pick areas of weakness (LB's last year, no depth at QB etc) but the end result is that the team has still played at an elite level regardless. I guess ultimately, the way I feel is that we as fans need to let Oregon be Oregon, without trying to turn the team into something else. We got here with the "Oregon Way" and we'll either sink or swim with the "Oregon Way."
I think it's really a matter of fans setting unrealistic comparisons against other teams. Among the teams who have been very good over the past decade, Oregon really is unique in that it's a program in a state without a deep talent pool of players (look at the talent coming out of California, Texas, Florida, and Ohio), and it's a school that isn't located in a large metro area (Oregon, OSU, and WSU have a disadvantage compared to the rest of the conference in this regard). I remember what it was like being an 18 year old kid and I think the appeal of big city life (or being very close to one) or warm weather with very attractive 18 year old girls is something that is understated. Many of us think about things related to recruiting as adults rather than through the lens of a recruit. To us, getting a job upon graduation is likely something that's pretty important if we were looking at a school but for the average 18 year old kid it isn't. On top of that, the kids focused on that who are wanting to play Pac 12 football would likely choose a school like Stanford, Cal, or UCLA if that was a top priority.
Ultimately, I think the coaching staff has proven their worth with building this program and with the types of players they're bringing in year over year. We can cherry pick areas of weakness (LB's last year, no depth at QB etc) but the end result is that the team has still played at an elite level regardless. I guess ultimately, the way I feel is that we as fans need to let Oregon be Oregon, without trying to turn the team into something else. We got here with the "Oregon Way" and we'll either sink or swim with the "Oregon Way."
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Talking to a couple guys as the opening, they told me Chins litterly recruited half our class the last two years. They blame his loss, for UO recruiting issues so far this year.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Thank god for days off, eh?
Re: pdxduck2013- Oregon wasn't built on the "Oregon Way" as if that's a single, static thing. Oregon was built on continuously doing something a little bit different than their peers. In the last 20 years, at different points that has meant taking players with checkered pasts, JUCO players, using Nike as a recruiting tool, using jerseys as a recruiting tool, putting up a billboard in Times Square, doing comprehensive background checks, limiting scholarship offers, telling recruits 'we'll win with you and we'll win without you,' pitching the Jaqua/student support system, and various combinations of those things. But, respectfully, "the Oregon Way" is not really a thing, because it's been fluid.
Re: buckmarkduck- it very much appears that Chins was brought on to take over some of the recruiting for other guys who simply don't have the passion nor ability to log the miles like they perhaps used to (Aiken, Neal, Pellum). I'm guessing Helf didn't suspect that a guy he was hiring with minimal experience would be getting a DC offer within 2-3 years. I'm not defending Helf, nor am I throwing him under the bus, just speaking to an understanding of how it happened. I do, actually, think Aiken is a liability on the recruiting trail. But what's tough about that is he's arguably the best DL coach in the Pac-12. A Hoke/Aiken combo could be lethal, or it could be horrible; only time will tell.
Re: pdxduck2013- Oregon wasn't built on the "Oregon Way" as if that's a single, static thing. Oregon was built on continuously doing something a little bit different than their peers. In the last 20 years, at different points that has meant taking players with checkered pasts, JUCO players, using Nike as a recruiting tool, using jerseys as a recruiting tool, putting up a billboard in Times Square, doing comprehensive background checks, limiting scholarship offers, telling recruits 'we'll win with you and we'll win without you,' pitching the Jaqua/student support system, and various combinations of those things. But, respectfully, "the Oregon Way" is not really a thing, because it's been fluid.
Re: buckmarkduck- it very much appears that Chins was brought on to take over some of the recruiting for other guys who simply don't have the passion nor ability to log the miles like they perhaps used to (Aiken, Neal, Pellum). I'm guessing Helf didn't suspect that a guy he was hiring with minimal experience would be getting a DC offer within 2-3 years. I'm not defending Helf, nor am I throwing him under the bus, just speaking to an understanding of how it happened. I do, actually, think Aiken is a liability on the recruiting trail. But what's tough about that is he's arguably the best DL coach in the Pac-12. A Hoke/Aiken combo could be lethal, or it could be horrible; only time will tell.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
In an interview once, I got a question about the following scenario: You own a coffee shop in a small neighborhood. Business has been good enough to support a decent lifestyle over the last several years. Suddenly, you get wind that there's a Starbucks opening up across the street in a month. What do you do?UOducksTK1 wrote: Fair enough. I guess I don't see an ideal solution, and I think we operate pretty efficiently given our situation and limitations. I guess I'm just curious then, what's your ideal solution?
This is what happens in college football at a nearly non-stop rate. There's a coaching hire, achievement, or new element introduced every year that shifts the landscape and forces you to react wisely or else you falter. So that leaves you with 1 realistic answer for the question above: Differentiate.
During the Chip Kelly era, Oregon did a phenomenal job of differentiation by selling something that hadn't been done before by selling "speed." They played fast, Chip talked fast, and Oregon players seemed to play faster than their official 40 times. As with all branding strategies, though, without proper reinvention and reinvestment, they grow stale. Today, half the country runs a similar offense to Oregon. 90% changed their jerseys. Chip is in the NFL.
But that doesn't mean they have all the things that make Oregon unique.
For the sake of length of this post, I'm going to focus on just Notre Dame, which is part of the peer group I used above. If I'm Notre Dame, I look introspectively and focus on a storied tradition, television deal with NBC, fairly academically prestigious, pretty big-name coach, recruits nationally, position group excellence on the offensive line and tight end, big time match-ups annually, located nearby certain talent hotbeds, new life experience compared to staying near home, college town, and alumni network.
How do you compete with that if you're Oregon? Well let's look.
If I'm Oregon, I look introspectively and focus on Nike partnership, academic major excellence (sports business, journalism, product design), unrivaled Jaqua Center that ensures academic success, constantly being the first/on the cutting edge, distraction-less environment (for a college), top facilities in the country, West Coast, big time matchups annually, offense that best utilizes skill players, position group excellence at QB and RB and DB and arguably DL, alumni network, recent success/momentum created in the last 20 years, recent Heisman winner, horizontal leadership model rather than top-down model, one of the most naturally beautiful areas of the country, new life experience compared to staying near home, located nearby certain talent hotbeds, 'cool' factor', recruits nationally, leading in sports science, college town, and culture of 'be yourself.'
As you can see, if you're an Oregon coach, there are lot of points where you can win, and many more where you can cancel out Notre Dame's perceived strengths (academics, alumni network, etc.). It comes down to proper messaging. So if Oregon identifies the right players at the right time, why couldn't they out-recruit Notre Dame?
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8822
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I should have been more clear, I was talking in regards to recruiting and not coaching ability. Pellum was recruiting coordinator as well which is what I was mostly referring in the context of this recruiting discussion. From what I can gather it sounds like the older tenured coaches are interested in putting the efforts required to be top notch recruiters.jimmy12 wrote:Are you making a broad assumption based on 1 coach? That isn't really fair. The Ducks upgraded at QB coach and hopefully at O-Coordinator (verdict still out obviously). They definitely upgraded at D coordinator (but by how much only time will tell). Sure Pellum has a job, but how big of an exposure point is it having him coach the LBs? I would say very little. Please stop this sky is falling BS. It is depressing for all who wasted time reading.
I agree though, if we're talking purely coaching then we have a lot to be excited about. It won't matter though if the talent we bring in starts to drop off. Which is what I think people worried about.
