Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
-
lmduck
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
To provide some clarity and some of you may know this and others may not but I will throw it out there for consideration.
Helfrich DID NOT want to promote Pellum. He was told to do so by some very large donors who wanted continuity in the program. Was it a mistake, yes, absolutely. Hind sight is always 20/20. He was told to give it two years and he did and then made a change.
Helfrich DID NOT want to promote Pellum. He was told to do so by some very large donors who wanted continuity in the program. Was it a mistake, yes, absolutely. Hind sight is always 20/20. He was told to give it two years and he did and then made a change.
-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
A coach being told had to hire Pellum.... interesting tidbit. I think it might be a bit of a stretch since the head coach whoever that might be will take the flack if it does not work out. I am not saying it is or is not true. The head coach should be allowed to make their own choices for whoever they pick to be their assistants since it is their neck that is on the line if it turns out bad. If he was not allowed to make this choice.... or had the determination to pick his own guy... makes me kind of wonder bout the whole ordeal.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I've heard he was told to fire Pellum by ONE major donor, but never to hire him as DC.
-
lmduck
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I can tell you for fact that Helfrich was told to promote Pellum.
-
rentdodger1
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2011 8:16 pm
- Location: Paradise Valley, Az.
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
lmduck wrote:To provide some clarity and some of you may know this and others may not but I will throw it out there for consideration.
Helfrich DID NOT want to promote Pellum. He was told to do so by some very large donors who wanted continuity in the program. Was it a mistake, yes, absolutely. Hind sight is always 20/20. He was told to give it two years and he did and then made a change.
This is true. The window was open to win the NC and the donors you refer to felt that any major defensive change might jeopardize that. Oregon went to the NC game and got run over by tOSU. The decision to make Pellum a short term fix and the hope he would work out long term backfired. I believe that Helfrich had the final call with Hoke and he could be finally the red ass that side of the ball needs. Also I don't think there where a lot of tears shed when Frost left.
-
lmduck
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
100% accurate about Pellum. Helfrich did not want to promote him as I originally said. For the reasons you cited, (program continuity) major donors DID NOT want a change. As I said, they were wrong and have privately admitted it.rentdodger1 wrote:lmduck wrote:To provide some clarity and some of you may know this and others may not but I will throw it out there for consideration.
Helfrich DID NOT want to promote Pellum. He was told to do so by some very large donors who wanted continuity in the program. Was it a mistake, yes, absolutely. Hind sight is always 20/20. He was told to give it two years and he did and then made a change.
This is true. The window was open to win the NC and the donors you refer to felt that any major defensive change might jeopardize that. Oregon went to the NC game and got run over by tOSU. The decision to make Pellum a short term fix and the hope he would work out long term backfired. I believe that Helfrich had the final call with Hoke and he could be finally the red ass that side of the ball needs. Also I don't think there where a lot of tears shed when Frost left.
With regard to Frost, also 100% accurate that some people were not unhappy he left. Frost always thought he was the smartest man in the room and that rubbed some of the other coaches the wrong way big time. All you have to do is read Greatwood's comments to get a feel for things:
Matt’s real sharp,” Greatwood said. “I like Matt because already we’ve been talking about marrying the formations in the run game plan that I come up with, along with his pass game plan. Already, I’ve probably had more communication just in those initial steps in the game plan than I had with Scott.
“I’m looking forward to that. If that’s the way it shakes down, I’m sure it’s going to be a great working relationship there.”
--
"We have a lot more conversation. We're a lot more detailed in what we're doing right now. I appreciate that," Oregon offensive line coach Steve Greatwood said. "Things aren't as quite fly-by-the-seat-of-our-pants. Things are coming together."
--
"I think we're all involved more as far as what we're doing with the offense," Greatwood said, "our input and obviously sharing the workload as far as scripting and all that stuff."
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I have heard this in circles. Frost was not a great position coach for WRs or QBs. (This is why QB development slowed). The only outlier question whether Matt can call plays and adjust during a game. This is a major question. When does Helf insert himself? When not?
- FlDuckFan
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5068
- Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
- GM: Orlando Magic GM
- Location: Florida
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
In fairness I don't think Frost was very good at calling plays and adjusting during a game. Living closer to Orlando than most of you, I am excited to see how he does at UCF.jimmy12 wrote:I have heard this in circles. Frost was not a great position coach for WRs or QBs. (This is why QB development slowed). The only outlier question whether Matt can call plays and adjust during a game. This is a major question. When does Helf insert himself? When not?
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I think we'll learn a LOT during his next 5 years as coach. If he finds success, then I will stand corrected and he will move to a higher profile job. If he doesn't then he'll be the coach at UCF for the next 5 years. There is a reason Nebraska did not hire him.
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5325
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I finally read this thread after avoiding it for the last week. I appreciate the info from people closer to the program. I know this has been said before, but it bears repeating - a pretty high percentage of the highly-rated guys that have come to Oregon in the past were flame-outs in college, or didn't academically qualify. I think it's at least possible that we had a decent recruiting class in 2016 compared to other years, we just don't realize it yet because everyone skips through the names looking for the five-star headline guys. We needed some great linebackers for the reset on defense, and it looks like we got some good ones. That was a relief to me. Remember when we always needed a skilled receiver or DL guy during the Chip years? There were always holes.
Trying to be the cool, innovative kid on the block is bound to backfire at some point. Even Apple has had its problems over the years with that approach. The real ace in the hole for the ducks must always be finding diamonds among the two to three star crowd and coaching them up to play against the big bad recruits from the LA schools. I would rather see efficiency in terms of finding guys that can contribute among the 85 scholarships.
Trying to be the cool, innovative kid on the block is bound to backfire at some point. Even Apple has had its problems over the years with that approach. The real ace in the hole for the ducks must always be finding diamonds among the two to three star crowd and coaching them up to play against the big bad recruits from the LA schools. I would rather see efficiency in terms of finding guys that can contribute among the 85 scholarships.
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Let's not forget that at the first Natty, I think every guy on the O-line except 1 was a 2 star
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
Comparing a 2-star in 2016 against a 2-star in 2006 is an impossible task. Today, there are Rivals and Nike camps, satellite camps, and Hudl. Jairus Byrd, the highest paid safety in the NFL and former Duck, was a 2-star out of high school, but if Nike camps existed back then I guarantee he would've been an invitee to The Opening. The practice of finding guys that nobody else has seen or is talking about is growing more and more difficult, and thus it has become a pretty unreliable means of filling a roster. There are still guys who haven't physically matured through high school who have 5* athleticism but don't look the part yet (Elliot Baker, who Oregon is recruiting now out of junior college fits that bill, as does former #1 pick out of Central Michigan, Eric Fisher), so that could be an effective strategy as long as you don't need an immediate impact. It's not easy, though. Boise State was the absolute best at both of these, but even they found it pretty unsustainable after a few stellar years.
To Phalanx's point, ranking the guys that enroll versus ranking who was signed is a better indication of the talent being brought in. I don't understand why the recruiting services hit publish on February 5th (national signing day) like that's the end of it all. I don't get what you're saying about Apple, though. Are you making the argument that Alabama's success in branding itself 'the elite team of CFB' doesn't help it recruit future national title-caliber players?
To Phalanx's point, ranking the guys that enroll versus ranking who was signed is a better indication of the talent being brought in. I don't understand why the recruiting services hit publish on February 5th (national signing day) like that's the end of it all. I don't get what you're saying about Apple, though. Are you making the argument that Alabama's success in branding itself 'the elite team of CFB' doesn't help it recruit future national title-caliber players?
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Honest Question: What Are Our Coaches Doing Wrong?
I get your point here, but there was plenty of camps 10 years ago. And Byrd was the son of an NFL player and coach, he had ample chances to get in front of the right people to be and invite to the opening, he wasn't some no name who's parents could let afford to get him to the camps so he could get noticed.StevensTechU wrote:Comparing a 2-star in 2016 against a 2-star in 2006 is an impossible task. Today, there are Rivals and Nike camps, satellite camps, and Hudl. Jairus Byrd, the highest paid safety in the NFL and former Duck, was a 2-star out of high school, but if Nike camps existed back then I guarantee he would've been an invitee to The Opening. The practice of finding guys that nobody else has seen or is talking about is growing more and more difficult, and thus it has become a pretty unreliable means of filling a roster. There are still guys who haven't physically matured through high school who have 5* athleticism but don't look the part yet (Elliot Baker, who Oregon is recruiting now out of junior college fits that bill, as does former #1 pick out of Central Michigan, Eric Fisher), so that could be an effective strategy as long as you don't need an immediate impact. It's not easy, though. Boise State was the absolute best at both of these, but even they found it pretty unsustainable after a few stellar years.
To Phalanx's point, ranking the guys that enroll versus ranking who was signed is a better indication of the talent being brought in. I don't understand why the recruiting services hit publish on February 5th (national signing day) like that's the end of it all. I don't get what you're saying about Apple, though. Are you making the argument that Alabama's success in branding itself 'the elite team of CFB' doesn't help it recruit future national title-caliber players?