3 big reasons for the loss today

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by SuperDuck »

pezsez1 wrote:
I think you might be homering a little. At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
Some of the PI calls against us were totally justified. But that last holding call was an absolute joke. Brown let go of the defensive player as soon as he turned around, but the defensive guy stumbled and the ref threw the flag.

The substitution issue was also bizarre. Refs blew that.

We didn't lose because of officiating though. No point blowing things up too much.

This^^^^

Even after all of that, which was a bunch of nonsense, the Ducks still had chances to win.
John 3:36
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by buckmarkduck »

I won't be surprised to see us finish strong again, like last year. I just pray this isn't the year we lose to UW, because we have the young talent to make a playoff run in 1-2 years. Seriously, our young OL could become the best OL we have had. They are just improving game to game, and Hanson is the best center we have had since Unger. Yes, even better than Grasu, as crazy as it sounds right now.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by SuperDuck »

buckmarkduck wrote:I won't be surprised to see us finish strong again, like last year. I just pray this isn't the year we lose to UW, because we have the young talent to make a playoff run in 1-2 years. Seriously, our young OL could become the best OL we have had. They are just improving game to game, and Hanson is the best center we have had since Unger. Yes, even better than Grasu, as crazy as it sounds right now.

I completely agree. Our two deep on both sides of the ball is very young and is already showing flashes of greatness. I'm thinking that we're 2 years away, but something special is definitely being built.

I also think we'll finish strong. Sheesh, we were 3-3 after 6 games last year. I can easily see us at 5-1 or at least 4-2. Personally, I don't think UW is as good as their ranking. Look at who they've played! A crappy Rutgers team, Idaho and Portland State. I think we'll beat them at home.

I understand that everyone is emotional right now after the close loss, including me, but the Ducks are in good shape AND in good hands for the future.
John 3:36
snapt
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 588
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:02 pm
Location: Behind the potato curtain

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by snapt »

You simply can't play aggressive in the secondary in the Pac 12. Haven't been able to in the last 15 years, any contact gets ticy tacy PI calls. Watch what they let slide in an SEC officiated game....

At the same time, with how much the refs were calling PI, why didn't we launch a few deep at the end and collect a few PI calls to go with us?
BOOF it!
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by GrantDuck »

greenyellow wrote:This season is the first season in a long time where there's really aren't any legitimate stars on the defense. In past years, you could at least name off 3-4 guys that you could count on every game and fans would instantly recognize them.
Arrion Springs is pretty darn good.
Pontius
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 257
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:45 am

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by Pontius »

squintsdd wrote:
Sooth wrote:
squintsdd wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
I'm surprised they even still call it football in whatever bizzaro universe you were watching the game in.
It's called reality, you're welcome to join anytime
That is some weak sauce. They showed the replay and in no such form was that a hold. I expect you offer an apology if and when you get around to reviewing the tape that belies your contention of reality.
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by Tray Dub »

There were lots of fair calls against us. We committed way too many penalties.

But it's also true that the holding call on Pharaoh was wrong (and not borderline either) and it took us out of easy field goal range with a chance at a touchdown. After that we needed a miracle to get our final drive revived, so yeah, that's basically a blown call that cost us the game (or at least a real shot at it). Couple that with the substitution BS that gave NU four points and it's fair to say blown calls were enough to lose us the game. Not that we couldn't have won in spite of them or that we didn't make our own mistakes, but it's no exaggeration to say bad calls lost us that game.
squintsdd
Senior
Posts: 2111
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:39 am

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by squintsdd »

Pontius wrote:
squintsdd wrote:
Sooth wrote:
squintsdd wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.
I'm surprised they even still call it football in whatever bizzaro universe you were watching the game in.
It's called reality, you're welcome to join anytime
That is some weak sauce. They showed the replay and in no such form was that a hold. I expect you offer an apology if and when you get around to reviewing the tape that belies your contention of reality.
Seriously, you expect an apology for not doing anything to insult you. Do expect participation trophies as well?
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by Alan »

Well back to......we're was that lace suggested? Reality? :lol:

After sleeping on it and thinking about it this morning over a couple of cups of coffee my thoughts on why we loss.

Prukop had a poor game, I think he may have realized he wasn't playing Montana St football anymore. 90k load crowd may have overwhelmed him. Flustered quickly took off too quick at times, missed his targets way to much.

Enough with the two point conversions, kick the ball...we do have one of the top kickers in the nation.... Which makes a field goal attempt okay also.

Tempo and get the ball to play makers out in space.

I won't harp on it anymore other than say Hunt's personal foul.

Edit to add, losing Royce didn't help although I thought the back ups did fine.

I will say I thought the defense played much better this week compared to the previous two weeks. They're not there yet but they looked better.

Finally, today is another day, time to move forward and look forward a facing one of the better Colorado teams we have seen in a while. They hung with Michigan pretty well for a while.

But the really good news is searching through today's NFL games, koin, channel six is televising the Titans Lions game at 10am!!! Life goes on.

Edit to add, dammit, CBS just switch it to the Steelers Bengals, time to whine about the Duck game some more.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40738
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by UOducksTK1 »

squintsdd wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:1. Really poor clock management to end the first half. I'm still 50/50 on Helfrich on the whole, but that was just a massive debacle.

2. Couldn't stop the run in the 2nd half consistently. Couldn't get pressure with 4 man pass rush at all.

3. Officiating. Phantom hold to kill our last drive. The too many men on the field where we didn't get a substitution chance that gave them an extra down , which they scored on, and 4 indefensible PI penalties. Worst..homering...ever.

There's lots of other little things(injuries, certain play calls, Prukop missing throws), but those were the big ones.
I think you might be homering a little. At least 2 of those PIs were correct, the hold on the last drive was correct.

What got us the loss were the penalties (135+ yards is ridiculous), Oregon's inability to stop the run, and all those really really stupid failed 2 point conversations. If Oregon had kicked an extra point every time after the successful conversion they would've won by a point.

I'm not calling for the firing of Helfrich, but he should be feeling his chair getting a little warm.
The hold on the last drive was pretty weak. Nebraska had many instances of holding/tackling guys that were far worse than Brown's offense. Ultimately, the reffing was not very consistent at all. Felt like we were playing Stanford in that sense.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
duck58
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 666
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2009 7:56 pm

Re: 3 big reasons for the loss today

Post by duck58 »

greenyellow wrote:
squintsdd wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:The 2 point conversion complaining is utter nonsense, sorry.

Live by the sword/die by the sword. Where were the complaints when it was working?
When was the last time oregon NEVER kicked an extra point
Probably not since the 2007 game against UCLA where they were held scoreless. Not using an All-American caliber kicker to get basically free points is on the coaches and Nelson for thinking every 2-pt try was a good one.

During CKs time we were 14/17 on 2pt conversions after the 1st TD in a game; 2/6 on those after other TDs. Those were due to game situations. CK did not choose to use the 2 pt conversion after 1st TD. None of the 2 pt conversions or lack of had any affect on the outcome of any game. His record would have been the same if he would have just kicked extra pts.

During Helfs time we are 7/15 on 2 pt conversions after the 1st TD and 2/14 after other TDs. Those were in the UC Davis game. Again, until Sat., none of those 2pt conversions or lack of had an affect on any game. The only possibility would be last years MSU game if we had tried and made all 4(not likely). CK would have kicked the rest after the 1st. on Sat.

I have never cared much for the 2 pt conversions except when the game situation dictates it. I finally checked the archives and found they were irrelevant to the outcome of any games before Sat. The scores and scoring summaries prove it. It may have looked good but it never really accomplished much.
Post Reply